Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 19:39]

Meeting date: Tuesday, November 17, 2026


Contents


First Minister’s Question Time


Back-bench Members

14:30


Milburn Report

Daniel Johnson (Edinburgh Southern) (Lab)

With an estimated one in eight young Scots neither earning nor learning, does the First Minister welcome the Milburn report, especially given its wide-ranging and cross-portfolio nature? Although the Scottish Government will not yet have considered the report in detail, do any ideas jump out at the First Minister as being a good idea, such as the youth opportunity service, which I think could make a real difference to young people in Scotland?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

There is a great deal in the Milburn review that the Government will consider. It is a substantial contribution to the debate. A number of elements in the Milburn review call for the application in England of the approach that we take here, in Scotland, which is very much characterised by the no one left behind approach that the Government takes. The focus on developing a range of vocational qualifications in our school education system, which I am very proud of, has grown substantially, enabling young people to enter the labour market.

The Government will consider all the issues. There are potentially some significant financial implications, which could be negative, for the Scottish Government, and we need to explore those in great detail. That depends, of course, on the reaction of the United Kingdom Government. I assure Mr Johnson that the Scottish Government will consider carefully all the contents of the Milburn review and will relate it to the substantial and effective practices that are being taken forward in Scotland.


Hyperscale Data Centres (Public Opposition)

Laura Moodie (South Scotland) (Green)

Over the weekend, an estimated 6,000 people took to the streets in an attempt to have their voices heard on hyperscale artificial intelligence data centres. Meanwhile, the proposed Chapelcross data centre in Dumfries and Galloway has attracted more than 15,000 objections in the public consultation period, which has now passed. With five weeks to go until Christmas, there is still no sign of any guidance from the Scottish Government on data centre applications. Does the First Minister think that it is right that the only way that communities can have their voices heard is by taking to the streets? Does he expect communities to make representations without knowing what the Government’s guidance on data centres will say? How will he ensure that the public have a further opportunity to comment once that guidance is published?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The first thing that I want to say is that I agree that members of the public should have the opportunity to set out their views and that their views should be listened to with respect. If members of the public choose to express their views by taking part in demonstrations, I respect entirely their desire to do so. I have taken part in a few demonstrations in my time, so I understand the importance of expressing our views in that way.

The Government is considering the formulation of the guidance on hyperscale data centres, as we promised to Parliament and as Parliament resolved. That will be published before the end of the year. The Government has already put in place substantial additional constraints and conditions that have to be applied in the consideration of such developments. I will ensure that there is wide and active debate around the contents of the guidance that the Government brings forward.


Neurodivergent Young People (Self-directed Support)

Finlay Carson (Galloway and West Dumfries) (Con)

Yesterday I met the fantastic Better Lives Partnership in Stranraer, which supports neurodivergent young people to achieve their full potential and move into education, employment and independent living. It told me that access to self-directed support, including to access the courses that are on, is increasingly being restricted to support deemed to be for critical need. Can the First Minister explain what the Government means by “critical need and how denying preventative support until there is an emergency can be compatible with the Government’s commitment to early intervention?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The work that Finlay Carson has recounted is very much at the heart of the Government’s approach to early intervention, which is to provide support that enables individuals to overcome any challenges that they face, in order that they have fulfilling lives. If that creates the opportunity to enter the labour market, it is all the better.

Many of those issues will be associated with some of the decisions that are required in connection with the Milburn review, which could well have an effect on some of the provision that we put in place.

Decisions on the provision of support at a local level will, I imagine, have been taken by health and social care partnerships, and we encourage all public bodies to support and develop early intervention mechanisms such as preventative interventions. The Better Lives Partnership, which Mr Carson mentioned, sounds like a very good example of that.


Built Heritage (George Cinema, Portobello)

Kate Campbell (Edinburgh Eastern, Musselburgh and Tranent) (SNP)

The owners of the B-listed George cinema, an art deco former cinema in Portobello, are applying for consent to demolish it. Having owned the building for almost a decade, during which time it has fallen from regular use into disrepair, they are applying on the basis that the building is unsafe. That is happening across Scotland. Can more be done, through the national planning framework, to protect our built heritage from that type of neglect and, ultimately, from destruction?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

I have a lot of sympathy with the point that Kate Campbell has put forward. As she has correctly indicated, a number of properties in that situation, of which the George cinema in Portobello is an example, are important for our built heritage but are in private ownership and are not being cared for in the way that we would all want.

