Official Report 369KB pdf
Good afternoon, colleagues. The first item of business is general question time. As always, in order to accommodate as many questions as possible, I ask for concise questions and answers.
Ferry Services (Dunoon to Gourock)
To ask the Scottish Government, in light of recent reports regarding the MV Argyll Flyer, what actions are being taken to deliver improvements on the Dunoon to Gourock ferry service. (S7O-00541)
As Jenni Minto will know, the MV Argyll Flyer unfortunately had to come out of service on the back of storm Boelo, due to the fact that it collided with something in the water. I had conversations with officials once I realised that the vessel was out of service, and I think that it was a log. As I have said to Jenni Minto previously, the Government is seeking to ensure through its vessels and ports plan that the vessels that serve the route are replaced. I believe that the timeline for that is around 2031 to 2036.
Given the consistent issues with the two vessels that service the route and the lack of a relief vessel, local community councils are now proposing that a single-vessel timetable be maintained on the route until new vessels are delivered. That would ensure that any mechanical issues with the vessels did not impact the service and would provide some much-needed reliability. Will the cabinet secretary support that proposal in the short term, until the new vessels are delivered? Although I appreciate the pulls on his diary, will he consider meeting my constituents?
I thank Jenni Minto for her kind invitation in that regard. We will see what we can do in as early a course as possible.
The wider suggestion that has been made is a thoughtful and helpful contribution from the community, and I will ensure that my officials take that forward with CalMac Ferries accordingly.
The cabinet secretary will be aware that there is increasing frustration among the local community councils, which now believe that they are repeatedly being palmed off by the Government with the promise of new vessels. According to the local council, the original plan was that they would be delivered in 2025, but the minister is now saying that another decade could pass before the communities get them. Is there no way that that could be speeded up?
The vessels and ports plan was produced at the same time as the islands connectivity plan during the previous session of Parliament—I believe that it was in 2025. It is important that we stick to that plan and seek to deliver its objectives.
Across the wider network, we are in the process of renewing a third of the entire CalMac fleet. I am sure that the Parliament will join me in expressing its delight that the MV Loch Indaal came into Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd’s ownership just the other day. We hope that we will have it sailing over to Scotland very soon.
Clyde Tunnel (Maintenance)
To ask the Scottish Government what progress it has made in relation to taking over responsibility for the maintenance of the Clyde tunnel in Glasgow. (S7O-00542)
I thank Colm Merrick for raising that important matter in the chamber. I assure him that my officials are in dialogue with those in Glasgow City Council on the matter, and we will take things forward accordingly.
When the First Minister announced plans to take over the running of the Clyde tunnel, he also pledged support for other measures, such as the establishment of an urban development corporation for the city centre and the next stages of feasibility work on the Clyde metro proposal. What progress has been made in relation to those pledges?
There is rightly significant interest in the Clyde metro proposal from the public and indeed parliamentarians. When I met Glasgow Airport Ltd recently, it was keen to talk to me about the opportunities that would come with that. I assure Mr Merrick that, on that matter and the other matter that he raises, my officials are in regular dialogue with the local authority and Strathclyde Partnership for Transport, and we will continue to make progress as quickly as we can.
The Clyde tunnel has been a vital artery for the whole Glasgow city region since it opened in 1963. For years, however, simply keeping the 2,500-feet-long tunnel operating has consumed 10 per cent of the whole city council’s roads budget for 1,200 miles of road. The proposal, which I have campaigned for since I came into the Parliament in 2021, is therefore a welcome move.
Can we get further clarity on the timescale for the transfer of the asset from Glasgow City Council to the Scottish ministers? Will the cabinet secretary seek capital investment in the tunnel in the upcoming Scottish budget, particularly in the approach roads and the Shieldhall overpass, which are in a critical state of disrepair?
I thank Mr Sweeney for his question and his continued advocacy on this important issue. I am glad that he and I are in agreement that the manifesto commitment that we made in this regard was a good one. He tempts me to veer into discussions about the Scottish budget, but I am afraid that I will not be able to do so. I am sure that he will be listening closely when the Deputy First Minister announces the budget, on 3 December.
Agritourism (Planning System)
To ask the Scottish Government how it will support agritourism businesses to grow through changes to the planning system. (S7O-00543)
I thank Mr Melville for his continued support for agritourism and for championing it in his constituency, whether it is about strawberries, blueberries or anything in between.
