Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 19:35]

Meeting date: Wednesday, November 18, 2026


Contents


Local Government Reform

The next item of business is a debate on motion S7M-02069, in the name of Ross Greer, on local government reform. Members who wish to speak in this debate should press their request-to-speak buttons now.

16:18

Ross Greer (West Scotland) (Green)

Imagine for a moment that most people in Scotland were paying the wrong rate of income tax. It would be a crisis that would demand a crisis-level response. Ministers would be making statements to the Parliament. I am quite sure that First Minister’s question time would be extremely robust, and I imagine that those who are inclined towards such a style of politics would be lodging motions of no confidence in the ministers who had allowed that situation to occur.

We do not really need to imagine it, because that is what is happening right now, but it is happening with the council tax. There is agreement across the Parliament that the council tax system is broken. We are in the perverse situation in which most households pay the wrong rate. Of those, about half pay more than they should and half pay less. That hides a really deep inequity, because it is overwhelmingly the poorest households who pay far more than they should—it is a huge proportion of their income and wealth—and the very wealthiest people who get off with an absolute steal.

Across this chamber, we have very different definitions of fairness, which are based on our ideology and ethics. However, the current situation meets absolutely none of the definitions of fairness that colleagues hold. From any political position, it is not only a disagreeable system but a broken system that fails by its own standards.

How have we got here? As we have heard before—and colleagues have certainly heard me say it often enough—the council tax

“has not been in date in my lifetime.”—[Official Report, 13 June 2024; c 88.]

When I first said that in the Parliament, I was the only member for whom that was the case. There are now members of every group in the Parliament who were born after the point at which the council tax was based on anything like an accurate property roll.

Daniel Johnson (Edinburgh Southern) (Lab)

The member is making an interesting point. I would argue that the council tax has never been accurate. Many of the valuations were done by so-called drive-by methodology in 1991. They have never been accurate. Would the member agree that that is an absurdity?

Ross Greer

Mr Johnson is absolutely right—and that takes us right back to the genesis of the council tax. It was a quick and dirty replacement for another failed system of local taxation—the poll tax. It was never supposed to be sustained for anything like as long as it has been. If we fail to grasp the matter in this session of Parliament, the council tax will be 40 years old. That is 40 years of failure, and it is an entirely avoidable situation.

We know what the challenges are with regard to fixing the tax and we know why we have got through so many decades of the Parliament but failed to fix it. There are winners and losers in any system of taxation and there are winners and losers when any change is made to it. In the current council tax system, the winners are overwhelmingly wealthier people—those with social, political and economic power—and they will be the losers if we fix the inequities in the system.

Last year, when I moved amendments to the Housing (Scotland) Bill, proposing revaluation exercises, MSPs from all parties agreed that the system was broken. At that point, however, they thought that it should be for the subsequent session of Parliament to fix the problem. Well, here we are in the subsequent session of Parliament. Many of the members who made those comments were re-elected, and I am glad to have them back to take part in this exercise. We have an opportunity to do that.

I give credit the First Minister and the Scottish Government. The Government was called on from all corners to be bold with its agenda for this session of Parliament, and it has made bold proposals for local government reorganisation. There are lots of concerns about the specifics of those proposals, and I am sure that we will get into them this afternoon, but they represent a bold and overdue debate—on something that we have not debated since this Parliament was re-established.

This afternoon’s debate is Parliament’s opportunity to say to the Government that we cannot and will not redraw the map without fixing the finances of our local councils. A lot has been said about the need for consensus before we can do that, and I want to explain how we can get there, but I will start by explaining the Greens’ starting position. We want to replace the council tax and non-domestic rates with a system of land value tax. We want a system that prevents land banking and property hoarding and is far more transparent than the current system. As an interim step, we would replace the council tax with a residential property tax, preferably based on individual property values, because they are far easier to collect and keep up to date now than they were in 1991. We could at least do that with a system of bands; we would just need far more of them than there are in the current system.

However, those are not red lines, and we are absolutely ready to hear proposals from other parties and to compromise with them, because we believe that there is a supermajority for council tax reform in this session. I think that there is a clear majority for taxing land and property, rather than completely replacing council tax with something such as a local income tax. I want to hear those proposals from other parties, because I believe that there is common ground to be found here.

I am proud of the previous reforms that we have made. Working together, the Greens and the Scottish National Party have given councils more power over taxation on holiday homes and empty properties. I wish that councils would use their discretion a bit better—for example, to exempt Ministry of Defence and Foreign Office personnel from that—but the system has broadly been successful. It has raised hundreds of millions of pounds and is helping to tackle the housing crisis caused by those properties.