In March this year, the Government published updated guidance on dealing with listed buildings that become dangerous. That guidance makes it clear that responsibility for the maintenance and upkeep of such buildings rests with their owners, who must comply with relevant legal requirements, and local authorities are responsible for taking enforcement action where appropriate.

Kate Campbell’s point, which has significant validity, is that, if an owner is not doing that but the building does not quite pass the test for being a dangerous building or posing a risk to the public, there is scope for us to explore what further intervention could be taken forward by local authorities. I am very happy for the Government to explore the issues that Kate Campbell has raised about whether any gaps in that provision could be filled by further guidance or legislative change.


Accessible and Adapted Social Housing (National Framework)

Thomas Kerr (Glasgow) (Reform)

In a response to a written question, the First Minister’s Government has confirmed to me that there are no plans for a national framework for recording accessible and adapted social housing.

One of my constituents, Tony Pearson, is in the public gallery this afternoon. Tony’s young daughter, Grayce, has spinal muscular atrophy, which is a progressive and life-limiting condition that affects her mobility and independence. The family is in desperate need of being rehoused, and I am assisting with that. Will the First Minister explain to Mr Pearson why his Government will not make the necessary changes to ease the burden on families such as the Pearsons, who already have to navigate a complex housing process? In addition, will he meet me and Mr Pearson to hear at first hand why Grayce’s register is so much needed?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

I am sorry to hear about the circumstances that Mr Pearson and his family are experiencing. The Government has increased the resource that we make available to local authorities to support the adaptation of properties so that they meet the needs of individuals and families, in recognition of the changing circumstances that individuals can experience.

Fundamentally, however, the issue is about local authority action and intervention. The Government makes available resources to support adaptation. That is an essential tool for the Government in ensuring that people are accommodated properly and effectively, and that we reduce the need for them to be accommodated in hospital because their home situation is not suitable.

Ministers will certainly address Mr Pearson’s specific circumstances, and I encourage Thomas Kerr to take up with the local authority the advancement of the issues around proper housing support for Mr Pearson.


Blythswood Care (Shoebox Appeal)

David Green (Caithness, Sutherland and Ross) (LD)

I recently visited Blythswood Care’s depot in Evanton, where its shoebox appeal is well under way. Last winter, more than 80,000 shoeboxes were distributed across eastern Europe. Will the First Minister join me in paying tribute to Blythswood? Will he also ensure that the Government fulfils its role by front-loading the welcome increase to the international development budget, as was recommended by the Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

First, I will convey, through Mr Green, my appreciation for the work of the Blythswood charity in Evanton. Its shoebox appeal has been an essential part of the support for many individuals and families, and the contribution of members of the public in Scotland to it is deeply appreciated.

In relation to international development, the Government has been increasing the funding available for that work, which is one of the issues that we are wrestling with in relation to the budget process. We look forward to engaging with Mr Green and his colleagues on that question.

Having seen the positive benefits of the Scottish Government’s investment in projects in Malawi and Zambia, I am certainly convinced of the significant obligation and benefit of our being involved in international development activity. I am glad that that position commands the support of the Liberal Democrats.


Legal Services (Consumer Protection)

Stuart McMillan (Inverclyde) (SNP)

The First Minister will be aware of the proposed group proceedings being pursued by Addleshaw Goddard on behalf of the former clients of McClure Solicitors, which was formerly based in Greenock. Following the conclusion of those proceedings, will the Scottish Government review whether the current legislative and regulatory framework concerning the provision of legal services provides adequate consumer protection? If it does not, what further reforms will the Scottish Government consider?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

I am very conscious of the distress that the collapse of McClure’s has caused so many individuals. I express my sympathy and support for them, as I know of the difficulties that have been faced.