The Scottish Government recognises the contribution and the diversity of agritourism across rural and island communities. It is important that, as we look to reform our planning system, we take that sector into account and see where it is possible to extend it. We also recognise the importance of planning in enabling good-quality development. Over the summer, as part of our 100 days commitment, I have held conversations around planning to see what needs to start, what needs to stop, what needs to change and what needs to reform.
I recently visited Balkello Farm’s hideaway experience, in my constituency, which is run by Caroline Millar, Scottish Agritourism’s sector lead.
Agritourism is worth almost £300 million to Scotland’s economy, but other countries reap far more from this vital sector. In Italy, farmers may convert existing buildings for guests, and, in Austria’s Salzburg region, planning law allows guest rooms and holiday flats within the farmhouse as part of the farm. Will the minister look at how planning could treat agritourism as dual use of the farm rather than a change of use, so that more farms can follow Balkello’s lead?
I thank Lloyd Melville for his contribution in looking at different authorities across different geographies. It is important to remain curious and to see what international best practice examples could be.
It is important to understand that, under current Scottish legislation, planning permission is not required to convert one or two bedrooms in a farmhouse to that use, depending on the overall number of bedrooms in the existing house.
The Scottish Government is committed to an ongoing review of permitted development rights, and any proposed amendment to existing permitted development rights would be subject to public consultation as part of an ongoing review.
Will the minister outline precisely what steps are being taken to ensure that local planning authorities treat diversification projects as economic development priorities rather than simple planning applications, in the light of the agritourism sector’s nearly £750-million investment pipeline, and what steps are being taken to ensure streamlined, time-bound planning processes?
It is for the decision maker to determine, on a case-by-case basis, what weight to attach to policies. As part of the development plan, the rural development policy of national planning framework 4 aims to encourage rural economic activity, innovation and diversification while ensuring that the distinctive character of a rural area is safeguarded but also enhanced.
Male Life Expectancy
To ask the Scottish Government what it is doing to improve male life expectancy and reduce premature deaths among men. (S7O-00544)
The Scottish Government welcomes the latest statistics confirming that the avoidable mortality rate in 2025 was at the lowest level since records began, in 2001. However, we recognise the need to reduce inequalities, including higher rates for males.
The Scottish Government’s population health framework aims to improve life expectancy and to reduce the life expectancy gap between the most-deprived 20 per cent of local areas and the national average by 2035, through action on the root causes of ill health.
Action is already progressing to address the leading causes of premature mortality. In 2026-27, the Scottish Government’s new alcohol and drugs strategic plan is being backed by £160 million of funding, while suicide prevention funding is at a record £3 million. The Scottish Government’s early cancer detection campaign has reached more than two million men, and the Scottish Government is funding healthy heart and lung checks in community venues, to reach those who may be less likely to visit a general practitioner.
We are currently in Movember, when men across the world are growing fetching moustaches to raise awareness of the important issue of men’s health, and today is international men’s health day. Men in Scotland still have the lowest life expectancy of men anywhere in the United Kingdom, with two in five dying prematurely, mostly from preventable causes. Across the north-east, from Dundee to Aberdeen, too many families are losing fathers, sons and brothers far too early. With ill health in men costing Scotland £1.73 billion a year, will the Scottish Government commit to producing a dedicated men’s health action plan, so that more men can live longer, healthier and happier lives with their families?
I admire the moustaches that are popping up around the chamber. They give us women a chance to have a giggle.
On a serious note, Movember draws attention to pernicious health inequalities that affect men. Reducing health inequalities and supporting people to live longer, healthier and more fulfilling lives remains a clear ambition for the Government. The population health framework that we published in June 2025 sets out our whole-system approach to improving population health and reducing inequalities over the next decade. The focus, rather than being on the development of a separate, stand-alone men’s health strategy, must be more immediately on ensuring that we work across all health policies to address inequalities and plug any potential gaps in support.
Although I did not have the courage to grow a moustache this month, I am a staunch supporter of Movember and was glad to facilitate a fringe meeting with the minister at the Scottish National Party conference.
The minister will be aware that, in 2024, 518 men died by probable suicide. That is nearly three times the rate for women in this country, and that number is still stubbornly high. What more can be done to reduce the rate of suicide among men and women?
Every suicide is a tragedy with a far-reaching impact on family, friends and the wider community. With an increased suicide prevention budget of £3 million this year, we are intensifying our efforts to reach people who are at higher risk of suicide, including men, who, as the member states, accounted for nearly three quarters of suicides in 2025.