Last year, through a Green amendment, we agreed to end the scandal whereby domestic abuse survivors are paying off their abusers’ council tax debts, and the Government announced just a few weeks ago how it would address that.

We also have an agreement to introduce a mansion tax, which will make the system a bit less unfair. However, if we deliver only that mansion tax, it will leave us in the perverse situation whereby we will have done a partial revaluation at the very top of the property scale and most people in Scotland will still be paying the wrong rate, because their properties will not have been revalued.

There is a huge opportunity for total redesign of the system. We do not need to reinvent the wheel to do that, so I am absolutely not asking the Government for another years-long commission process. I do not want us to end up with another report like the one that came from the 2015 commission on local tax reform. That was an excellent piece of work, but it was put in a cupboard so deep and so far away in the bowels of Scottish Government headquarters that, when the previous session’s Finance and Public Administration Committee asked for a copy of it, the Government had to use the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine to find it, because the domain had expired on the website that the Government was storing it on. We cannot do that again.

I welcome the amendment from the Labour Party.

Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con)

I am listening with great interest to Ross Greer’s arguments about replacing council tax. As he said, we have been having these conversations for 20 years. Does it not tell him something that, in 20 years, nobody has come up with a viable, attractive alternative? Why does he think that it will happen now?

Ross Greer

Mr Fraser will be well aware that, for 20 years, the Scottish Greens have come up with a range of viable and attractive alternatives. It is a shame that, while others in the chamber were trying to find a solution, Mr Fraser’s party did not even enter the room to take part in those discussions. I disagree with Mr Fraser’s amendment, but I sincerely want to know the Tories’ position. I believe that Mr Fraser will not pretend that the current council tax system is working. Certainly, it is not working as intended. He has a bit of a Twitter troll, court jester profile in Parliament, but he is, or once was, a serious intellectual in Conservative politics.

I want to know what Mr Fraser would do to fix the system. I know that he does not agree with my proposals, but the Greens have already said that we are willing to compromise, so I want to hear from him, in the same way that I want to hear from other parties.

I agree with Labour’s amendment, although I am sure that members would agree that cross-party talks cannot be just a repeat of the 2015 process. We have done that already and can start from there and move forward. The process can include organisations beyond political parties. For example, Marie Curie has highlighted problems that those with terminal illnesses face with the current council tax system and has proposed a simple solution, which would be to transfer Social Security Scotland’s special rules for terminal illness to the council tax relief system. We know what the problems are, there are a range of solutions, and the Greens are willing to compromise with others to achieve them.

We cannot get to 2031 and be celebrating the 40th birthday of a broken and unfair system. Regardless of what happens overall with reorganisation, I am asking the Parliament to take the opportunity to say that this will be the session when MSPs finally fix a system that is universally recognised as being broken and unfair and replace it with a system that supports our local services and ensures that what people have to pay corresponds with their ability to do so.

I move,

That the Parliament agrees that local government reorganisation must include greater fiscal empowerment of councils, including the replacement of the current outdated council tax system with a fairer and more progressive model, and instructs the Scottish Government to lay out the process by which it aims to achieve this in its forthcoming reorganisation proposals.

I call Hannah Mary Goodlad to speak to and move amendment S7M-02069.3.

16:27

The Minister for Public Finance (Hannah Mary Goodlad)

I welcome the opportunity to set out the Government’s view on how we can make local taxation fairer, alongside our work to reform Scotland’s local governance landscape. I give a commitment that we will celebrate Ross Greer’s 40th birthday, but we will not celebrate the 40th birthday of the council tax in its current form in 2031.

The Scottish Government recognises the broad ambition behind the motion. We recognise that reform of local governance arrangements and the current local council tax system will help us to deliver more impactful and financially sustainable public services for our communities. A council tax system that is based on 1991 property values demands change. I would expect to find substantial common ground across the chamber, even from the Tories, on that point. As Mr Greer rightly pointed out, to date, progress has faltered on securing cross-party agreement on many points, including the specific nature of council tax reform and what any change should look like in practice.

We want councils to have reliable resources to deliver public services and we want communities to have a meaningful say on decisions that affect them. We want households to be treated fairly. We also want any change to be workable in every part of Scotland.

Will the member give way?

Hannah Mary Goodlad

I will, in a minute.

The question is not whether we should engage with council tax reform, but how we should turn a widely shared ambition into a reformed model that councils can administer, households can understand and the Parliament can deliver with confidence.