We are currently implementing the Regulation of Legal Services (Scotland) Act 2025, which introduces the authorisation of legal businesses. That will bring benefits such as greater consistency in the regulation of legal firms, enabling the Law Society of Scotland, as the regulator, to identify and address deficiencies early. I suspect that, had we had that, that would have helped the situation with McClure’s, which Mr McMillan has pursued with such tenacity over a number of years.

The 2025 act includes measures that are designed to strengthen consumer protection. However, the Government remains open to considering additional measures, should the ones that we are taking not provide adequate protection as sought by Mr McMillan on behalf of his constituents and many others who are affected by the McClure’s case.


Hydropower Schemes (Business Rates Valuations)

Joe Fagan (South Scotland) (Lab)

The vast majority of the United Kingdom’s hydropower potential is in Scotland, yet industry leaders warn that more than 400 small hydro schemes here are at risk because our business rate valuations for small hydropower schemes are so much higher than they are for comparable wind and solar projects. Assessors are being legally challenged. I do not expect the First Minister to comment on that, but I would ask him to address Government policy. I cannot believe that it is the Government’s policy intention that rateable values should deter investment in renewables at that scale, so will the First Minister intervene?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

Mr Fagan correctly identifies that a legal challenge to the valuations is under way, so I will steer clear of commenting on that particular issue. I will say that we deliver the most generous non-domestic rates relief in the United Kingdom for renewable generators, including small-scale hydro generators, and the vast majority of hydro schemes benefit from the relief in full.

We will always engage in making sure that Scotland’s renewable energy resources can be developed in that way. I am very familiar with the issues that Mr Fagan raises—a number of schemes in my constituency are affected by those issues—and I want to make clear how much the Government values the hydroelectric foundations of the renewable energy journey that we are enjoying in Scotland. That is a central part of how we take forward the means of developing that potential.


General Practice (Information Technology)

Adam Harley (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (LD)

Susan Murray MP and I recently met general practitioners in Bishopbriggs who told us that, since their practices were moved to the Vision information technology system in September, the number of patients that they have time to see has been cut in half, because the system is so difficult to use. One GP described it as

“like trying to eat a bowl of soup with a fork.”

Since I raised the issue with the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care a fortnight ago, hundreds of GPs from across Scotland have contacted me, describing the system as “demoralising” and “unsafe”.

With patients already waiting too long and doctors under huge pressure, the last thing that our national health service needs is failing IT. Will the First Minister commit to fixing that as a matter of urgency, and will he meet GPs to hear their concerns at first hand?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The health secretary engages in a great deal of dialogue with GPs, and she will be happy to discuss the questions that there are on the GP IT reprovisioning programme. Due to supplier withdrawals, Vision 3 is currently the only GP IT system that is available under the national framework. We are working closely with the GP community to ensure that the system works effectively in order to support patients. The health secretary will be happy to engage with general practitioners on that important issue.


Asylum Processing (European Union Member States and Rwanda)

Craig Hoy (Dumfriesshire) (Con)

Given that the Scottish National Party wants Scotland to remain at the heart of Europe and that his Government’s position is to remain aligned with European Union member states, will the First Minister join me in welcoming the new EU policy of processing failed asylum seekers in Rwanda?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

From what I have seen, it is not an EU policy. I think that it is the policy of a few EU member states, which is a completely different proposition. Allow me to point out that the Conservatives are always going on at me about ensuring that my statements to the Parliament are accurate, so let us ensure that the Conservatives’ statements to the Parliament are accurate.

The other thing to note is that the policies that are connected to transporting people to Rwanda were tried by the Conservative Government. With the usual Conservative effectiveness, the Government failed completely. It spent a huge amount of money, achieved absolutely nothing and had nothing to show for it, and we are all now paying the price. That is just typical of the Conservatives.


Police Custody Facilities (Kilmarnock)

Alan Brown (Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley) (SNP)

The closure of holding cells at Kilmarnock means that, when police make arrests, they can be off the streets for up to three hours, due to the need to travel to Saltcoats and the increased processing time there. If Saltcoats is full, officers from Ayrshire have to travel much further afield.