Our aim is for any child, young person or adult who has thoughts of taking their own life, or who is affected by suicide in any way, to get the help that they need and feel a sense of hope. We are determined to address the stubborn trend of male suicide, and we continue to test new and creative ways to reach and support men. For that reason, we are investing in peer support across Scotland’s communities, knowing that it can work well for many men.
Women’s Rugby
To ask the Scottish Government what steps can be taken to support the growth of women’s rugby, in light of its reported contribution to physical health, mental wellbeing and community engagement. (S7O-00545)
The member knows that that is a question after my own heart. However, the whole Scottish Government recognises the positive impact of sport and physical activity for women and girls, and we remain committed to closing the gendered gap in participation.
Scottish Rugby will soon publish its new women and girls strategy for 2026 to 2030, which will help to accelerate growth in the game. We will continue to work with Scottish Rugby to support the strategy’s implementation and the wider development of the women’s and girls’ game. Increasing participation and visibility remains a priority. We want to build on the growing profile of women’s rugby, and wider sports, to inspire more women and girls to get involved.
Our commitment to addressing gender inequality in sport is reflected through our signing of the International Working Group on Women’s Sport’s “Brighton plus Helsinki 2014 Declaration on Women and Sport”, our Scottish women and girls in sport week campaign and the recently established project 2035 girls’ and women’s football taskforce.
Bishopton Rugby Football Club, in my constituency—which has recently, for the first time in its history, elected a woman as its club president—has introduced a postpartum plan to help women to return to rugby safely, in recognition of the importance of supporting their physical recovery alongside their emotional and mental wellbeing. Does the minister agree that recognition should be given to the role of community rugby clubs in supporting the health and wellbeing of women and girls through participation opportunities, health education initiatives and programmes that support women throughout the different stages of their lives, including when they return to sport after pregnancy? Will she join me on a visit to Bishopton rugby club to hear more about the fantastic work that it does and, possibly, to participate in a wee practice when her diary allows?
The concept of short, sharp questions and answers has been lost on some members this afternoon. A lot of people are not going to get in with their supplementaries.
I would be delighted to join Michelle Campbell. The Scottish Government recognises the important role that sport and physical activity play in supporting the health and wellbeing of women and girls throughout their lives.
I congratulate Bishopton rugby club on the appointment of its female president. Strong female leadership in sport provides visible role models who can motivate, promote and inspire women and girls to participate in sport and stay active. I am also delighted to hear about the club’s postpartum plan, which supports women to return to rugby safely. I would welcome the opportunity to visit the club and hear more about that fantastic initiative.
I declare an interest in that I am a—now part-time—coach and referee and a passionate supporter of girls’ and boys’ rugby. I agree that it has significant emotional and physical benefits for a diverse cohort of young people.
Are we giving certain clubs preferential access to resources, which is drawing young players away from other clubs? That would risk reducing participation opportunities for young people and undermining the long-term sustainability of grass-roots rugby. Does the minister share my concern that we are at risk of placing too great a priority on developing elite player pathways at the expense of grass-roots participation for all?
I would be more than happy to hear about the substance of the concerns behind Duncan Dunlop’s question. I assure him that, when I have had conversations with Scottish Rugby, it has been focused on enhancing grass-roots rugby. It has a strategy to encourage women and girls into rugby, which will be published very soon, and I am keen to work with it on its aim of increasing participation in rugby among women, girls, boys and men. As Duncan Dunlop knows, we share a love of that sport, and I would be keen to work with him on that issue.
Schools (Allotments and Food Education)
To ask the Scottish Government how it is supporting schools to develop allotments and food growing spaces, including what steps it is taking to ensure that pupils gain practical knowledge and experience of food production through the curriculum. (S7O-00546)
Food education is an integral part of the curriculum for excellence. Our refreshed learning estate strategy, which we co-produced with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, encourages diverse outdoor spaces that can support activities such as food growing. That sits alongside proposals to update the School Premises (General Requirements and Standards) (Scotland) Regulations 1967, in which questions about horticulture areas and more have been considered.
To complement all that work, this year, we have provided £310,000 to the Royal Highland Education Trust to deliver practical food and farming education, with farm visits for up to 18,000 pupils and digital learning that reaches more than 80,000 young people.
The Good Food Nation (Scotland) Act 2022 has the potential to transform our nation’s relationships to and with food, creating links to health and environmental stewardship. Schools have a vital role to play in embedding those values in children at an early age. What guidance will be available to schools to support the involvement of children and young people in the development of good food plans, to ensure that their views are properly reflected in that work?