Daniel Johnson

The minister is making good points about the sustainability of any future levy and about ensuring that local government finances are sustainable. There is also an interaction between council tax and non-domestic rates. Does the minister agree that those two areas need to be looked at holistically, because there is such an interaction?

Hannah Mary Goodlad

There is an interaction between many parts of our financial system and local governance reform. That is why the local governance reform process that the Government is taking forward, which will involve looking at our councils, our bespoke island solutions and our regions, provides us with the opportunity to look at finance and local government structures together in the round. It is not possible to resolve structural issues without looking at the powers—they are interlinked.

As Mr Johnson knows, we are engaging—I am providing leadership on this, along with the Deputy First Minister—in a wholesale review of non-domestic rates. The fact that such a review was missing from this year’s UK budget was very disappointing. There is work to be done in that regard.

We are not starting from scratch. In the previous parliamentary session, colleagues worked with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on a substantial joint programme of evidence gathering and engagement. That work included independent analysis by the Institute for Fiscal Studies, a 14-week public consultation and five public engagement events across Scotland, and round-table sessions with tax experts. Eighty-two per cent of respondents to the consultation supported reform and 67 per cent supported a full revaluation. The consultation and public engagement process identified a banded approach to council tax as a preferred model. That evidence base, alongside the discussions around local governance reform, provides us with an opportunity for cross-party agreement on the need to make progress.

Ross Greer

The minister correctly makes the point that the reform process will require cross-party agreement. In talking about what it believes is required, the Government has often used the word “consensus”. Will the minister clarify that that does not mean achieving unanimity across the Parliament? Achieving unanimity is unrealistic, but it is clear that a supermajority of members are willing to proceed with reform.

Hannah Mary Goodlad

I welcome the chance to set out some of the definitions and the semantics. Personally—I also use my influence in Government on this—I believe that the best decisions are made when there is disagreement and diversity of thought, because that means that we have to come together and decide on the direction of travel. However, in any good business or industry, it is necessary to start with a desired result. That involves asking, “What are we trying to solve?” Once we have done that, we can project manage the process, look at the tasks and the risk picture and crack on.

We need to have a cross-party working group, and we need to get together in the new year to define the direction of travel. We should not be shy of any disagreement that may occur, because it is through that process that we will find an agreed way forward.

With regard to local governance, the Greens and Mr Greer are correct in identifying that governance and finance go hand in hand and belong in the same conversation. In fact, as I mentioned to Mr Johnson, they cannot and should not be separated. Power without responsibility is meaningless, and responsibility without the correct leverage is utterly powerless. We must have that conversation in tandem and in partnership—it must be a holistic discussion about decision making, funding, revenue generation and fiscal autonomy. We must come to the correct conclusions about the level at which those responsibilities best sit, whether that is regionally, nationally or locally, taking account of the need for bespoke island solutions.

Flexibility is important. We know that we are a diverse country and that what works well in one area is not necessarily the best approach for another area. We need to develop the functions and the accountability and funding arrangements together, so that each part supports the others. Ongoing engagement will inform the development of further proposals, and more details will be announced in due course.

Throughout the process, our approach should be devolution by default. The Scottish Government will continue to call on the UK Government to support the further devolution of powers. I hope that I can rely on our Labour colleagues to match that call. It is critical that the democratic mandate of this Parliament is respected. I welcome the Prime Minister’s commitment not to bypass the Scottish Parliament on the devolution of further powers to the regions in Scotland. The Deputy First Minister, the Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform and I are keen to work with colleagues across the Parliament, and with local government, on the principles that should guide that settlement, including as part of the ongoing dialogue on local governance arrangements.

I am aware of the time.

I want to build on the work that has already been done and the work that we are undertaking on local governance reform, which provides us with a golden opportunity to tackle the issue together. We have a solid foundation, and we are now laying the groundwork to build on that. I invite the Scottish Greens—and, indeed, other parties across the Parliament—to join us, and I look forward to hearing some of the ideas that are raised in the debate. If we can reach cross-party agreement on a fair and deliverable model of council tax reform, the Government will consider the legislative opportunities that are available to deliver that, and ensure that we celebrate Ross Greer’s birthday in 2031.

I move amendment S7M-02069.3, to insert at end:

“agrees that local government reform is necessary and should be concluded during the current parliamentary session; notes the Prime Minister’s commitment to support the devolution of powers from the UK government to regions in Scotland; welcomes the Prime Minister’s commitment not to bypass the Scottish Parliament in the devolution of these further powers; recognises that greater devolution of responsibilities to regions will require regional structures to be delivered; supports the view that, alongside new regional structures, new community level structures are also required to give a greater voice to local communities, and believes there are opportunities to place responsibilities that currently rest with non-departmental public bodies within the powers of new regional structures for local government.”

