Official Report 162KB pdf
14:05
The next item of business is general question time. A lot of members are keen to ask supplementaries, so I would appreciate short, sharp questions and answers.
Housing Supply
I refer members to my registered interest as a Falkirk councillor.
To ask the Scottish Government what progress is being made towards addressing Scotland’s housing emergency, including what discussions it has had with all stakeholders to increase house building across all tenures. (S7O-00507)
The Scottish Government has taken action to address immediate pressures by delivering a co-ordinated national response that is helping families to access permanent homes and helping to increase the housing supply across Scotland. Housing remains a key priority for the Government, and that ambition is supported by investment of up to £4.9 billion over the next four years, including a record £4.1 billion of public sector funding to support the delivery of around 36,000 affordable homes.
We continue to work closely and collaboratively with a range of housing partners, including councils, housing associations and the house building industry, to deliver more homes across Scotland.
Over the past four years, as housing portfolio holder at Falkirk Council, I became acutely aware of the financial challenges in bringing forward housing projects such as the 137 social homes that are currently being built in Denny. Those financial challenges will affect all tenures of housing. With recent news that general inflation is likely to rise to 5 per cent and remain there, does the cabinet secretary agree that action has to be taken by the United Kingdom Government as a matter of urgency to support house building across Scotland? Can she outline any further steps that the Scottish Government can take to support private and social housing in Scotland?
I agree with the member that rising costs and wider economic pressures present significant challenges to the delivery of homes across tenures. That is the context that we are in, and the example that Gary Bouse gives from Denny is an important one.
The Scottish Government will continue to do all that it can within its powers and resources to support housing delivery. Obviously, the Government will work with the Scottish National Investment Bank and support private investors to find opportunities in Scotland. However, the UK Government must also take action to provide greater economic stability—indeed, any economic stability—and tackle inflationary pressures. That will create the conditions that will support housing investment across Scotland and the UK.
Across the west Highlands, a significant hurdle to small rural housing developments is the cost of essential infrastructure, including improving road junctions and water and sewage connections. What will the cabinet secretary do to provide additional support to overcome those costs and help to get much-needed rural homes built?
The Government has a number of rural and island housing support grants that can assist with provision in rural and island areas. Obviously, we have benchmarking in the affordable housing supply programme, but that is there as a benchmark and not a ceiling, because we recognise the additional costs of building in rural and island communities. The planning minister is very conscious of the challenges that are faced in rural and island communities. As she is doing her work to see what can be done to simplify and assist house builders and others, that issue is another area that will be taken into consideration.
I recognise the ambition and the progress that the Government is making in addressing the housing emergency, but what reassurance can the cabinet secretary offer areas such as mine that rurality will be given sufficient weight as a factor when designing schemes through more homes Scotland to reflect the increased costs and difficulty of building in areas such as Midlothian and the Borders?
Calum Kerr raises an important point. Recently, I had a useful meeting with South of Scotland Enterprise to discuss the issues that he touched on regarding his constituency, which of course apply across the Borders and also Dumfries and Galloway. I also had an exceptionally useful meeting recently with Mull and Iona Community Trust, which was attended by the constituency member, Jenni Minto, and I also attended the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations rural and islands housing conference to talk about how we can use our new agency, more homes Scotland, and the specific workstream that it is developing on rural and island housing to support greater levels of house building in those areas.
There are more than 180,000 pending applications for social housing across Scotland, with 19,000 households in temporary accommodation and more than 4,000 people sleeping on the streets. How is the Scottish Government working to increase social housing availability to meet that need, and how will households who are in temporary accommodation and sleeping rough be supported into long-term accommodation, so that we can finally eradicate homelessness in Scotland?
I will provide some examples of how we are looking to ensure that we make the best use of our current stock. The Scottish Government is working to support the Scottish Empty Homes Partnership to ensure that empty homes across different communities in Scotland are brought back into use, and it will be even better if that can be done in a way that provides affordable housing. The number of applications to and starts in the affordable housing supply programme is also increasing, which is welcome as we build up the pace to support the provision of new homes and do more work to support the current and existing stock.
