Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 18:48]

Meeting date: Thursday, November 19, 2026


Contents


Prevention and Preventative Budgeting

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Katy Clark)

The next item of business is a debate on motion S7M-02089, in the name of Ivan McKee, on prevention and preventative budgeting.

Members who wish to speak should press their request-to-speak button now. There will be a short pause to allow members on the front benches to take their places.

I ask members to note that the debate is starting late due to both First Minister’s question time and Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body questions running late. It would therefore be helpful if speakers could speak within the time limits that they have agreed with their business managers.

15:02

The Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform (Ivan McKee)

I am delighted to open the debate on prevention and preventative budgeting.

Prevention is central to how we improve outcomes for the people of Scotland, sustain the public services on which we all rely and ensure that our public finances remain sustainable for the future. That is why prevention lies at the heart of our public service reform strategy and the Government’s wider programme for this parliamentary session.

The debate comes at an important moment. As we look ahead to the budget, we have an opportunity to consider how a more preventative approach to budgeting and investment can help us to make the shift to directing resources towards better long-term outcomes.

I begin by recognising that prevention is not a new idea. It is one of the core principles of the work of the Christie commission, and it has deep roots in Scottish policy making, with support spanning political parties, public services, the third sector and communities.

Although the principle is well established, the imperative to act has never been stronger. Scotland is facing significant and growing pressures. Demand for public services is rising, and the needs of those who access them are becoming increasingly complex. Demographic change, persistent inequalities and wider economic pressures are placing further strain on our services and communities. At the same time, the public finances within which we must respond remain under considerable pressure.

Those challenges are not unique to Scotland. Governments around the world face the same fundamental challenge of how to improve outcomes for people while ensuring that public services remain high quality, effective and financially sustainable for the future.

The good news is that Scotland already has strong foundations on which to build. Our evidence report, “Learning from 25 years of Preventative Interventions in Scotland”, which was published last year, shows that we have considerable experience of turning the principle of prevention into practical action. Examples include the family nurse partnership, backed by strong international evidence showing the benefits of investing early to improve outcomes and reduce future demand. It has increased breastfeeding, supported earlier identification of developmental concerns and strengthened connections to community support. Another example is minimum unit pricing, which has significantly reduced the number of deaths from alcohol and lowered pressure on hospitals in Scotland. A 4 per cent reduction in the number of alcohol-related admissions is attributable to that policy.

Adam Harley (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (LD)

The cabinet secretary will be aware that delayed discharge is costing Scotland at least £1.2 million every day, keeping people in hospital who do not want or medically need to be there. Does he agree that investment in social care in the community as a means of creating long-term savings would be a fantastic form of preventative spending in the health portfolio?

Ivan McKee

Yes, I agree. We wrestle with the challenge of why we still have 2,000 people in delayed discharge, at a cost per day that is significantly higher than it would be if those people were in a different setting. The challenge that we face is how to align resources so that they are in the right place, where they can make a difference. I absolutely agree, which is why the Government is looking at how we can make changes to how we organise social care, to support getting the right money in the right place.

I turn back to our “Learning from 25 years of Preventative Interventions in Scotland” document. Our cashback for communities programme has supported young people to move away from antisocial and criminal behaviour. In 2025-26, more than 8,000 young people reported reduced involvement in antisocial or criminal behaviour through the programme, which is helping to prevent those who are most at risk from entering the justice system.

We are building on that track record through our invest to save fund. Almost £30 million of investment that was approved for 2026-27 is forecast to deliver around £170 million-worth of benefits over five years through prevention, cashable savings, cost avoidance and wider reform.

Taken together, those examples demonstrate a simple but powerful truth: prevention works.

Craig Hoy (Dumfriesshire) (Con)

Scotland’s drug deaths should be our national shame, yet, in the previous session of Parliament, the Government voted down Douglas Ross’s Right to Addiction Recovery (Scotland) Bill. If it is committed to prevention rather than cure, why did it do that?

Ivan McKee

Craig Hoy is well aware that the Government is taking forward a range of interventions backed by significant investment to address the challenge that he raises.

By acting earlier and tackling underlying causes, we can improve outcomes for people and reduce pressure on our public services. The challenge now is to make those successes the norm instead of the exception.

As our public service reform strategy recognises, we cannot be satisfied with progress at the margins. We must accelerate the shift towards prevention and make it a defining feature of how public services are planned, funded and delivered across Scotland. That means understanding and addressing the barriers that too often stand in the way of preventative action, including siloed services and budgets and a complex services landscape that delays support.

We need to work more effectively across organisational and portfolio boundaries, align around shared outcomes and create greater flexibility to invest early when we know that that can improve lives and reduce future demand on services. Put simply, we need to make prevention easier to deliver, easier to fund and easier to sustain. That is why prevention sits at the heart of our reform agenda. Our ambition is not simply to deliver more preventative programmes but to build a system in which prevention shapes how services are designed, resources are allocated and investment decisions are made.

We have made significant progress through the public service reform strategy to move prevention from ambition into practical delivery. Central to that has been the establishment of the Government’s prevention unit to provide a clear focus, connecting activity across Government and partners and supporting prevention to be more of a routine part of planning, investing and budget decisions. One of the unit’s key areas of work has been advancing preventative budgeting, helping to ensure that spending decisions better reflect the long-term outcomes that we want to achieve.

Earlier this year, the unit developed and published a preventative budgeting tool and piloted it across roughly 40 per cent of the Scottish budget. That work identified around £3 billion of preventative spending across the areas that were examined, with preventative investment identified in every portfolio that was involved.

For the first time, we have a much clearer picture of where preventative investment is already happening, giving us a stronger evidence base and a baseline from which to make future spending decisions. We are now extending that approach across the full Scottish budget, so that the evidence can inform the 2027-28 budget process and future spending decisions.

The potential of the work extends well beyond central Government. We are supporting national health service boards and local authorities to apply the approach to their own budgets, helping them to better understand their preventative spend and to use that insight to inform future investment decisions.

We want to go further. In this year’s programme for government we announced the creation of the Scottish prevention investment framework, which will build on our preventative budgeting work to create a more systematic approach to identifying strong preventative investment opportunities, aligning them with public and external sources of funding and demonstrating their impact through better outcomes, reduced demand for services and long-term value for money.

Alongside that, we are developing social impact partnerships, bringing together public and private investment to pursue innovative preventative approaches to some of Scotland’s most complex social challenges. That sits alongside preventative action across the programme for government, supporting children and families going through homelessness, reducing reoffending and tackling the underlying causes of poor outcomes. That includes investment in measures such as the whole family wellbeing fund, the housing first approach and wider action to expand access to early intervention and support for those at risk of entering the justice system.

Together, those actions show that Scotland is not just talking about prevention; we are putting it into practice. The challenge is not simply to do more, but to work differently: aligning around shared outcomes, making better use of evidence and directing our combined resources towards the intervention that can have the greatest long-term impact. That is why we are investing in approaches that strengthen collaboration and local capacity, including our support for social enterprise, our commitment to community wealth building, our partnership work with the third sector and our commitment to fairer and more sustainable funding arrangements.

In the previous session, the Parliament unanimously backed the Community Wealth Building (Scotland) Bill, which I brought forward, recognising the importance of ensuring that wealth is generated, circulated and retained within our communities. That shows that prevention is not only about reforming public services; it is about working with businesses, anchor institutions and communities to address the root causes of poor outcomes, creating stronger local economies and more resilient places.

The opportunity before us is a shared one. Only by working together can we make further progress in delivering the shift towards prevention. However, we must recognise the challenges that we face in making that shift. When facing fiscal challenges viewed through the lens of siloed budgets, it is often too easy to reduce spending on the things that matter the most—the investments in prevention that deliver results elsewhere in the system at a future date. This is something that we need to guard against, and it is something that the preventative budget process will help us to identify. It is a matter of ensuring that that does not happen.

I believe that there is a shared purpose across the chamber: improving people’s lives, acting earlier where we can and ensuring that our public services remain sustainable for the future. The question before us is no longer whether prevention matters. It is how we make it happen at greater pace and on a greater scale to have the greatest impact; it is about how we address the systemic barriers.

We have evidence of what works, and we have strong foundations to build on. Now, we must accelerate the shift, turning prevention into better outcomes for people, stronger communities and more sustainable public services. That is the challenge—and indeed the opportunity—before us. I look forward to hearing members’ contributions.

I move,

That the Parliament recognises that accelerating the shift towards prevention is essential to improving outcomes for people and communities and securing the long-term sustainability of public services in Scotland; welcomes action through the Public Service Reform Strategy to embed prevention, including through the establishment of the Prevention Unit, the development of preventative budgeting approaches and the implementation of a Prevention Investment Framework; further welcomes the Scottish Government's work to shift to action, including support for families and childcare, action to improve population health through earlier intervention and more community-based care, and the exploration of investment approaches, such as Social Impact Partner’s Investment, which focus on early intervention and prevention, and supports continued collaboration across all levels of government, public services, communities, the third sector and other partners to make prevention a central principle of public service reform, budgeting and investment in Scotland.

15:13

Joe Fagan (South Scotland) (Lab)

I refer to my entry in the register of members’ interests as a serving councillor.