We expect that the views of children and young people are always taken into account in relation to matters that concern them. Children’s voices have already helped to shape Scotland’s first national good food nation plan through a dedicated consultation, which was designed specifically for school-aged young people.
Health and Wellbeing (Men and Boys)
To ask the Scottish Government what steps it is taking to support the health and wellbeing of men and boys. (S7O-00547)
The Scottish Government is taking targeted action to improve the health and wellbeing of men and boys, alongside its whole-system approach through the population health framework. That includes targeted marketing of the “Be the Early Bird” cancer campaign, which has reached more than two million men; continued support for the Scottish Men’s Sheds Association to tackle isolation and loneliness; and investment in the “Changing room—extra time” programme, which uses football to help men look after their mental health.
The Scottish Government is also improving prostate cancer care through the new national clinical management pathway. We are working to implement the United Kingdom National Screening Committee’s recommendation on prostate screening for men who are at higher genetic risk. In 2026-27, the Scottish Government’s £160 million alcohol and drugs strategic plan, and an additional £40 million investment in sport and physical activity, will further support better outcomes, including for men and boys.
Today marks international men’s day. Promoting healthier men and boys and positive masculinity goes hand in hand with the Government’s priority of tackling violence against women and girls, and it benefits our families, communities and workplaces across the country.
I am disappointed, though, that the minister and the Government have ruled out introducing a health plan for men and boys, when we have the “Women’s Health Plan” for women and girls. That needs to change, and I hope that the minister will think again about that.
Will the minister also commit to building a wider agenda on men’s and boys’ health, including by considering having a dedicated champion for men and boys and by supporting the proposed advisory council on men and boys?
I am certainly open to having continued conversations on the issue. I recognise the challenges that men and boys face. In our mortality statistics, they are overrepresented in alcohol, drug, suicide, cardiovascular and cancer deaths. There is a lot of work that we can do together, and I am more than happy to continue conversations about how best we can tackle the issue. As I said, we have a programme of work across the piece that reaches the whole population, which will benefit the men who are overrepresented in those statistics.
The minister knows that the healthy life expectancy for males—that is, the number of years during which somebody will, on average, be healthy—has declined from 62.2 years in 2015 to 59.1 years in 2023. That is across all classes, although poorer people have a much worse outcome. What research work will the Government undertake to look into that issue?
The Government works with some brilliant academics in Scotland, not least those at the Glasgow Centre for Population Health, who help to inform Government policy. We have world-recognised experts in suicide prevention working in our academia, who also work with us to inform Government policy. We do not commission research directly from those people, but we take their learning and incorporate it into our policy where we can. For that reason, our policy in Scotland is far more robust than it would be without such input.
Rail Infrastructure Works (Outsourcing)
To ask the Scottish Government what discussions it has had with the United Kingdom Government and Network Rail concerning ending the outsourcing of rail infrastructure works. (S7O-00548)
Despite the Scottish Government providing Network Rail with £4.2 billion of funding between 2024 and 2029, it is not accountable to Scottish ministers—it is accountable to Labour Party ministers through the Department for Transport. However, I am happy to explore engaging with UK Labour ministers on Katy Clark’s behalf, if she would like me to do so.
The National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers—RMT—has written to the Scottish Government to set out ways in which savings can be made, including by bringing Network Rail Scotland’s renewal work in house, which the RMT estimates could save up to £140 million a year.
Will the Scottish Government and Network Rail engage with the RMT on those proposals? I would be happy to work with the cabinet secretary to make representations to the UK Government, if that would be helpful.
I am always happy to engage proactively and constructively with the RMT. It has made a thoughtful contribution. I think that I am meant to be meeting with the RMT soon. I am sure that this matter will be a discussion point between us.
Does the cabinet secretary share the concern of many ScotRail employees that they often bear the brunt of passenger frustration that two thirds of delays are due to problems caused entirely by faulty or damaged Network Rail infrastructure? Does he agree that it is time that Network Rail’s infrastructure was devolved and integrated with ScotRail to ensure that the people of Scotland have full control over our railways?
Patricia Gibson makes a very good point. I can update members on some of those matters. I wrote to the UK Government’s Minister for Rail, Lord Hendy, following Mr Burnham becoming Prime Minister and telling us all that he was in favour of further devolution, to ask that those additional rail powers be devolved to Scotland. Unsurprisingly, I received a negative response to that request, which shows that, although Mr Burnham is keen to talk the talk on devolution, when it comes to taking action, he is very much found wanting.