16:35

Joe Fagan (South Scotland) (Lab)

I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests, which states that I am a serving councillor.

There can be no argument about the fact that the council tax is flawed. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation described the current system as

“desperately in need of reform”

and warned that one in 10 of the lowest-income households are behind on their council tax bills. The IFS has said that the council tax is “regressive and distortionary”; as Ross Greer set out, most homes are incorrectly banded. In his new book—which I have yet to read—Professor Kenneth Gibb said that council taxes are “archaic” and “badly designed”. He argues that no

“reasonable property tax can be based on such outdated values”

from 1991.

Yet, despite repeated commitments to scrap or reform the system, the council tax remains. I must point out that almost 20 of the 33 years that the council tax has been in place in Scotland have been under this SNP Government. It is now more the SNP’s council tax than John Major’s. Thankfully, there are prospects for change, and Scottish Labour is prepared to work on a cross-party basis to build a majority for that. Indeed, since the election in May, we have twice lodged amendments that secured parliamentary support for cross-party talks. We believe that it is important to build political and public support to ensure that reforms are fairly designed and implemented. I agree with much of Ross Greer’s critique of the system that we have now.

The purpose of the Labour amendment is to introduce a reality check into the debate about reorganising local government and to ensure that, if no consensus emerges around the next steps for redrawing the municipal map of Scotland, we continue to pursue shared ambitions that can command support. Those shared ambitions must surely include establishing a system of local taxation that reflects the times in which we live rather than the property market of 1991, modernising the way in which decisions are made and a new policy of regional growth and development.

I say to the Scottish Government that, although there is certainly common ground between us on regional growth and empowerment, it really needs to get its act together on local government reform. It is asking the Parliament to endorse proposals to fundamentally change local government in this country before its period of “intensive engagement” has concluded or meaningful consultation has even begun. That is not serious governance, and it is not a position that a serious Parliament should endorse.

My concern about the reorganisation debate is not just that the proposals that the Scottish Government shared were absent from the manifesto that it stood on just six months ago. It is not just that, for the past 20 years, the Government has been a centralising Government that has systematically underfunded and undermined local authorities. It is not just the massive uncertainty that reorganisation creates for a workforce that is emerging from years of crisis and austerity, and it is not just that reorganisation will impede the real and progressive public service reform that workers and innovators are delivering right now across local government. My concern is also that the Government’s approach is incongruent given the steps that local and central Government have taken together to reset a relationship that our communities need to work. That includes important steps such as the Verity house agreement and the incorporation of the European Charter of Local Self-Government into law only last month.

I ask the Parliament to move faster on regional growth, an area in which councils are actively pushing for change, and to get serious about replacing the council tax with a fairer system, but not to impose a total reorganisation for which no party has built a case or secured a mandate. Reorganisation will have consequences, and our public services and public servants deserve better. For those reasons, I move amendment S7M-02069.1, to insert at end:

“; notes that the Parliament has voted for cross-party talks on the future of the council tax; further notes the content of the European Charter of Local Self-Government, which was incorporated into law in October 2026, and the Verity House Agreement, which states that the Scottish Government and local authorities will work together to ‘deliver sustainable person-centred public services recognising the fiscal challenges, ageing demography and opportunities to innovate’, and believes that, even if no consensus can be reached on local government reorganisation, the Scottish Government should nonetheless work to replace the council tax and progress regional devolution.”

I call Murdo Fraser to speak to and move amendment S7M-02069.2 for up to four minutes.

16:39

Murdo Fraser (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con)

I do not know whether it hurts me more to be described by Ross Greer as a court jester or as an intellectual—I think that he would call that a balanced analysis.

Ross Greer has perhaps brought us to the chamber on false pretences, because, although the subject of the debate is local government reform, I have hardly heard a word from him about that—indeed, he talked a great deal about reform of local government finance but very little about reform of its structures. I hope that we will hear a bit more about what the Greens think about the proposals for the structural reform of local government, because that is where much of the interest in the debate lies. I hope, too, that when they talk about standing up for local communities, the Greens mean it, for a change, and that they will not fall into line and be the nodding dogs for the SNP on the issue, as they are on so many others.

It would be a kindness to say that the SNP’s plans for local government have been drawn up on the back of a fag packet. What we have are proposals for a new regional tier for as few as six regional authorities and up to 160 local councils at the community level; however, there is little clarity on what the division of responsibilities or, indeed, what the regions or the role of councillors would be on those new bodies.

Will the member give way?

If Mr Melville wants to tell me the answers to all those questions, I will happily give way.