I welcome the cabinet secretary’s remarks and the recognition from the Government that prevention must be a central feature of our plans for the future of public services. We agree that services should be geared up to intervene earlier, and that we must tackle the underlying inequalities that drive so much service demand. We agree that prevention is essential both to the long-term sustainability of our public finances and to the long-term wellbeing of our country.

I start by inviting the Parliament to ask itself a question. How did Scotland go from being a pioneer in prevention to a country struggling with the consequences of a failure to prevent, a failure to innovate and a failure to reform, with the results today being so mixed?

There was a time when Scotland was ahead of the game—when, 20 years ago, the Kerr report on “Building a Health Service Fit for the Future” set out a vision for a modern health service to be built around anticipatory care, early intervention and supporting people closer to home. We knew then the scale of the demographic change that Scotland would face, and we knew that our health service had to shift the balance of care decisively towards communities. At much the same time, Strathclyde Police pioneered a public health approach to violent crime with the violence reduction unit. That was an exemplar in reform, with a legacy that endures today. Fifteen years ago, the Christie commission set out a compelling vision for the future of public services based on prevention and partnership and real empowerment.

Those were not timid ideas—they were ambitious, progressive and, in many respects, ahead of their time. They were underpinned by a hard and compelling logic that it is impossible to dispute: that prevention works. The vision behind prevention is not new, therefore, but Scotland has fallen short in delivering it, and that failure has had profound financial, social and human costs.

I do not deny the progress that has been made. There are excellent examples of preventative work taking place across the country. I chaired South Lanarkshire’s community planning partnership as we became one of only three Marmot pilots in Scotland, and I hope that that work can be expanded with Public Health Scotland and its partners. Tonight, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities is holding its annual excellence awards, giving national recognition to services that innovate and excel. The whole family support model is delivering on the ground, and I welcome the establishment of the prevention unit.

The real test of reform, however, is how services improve, and too many services are now in a weaker position than they were 15 years ago. There are more than 30,000 national health service waits that are longer than a year, six months on from a Government pledge to scrap them. The prison population is at a record high, and more than 10,000 children are going to bed tonight in temporary accommodation. Those are the outcomes that we need to change, and changing outcomes matters more than changing structures, because it means changing lives.

We hear a great deal about reorganising councils and the architecture of the state. Scottish Labour certainly believes in change, and in building regional power and rationalising the number of health boards, but changing boundaries on a map will not in itself change the life chances of our people. If it is the Scottish Government’s intention to merge public bodies, reduce the number of health boards, reform integration joint boards, redraw the council map and implement its education adviser’s report, all in one session of Parliament, I warn it that it will deprive services of the capacity that they need to drive real, deliverable progressive reform. That capacity has already been degraded through years of cuts and inaction.

Ivan McKee

This is a genuine question. We all recognise that a shift to prevention is important, but the challenge is always how we free up the resources to make that intervention while we are dealing with challenges day in, day out in providing services as a result of the current situation that we face. Does the member recognise that much of the work that we are taking forward on the rationalisation of public bodies and health boards, and our other work, is to remove duplication, share services and ensure that resources move into a space where we can use them for preventative interventions, rather than duplicating services and management layers across so many public bodies?

Joe Fagan

Yes, I do. The cabinet secretary will find an ally in the Scottish Labour Party where we agree that that is going to achieve results, but he will hear warnings from us, too, as he would expect. Saying so is not resistance to reform—it is a warning that Government needs to hear. It is a plea from those of us who want to achieve real reform.

If the Scottish Government does not rethink its approach on at least some of those issues, it will make it impossible to deliver the outcomes-focused reform that will bring the progressive, preventative agenda to life. The Government should make the changes that matter most.

The ill-timed—if I may say so, diplomatically—and maybe even incoherent approach to the local governance proposals will be an obstacle to reform. I think that there is a better way. It is finding what works, scaling it up, making a difference, delivering better outcomes and narrowing the fiscal gap at the same time, combining efficiency with social justice and liberating our public services from the costs of a failure to intervene and to innovate in years gone by. That is real public service reform. It comes from prevention, collaboration and empowerment, and from principles long established by the Christie commission and neglected for too long.

I welcome the growing prominence of early intervention and practical steps to embed preventative spending. I ask the Government to reflect on what more it can do to ensure that those who scrutinise public spending can track those preventative interventions to real outcomes, and I suggest that it does more to quantify the reactive spending that we have to bring down at a time when the public finances are strained because of those drivers of demand.

The Government’s invest to save fund is currently worth only £30 million, which is 0.04 per cent of the total budget, according to the Scottish Trades Union Congress. The Scottish Police Authority is warning that prevention could be scaled back, health and social care partnerships face a collective fiscal gap of £450 million this year, and many are divesting from prevention in order to sustain core services.

That is the reality right now. Faced with immediate fiscal pressures, Government demands for short-term savings and the expectation that they will deliver long-term change, public services are in a challenging position. That is what we have to work through: we have to create and preserve the capacity to scale up preventative spending while bringing down reactive spending. It is not easy, but it is necessary, and it is how we will make meaningful change.

The Government has a choice between real reform that leads to transformation or another five wasted years, 15 years on from the Christie commission. We have a moral responsibility to get this right and to turn a progressive majority in this Parliament into progressive action.

I appreciate that the member took a lengthy intervention, but he will need to wind up now.

Joe Fagan

I will finish simply by saying that we have to do more to track outcomes, to apply the principles of the Christie commission, to embed prevention and to bring meaningful change to people’s services and people’s lives.

I move amendment S7M02089.1, to insert at end:

“; notes that it is 15 years since the publication of the Christie Commission report on the future delivery of public services and that its vision has not been delivered to its full potential; believes that information on preventative spending and outcomes arising from such spending should be transparent and accessible, and considers that public service reform should prioritise prevention, improved outcomes and action to address the drivers of demand, including health inequalities, over administrative restructuring.”

I remind members who wish to speak that they should press their request-to-speak buttons.

I call David Smith to move and speak to amendment S7M-02089.3.

15:21

David Smith (West Scotland) (Reform)

I start by recognising the good intent behind the cabinet secretary’s motion. That prevention is better than cure is a principle that is very easy for everyone to understand and one that the whole Parliament can get behind. In her report from 2011, Dr Christie made a number of very clear, concise and unambiguous statements. In the first one that I will quote, she reflected on previous years:

“A cycle of deprivation and low aspiration has been allowed to persist because preventative measures have not been prioritised.”

That was written 15 years ago, but it is almost like it was written yesterday. Christie also stated clearly:

“I urge them to act quickly and decisively—as a society, we no longer have time for delay. I believe the way forward is clear and it is now essential that the Scottish Government exercises its leadership by initiating a fundamental public service reform process.”

I am encouraged that at least one member of the Scottish Government might have read that report and now seems to be acting on it.

When writing about the approach to reform, Christie stated:

“The need for reform is now urgent. If it is not substantially achieved in this Parliament, the chance to fashion an effective, sustainable and valued form of delivering public services for the future may be lost. We cannot allow the obstacles that have hampered reform in the past to thwart the action that is now required.”

Again, that was 15 years ago. I thank Dr Christie for her efforts in creating the report and express my apologies that my thanks come 15 years after the event.

That clear, concise and unambiguous statement was a warning to the Government. Now, let us consider where we are today with respect to our public services. General practitioners are in crisis; hospitals are in crisis; our ambulance services are in crisis; social care is in crisis; residential care services are in crisis; care-at-home services are in crisis; drug and alcohol services are in crisis; our mental health services are in crisis—I name but a few.

There are some obvious key points that I would like to make, but I have no doubt that others in the chamber will make the same points, so I will talk about something a little less obvious.

We are becoming a society where many people find themselves out of work and view the prospect of returning to work as hopeless. Right now, many people living on benefits or pensions are having to choose between heating and eating. Our cohort of young people who are not in education, employment or training, who have been a topic of much discussion lately, are particularly vulnerable to that collective sense of hopelessness. Of course, there are also those in work who are working every hour that they can to try to keep up with the cost of living. Many working people are not taking time off to spend time with their families, are not eating healthily, do not have hobbies, are living incredibly stressful lives, and are all falling into despair, with the result that they will eventually need help from our medical and social care professionals.

I do not want to portray work and resolving the cost of living as a silver bullet for everything, because that would be completely wrong. However, stress is an important factor and will continue to be a root cause of many conditions that drive people towards our medical and social care professionals. If we can recognise and prioritise these cohorts and target effective preventative spending in those areas, we will prevent a lot of additional spend and effort in the years that follow.

We need to recognise that, when we talk about preventative spending, or about work, creating jobs and growing the economy, we are talking about the same thing. As we enter the era of public service reform, we also need to recognise that there will be a period of instability to services as they are reformed and transitions take place. We must also ensure that, among all the crises that are engulfing our public services, we do not take Dr Christie’s report at face value. We are now 15 years into the future and the Government did not heed her warnings. If Dr Christie wrote a new report today, would she make the same statements?

Our motion calls for a simple, focused approach: we need to resolve the crises, stabilise services and then we can have a more focused conversation about prevention.