A ministerial response has stated that that is an operational matter for Police Scotland, but we cannot ignore decisions that front-line police are raising concerns about. Will the First Minister intervene as part of the budget discussions with Police Scotland?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The issues that Mr Brown has raised about the custody cells at Kilmarnock are important. I understand the significance of ensuring that police resources can be used efficiently in localities. Police Scotland will make judgments about the most appropriate locations for such provision to meet its service expectations. However, I will take from the exchange today the importance that Mr Brown has attached to the custody suite being available in Kilmarnock. We will consider that as part of the budget process that will progress in the weeks to come.


Water Quality (Kinghorn Harbour Beach)

Mark Ruskell (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green)

This morning, Kinghorn harbour beach received its fifth consecutive poor water quality report and now faces losing its bathing water designation. That is devastating for the community and all those who love the place. Although I welcome Scottish Water’s and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency’s commitment to solving the problems at Kinghorn, it is clear that a change in the law is needed to deal with rogue sewage connections and many other pollution issues that affect our coasts.

When will the First Minister’s Government introduce a clean water bill to protect the beaches that we love?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The general point that I will make is that this morning’s water quality report demonstrates the extensive strength of water quality in Scotland. If my memory serves me right, 96 per cent of beaches are designated as meeting the standard. I think that that is the right number, but I am saying that from my recollection.

In relation to Kinghorn, I am aware that extensive investigations have been conducted in order to identify a number of pollution sources, but the evidence suggests that sources of sewage pollution remain, and further explanation will be required to identify those sources.

I do not agree with Mr Ruskell that there is a weakness in the legislative framework. The legislative framework identifies the conditions that need to improve and informs the investigations that are carried out. I completely accept Mr Ruskell’s frustration that it is taking a long time. Issues are sometimes not readily identifiable, but the general pattern for water quality in Scotland is encouraging, which I welcome. Where there are problems, we should address them, and I believe that we have the legislative framework to do so.


Colleges (2027-28 Budget)

Amanda Lindsay (Central Scotland and Lothians West) (Reform)

What action will the Scottish Government take in the upcoming 2027-28 budget to prevent campus closures, compulsory redundancies and potential insolvencies across Scotland’s college sector, following warnings from Colleges Scotland that “a below-inflation settlement” will push further education into a “crisis state”?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The work of our colleges is very important in Scotland, and in the previous budget, we significantly increased the budget available to colleges.

Amanda Lindsay asked me about the importance of an above-inflation settlement. I have to point out to the Parliament that the Government has not had an inflation-based settlement from the United Kingdom Government. Indeed, we are dealing with an erosion of our budget to the tune of £650 million because there has not been a real-terms settlement.

These are some of the difficulties that the Government is having to wrestle with. I understand the strength of Amanda Lindsay’s point about a real-terms settlement for the college sector, but the Government is wrestling with these issues because we have had a settlement below inflation. That will apply across a range of different policy areas in the budget, and the Parliament will have the opportunity to consider the budget when it is set out on 3 December.


Nurses (Employment)

Helen McDade (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Reform)

Does the First Minister agree that Scotland cannot continue to talk about nursing shortages, safe staffing and investing in the future of the national health service while it is failing to provide employment opportunities for the very people who could help to address those problems—specifically, newly qualified paediatric nurses who cannot find positions? What will the Government do to ensure that we do not waste our money on helping people to get trained, only for them to discover that they cannot get a job?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The Government takes forward an approach to workforce planning in relation to the identification of the number of trainees who we wish to support, with the objective of creating opportunities for those individuals to participate in the national health service. We work to make sure that the appropriate opportunities are available to be filled by the skilled personnel who undertake their training in Scotland.


Home Heating Support Fund

Steven Bonnar (Uddingston and Bellshill) (SNP)

Families in Uddingston and Bellshill who struggle to afford to top up their pre-payment meters can find themselves without heating, in particular during the winter months. The home heating support fund previously provided vital emergency assistance to help households experiencing fuel poverty, but that support is no longer available. What consideration is Scottish Government giving to reinstating the heating support fund or introducing an equivalent emergency support scheme to ensure that families who are facing an immediate energy crisis can access the help that they need when they need it most?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

We have in place a range of different interventions to support families who face challenges with their costs. We have the best cost of living package across the United Kingdom, and the work that is undertaken through some of the emergency support and the discretionary housing payments is designed to support families at that particular time.