The member would be the first to criticise the Scottish Government if it had come forward with such prescriptive proposals.

Murdo Fraser

I know that Mr Melville is relatively new here, but I remind him that the SNP is actually in government. If it has some ideas, perhaps it might tell us what they are, so that we can debate them instead of our debating in a vacuum.

Local government reform was announced in the programme for government with just a three-month consultation period.

Will the member give way?

Oh, yes, I will give way to Mr Greer—maybe he knows what the Scottish Government is planning, because the rest of us do not.

Ross Greer

As I know Mr Fraser to be a voracious reader, I am surprised that he missed the detailed paper that the Scottish Greens published over the summer, in which we laid out the exact form of the two-tier system of local government that we propose. We were delighted that the First Minister quoted directly from that paper when he announced his programme for government.

We have significant concerns about what the SNP has proposed. I was perhaps uncharitable when I described Mr Fraser as a court jester—a more diplomatic way of putting it would be to say that he is not quite the Liz Smith of this session’s Conservative Party—

Members: Oh!

Ross Greer

I will put the question back to him: would he like to lay out the Conservatives’ proposals for either reform of local government or replacement of the council tax? It is very easy to oppose ideas for tackling those problems but, for decades, we have not heard a single proposal on what the Conservative Party would do to fix any of them.

Murdo Fraser

That is a lengthy intervention. I say gently to Mr Greer that if the Scottish Government has, indeed, based its plans on what the Greens have proposed, that makes those proposals even less attractive to us. However, we will see.

On the point about positive ideas, I will say something about local government reform now and will directly address the issue of local government finance in my winding-up speech, because I have something to say about that then.

It is interesting that the First Minister apparently took only 75 minutes before considering putting council reform in the programme for government. Let us put that in context. In 1966, when the Wheatley commission reported on the creation of the structure of regional and district councils, it took nine years before that was implemented. When the more recent local government reorganisation came about, in 1996, it had first been proposed by Iain Lang in 1991, so the debate and consultation process had taken five years. Instead, the SNP is proceeding at breakneck speed to introduce a new system that, as far as I can see, seems to have absolutely no support from anybody apart from SNP ministers.

Will the member take an intervention?

I will take as many interventions as I can, Presiding Officer, if I can get the time back.

What timescale would Mr Fraser propose?

Murdo Fraser

I have just outlined the time that it took to work on such reforms in the past. If Hannah Mary Goodlad listened to people in her party, she would know how unhappy they are with what is proposed. In Fife, councillors across the spectrum do not want to go into a bigger region that involves Edinburgh or, for that matter, Stirling, Clackmannan or Perth and Kinross. In Perth and Kinross, the council’s unanimous view is that those ideas—

Will the member take an intervention?

Murdo Fraser

Just let me finish my sentence, Mr Kerr. [Laughter.] In Perth and Kinross, it is the unanimous view of the council that it does not want to be part of a larger regional structure. Even the First Minister’s own SNP councillors in his constituency oppose what the Scottish Government is planning to do. Perhaps Mr Kerr can explain why those ideas are so great.

Alex Kerr

I declare an interest as an SNP councillor who is in favour of public service reform in the local government space.

Mr Fraser needs to pick a lane here. Either the Government is going way too fast, and it should undertake loads of consultation and get the answers right away, or we need to go much more slowly. Which one is it? Should we go very fast or very slowly—or should we undertake consultation, which we have done, lay out a provisional structure and, after the consultation, decide on the direction of travel?

Murdo Fraser

Perhaps Mr Kerr should start listening to his SNP council colleagues in different parts of the country, who are making arguments that are much more akin to mine than to his.

I will address the question that Ross Greer posed about reform. I do not think that anybody is against genuine reform of local government. We already know that some councils are interested in combining. We also know that some councils are interested in working more regionally—either in a formalised structure or in a less formalised structure—and in sharing services, as some already do; there might be more scope to do that.

Before we make decisions about radical and detailed reform, we must answer some serious questions, at least in principle. What exactly is local government for, and how should it be funded? Mr Greer made a fair point about that. Over the past two decades of the SNP in government, councils have seen their budgets slashed, leaving them with no choice but to cut non-essential services such as libraries and leisure centres, and to cut, for example, the number of classroom assistants. The councils feel that they have become local delivery offices for Scottish Government policies rather than centres of government in their own right.

I say gently to Mr Greer that many of the budgets that involved cutting the funding to local government were backed by his party in this chamber, and he should reflect on that.