The Government motion simply does not contain enough detail for us to get behind it. I encourage all members to support the Reform amendment and I look forward to hearing contributions from across the chamber, because this is a very important issue.

I move amendment S7M-02089.3, to leave out from first “welcomes” to end, and insert:

“recognises the good intentions behind the Scottish Government’s prevention and preventative budgeting proposals, but expresses concern that there are no published outcomes against which progress can be assessed; agrees that effective scrutiny requires benchmarks for success to be defined in advance, and not subsequently and selectively choosing comparators that might only show an unduly positive outcome; recognises that, for preventative measures to be effective, measures that bring stability to services also need to be implemented; acknowledges that requiring frontline workers to follow additional new processes while they are working through a service crisis could be counterproductive, and further acknowledges that the current environment created by the cost of living crisis has a negative impact on mental and physical health in the workplace, and that measures to tackle the cost of living crisis can themselves constitute preventative measures that could reduce demand on public services.”

I call Lorna Slater to speak to and move amendment S7M-02089.2.

15:26

Lorna Slater (Edinburgh Central) (Green)

I will speak to and move the amendment in my name, and I am also happy to support the Labour amendment, particularly its reference to implementing the recommendations of the Christie commission.

The Scottish Greens have long campaigned for preventative spending—I can find it in our manifesto as far back as 2011. We want a healthy society, not one that just picks up the pieces. However, as the Public Service Reform Committee heard in evidence last week, nearly everything that Governments do could be considered preventative, so we need to be more specific about what we mean and about what outcomes we intend to achieve.

The case for preventative spending to improve health outcomes, particularly for conditions that affect so many Scots, is solid. Excellent measures that we can all support include increasing access to screening and early diagnosis programmes for cancer detection and cardiovascular risk, as well as creating a network of NHS, third sector and community services to identify and manage cardiovascular risk factors before more serious illness develops. In her closing remarks, my colleague Kayleigh Kinross-O’Neill will speak more about prevention in healthcare.

Ivan McKee

Lorna Slater makes the clear point that we need to be able to identify the correct type of prevention and that everything could be considered prevention, so she will welcome the work that is being taken forward by the prevention unit, whereby prevention has been categorised as primary, secondary or tertiary, with very clear definitions around those categories.

Lorna Slater

I do welcome that, and I look forward to seeing that work at the Public Service Reform Committee. We had a discussion about that, and understanding the Government’s position would be very helpful to us.

One of the key places where we can support the people of Scotland to thrive and deal with the challenges that they face before they hit crisis point is within local government. For example, again, last week at the Public Service Reform Committee, we heard what sounds like a really simple example. If councils spend additional resources on gritting pavements when it is icy, the NHS has fewer broken hips and wrists to treat, and we avoid the secondary costs of missed work and unavailable childcare. It sounds simple, but local government and the NHS are funded from different pots. Additional spending by local government might save money for the NHS and help the wider economy, but it does not help local governments to balance their budgets. When a council invests in early years support, homelessness prevention or active communities, the resulting financial savings often accrue in the NHS or the justice system rather than on the council’s own balance sheet.

With local government reform, we have the opportunity to build in structures to support councils and reward them for taking preventative measures, and we must take it. COSLA has consistently warned that single-year budget settlements and heavily ring-fenced national commitments restrict councils’ ability to plan multiyear preventative programmes or tailor interventions to local communities. For example, Scottish Borders Council committed to investing in early intervention in affordable housing by earmarking more than £2 million from second home council tax revenue. Yet, by November 2026, finance briefings forecast a £1.8 million overspend driven by acute crisis costs, which is forcing the council to balance long-term preventative capital build against immediate statutory pressures. We cannot implement preventative spending if Scottish councils are not adequately funded with multiyear funding and if they do not see the rewards of investing their own finances in prevention.

Another significant opportunity for prevention is in tackling poverty. Poverty is expensive. People who experience poverty, particularly when they are growing up, statistically have worse mental and physical health and suffer educational underachievement and increased worklessness, insecure employment and involvement with the criminal justice system. All those things are wildly expensive for us, as a society, to correct. Effectively tackling poverty and deprivation in the first place pays dividends to society and reduces the demands for the sort of crisis services that are so very expensive to deliver.

Prevention in our public services also means preventing the public services themselves from failing. To that end, we can and should reconsider the powers of the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman. The Scottish Parliament must introduce legislation to grant the SPSO own-initiative investigation powers to identify systemic public service failures and improve outcomes for service users. Indeed, recommendation 155 in the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body’s final report “SPCB Supported Bodies Landscape Review” states:

“Based on overwhelming evidence gathered, the Committee recommends that the SPSO is given enhanced powers to enable them to conduct own-initiative investigations in the public interest. We believe this change could identify and report on potential failures in the public sector more efficiently, and in doing so, deliver greater value for public money by helping to prevent systemic failures arising in future. We ask the Scottish Government to work with the SPCB to identify an appropriate legislative vehicle to make this change in early course. While we recognise that some additional resources will be required to ensure successful delivery, our expectation is that this will save money in the longer term.”

I very much hope that the cabinet secretary is willing to move forward with that.

The Scottish Greens believe that we cannot thrive or be mentally or physically well unless our natural environment is also thriving. Clean air, clean water to drink and swim in, access to nature and green spaces, safe active travel, affordable and reliable public transport, and communal and community spaces are fundamental infrastructure that is needed to reduce the sort of crises that create so much misery and put so much demand on our public services. Social isolation, unsafe environments and lack of access to green spaces and nature are harmful and damaging, and they are, therefore, costly.

Those things are not optional extras. The impacts of the climate catastrophe are accelerating, and the number of people and places affected by drought, flood, fire and extreme heat will increase. Communities will need support to implement things such as catchment-level water management, money for nature restoration and the responsibility and resources for local climate and emergency resilience.

In 2011, as colleagues have said, the Christie commission report estimated that as much as 40 per cent of public spending was absorbed in addressing avoidable social problems associated with poverty, poor health, worklessness, crime and other forms of disadvantage, which made prevention both a social and fiscal imperative. At the Public Service Reform Committee, we asked witnesses why the recommendations of the 2011 Christie commission had not been implemented, and the answer was, “Because it costs money up front.” Investment to change and improve will mean having more money in the long run. So, if we are going to make those changes, we will need to find the money and spend it on the right things.

I move amendment S7M-02089.2, to insert at end:

“; recognises the importance of preventative spending in tackling health inequalities, including through increasing access to screening and early diagnosis programmes; further recognises that a flourishing natural environment can boost health and wellbeing and that investment in green spaces, safer streets, active travel and measures to mitigate the impact of climate shocks constitutes preventative spending that can help create healthier, more prosperous communities that are better able to respond to social, economic and climate challenges.”

15:33

Craig Hoy (Dumfriesshire) (Con)

Conceptually, this is a worthwhile debate, and I welcome the Government’s renewed focus on prevention. However, that will happen only if the SNP Government now commits to accelerating, in hard cash terms, the spending shift towards prevention. It is crystal clear that the Government faces a tricky budget, so it will be interesting to see whether the minister’s influence over the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government is sufficient for there to be a real pivot towards preventative spending now.

I say at the outset that I do not believe that welfare in its truest form is preventative spending. It may or may not be effective—that is a debate for another day—but it is not preventative, because it deals with the consequences of a problem that already exists, be that child poverty, the poor mental health of thousands of Scotland’s young people or the growing problem of economic inactivity. As Alan Milburn identified this week, welfare is, in effect, a sticking plaster and not a long-term solution to the significant underlying social and economic problems that have been allowed to fester and that, in many cases, have got worse under the SNP Government.

The SNP’s motion states that

“prevention is essential to improving outcomes for people and communities and securing the long-term sustainability of public services in Scotland”.

However, with a £5 billion budget black hole of the Government’s own making, its back is against the wall.

As Lorna Slater said, we know that the returns on preventative spending are often measured over years and not months. The SNP evangelises about prevention, but let us consider some of the recent spending decisions that it has made, because history repeats itself and past performance is the best predictor of future performance.

Here is the recent record. In 2024-25, the affordable housing budget was slashed by 26 per cent, and police numbers in Scotland have fallen by roughly 1,000 since 2018. Now, there is a warning from the Scottish Police Federation that a flat-cash settlement next year could potentially result in a further reduction in the number of police officers by 1,000. That would undoubtedly have an impact on preventative policing.

Again in 2024-25, there were nearly £20 million of cuts to mental health services in Scotland. NHS Lothian is now reporting a reduction of £250,000 in psychology and a £400,000 reduction in the child and adult mental health services budget. Also in 2024-25, the flexible workforce development fund was withdrawn and totally unfunded, meaning that there was £10 million less to help employers to retain staff, to tackle skills shortages and to support people to remain in work or return to work.

This year, more than £7 million-worth of preventative services face cuts as integration joint boards come under intense pressure due to the SNP’s funding settlement. Health and Social Care Scotland has warned that removing those services risks increasing demand for more expensive crisis interventions. As our amendment makes clear, the Government has repeatedly reduced financial support for services that are intended to prevent problems from becoming crises.