It would also have helped us if the freeze on the local housing allowance had been removed; that would have helped enormously to lift families out of poverty and to help them to deal with the energy costs that they are wrestling with. Nonetheless, I assure Mr Bonnar of the range of interventions that the Government has in place to meet the needs of members of the public.


Councils (Funding)

Katy Clark (West Scotland) (Lab)

Councils across West Scotland are to face significant financial challenges yet again when setting their budgets for next year. North Ayrshire Council is facing a budget gap of more than £8 million, East Dunbartonshire Council is facing a gap of £7 million and Inverclyde Council is facing a gap of up to £22 million by 2030; while West Dunbartonshire Council’s gap could be almost £45 million in the same period.

Does the First Minister accept that councils have not been getting their fair share of funding and that they need increased and sustained funding to protect jobs and services? Will the budget deliver that?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The Government has, just in the most recent financial year, given a very significant increase to local authority funding, and we aim to support local services to the greatest extent possible.

As I have just recounted in my answer to Amanda Lindsay, the Government’s budget is not increasing in real terms. We can distribute only those resources that are under our control, and we must live within our resources.

We are engaging with local authorities on those questions. I will be addressing the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities conference on Thursday, and we will discuss those issues. I simply make the point that the Government must live within the resources that it has available to it.

Of course, there is scope for us to engage with the Labour Party on the specifics of the budget. We have to secure agreement in the Parliament on the terms of the budget, and I am sure that the Deputy First Minister will look forward to those discussions to ensure that common ground can be established on this and many other important questions.


St Abbs Lifeboat

Rachael Hamilton (Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire) (Con)

Since 2016, St Abbs Lifeboat, which is based in my constituency, has operated an independent service. Thanks to the dedication of local volunteers, it has continued to protect and save lives. Will the First Minister whole-heartedly join me in congratulating volunteers and crew after they received the prestigious King’s award for voluntary service, and will he recognise the remarkable contribution that they provide to saving lives at sea?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

I am absolutely delighted to acknowledge the success of the St Abbs Lifeboat crew and the support team on receiving the King’s award for voluntary service. It is a commendation of the highest standard of achievement and commitment, and it is very well deserved.

The Royal National Lifeboat Institution is a magnificent organisation, funded by volunteers, that undertakes life-saving work the length and breadth of the country. I must say that some of the commentary that has been directed at the RNLI in recent times for carrying out the important and generous task of saving other people’s lives is absolutely reprehensible. I know that Rachael Hamilton and I will very much agree in our tribute to the magnificent work of the RNLI and its volunteers around the country, especially those in St Abbs, who put their lives at risk to protect others.


Men’s Sheds

Dawn Black (Angus North and Mearns) (SNP)

Will the First Minister say what consideration has been given to increasing funding for the Scottish Men’s Sheds Association, given the contribution that men’s sheds make to tackling social isolation, improving mental health and supporting community wellbeing across Scotland, which consequently reduces costs elsewhere?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The Scottish men’s shed movement is an important part of supporting men’s health, and Dawn Black rightly pays tribute to that organisation. On Friday, I had the privilege of joining the team at the men’s shed in Aberfeldy to see at first hand the outstanding work that is undertaken there.

The Government has invested nearly £1 million in the Scottish Men’s Sheds Association since 2016, and we will be considering those issues as part of the budget. Some of the work is spread across community mental health and wellbeing support and social isolation and loneliness support.

I take this opportunity to commend the Scottish Men’s Sheds Association on the excellent work that it and its member organisations around the country have done.


Status of Scotland’s Ports

Amanda Bland (Central Scotland and Lothians West) (Ind)

Following the United Kingdom Government’s decision not to grant ports critical national priority status, will the First Minister make representations to Westminster to ensure that strategically important port infrastructure around the Forth, including Grangemouth in my Central Scotland and Lothian’s West region, receives appropriate national recognition, given its importance to Scotland’s energy security, economic resilience and skilled jobs?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

I will explore that interesting point. Ordinarily—certainly in my view—Grangemouth and the Grangemouth port, as well as other ports at Leith and Rosyth on the River Forth, are absolutely fundamental to the critical national infrastructure of the country.