Publicly Supported Organisations (Scrutiny and Accountability)
To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on whether publicly supported organisations with policy and political ambitions should be open to scrutiny and accountability. (S7O-00549)
The Government funds a broad range of organisations to deliver agreed services and outcomes for the public, with regular monitoring and reporting to ensure successful delivery of their projects. An organisation that is supported by public funds should be open to scrutiny and accountability at the appropriate level, but it should not be restricted from advocating for or against a change in policy or participating in political debate simply because it receives public funding for a project.
Since 2020, the Scottish Refugee Council has received more than £10.6 million in public funding, but just two weeks ago, in this very building, it was pushing what can, at best, be described as highly dubious political points. Its objectives incentivise serious organised crime groups to ship their customers across the English Channel in the hope that they will come to Scotland. Does the cabinet secretary share my frustration at the use of taxpayers’ money to push a dangerous and highly politicised agenda?
What I have frustration about—[Interruption.]
Excuse me, cabinet secretary. Will members stop all these individual conversations while we are trying to hear the cabinet secretary respond to a question? I am surprised to hear that from members who are themselves keen to ask supplementary questions this afternoon but are willing to talk while others are answering questions.
Sorry, cabinet secretary—please start again.
I have real frustration with members of Reform coming to the chamber to accuse organisations that are well respected in public discourse of coming to Parliament and sharing their views. Perhaps Reform members are uncomfortable because the Scottish Refugee Council came here to ensure that MSPs had information to hand—not the disinformation that is spread by Reform and not the attacks on people in our communities that are spread by Reform.
My frustration, if I have any, is with members who come here and accuse people—I think that I heard an accusation that the Scottish Refugee Council has an association with organised crime. We are getting to the point of ridiculousness. My frustration lies in how Reform members are quite happy to come here and accuse people of things with no evidence, yet they themselves have an impact on communities, which suffer because of the division that they spread.
Mental Health Service (Rural Areas)
To ask the Scottish Government what further support it will provide for rural mental health services. (S7O-00550)
Rural mental health services are a priority for the Government, which is why we established the national rural and islands mental health forum in partnership with Change Mental Health.
The communities mental health and wellbeing fund for adults has a specific focus on supporting rural communities. Since 2021, we have invested £99 million in the fund, supporting projects across Scotland, including more than 1,100 in rural and island areas.
In addition, we support a number of rural and farming organisations to provide mental health support, including the Royal Scottish Agricultural Benevolent Institution, which provides counselling, suicide prevention support and mental health training for agricultural workers. Next year, we will double our existing funding to Farmstrong Scotland for the continued development of its wellbeing programme for the farming and crofting sectors.
People in rural communities often face acute problems in accessing mental health support. Where there is support, such as that provided by Change Mental Health, it is invaluable, but a lack of services, recruitment issues, digital exclusion and transport challenges all act as barriers.
Last year, Farmstrong Scotland reported that around a third of our farmers are dealing with low wellbeing, so more needs to be done. Will the Scottish Government commit to working with stakeholders, people in rural areas and interested MSPs to deliver a dedicated rural mental health strategy across this parliamentary session?
As I said in my first answer, we certainly recognise the challenges that rural communities face. I, too, represent a rural community, and I am very aware of the issues that Finlay Carson has described. I am more than happy to work with him and stakeholders to tackle those and ensure equity of access to the high-quality care that people in more urban areas can expect.
In September, I raised concerns about the mental health impact of bluetongue on farmers in south-west Scotland, a concern that was supported by research into previous livestock disease outbreaks. The Minister for Agriculture, Marine and the Islands pointed to Scottish Government funding for the Royal Scottish Agricultural Benevolent Institution—RSABI—as evidence of the support being provided. Subsequent correspondence identified only nationwide funding, with no specific provision identified for farmers in bluetongue-affected areas. Will the Scottish Government consider providing dedicated mental health funding for farmers and other agriculture-based professionals affected by future livestock disease outbreaks?
I certainly recognise the challenge that the member describes, and I am more than happy to work with her on the issue. Although agriculture is not my speciality, I am aware that a number of challenges face our farming and crofting community that would require a specific response, including a mental wellbeing response. I am happy to work with the member in future on all those issues facing our farming and crofting community.
That concludes general questions. My apologies to the many members I was unable to take for supplementaries.