In closing, I will mention at greater length the issue with commissioned services, which are often delivered by the third sector with local government funding. Each and every single year, those organisations that are, in effect, providing public services face financial challenges, and they often repeatedly have to put their own staff on redundancy alert. I believe that that is because ministers, who are always on the lookout for a press release or a cheap headline, often respond to failure with new strategies and spending commitments instead of looking at the ground level and at those who deliver such important projects and programmes.

If there is to be a step change, I welcome that, because a commitment to concrete and genuine prevention would mean stronger families and safer and healthier communities. What would that look like in this year’s budget? It would mean more resources for councils that have been forced to close community centres and shut down youth projects that prevent young people from falling through the cracks in life. It would mean restoring the colleges budget, so that young people get the skills to give them the best start in life. It would mean providing the police with the right resources to deter crime, deliver safer streets and tackle the social and economic costs of antisocial behaviour. It would also mean a commitment in the short and long terms to reducing the welfare bill, so that more money could flow into our NHS and other front-line services.

In recent budgets, ministers have pointed to the fact that they are pivoting to preventative spend and tagging budget lines accordingly. It is easy to label certain aspects of public expenditure as preventative, but the money must then be invested in them year in and year out. Audit Scotland has also raised concerns about one-off funding streams and a here today, gone tomorrow approach to funding and defunding vital areas of spend—for example, social housing.

Ministers are also presiding over declining capital budgets in health, and waiting times are a problem. I ask the minister what the point of having more doctors and better-paid nurses is if the operating theatre capacity is not there in our NHS. Ultimately, the old adage applies: a small saving today could reduce significant cost pressures tomorrow.

The Government is good at talking the talk, but is the minister really committed to walking the walk? As the other amendments make clear, the Government may be full of good intentions, but if the benchmarks are not clear and the outcomes are not identifiable, that will ultimately be no more than an exercise in budget window dressing. As the budget approaches, we must see a clear, visible and determined effort by ministers to prioritise proven early intervention that will reduce the pressure on our public services and public finances.

I move amendment S7M-02089.4, to leave out from the first “welcomes” to end and insert:

“regrets that the Scottish Government has still not clearly defined 'preventative spend' and has repeatedly reduced financial support for services intended to stop problems from becoming crises; believes that ministers too often respond to failure with new strategies and spending commitments rather than tackling rising demand; considers that genuine prevention means stronger families and safer, healthier communities, helping more people into work and supporting effective local services; notes Audit Scotland’s concerns regarding one-off funding streams, declining health capital budgets and difficulties tagging complex social care versus health spending, which collectively undermine efforts to achieve a whole-system shift, and calls on the Scottish Government to prioritise proven early intervention that reduces future pressure on public services and the public finances.”

15:40

David Green (Caithness, Sutherland and Ross) (LD)

This is an important debate. Shifting spending on services towards prevention is essential, and I therefore welcome the fact that the Government’s motion says that that is essential to improving public services. However, that is not a new observation, and we have heard from other members, including Joe Fagan in front of me, that the challenge was identified by the Christie commission 15 years ago when it said:

“Addressing the ‘failure demand’ that results from focussing on consequences rather than causes, and approaches which alienate or disempower service users, has a high cost for society and high costs for public services.”

That shift was urgent then and is even more so now. The Government’s renewed focus on prevention is, I think, an admission, as its public sector reform strategy says, that

“we have not made sufficient change to ensure our system is prioritising prevention”.

The evidence of the failure to achieve a substantial shift towards prevention is written all over our public services. To put it bluntly, they are not delivering the outcomes that people across Scotland need or expect. Prevention and preventative budgeting give an opportunity to change that, and one that we should not underestimate.

The enthusiastic reaction to recent proposals made by the Chancellor of the Exchequer to ring fence preventative budgets for individual departments in the next United Kingdom spending review was instructive. The Institute for Government described it as potentially transformational and said that it could give both a clear baseline to measure progress on the shift to prevention and greater flexibility to public services to manage preventative spending in the most effective way.

As the Public Service Reform Committee heard last week, we do not yet know when the UK Government intends to incorporate the required preventative ring fencing into the fiscal arrangements for Scotland or other devolved Governments, but the Scottish Government will have to consider that as it implements its own measures.

I welcome the Scottish Government’s pilot approach earlier this year to identifying preventative spend. It was useful but highlighted some of the limitations of current budget data and raised questions about aspects of the definition of preventative spending. I can see the cabinet secretary nodding about some of the lessons that can be learned from that.

On a technical level, the Fraser of Allander Institute has noted that the level 4 budget data used in the pilot is

“far too aggregated to support meaningful analysis of spend.”

Moreover, Volunteer Scotland has identified the need for preventative budgeting to consider what is actually spent and not just what is allocated in a budget line.

To put that differently, this cannot simply be an exercise in tagging broad areas of spending as being preventative: we need detailed consideration of what works best, coupled with mechanisms that will enable the difficult process of shifting spending towards prevention when services are already under pressure.

Ivan McKee

I reinforce the member’s point. A lot of technical things have to happen to make this meaningful. We are not taking a broad-brush approach, which is why it will take time, but a power of work is being done and we are keen to work with others from across the chamber to ensure that we get it right.

David Green

I welcome that constructive approach.

Beyond those measures, we must also consider the cultural change that is required for the shift to preventative approaches. I have heard the cabinet secretary talk about that at length. As the Institute for Government has said,

“Overcentralisation makes it harder to shift to a preventative approach.”

That is true at an institutional level and it is a challenge for a Scottish Government whose instinct, I fear, is all too often to centralise control. The minister, Hannah Mary Goodlad, and I have often talked about that.

That is also true at the level of the individual staff who work in Scotland’s public services. My party set out plans in its manifesto to enable and empower civil servants to innovate, to test promising ideas and to scale them up when they are successful. That would be a start, but we must also consider the concentration of Scotland’s civil service in the central belt.

The needs of rural and remote communities in Scotland often differ from those of urban communities. A preventive approach that works in Glasgow or Edinburgh—

Ivan McKee

I am very keen to talk about how we can make the civil service more innovative, which is a passion of mine.

With regard to decentralisation, I am sure that the member will welcome our proposals for community authorities, which are aimed at shifting power down to local community level.

On community authorities, the Deputy First Minister has said that no powers will be shifted down from the Parliament. [Interruption.] She said that on STV.

Ivan McKee

That is not an accurate representation of where we are at. We have been extremely clear that we are in the business of devolving powers to the regional level on economic development, transport, skills, housing and a range of other areas as we work through the process.

David Green

As I have indicated previously, we will continue to engage constructively with the Government to make community authorities work, but I fear that the consultation process that has been set out is far too short, as the Government’s front-bench team knows. That needs to be addressed.

I return to Ivan McKee’s favourite idea—that of an innovative civil service. The challenges will be different in different parts of the country, and those different circumstances need to be at the heart of the Scottish Government’s thinking on how to tackle the challenges. That is why I urge ministers to ensure that the upcoming location policy for civil servants is right, that it protects opportunities in rural Scotland and that it builds a civil service that reflects all of Scotland.

Before I conclude, I want to put on record a point that has been made in earlier exchanges—that the Scottish Government must recognise the importance of the preventative work that is undertaken in the third sector. There are numerous examples of that work, a few of which I will quickly illustrate.

The nook from Scottish Action for Mental Health provides accessible drop-in mental health and wellbeing support that helps people to get the earlier preventative mental health care that they need. Aberlour’s family financial wellbeing pilot in Tayside demonstrates how local authorities and the third sector can work together to support families who are experiencing public debt challenges. Chest Heart and Stroke Scotland’s healthy heart and lung checks programme aims to improve early detection, reduce health inequalities and strengthen preventive investment. All those services are very welcome.

Those examples, along with many others that I have not had time to mention, demonstrate the potential for early intervention. If the Government is to be successful in improving services and shifting spending towards prevention in the way that it intends, it is crucial, as Craig Hoy said, that it values the independent and third sector.

We move to the open debate.

15:47

Bob Doris (Glasgow Kelvin and Maryhill) (SNP)

It is not difficult to identify areas of Scottish Government policy that can be considered to be preventative spend measures. I will name three.

The abolition of prescription charges in 2011 helped to ensure that all those who need medicines get them free at the point of need. The extension in 2022 of universal free nutritious school meals to children up to primary 5 helped to ensure that young people get the best start in life when they go to school, through having a warm meal in their belly. As we heard earlier, the NHS family nurse partnership programme, which was first piloted in 2010 and was fully rolled out across Scotland by 2018, supports young mums during pregnancy and until their children are two.

Those three long-standing preventative spend initiatives are well established and embedded in Scotland’s public service provision, and the Scottish Government is now taking steps to systematically track preventative spend across all its budgets. I welcome the establishment of the prevention unit and the fact that the budget for 2027-28 will identify how much of that budget can be considered to be preventative spend, but the Public Service Reform Committee, of which I am the convener, has urged the Scottish Government to clearly distinguish between existing preventative spend activity in the current 2026-27 financial year, such as the three initiatives that I mentioned, and new activity in the coming financial year.

Such an exercise must be more than an administrative task. It must support the Government and other public bodies to make informed policy and investment decisions and aid Parliament in our scrutiny of those decisions. The provision of robust baseline data will allow us to compare and contrast preventative spend from one year to the next and, ultimately, over the parliamentary session. However, for that process to be meaningful, the development and application of the proposed Scottish prevention investment framework will be likely to be crucial.