Any reform of local government needs to be based on the principle that councils are a tier of government in their own right. That needs to come with the security of funding from the Scottish Government that provides them with a certainty that does not currently exist. That is why we have proposed something equivalent to the Barnett formula, which would say that, when the Scottish Government’s budget from Westminster increases, a set share of that should go to local government. I hope that members will reflect on that suggestion.

The system of funding needs to be fair, particularly to rural areas—

You must conclude, Mr Fraser.

Murdo Fraser

Those are the points in my amendment, which I am very happy to move.

I move amendment S7M-02069.2, to leave out from “agrees” to end and insert:

“notes the widespread opposition to the Scottish Government’s plans for local government reform and the rushed timetable for consultation, which demonstrates contempt for stakeholders; believes that imposing a new regional tier would not provide efficiencies or benefit local communities; further believes that there is an opportunity for meaningful reform, which needs to be progressed through consensus, and considers that any such reform must be based on an understanding of the role and function of local government and its autonomy from the Scottish Government, and must deliver a fair, secure and stable funding settlement for councils across Scotland, with proper recognition of the additional costs of delivering services in rural communities.”

16:47

Angela Ross (Edinburgh and Lothians East) (Reform)

A tax can be progressive on paper and still feel unfair when the bill is opened at the kitchen table, and that can be the case for a variety of reasons. We know that our communities need services and that they need proper funding, but it is difficult to establish what that system is, if it is to be truly fair to all. Of course, that is what we, as politicians, must endeavour to do.

I feel disheartened when I come to the chamber and realise that, despite having had decades to make a difference here, we are still grappling with this issue today. Many of us know from what we have heard on people’s doorsteps that they are unhappy with council tax charges and the services that they receive in return. Equally, we know that councils across the country are stretched—we are seeing many councils in that position—and are trying to balance budgets and resources. However, is this a cash issue alone, or are there other underlying processes and inefficiencies that we must change to address the situation in its totality?

It is imperative that we understand the problem that we are trying to solve, and not just use tax reform as an opportunity for wealth redistribution. It must be about improving the situation. Throwing more money at a broken system and expecting better outcomes will not work.

The motion from the Greens calls for

“greater fiscal empowerment of councils, including the replacement of the current … council tax system with a fairer … model”.

We support providing councils with the opportunity to have greater control over raising revenue to support better costing and spending, and we support looking at an outdated system that is based on house valuations from the 90s. Indeed—and I hate to add this—I was around when that occurred. We do note that, in 2017, multipliers were added to the higher bands, and it would be really good to have a thorough assessment of that adjustment and its impact in order to understand whether it had made any difference and whether communities felt as though they had benefited from it.

Council tax is intended to be progressive, with those living in higher-value properties generally paying more than those in lower-value ones. We agree with the diagnosis set out in the motion, but the solution that we would propose is perhaps different.

Our view of the word “progressive”, when it comes to action, is slightly different to the Greens’ interpretation of it. We need a fair, transparent and accountable model if true changes are to be felt. An assessment of what does and does not work in the tax system is vital before we can start to state what the solution should be. Only once that is done will we be able to determine the correct mechanism to use.

With regard to cross-party working, we are willing to look at what ideas we could bring to the table. I am sure that it would be much better if we could put our heads together.

One question that I have is this: when the motion talks about a “progressive model”, is it referring to income, property value, wealth, pension wealth or assets? After all, each of those things is very different from the others.

The motion raises two other questions: what would make a new, “fairer” system, and what new power would it give to councils? That is really important. We must ensure that councils gain more control over how much revenue they raise and how they raise it. Having a new system that revolves around changes to household pay while council powers remain the same will not create the effects that we need.

If the Government chose to accept the Green proposal, part of the process would be showing what choices councils would gain. Scotland’s councils face a range of challenges that must be considered. Indeed, the problem is so wide that a reform programme must come into play.

Please conclude.

Angela Ross

We are looking at how we can improve a broken system that nobody is happy with. We need to ensure that, if it is to be progressive, it is truly progressive against the correct measurement, and we need to be aware of what problem we are trying to solve. It feels as though we have not got there in the time that the SNP has been in government, and we need to get there quicker for the people out there.

16:52

Morven-May MacCallum (Highlands and Islands) (LD)

I declare that I am a sitting councillor.

I thank the Greens for bringing this debate to the Parliament—it is long overdue and warmly welcomed. We all know that council tax is outdated, relying on valuations made in 1991 that have no bearing on household income or ability to pay. As council budgets get tighter and tighter, our constituents watch as their council tax bills rise year after year and, all the while, councils are struggling to deliver the same standard of services for their residents. As the Joseph Rowntree Foundation has said, we have to fix this, because it is breaking local democracy.