Inquiry into White Working Class Educational Outcomes
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the first phase of the independent inquiry into white working class educational outcomes, including whether there are any comparable themes in Scotland. (S7O-00508)
As I wrote on 24 July in response to Mr Kerr’s very similar written question, we do not measure attainment or educational outcomes by class in Scotland. However, we measure them by deprivation using the Scottish index of multiple deprivation, and we use several key policies, not least the Scottish attainment challenge, to mitigate the impact of poverty on educational outcomes. Those policies have collectively resulted in important progress being made in closing the poverty-related attainment gap. Notably, that includes reducing the gap for young people who leave school and go on to a positive initial destination by almost two thirds since 2009-10.
Today’s long-awaited Milburn report, which shows that almost 1 million 16 to 24-year-olds across Britain are being left behind, will make for a sobering read for countless Labour, Tory and Scottish National Party politicians. We already know that Scotland’s attainment gap is wider than it was before the pandemic, and the cabinet secretary must surely recognise that there is a systemic problem with educational outcomes for white children from working-class backgrounds. Will the Scottish Government therefore commit to a dedicated inquiry to specifically examine the educational attainment of white working-class pupils in order to understand why they continue to be left behind, or will the cabinet secretary continue to leave a generation of young Scots on the dole with no hope, aspiration or opportunity?
I care about white children as much as I care about working-class children and every young person and child in this country regardless of their social or demographic background and regardless of their race or ethnicity. Alan Milburn’s report is extensive, and the Government will take our time to consider its recommendations as they pertain to education and skills and social security.
For my part, which is in the education portfolio, I can see that a great deal of what Mr Milburn is recommending for England is aligned with what the SNP has been pursuing in Scotland for many years. We have pursued a strong mix of vocational and academic qualifications and pathways from school, a broad general education in the early years and close alignment between schools and colleges, and it now looks as though recommendations are being made for England to follow suit. Young people have been waiting an awful long time for a UK Government to realise that such action is required.
The independent inquiry highlighted the importance of early identification of literacy difficulties. In light of those findings, will the Scottish Government consider introducing a statutory national phonics screening check for all primary school children in Scotland, similar to the phonics screening check that is used in England, to identify children who might be falling behind at an early stage and ensure that they receive the right support at the right time, in keeping with the principles of getting it right for every child?
I welcome Amanda Bland’s reference to and endorsement of getting it right for every child. It goes to the heart of what I said to Mr Kerr, because it is about every child and not only those that he would pick and choose to care about from one moment to the next.
Amanda Bland knows, because we have had exchanges on this before, that our curriculum is undergoing the biggest update since the inception of curriculum for excellence, and that includes literacy, including in the earliest years, and consideration of phonics. That work is under way. Education Scotland has just published the first extensive draft of the new framework, and I encourage Amanda Bland to engage with that process.
Early Learning and Childcare (Expansion of Eligibility)
To ask the Scottish Government what progress it has made in considering extending eligibility for funded early learning and childcare from age two to children from multiple births. (S7O-00509)
We recognise that childcare costs can be a challenge for families and that they can have a particular impact on families with multiple births. As the Minister for Children, Young People and The Promise, Siobhian Brown, set out in a response to Monica Lennon in the chamber in October, we are developing a blueprint for childcare transformation, which will be published and consulted on next year. I assure Mr Day that the question of the extra costs that accrue to families with multiple births will be part of that work, and I encourage everyone with an interest to participate in the consultation.
I welcome the Scottish Government’s commitment to expanding childcare to support family incomes and help parents across employment. However, that transformation will take time. Meanwhile, families with twins, triplets or other multiples face the immediate costs of paying for several childcare places at once. Ahead of the wider expansion, will the cabinet secretary consider making multiple birth status an eligibility criterion for funded early learning and childcare from the age of two? Will she set out when a decision on that could be reached?
I affirm that, as I said in my earlier answer, the extra costs that accrue to families with multiple births will be taken into account, along with rurality and families with children who have additional support requirements and disabilities. The experience of all those families in accessing the 1,140 hours offer, which was significant and which we have successfully rolled out, is being taken into account as we consider the transformation and the Government’s commitment to extend the childcare offer from the age of nine months until primary 7. As I said, the minister is developing that blueprint and will set it out for consultation.
Although consideration of that expansion is welcome, providers across Scotland continue to raise concerns that the funding rates do not accurately reflect the costs of delivery. The National Day Nurseries Association has noted that 93 per cent of providers say that the sustainable rates do not cover delivery costs. Will the cabinet secretary give a commitment to review the sustainable rates setting process before introducing any further childcare expansion?