I understand that the framework will

“establish a consistent approach to assessing, prioritising and evidencing preventative investment”

and inform investment decisions to

“deliver long-term social and fiscal benefits while reducing future pressures on public services.”

The Parliament will have to properly understand the investment framework if we are to effectively scrutinise what the Scottish Government is doing. Asserting such things is different from scrutinising them, and we will have to fully understand the framework. However, I welcome the direction of travel.

In addition, the framework’s related requirements and associated guidance must be practical and proportionate. The process is not an end in itself. Rather, it must support ongoing monitoring of outcomes, which I know is intended, and not detract from them. That being said, a more open and transparent process will not in itself drive public service reform. A space still needs to exist for innovating and trying something different. Alternative delivery models across public bodies must be considered and supported by the prevention investment framework, and all partners must feel that they are equal and valued parts of that process.

I was pleased to learn of the Scottish Government’s support for social impact partnerships, which I hurriedly googled when I saw the term in the Government’s motion. The cabinet secretary will know of my interest in palliative care, and from what I can see, Scotland’s hospices and hospice at home network have been social impact partners for generations, since long before the term was coined. Public service reform must be an opportunity to ensure that third sector organisations are strategic partners in improving things. I will give two examples of that.

First, Glasgow city health and social care partnership recently decided to terminate a contract with Marie Curie to provide fast-track specialist nursing support for people in their homes. That will save £240,000 a year, but the partnership will also lose the £200,000 that Marie Curie put towards that valued service.

I have been in correspondence with the HSCP and I note that it took the view that support is better delivered directly by district nurses. It considered that reform was required, and I acknowledge that it faces tight budgets. However, I would have hoped that discussions between Glasgow’s HSCP and Marie Curie could have delivered a meaningful partnership under public service reform to co-produce a new model, rather than the service being terminated. I look forward to constructive chats with Glasgow’s health and social care partnership, but that does not augur well for public service reform. We need to change that culture.

Adam Harley

Bob Doris’s point lays bare the potential human impact and the importance of getting this right at a human level, because people will have been relying on those services. We need to be incredibly careful in that regard as part of consultation on the preventative spending agenda.

Bob Doris

I am happy to concur with Mr Harley’s comments.

I would like to know how the cabinet secretary can provide a meaningful place for Scotland’s third sector within public service reform and a more collegiate culture whereby we can have co-produced services rather than commissioned services.

My time is running out, but I want to mention my second example, which is the groundbreaking work of Highland Hospice and the end-of-life care together model in NHS Highland. Money was provided by Macmillan Cancer Support and Highland Hospice, but money was not mainstreamed by NHS Highland to continue to deliver the service, which prevents people from going into hospital for unscheduled care and makes a real difference to NHS Highland.

I cannot for the life of me work out why a pilot would be started without people working out how money could be mainstreamed at the start, rather than NHS Highland waiting until the end of the pilot to say, “We don’t have any money to do this.” There has to be a better way under public service reform.

The Scottish Government has had a £30 million invest to save fund for the past two years that is focused on areas such as digital transformation and supporting voluntary severance schemes. We have to make sure that that fund is opened out into preventative spend in areas such as palliative care. That is not what it says on the tin at present, but that has to change.

Do I have any time left, Presiding Officer?

No.

I do not. I ask the Government to reflect on the comments that I have made, and I leave my remarks at that.

15:54

Heather Anderson (Dundee City West) (SNP)

I declare that I am a serving councillor on Dundee City Council. As a Dundonian, I would like to put on the record that, after a wait of 13 years—a period that some might describe as a generation—Grand Theft Auto VI has arrived. The video game has already been universally described as a masterpiece. To all the developers who have worked on it over the past decade, I express my congratulations on the job that they have done.

As a councillor, I do not need any convincing about the impact and importance of prevention work. Much of the work that councillors do—from providing housing to collecting bins, maintaining parks and running schools—is focused on the 80 per cent of determinants of health that are not dealt with by the health service.

It is often the small things that make a difference. For the past couple of winters, Dundee City Council has run the open doors programme, which provides warm spaces across our libraries, community halls and public venues. The offer is simple: a cup of tea, something to eat and some company. It also provides support with energy costs, which will be greatly needed in January next year, when those costs will increase by 26 per cent.

Sometimes, a cup of tea and a welcome can make all the difference. For someone who feels forgotten and cold in a house that they are scared to heat, such a connection can help them to rebuild the resilience that they need to get through tough times. We may never know how many people we have prevented from falling down the stairs in their house and ending up in accident and emergency. However, we do know that although tea bags do not cost much, their impact can be invaluable.

As a councillor who has had to help to balance no fewer than nine council budgets, I know that the hardest decisions are on so-called discretionary payments. Such payments are described as discretionary because they do not fund statutory services, which means that the services that they can fund are always under pressure. Even the open doors programme is at risk.

Therefore, I will make a few pleas to the cabinet secretary on behalf of local government. First, if we are to make progress on prevention, we must find a way to identify and protect local authorities’ discretionary spending. That is the life-blood of preventative work.

Secondly, can we ensure that local authorities and COSLA embrace the Scottish Government prevention unit’s methodology for identifying preventative spending, so that we can begin to analyse budgets all the way through to delivery?

Thirdly, can we re-evaluate and value the work of community development and youth work staff? Community development staff are the silent engineers of community connection and cohesion. We cannot do prevention without them, so they need to be protected.

Another area in which prevention is vital is youth work. Yesterday, I was pleased to sponsor a morning event with Winning Scotland, entitled “Building a Scotland young people deserve”. Winning Scotland uses the Planet Youth prevention model, which was developed in Iceland. It gathers young people’s experiences and views then uses those insights both to target preventative measures to reduce the risks that young people face and to strengthen the protective factors needed to increase their resilience and self-esteem. Backed by £3 million in Scottish Government investment, Planet Youth’s evidence-based prevention model uses data collected directly from young people to guide the work done through its network. It found that, between 2021 and 2025, the level of suicidal thoughts among respondents fell from 41 per cent to 23 per cent; smoking halved; drinking dropped by almost a third; and weekly community participation rose from 58 per cent to 68 per cent. Those are verifiable results that prove that prevention work makes a difference.

We all know that we need to shift health spending towards prevention—we have known it for decades. As I mentioned earlier, 80 per cent of the determinants of health exist outside the healthcare system. That means that more money must be made available for local government, the third sector and the care sector.

We also know that prevention is not just a way of alleviating pressure on the health service—although that is important—but is about helping people to live healthier and more resilient lives. The prevention unit’s preventative spend pilot programme has been very useful. It examined 41 per cent of the Scottish Government’s 2025-26 budget and found that only 15 per cent of that spending was preventative, while 52 per cent was put into acute and responsive services. The analysis also found that most of the tiny bit of the budget that was spent on prevention was used in areas where risk had already been identified, while only 18 per cent of it went to population-level primary prevention measures such as free school meals and vaccinations. We need to invest further upstream.

If we are to redirect a percentage of the budget towards prevention, we also need new indicators and new targets. Acute interventions are vital—every operation matters—but, if all that we ever measure are those acute interventions, they will be the only things that count. We need to design new targets that identify wellbeing and health, not just the absence of good health.

I welcome the prevention initiative. I think that we are serious about doing something about it over this parliamentary session. I look forward to reviewing the whole budget and identifying areas of preventative spend. We need to work with our partners in the third sector and local government to ensure that we follow that spend through to the point of delivery.

16:00

Joe Long (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Lab)

It is clear, from this debate and previous ones so far this parliamentary session, and certainly from meetings of the Health, Care and Sport Committee on which I sit, that there is cross-party consensus on the need to resource preventative action properly. Fifteen years on from the Christie report, it is past time to deliver on that imperative. Therefore, the Scottish Government’s motion is welcome and will find no argument from Labour members. As always, though, the proof of the pudding will be in the eating, so we look forward to seeing on 3 December a budget that clearly demonstrates that commitment.

Preventative budget tagging, which has been piloted already, will be a helpful tool in scrutinising and monitoring the fulfilment of that ambition, if it is implemented meaningfully and consistently. When it comes to health outcomes, we know that much of the work to prevent ill health takes place outside health services, in community settings that support a healthy lifestyle, physical activity and social connection. It also tackles wider inequalities and determinants of ill health, such as poverty, housing and a poor environment, as Scotland’s population health framework recognises.

The Scottish Government’s preventative budgeting tool pilot distinguishes that work, but only a small percentage is classified as primary prevention—that community-based work. That makes it logical to provide significant increased funding to community-based services. If we are serious about budget tagging as a means of measuring preventative spend, we need not only to tag existing activities as preventative but to demonstrate, through tagging, where a genuine shift is taking place in resource allocation. Such a shift also demands that we follow robust evidence and outline clear measures of success if we are to properly scrutinise where preventative initiatives are working or face obstacles.

Michelle Campbell (Renfrewshire North and Cardonald) (SNP)

Does Joe Long agree that the refreshed national performance framework is where we should see where outcomes are deliverable and where there are fundamental changes, which would allow us to see where preventative spend is having the best impact for our communities?