Turning to the wider impacts of local government reform, which have already been mentioned in the debate, I note COSLA’s estimate that, the last time there was local government reform, it cost more than £600 million in today’s money. Every penny that is spent on reform today is a penny that could be spent on schools, roads or tackling poverty. I note, too, that the Joseph Rowntree Foundation has warned of a risk of council reorganisation becoming a distraction from the far more important work of improving people’s lives.

As a local councillor, I have spent a lot of time speaking to other councillors about their views on reform. Candidly, they have told me that they are frustrated at the lack of consultation, they feel blindsided by the fact that proposals appear out of nowhere and they are concerned that local government is about to be altered without their consent. If this is truly a national conversation, we must do more to bring local councillors on board, which means addressing the problems that they see as causing the greatest challenges in their communities. We can do that by giving them more powers and better funding deals and by acknowledging the existing partnerships that councils have already built.

For example, in my region, eight local authorities work together through the northern alliance on education and children’s services. Separately, I know that South Lanarkshire and North Lanarkshire have a great cross-council working arrangement across a wide range of matters. Our councils are already being strategic, and we should be doing more to encourage that instead of asking them to start from scratch.

With all that said, it is important that we are having the conversation, and I am glad that the Government has given us the opportunity to do so. I ask it to reflect on the concerns that have been raised in the debate by councillors and other members.

The conversation needs to be longer. A three-month consultation is not long enough to gather the range of views and evidence that are needed for us to get this right. There is a concern that pushing forward with reform now will result in a rushed job, perhaps failing to solve the very problems that we are trying to address. Indeed, the Accounts Commission has told us that the case for reform is clearly there, but that it cannot see evidence that the Government’s proposals will resolve the problems that councils are facing.

We will support the Greens’ motion today, without lodging an amendment. However, it will solve only part of the problem, because we still need to fund councils properly, acknowledge and support the work that they already do and, ultimately, ensure that any reform is built alongside local councillors, who are at the heart of our communities.

We move to the open debate.

16:56

Katie Hagmann (Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley) (SNP)

I entered the Parliament as a serving local government councillor, a role that I held with pride for nine years and that not only gave me the opportunity to be my council’s convener and civic head but afforded me the chance to serve as the national spokesperson for finance and resources. It was an enormous privilege and it shaped my journey into politics and public service. However, much as I prided myself on my leadership role in local government, it was a key reason for standing in the parliamentary elections in May. I wanted to bring to our national Parliament my experience of local government and the challenges that our local councils face.

Setting budgets and delivering policy on the front line was hard and it is getting harder. I do not think that any member can dispute that. Our incredible local government workforce does amazing things every day. Although it might be easy to talk down our councils, we need only look at the COSLA excellence awards, which will take place tomorrow night, to see that there is much to celebrate. It is fair to say, though, that challenges persist and that, without the opportunity for reform, we will not be able to meet the demands of our communities for what they need and deserve.

The motion talks about the “outdated” model of council tax, and I completely agree with that view. The case for reform—or, at least, for re-evaluation—has been made numerous times in various forums. I believe that all members across all parties agree that we must collectively deliver on the reform of council tax.

However, that is the easy bit. What that looks like and how it will be delivered will be very much harder. How do we balance areas in which there might be perceived winners with those in which there are apparent losers? How do we balance areas in which populations are growing faster than services can be delivered with others that face depopulation, which, in turn, threatens the sustainability of services? Those are the challenges that we must all grapple with. However, meeting them is possible if everyone is willing to work together.

I want to touch on a positive example of partnership working within local government, which achieved what it set out to do and what the motion calls for: the creation of the greater fiscal empowerment of councils. The Visitor Levy (Scotland) Bill was a fiscal lever that was created for local government to use, or not—it allowed councils the ability to use their discretion, based on local need.

Back in May 2024, in a joint press release with the Scottish Government, I said of the bill that

“The opportunity of these … powers recognise the great diversity of Scotland’s communities, acknowledging that a one-size-fits all approach does not work. It will allow councils to respond to the needs and circumstances of both the local communities and our important visitor economies. …The visitor levy is a crucial step towards greater empowerment for local government”.

One size never fits all, and, as the Scottish Government embarks on its highly ambitious and exciting plans to reform local government, I urge that that sentiment sit firmly at the centre of its work. Our people and our communities must come first.

I welcome the launch of our national conversation on local government, but we must work collectively with our communities, our workforce, our elected councillors and our third sector and private partners. This is a job for us all, especially if we are to be bold and brave in this space and ensure that we really do put people before structures.