I will take away Amanda Bland’s point to satisfy myself that the appropriate approach is being taken. However, for the record today, I view the port at Grangemouth, as well as the ports at Rosyth and Leith, as central to the critical national infrastructure of the country, and I will make sure that the issues are properly addressed.


Project Esperanza (Support)

Kate Nevens (Edinburgh and Lothians East) (Green)

Over the past few weeks, Project Esperanza—an incredible grass-roots initiative based in my region, which offers support to families and women of African heritage—has faced some awful threats and intimidation after some members of this Parliament attempted to disrupt its access to funding. Will the First Minister join me in condemning those attacks on Project Esperanza and in reiterating the right of Project Esperanza, and all charities, to conduct advocacy work to advance the aims of the organisation and the people that it supports? Will he set out the specific measures that his Government is taking to ensure that specialist black and brown-led organisations can access crisis support when they receive such threats and intimidation, so that they can continue their vital work?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

Kate Nevens raises a number of important issues. Distinctively, the issues in relation to the operation of charities are regulated by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator—OSCR—and it would be wrong for me to intrude on that regulatory function. However, I make it clear that I value the work that Project Esperanza is doing to advocate for individuals and I am appalled that it has suffered intimidation and been undermined as a consequence of comments made by members of this Parliament. It is important that the Government’s approach, which is set out in the community cohesion measures that I explained in the programme for government, are designed to reach projects of that nature, to make sure that individuals who need their support can attract it. I give that commitment today.


National Emergency Briefing

I understand that, on Friday, the First Minister attended a screening of the national emergency briefing. Does he have any reflections on the film and has he given any consideration to the campaign’s call for a televised Government briefing?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

I had a busy day in Aberfeldy on Friday—I also saw the screening of the national emergency briefing film. I had an excellent discussion with local representatives who are engaged in the campaign. Mr Barratt was involved in hosting the screening of the national emergency briefing here in the Parliament a few weeks ago and I welcomed his intervention, supported by other members of the Parliament, to make that happen.

The film was a powerful explanation of the climate crisis that we face and the necessity of taking action. I welcome many of the initiatives and measures that the film sets out. On the issue of a televised Government emergency briefing, I am sympathetic to the aspirations that the national emergency briefing team sets out. We have to take steps to strengthen public awareness of the challenges that we face and the need to take action to address the climate and nature emergency. I would be happy to discuss those issues with Mr Barratt and those involved in the briefing in due course.


Historic Environment Scotland (Governance)

Stephen Kerr (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con)

Historic Environment Scotland is in crisis. The Auditor General has warned of continuing failures in governance, staff have lost confidence in the leadership and, now, three senior officials have been suspended. Angus Robertson failed to get a grip on the situation and, so far, Màiri McAllan has failed to get a grip on it. Will the First Minister tell the Parliament when his Government intends to take responsibility for sorting out this mess?

The First Minister (John Swinney)

The Government takes responsibility for all the issues that happen in its name. I answer questions here twice a week and, at all times, I accept the responsibility of the Government—so there is no need for Mr Kerr to be concerned about that.

New leadership has been appointed to Historic Environment Scotland and we expect that leadership to deliver on the necessary steps to improve the operating culture. I will not speculate on any issues about staffing matters—it would be completely inappropriate for me to do so. However, I can say to Mr Kerr that the Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic, Màiri McAllan, is in active dialogue about the necessary improvements at Historic Environment Scotland. The new leadership that is in place will take forward that agenda.

The Presiding Officer (Kenneth Gibson)

That concludes First Minister’s questions from back-bench members.

I have to say that, although I apologise to the many members whose questions I was unable to take, some members submitted excellent questions that I was willing to take but they did not press their request-to-speak button. Those included members of more than one political party, and we were unable to catch their eye. If you are going to go to the bother of writing a good-quality question, please make sure that you press your button to enable you to speak. Thank you.