Joe Long

The member has either read my mind or read my speech. I will come back to that point, but I will say just now that we find ourselves in agreement on it.

I welcome the place-based approach to tackling social inequalities that is used in the Marmot places, but we also need to learn the longer-term lessons from existing community planning partnerships, which were introduced after the Christie review. We are not starting from scratch, so we must learn the lessons from what has already been tried. I hope that we will finally see a shift from crisis to prevention that is properly tagged, tracked and evaluated.

Although I am fully on board with the shift, I posit that prevention cannot be the only paradigm through which we make public policy. We also need hopeful and clear vision of what living well looks like, and we should not entirely lose our focus on wellbeing in political discourse in Scotland. Budget tagging is an important tool, but prevention is just one side of the coin. We also need Scotland’s national performance framework to be completed and brought into our policy conversations so that we can show the positive outcomes that we seek for people in Scotland.

For example, I have said several times in the chamber that we cannot judge the success of social care solely by seeing reduced delayed discharge figures. Social care is about much more than that; it is about providing people with a good life, on their own terms, in the community. The same principle runs across public service provision. We need to be clear not only about what we seek to prevent but about what individual and collective wellbeing looks like.

Let us shift from reacting to crisis to resourcing prevention, but let us also agree that the prize is a Scotland in which people live well. We need to demonstrate, on the one hand, a shift and a measurable reduction in inequalities, ill health and poor life outcomes and, on the other, an increase in the positive outcomes that demonstrate individual and collective wellbeing. I hope that both of those ambitions will be evident in December’s budget and in the Scottish Government’s public service reform process.

I call Emma Roddick, who joins us remotely.

16:04

Emma Roddick (Inverness and Nairn) (SNP)

Nobody stands up in the Parliament to argue in favour of waiting until a crisis hits before we spend public money. The hard part, and the reason why we are debating this again, is making preventative budgeting work in practice when budgets are tight and people are in crisis and can see how the decisions that we make affect—or do not affect—their immediate situation. That emergency firefighting demand is in front of us every day.

I want to talk about the need for rural proofing and Inverness proofing—because Inverness may be a growing city but, when it comes to delivering public services, it faces the same pressures as the rural communities around it in Nairnshire and across the Highlands. We struggle to recruit; it costs more to deliver services across a massive area; and, often, statistics are shared with rural and island communities because those statistics are at a council level or wider, which often creates a meaningless average that tells us nothing.

If we measure the return on preventative investment using any formula based on population density, the Highlands will always lose out. You cannot reach thousands of people from a city-centre hub when your catchment area covers half of Scotland. We must accept that preventative work in the Highlands requires a higher up-front spend per head. If we do not pay that up-front cost, we will end up paying far more later on for emergency patient transfers, acute admissions at Raigmore and crisis interventions.

That brings me to what genuine prevention looks like. We have heard a lot about health and social care, which is unsurprising in a debate about prevention, but some of the most effective preventative spending that we can do happens in housing.

David Green

I thank Emma Roddick in the Highlands for taking an intervention from down here in Edinburgh. She makes a brilliant case for the need for rural proofing. Does she agree that the Government should consider legislating for rural proofing—or for rural proofing impact assessments—potentially in the rural renewal bill that we are expecting?

Emma Roddick

That is a novel idea. I recall a former colleague raising the possibility of that type of bill in a previous parliamentary session. The Rural Affairs Committee is considering what rural proofing could look like, whether it is introduced by the Parliament or the Government. I would be happy to talk to David Green and others about that.

Going back to housing, shelter sits at the very bottom of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs alongside food and water. We cannot expect someone to engage with preventative healthcare, manage a chronic condition, hold down a job or recover from trauma if they do not have a safe, warm and secure roof over their head. If they do not know where they are sleeping next week or whether their rent payment will bounce, that is where their head will be.

The figures highlighted by Crisis, following the latest homelessness statistics, show the scale of the challenge that we are dealing with. Levels of homelessness have risen. More than 19,000 households are living in temporary accommodation—the highest number since records began. Crucially for us here, Crisis points out:

“2,005 households, nearly 5% of all applications, became homeless straight from prison, hospital or a children’s residential placement”.

That shows that our prevention systems are not working.

The human cost is devastating but, if we look at it from a financial perspective, it still does not add up. A few weeks ago, I welcomed John, from Crisis’s lived experience panel, to the Parliament. During time for reflection, he spoke about the “Million Dollar Murray” essay in The New Yorker, which looked at how quickly chronic homelessness could cost the public a million dollars without doing any good for Murray or stopping the cycle that he was stuck in. That could have been done by those systems talking to one another and someone stepping in to figure out the core issue in play.

When someone is discharged from hospital into homelessness or left in cold, damp or insecure housing, we are guaranteeing that they will end up back in acute services really quickly. The new homelessness prevention duties, alongside the fund and the expansion of housing first, are welcome steps. If we want to reduce long-term pressure on the NHS, investing in permanent affordable housing is as direct a preventative health measure as anything in the health portfolio.

We also need to be honest about how we fund the third sector and we need to put money where we know that it works. Charities across Scotland are already doing extraordinary work but, too often, they are caught out when one public body makes a cut to balance its books. One example is Carr Gomm’s mobile home care team in Argyll and Bute. Between April 2023 and October 2025, six mobile teams carried out nearly 63,000 visits. They provided rapid-response flexible wraparound support for up to six weeks that helped people to get home safely from hospital, which involved adapting support and stepping in to prevent unnecessary hospital admissions. Over 30 months, the teams prevented more than 1,000 admissions and facilitated more than 2,100 discharges.

That is what we need to bridge the gap when people are waiting for care packages but are otherwise fit for discharge, or when they need immediate support to avoid going into hospital in the first place. However, because of financial pressures, the health and social care partnership cancelled three of those teams in 2024 and the remaining three this year. Those teams cost an average of £158,000 a year, but delayed discharges for Argyll and Bute residents cost the NHS an average of £5.9 million a year. That is nearly half a million pounds every month. Cutting that £158,000 service did not save a penny; it just shunted the cost on to the Ambulance Service, NHS Highland and the local council.

My colleague Bob Doris mentioned the Highland Hospice, which deals with people at the end of their life but which is still managing to lead on preventative spend. I remember feeling like I was bashing my head against a wall when I tried to support the hospice with its palliative care helpline in the previous session of Parliament. We know that it saves hospital bed days, prevents people from hitting crisis and saves the NHS money, yet the funding is still being covered by the hospice. I can only imagine how much more frustrating that is for those involved. That is the exact mentality that we must end.

Preventative budgeting requires political courage, because the savings rarely show up in the same financial year or even in the same portfolio, but it is just as easy to defend as it is to criticise.

Please conclude.

People will understand those arguments, so let us get on with it.

16:11

Helen McDade (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Reform)

The Health, Care and Sport Committee has, as others have mentioned, considered preventative spend a lot. I have good news for the cabinet secretary, because I have a couple of really good examples of where he can save money very soon.

I thank Bob Doris for bringing the stroke thrombectomy team in yesterday to talk to us. The team is really inspiring, and it is working hard. The team wants to roll out the 24/7 stroke thrombectomy service to others. The team members have worked hard to come up with innovative ways to do it themselves in Dundee, Lothian and Glasgow, but it needs to go further.

The great thing about the service is that it is transformational. Anyone who is familiar with it knows that, instead of people having a stroke and ending up in a care home, they might walk out of the hospital several days later. We must roll out the service, which I know the cabinet secretary and minister are in favour of. I know that there is a plan, but the plan is to move at a certain rate. We need to spend the money as quickly as possible. We need to learn from those surgeons and get the service rolled out.

It is not easy to do that. I worked in a job that involved providing 24/7 cover, and nobody wants to do it. If they are not doing it at the moment, something needs to change. We might even have to pay people to sit around not doing anything during the night, so that they are there when required. We must also work with the Ambulance Service. The stroke thrombectomy service really is transformational, and it involves preventative spend. Someone might come in unable to walk but be able to walk back out. We must consider doing things differently and making that change.

It was really exciting to see the stroke thrombectomy team. We have also had, within the past 24 hours in the Parliament, a professor talk to us about the glucagon-like peptide-1 weight-loss drug. I am not usually in favour of just rolling out drugs, but there is no doubt that, when people are obese or very overweight, they are at risk of cardiac problems, diabetes and musculoskeletal issues—the list of issues is endless. A lot of people are paying for the drug themselves, which is not great, because they are getting it from who knows where. However, such drugs are another example of preventative spend. We need to look much further into it before the drug is given to children, though. I am concerned that children are on it, and we do not know what impact it might have on their growth.

Unlike most preventative spend stuff, you can look at that and say, “Next year, we will have saved X number of people who come in with these conditions.”

Bob Doris

Helen McDade mentioned weight-loss drugs. She might be aware that there is an issue with getting those weight-loss drugs adopted on to NHS formularies, of which there are 14 across Scotland, so that they can be prescribed. I wonder whether moving from 14 to two health boards might speed up not just the approval but the adoption of those new medicines.