Alongside the question of who may access the provision and how, the minister will consider the rates and a range of other matters as part of the transformation. However, it is worth putting on the record that, under the jointly agreed funding follows the child framework—we believe strongly in that principle—local authorities are responsible for setting rates that reflect the costs of delivery. Sustainable rates have increased by more than 87 per cent during the 1,140 hours expansion, with more than 90 per cent of workers who deliver funded ELC now being paid more than the real living wage.
I will welcome the opportunity to scrutinise the blueprint when it arrives. However, the cabinet secretary will be aware of other issues with the current provision of funded childcare, such as the workforce; rates per child, which have just been mentioned; cross-boundary arrangements; and term-time start dates—and the list goes on. In order to give confidence to nursery providers and parents, will she update Parliament on the work that is being undertaken right now to resolve the issues before any announcement is made about the expansion of childcare?
The member knows and, I think, understands that the Government’s expectation is that local authorities should be putting in place cross-boundary arrangements. I emphasised our funding follows the child principle in my response to Claire Baker. That is our expectation, and a number of local authorities manage that very well.
I understand that the question whether children start at the age of three is difficult for parents across Scotland. We have committed to looking at that as part of the transformation. I have said on the record before that there can be practical difficulties, such as having new starts every Monday, as some providers have put it to me. Rates, wages and workforce availability are being closely considered by the Government.
Tenement Buildings (Maintenance)
To ask the Scottish Government when it plans to introduce legislation on tenement maintenance. (S7O-00510)
I remain committed to taking action to deliver the changes that are needed to support owners and ensure that common property is protected and preserved for the benefit of future generations. The Government is in the early stages of the work and will explore the issues that have been raised in the Scottish Law Commission’s report, as well as engaging with key stakeholders on potential next steps. I am not in a position to provide a timetable for that work yet, but I commit to updating the Parliament as the work progresses.
The tenement maintenance working group was established in March 2018, which was more than eight and a half years ago. Its final recommendations were published in June 2019 and the Scottish Law Commission reported on compulsory owners associations in December 2025, which was almost one year ago. This parliamentary session will end in 2031. If it takes until then for legislation to be passed, it will have been 13 years since the group was established. It could take even longer than that for any action, which is little comfort to the owners of a crumbling tenement block in Glasgow’s south side. The cabinet secretary knows all about that; those residents have been out of their homes for more than a year.
The member needs to ask a question, please.
Given the length of time that has elapsed, will the cabinet secretary agree to meet me and other interested members in order to see how we can move the issue forward collectively?
I hope that Graham Simpson will be pleased to know that I have met officials in the past couple of weeks to discuss how that work can be taken forward. In that meeting, I discussed how important it was that we linked with the members of the working group on tenement maintenance, as well as new members who may not have been involved to date but have a particular interest in the issues.
I am always delighted to meet Mr Simpson to discuss housing issues. We will endeavour to ensure that members who wish to take part can provide their views in a timely manner so that they are taken into consideration as I develop the work.
Lots of members are keen to come in, but time is running away from us. I will take one more supplementary.
We know that tenement and four in a block-style properties can have multiple owners and often struggle to organise and finance shared repairs, maintenance and enhancement work. Can the cabinet secretary tell us more about the work that the Scottish Government is taking forward to enable repairs, maintenance and environmental enhancements to such properties?
The Government is looking at the work that was undertaken by the SLC and the recommendations in its report, as well as the work of the working group, which I referenced in my answer to Graham Simpson. It is important that we look at the legislative changes that are required, as well as noting that there would be a change for property owners. It is important for us to recognise that issue so that we get the work right, which is why I will keep members up to date.
M8 Woodside Eastbound Viaduct
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on the progress of the M8 Woodside eastbound viaduct. (S7O-00511)
Extensive and essential concrete repairs are required to joints. We anticipate that the eastbound carriageway will reopen in early 2027 and we expect the westbound works to be completed in the second half of next year.
It is opportune that I update the Parliament that we expect the costs of the completed project to be in the region of £175 million to £185 million. I thank Pauline McNeill for her continued interest in the matter and I thank residents, businesses and commuters for their continued patience while the essential works are undertaken.
I hope that the cabinet secretary shares my disappointment, because the road was supposed to be opened in autumn 2026 after five years of work. I was not aware, but I now know, that the road will be opened in the early part of 2027.