Helen McDade

We already have strategic health boards, and we could do that. There is no doubt that we would want some services to be looked at beyond our current health boards. However, going to two health boards is another debate, and I am sure that we could discuss the issues that might arise with people getting local input and going where they would most like to go. We already have some strategic health boards, and I accept the member’s point.

I ask the cabinet secretary to look into the issue and consider the examples that we would see the benefit from and that would not be as hard to implement as a lot of others.

16:15

Katie Hagmann (Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley) (SNP)

I am delighted to speak in today’s debate on prevention and preventative budgeting.

If we want to create a healthier, fairer and more sustainable Scotland, prevention cannot be an afterthought. It must sit at the very heart of our ambitions, our policies and our decisions about how we invest public money. However, I acknowledge that that is not always easy. As I have said before in the chamber, change can be unsettling. It can create uncertainty and fear and, at times, it can feel uncomfortable, but if we are serious about improving outcomes for people and communities, we must be willing to have honest conversations about how we use the resources that are available to us.

Before we discuss budgets, programmes or services, we must first answer more fundamental questions. What kind of country do we want Scotland to be? What outcomes are we trying to achieve? It is only by being clear about the outcomes that we can have any hope of delivering them.

Public Health Scotland is clear in its ambitions. It wants more people to live longer, healthier lives and to reduce the unacceptable gap in healthy life expectancy that exists across our society today. We can all agree with those aims. The difficult question is how we achieve them in a sustainable manner. That is not a new debate and, as members from across the chamber have said, the Christie commission highlighted that Scotland was spending too much time and resource dealing with the consequences of disadvantage, instead of addressing its cause. The same principles run through the Marmot review and the work that has followed on tackling the social determinants of health.

The evidence has been remarkably consistent: if we want better outcomes, we must intervene earlier; if we want to reduce demand on public services, we must prevent problems before they reach crisis point; and if we want sustainable public finances, we must invest further upstream. Collectively, we must agree on the outcomes that we want to create and, in doing so, I hope that fear can be diminished. By working together in a genuinely collaborative way, we can build trust. Collaboration is critical, because prevention cannot be delivered by Government alone. It requires national Government, local government, public services, the third sector, communities and citizens all working together towards our shared goals.

One of the greatest privileges of my role is the opportunity to work with and support young people. Our young people are brilliant. They are engaged, compassionate, ambitious and determined. We have a duty to ensure that their futures are as bright as possible. The value of youth work and youth clubs can never be overestimated. Spaces where young people can build friendships, develop confidence, gain new skills and simply spend time together are saving lives.

Craig Hoy

Having served on it until recently, Katie Hagmann will know the acute financial pressures that Dumfries and Galloway Council faces. Will she join me in appealing to the Scottish Government to ensure that it does not short-change rural councils? Otherwise, many of the programmes and initiatives that take place at the ground level will be further cut, which, ultimately, will store up problems for future generations.

Katie Hagmann

The title of today’s debate is “Prevention and Preventative Budgeting”. I absolutely support the Government in how that is taken forward, and I absolutely support all our rural communities. That is a discussion and dialogue that I think everybody across the chamber is committed to.

I have mentioned the value of youth work, but there are many more examples of prevention measures that impact our young people. The best start grants are preventative, as are the childsmile programme, investment in early learning and childcare, the Scottish child payment and free school meals. There is so much more that I could say in the same vein. However, it is not just about our young people; we must ensure that we all have the opportunity to age well. Community healthcare and helping older people to live independently for longer is crucial.

Too often, prevention is discussed solely in relation to health services. However, it starts before a child is born, and it continues throughout childhood and the teenage years, and into adulthood and later life. It can be found in housing policy, education policy, food policy and anti-poverty policy. Whenever we help people before problems escalate, we improve lives and reduce future demands on services.

There remains a challenge that we must address honestly. How do we invest more resources upstream while continuing to meet the significant pressures that services face today? What areas will we disinvest from? That is not a simple question, and I suspect that many of those working across public services know that there is no simple answer. I believe, however, that that answer cannot be a delay to taking action. We already know that investing in prevention delivers benefits for individuals, communities and public finances alike. The longer we wait, the greater the pressures become. Prevention is not just a spending priority; it is a way of thinking. It is about designing services around people and tackling root causes instead of continually managing consequences. It is about putting people before structures.

Prevention and preventative budgeting is ultimately about building a Scotland where everyone has the opportunity to live a healthier, happier and more fulfilling life. I look forward to seeing that ambition take a step forward to delivery, and I am pleased to support the motion.

16:21

Keith Brown (Clackmannanshire and Dunblane) (SNP)

I welcome the debate and the Government’s commitment to accelerating the shift towards prevention, particularly through the new prevention unit and the development of a prevention investment framework.

A couple of aspects of the debate have been quite disappointing, to be honest. In particular, the opening speeches from the Labour Party and the Conservative Party showed a certain degree of self-delusion. We would hope that, over time, we might get a much more responsible debate.

For example, Joe Fagan talked about a lack of progress. There is an element of truth in that: we would all like to have seen more progress. However, he never mentioned the financial crisis, Brexit or the pandemic, all of which have had a major impact. We have had 17 years of austerity funding, certainly in terms of revenue and even more so in terms of capital. Those factors inhibit our ability to take initiatives. Even those who do not agree whole-heartedly with the scale of that could at least acknowledge the fact that those things have happened. That would make for a much more sensible debate.

As for the Craig Hoy and his list of demands—more money for local government, more money for hospitals, and sorting out that £5 billion black hole that people keep talking about—we heard no indication of where any of the money will come from. I thought that the economic illiteracy of the Tory party had died with Liz Truss’s premiership, but there is nothing in what the Tories are saying that gives any indication that they have any idea of the scale of the issues facing people. It is about time that they did.

Over the time that I have been here, as far as I remember, neither Labour nor Tory members have ever proposed an amendment to the budget by saying, “Put more money into this,” or, “Put more money into that.” There is no commitment or willingness to do the serious work in relation to this area, and that is disappointing.

There is an important distinction between prevention and preventative budgeting. Prevention is about what we do; preventative budgeting is how we substantially resource it. We have all heard people tell us that, if we spent money in one particular place, we could save a fortune. We must have the money to spend there, however. Members should bear in mind the financial situation that the country has been in for a long time.

If it comes down to the usual debate about who is responsible, the Scottish Government must accept responsibility for what it does, but it was Wes Streeting who said, when asked to explain why the health service was in such a bad state in Wales, that

“all roads … lead back to Westminster”.

That is the foundation of the financing of the various Administrations.

I would like to draw on some of the points that Katie Hagmann made.

Carol Mochan (South Scotland) (Lab)

I hope that the member might agree that we have had some reasonable debates in the chamber. I do not think that it is unfair for him to discuss the wider crisis and so on. In fairness, however, noting how the member started his speech, I would reflect back on that last comment about all roads leading back to Westminster. In a debate in this chamber, there are some things where we should be talking about what we can do within the financial constraints. That would be helpful as well.

Keith Brown

I do not disagree with the point that Carol Mochan makes—I have tried to say that. The Scottish Government has to accept responsibility. I think that the Scottish Government—here is a heresy—should acknowledge the fact that we have not been able to fund local government to the extent that we should in order to cover all the things that it does.

Nonetheless, we should look at what local government here has done. We have not had a single council go to the wall in Scotland. In England, there are councils—I do not know how many it is now—that have gone to the wall; commissioners have been brought in and the council has gone bankrupt. There is a similar situation in Wales. Local government in Scotland has managed in the circumstances, but we should at least acknowledge the overall environment. Yes, councils have responsibilities—I accept that.

However, to pick up on some of the points that Katie Hagmann made, I will draw on one experience from Clackmannanshire Council in my constituency. The council has done some genuinely innovative work through the family wellbeing partnership, supported by the Government and public and third sector partners. What makes it different is that it starts with the needs of people and families. Harry—I forget the guy’s second name; that is terrible.

Burns.

Keith Brown

Harry Burns used to always say that that is where we should start, and he highlighted a couple of initiatives down in the north of England that started with the premise of asking people what they actually wanted rather than all the things that we give to them, some of which they do not want.

That is what Clackmannanshire Council has done. It started with that approach of seeing what people wanted. Through the child wellbeing partnerships, 860 children across 436 families were supported between April and September this year. Childcare is being used as a gateway to wider family support, employment and training, helping to tackle the underlying causes of poverty before difficulties escalate. That also reflects our commitment to keeping the Promise, ensuring that families get the right support at the right time.

I want to mention one other thing, rather than go through what is left in my speech notes. One of the biggest areas, which was mentioned by Emma Roddick, has to be homelessness. What we pay—especially in Edinburgh and Glasgow, but in other parts of the country, too, even in Stirling—for people to be kept in substandard homeless accommodation is absolutely astonishing. If we can manage it, whether through pension funds or through taking devolved responsibility for child benefit—as I argued that we should have done; it was on offer at one stage—we have to be able to fund a proper house-building programme that can take people out of substandard accommodation, not only because it is not good accommodation but because that could save an absolute fortune. That is preventative spending.

Will the member take an intervention?

I am sorry, Mr Hoy—I do not have much time. I am in my last minute.

You can take an intervention if you so wish.

Okay.