Will the cabinet secretary commit today to giving the public and my constituents better engagement with Transport Scotland on the progress on this very important road? I know that he shares my view on the critical importance of the M8 for the east and west of Scotland, but it is about time that we had more up-to-date information on when the road will be complete.
Like me, Pauline McNeill has been under the viaduct and seen the extent of the essential works that have been required. She will be cognisant of the issues that relate to the existence of a sewer in a place that was not anticipated, the proximity of the Strathclyde Partnership for Transport subway and the need to ensure that that remains safe, and the procurement challenges that undoubtedly exist because of global matters. If there is more work to be done, I will be quite happy to engage with the member. I share her disappointment, but we anticipate the eastbound carriageway being opened in early 2027. I hope that that is some comfort to road users, residents and businesses, who I know want the work to be completed as quickly as possible.
School Assessments (Priorities)
To ask the Scottish Government when it will produce a plan on priorities for school assessments, including the reintroduction of the Scottish survey of literacy and numeracy. (S7O-00512)
During our debate on education on 11 November, it was clear that there is a great deal of common ground across the chamber, and I was very pleased that Parliament backed a position that means that we are not tied to one approach, including the Scottish survey, but instead agreed to engagement on those matters. I will reach out to members across the chamber to have those conversations shortly.
Scottish Labour is very clear that the change is needed now, so will the cabinet secretary outline when the cross-party talks will start, so that we do not see reforms being kicked into the long grass?
There is no sense whatsoever from this Government of reforms being kicked into the long grass. As a Government, we are poised and taking forward reform across the public sector under the First Minister’s public service reform agenda.
We do not agree that the Scottish survey is the best route. That would involve returning to something that, at the time, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development was clear did not offer specificity, and I want specificity on the data in our education system. I will reach out to members shortly, and we can have a full discussion about the right approach.
Community Health Services (NHS Lanarkshire)
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on plans to expand community health services across NHS Lanarkshire as part of its wider shift towards preventative healthcare. (S7O-00513)
Our programme for government sets out a clear commitment to shift the balance of care closer to home by strengthening community support and bringing services together around people and places. Our community first preventative approach will be supported by investment in community health and care hubs and the improved use, maintenance and sustainability of community assets, including general practitioner premises, community hospitals, community centres and the wider public sector estate. That will be nationally enabled but locally designed and delivered, ensuring that services reflect the specific needs of local areas, such as Lanarkshire, to reduce inequalities and support the sustainability of community health and social care services for the future.
Like the minister, I note that more community facilities are key to reducing the pressure on acute services in our national health service and across our public sector. In my constituency, there has been a commitment for investment in a community health hub and GP walk-in centre in Hamilton. Can the minister provide an update on progress towards delivery of that development?
Although there are not currently plans for a walk-in service in Hamilton, I am sure that Alex Kerr will be very vociferous in lobbying for one. NHS Lanarkshire is taking forward plans to expand walk-in services across Lanarkshire, including new services in East Kilbride and North Lanarkshire.
Care Homes (Emergency Preparedness)
To ask the Scottish Government, with regard to recent United Kingdom Government advice that households should prepare for emergencies with three days of supplies and for power outages, what assessment it has made of the preparedness of care homes in Scotland. (S7O-00514)
Scotland already promotes emergency preparedness through Ready Scotland, which provides advice and guidance to help individuals, communities and businesses to prepare for and respond to emergencies and disruption. Care homes are expected to have appropriate emergency preparedness, business continuity and contingency arrangements in place to support the safety and wellbeing of residents during disruptive events, including severe weather, power outages and other emergencies. Relevant national resilience and preparedness guidance is available through Ready Scotland and wider Scottish resilience arrangements.
I have personally asked care homes what their arrangements are, and they have said that the power providers would bring in generators. However, what will care homes be expected to do if there is a major power outage? The power companies would not have enough generators. If the Government does not know the percentage of care homes that have their own arrangements, will it ask the Care Inspectorate to look into the situation before the worst of winter comes?
I appreciate Helen McDade’s concerns. However, Scottish care homes are expected to have robust business continuity and emergency plans that address power outages and ensure that residents can continue to receive safe care. The health and care standards are expected to be maintained at all times, and the Care Inspectorate, as the independent regulator, is responsible for the inspection and enforcement of those standards.
That concludes general question time. I apologise to the many members whom I was unable to take this afternoon.
Previous
Business Motion