I thank the member for taking an intervention. He says that the Scottish Government should take responsibility where responsibility is due. It was the SNP Government that reduced the affordable housing budget by 26 per cent in 2024-25.

Keith Brown

The member has mentioned that, and I have said that the Scottish Government has to take responsibility for its actions, but I wish that he would take some responsibility for the overall situation, and he just will not do it. That is the denial and the delusion that goes on in the Conservative party, along with new demands every week for more money to be spent on this, that and the other.

One other example that I want to mention is the STRIVE—safeguarding through rapid intervention—team in Clackmannanshire, which brings together housing, police, health, social work and other partners. An evaluation of just 13 STRIVE cases estimated the potential lifetime savings to the public purse at £66 million.

Will the member take an intervention?

I will do, if the Presiding Officer is feeling generous.

I call Ivan McKee.

Ivan McKee

Does the member recognise, with regard to the previous point that Craig Hoy raised, that the reason for the reduction in the housing budget in that particular year was because of a significant reduction—from memory, I think that it was about 9 or 10 per cent—in the capital budget from what was then a Conservative UK Government?

Keith Brown

I acknowledge that point. It raises a point about what the Conservatives, and sometimes some of the Labour Party members, think that their role in the chamber is. Surely it should be to speak up for proper resourcing from Westminster, not just parroting whatever Westminster tells us. Had the Tories spoken up, perhaps they would not be reduced to the handful of members that they now have in the chamber.

I mentioned a couple of examples in Clackmannanshire. I also want to mention the Scottish Government’s prevention investment framework, which offers a real opportunity to change how we fund public services. In that case, the Scottish Government has been very helpful in enabling Clackmannanshire to take forward those initiatives. The council has some of the worst deprivation statistics in Scotland. We often hear about Glasgow, because the scale of deprivation is so great there, but its profound nature is just as bad in Clackmannanshire. It has therefore been important, especially for a small council, to have the support of the Government.

I go back to the overall situation with budgets. With limited borrowing powers and budgets that are—to state the obvious, it seems to me; it should not be contentious to say it—heavily dependent on Westminster decisions, we lack the flexibility to invest for the longer term. The difficulty is that, for a period, we have to fund both ends of the system, and investing in prevention will continue to come up against existing demand for essential services.

I will finish on this point, which repeats the point that I started off with—

Please conclude.

Keith Brown

As Katie Hagmannn said, if people are genuinely serious about this debate, then, before they say that money must be put into making savings in one place, they must identify what they would cut to get that money. Some might say that that is the Government’s responsibility, and so it is, and the Government will do that, because it is going to have to do it. However, members of this Parliament can do it as well: they are free to make suggestions and say what they think should be cut in order that the money can be invested elsewhere. The members on the Conservative benches are free to go on the welfare-hunting trips that they regularly engage in—

Please conclude.

There is no reason why they cannot do that. I appeal for a bit more of a joined-up debate in future.

We now move to the winding-up speeches. I call David Green.

16:30

A lot of what Keith Brown said in his speech was—

Mince.

David Green

—relatively fair-minded. In general, it was. I hope that Joe Fagan will get to watch the exchanges later, and I am sure that he will be able to have a conversation afterwards.

In his speech, Joe Fagan set out the historical context of the debate, addressing where we have come from with regard to the Christie commission and where we are now. He posed some important challenges for the Government regarding local government reform, an issue on which the cabinet secretary and I had an exchange earlier in the debate. If the Government gets its way, there will be significant up-front costs, the extent of which we do not yet know. I understand that Common Weal estimates those to be around £2 billion, so we need to recognise some of the weighty challenges that the Government will have to engage with in order to achieve any consensus.

The other Joe, Joe Long—we have double Joe here today—made a good point in relation to wellbeing, and I recognise some of the progress that the Treasury has made on trying to track that.

David Smith made a great attempt at oratory. He will have been disappointed—I was—that he did not have members behind him banging their desks as he listed one crisis after another. As a Liberal Democrat, I experience that quite often, but there we go.

We heard from Malcolm Offord at First Minister’s question time that Reform is apparently a party that is full of ideas. Unfortunately, I do not think that I heard any of them in David Smith’s speech. However, I will be fair-minded and say that Helen McDade tried to bring some to the exchanges.

Lorna Slater made important points about the various pots of money—not least in the areas of health and social care—and how they can be aligned within the Government’s tracking of preventive spend. That was a helpful contribution to the debate.

Craig Hoy made a number of fair points about speculation around preventive spend. We need to acknowledge that issue and wrestle with it. He alluded to multiyear funding, but he also made a lot of calls in relation to councils and colleges. I do not know whether his party is doing this—perhaps his speech was an indication that it is—but we are going through a budget process right now, and I am sure that those on the Government front bench will seek to engage with his party if it comes forward with suggestions. Perhaps this is the first time that the Conservatives will engage with the budget process.

For the record, we are engaged in that process. We have suggested £1.5 billion-worth of tax cuts and additional spending and £1.5 billion of savings. As ever, our budget is fully costed.

David Green

I stand potentially corrected. I will see how meaningful some of the discussions with the Government have been in the read-out.

In particular, I commend Bob Doris’s on his speech. He is recognised as a real champion of hospice care and palliative care. I note his remarks about the Highland Hospice, which I very much appreciated, and I will just quickly plug my members’ business debate on the hospice next week—I hope that members will be able to attend. There is a challenge not just for the Government, with regard to the framework, but for MSPs, with regard to the cultural change that is required if we are to understand what preventive spend will mean in terms of up-front costs.

I will come to my concluding points. I reiterate Heather Anderson’s points about Planet Youth Scotland. I understand that she had a breakfast meeting with the organisation earlier this week. It is an important organisation that is doing terrific work, particularly in my constituency and across the Highlands. It is genuinely making young people feel safer, more optimistic and better about themselves. That will be important for our services right down the line.

Please conclude.

It is important that the Government recognises that it needs to take the whole country with it, not just this Parliament, as a serious cultural shift must be made.

16:34

Craig Hoy

This has been a genuinely solid debate—although perhaps not entirely: Keith Brown is a very different character outside the chamber than he is in the chamber, and I think that he reinforced his in-chamber character today with what was a churlish and partisan contribution.

I welcomed what I heard in various speeches from across the chamber. Heather Anderson was absolutely right to say that, 15 years after the Christie commission, it is still disappointing that just 15 per cent of spend is genuinely preventative. If that is a benchmark, the Government needs to improve on that.

Joe Fagan was absolutely right to say that the Government is potentially biting off more than it can chew with simultaneously trying to reform the public sector and the quango state, create two mega health boards and also create up to 160 new local authorities and six to 10 mega authorities. The minister is competent, but I am not sure that even he can rise to that challenge. Before my praise goes to the minister’s head, I will point out some of the difficulties that he is now experiencing, which could negatively impact on his capacity to pivot to preventative spend.

I draw his attention to today’s section 22 report from Stephen Boyle, in which he makes quite clear that the gap between the projected available funding and the cost of public services still needs to be closed in-year and in future years. He warns that the problem of setting out how those savings will be achieved is due to

“a lack of specific milestones and timelines”

within the Scottish Government’s budgeting and accounting processes. Therefore, as the minister embarks on dramatic reviews of how the Government will allocate preventative spending, perhaps he must also consider some of the granular detail and the criticisms that have come forward from Audit Scotland regarding the way in which the Government has managed its budget and financing processes to date.

Lorna Slater was absolutely right to draw attention to the importance of early diagnosis and detection. However, because of the year-on-year funding issues that face primary care, it is getting increasingly difficult for people to see a GP, and that is often the first point of contact with the medical profession, so problems are being stored up in our NHS because of the lack of access to primary care.

David Green was also absolutely correct to flag some of the comments that the Fraser of Allander Institute has made in relation to the way that the data is being managed and analysed. Bob Doris rightly alluded to that when he said that, as we go through the spending and tag what is preventative, we should be looking for new activity, rather than simply building up a cumulative picture of the way in which money is spent overall.

Ultimately, the way in which the Government will succeed—if, indeed, it does succeed—is for preventative spend to be part of the DNA of the budgeting process. I am concerned when the solution is another unit, strategy or framework, rather than making sure that the process is firmly embedded in the principle of the core public finances.

I commented earlier on the situation that faces councils, which is where the Government could, most of all, undermine its efforts to pivot to preventative spending. Last year, in my constituency, Dumfries and Galloway Council was considering entirely defunding the Dumfries and Galloway Citizens Advice Service, which would have meant the service closing. The service fought a very effective rearguard action to make sure that that did not happen. In doing so, it pointed out that, for every £1 invested into a local citizens advice service, the return to society was £50. There is no clearer example of local government or the Government making a short-term funding cut that has long-term and serious consequences.

Ultimately, the Government now needs to double down and make sure that the initial vision for preventative spend, as identified by the Christie commission, is driven right through the process. That means that it must be meaningful, manageable and deliverable and, if it is those three things, it should be effective. However, given some of the criticism that we have seen from Audit Scotland, the Government will have to ensure that the processes and procedures are in place, so that it actually delivers on its agenda and strategy to create truly preventative spend throughout Scotland’s public finances.

The rest of this Official Report will be published progressively as soon as the text is available.