Last week, I stood down from my role as an elected councillor. In my letter of resignation, I shared that

“I stood for election as I wanted to ensure our communities and individuals had the very best of representation”.

That still holds true, and, although I might stand here, in Edinburgh, rather than in my local council chamber, my commitment to protecting front-line essential services remains true.

17:01

Alex Kerr (Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse) (SNP)

I declare an interest as a councillor in Glasgow City Council.

It will be no surprise to anyone that I believe in Scotland’s right to steer its own future as an independent nation, but I also believe that the principle of self-governance applies when it comes to giving the regions that make up Scotland the powers that they need to prosper and deliver for our communities.

Just last week, I publicly called for the Scottish Government to consider devolving non-domestic rates to new regional local authorities as part of the public service reform agenda, putting the incentives for driving economic growth, and the benefits of that growth, at the heart of our regions.

In the face of increasing pressure on our public services and a spiralling cost of living crisis that is driven largely by forces outwith our control, the First Minister has shown the bold leadership that is required to ensure that our public services are designed to face an uncertain future and to continue delivering for our people.

From my conversations with the public and with stakeholders, it seems that most already instinctively understand the need for the sweeping changes that are being considered as part of these reforms. The suggestions and feedback that I have had from experts in various fields, and which I have heard in my time on the Public Service Reform Committee, have reinforced my faith in the Scottish people’s ability to rise to that challenge.

I am also a firm believer that the best ways to do things often begin to grow out of necessity before legislation and structures formalise them. We can see the economic benefits of regionalisation through the work of our city regions. In my area, that is the Glasgow City Region, which comprises South Lanarkshire, North Lanarkshire, East Renfrewshire, East Dunbartonshire, Glasgow City Council, Inverclyde, Renfrewshire and West Dunbartonshire.

Just yesterday, the Glasgow City Region cabinet shared with MSPs in the region a draft devolution framework to enhance the powers of our region and to help transform the economy with a £7.5 billion programme over the next 10 years. I know that the Glasgow City Region cabinet and the hard-working team that supports it have been working on those proposals for some time, and I know that they will be given proper consideration by the Government as part of the public service reform process. I strongly urge other organisations in the public sector to follow their lead and come forward with their ideas and suggestions, as the expertise of those who work and deliver services to the public are going to be crucial to making public service reform work.

Replacing council tax is a huge task, and it requires as broad a political consensus as possible. By its nature, council tax is a regressive tax, but, if we are changing it to a revenue-neutral system, we will be moving the burden through a complex process while not guaranteeing that we will raise additional income for public services into the bargain. That is one of the reasons why I believe that we all, across the chamber, have a huge responsibility to work together to build as wide a consensus as possible for changes to council tax, ensuring that, if we tie it to local government reform, we do not endanger either local government or council tax reform.

Fundamentally, growing our tax base through promoting economic growth and bringing in additional resources to deliver our public services has to be at the forefront of our minds as we explore what the future of local government in Scotland will look like. The previous local government review was around 30 years ago, and we should not lose sight of the fact that the decisions that we take in the current session of Parliament represent an unprecedented chance to change how our public services are structured. The last time that local government was reorganised, I was two years old.

We can see the benefits of devolution in the gross value added regional figures that were released recently by the Office for National Statistics. Just before the Scottish Parliament was reconvened, in 1999, the UK’s largest city regions after London were greater Manchester, greater Birmingham, greater Leeds and greater Glasgow, in that order. All of those city regions had economies of roughly the same strength. However, by 2024, Glasgow topped the chart. When it comes to percentage change in GVA per capita over that period, east-central Scotland grew by 56.7 per cent, London grew by 38.2 per cent and west-central Scotland grew by 37.7 per cent, followed by Manchester at 35.9 per cent.

That shows the benefit of decisions being made in Scotland, in this place, by those who live and work here, and it underlines the need to look at devolution to the Scottish Parliament as part of the process of reform, as well as from the Parliament outwards to the regions. It is simply not sustainable for the Scottish Parliament to be constrained by its inability to properly borrow. With increasing calls for multiyear funding from our Parliament’s budget, the budget that this Parliament receives from the UK must grow and be sustainable over years, in order to accommodate those demands. That will probably require changes to the fiscal framework to properly empower this Parliament. If the Prime Minister is as serious about devolution as he claims to be, he must put those changes on the table.

I will end on a note of consensus. I look forward to working with colleagues across the chamber as we redesign our public services for the future.

17:06

George Adam (Paisley) (SNP)

When Alex Kerr was talking about the Glasgow City Region, I thought that he and I were going to have our first falling out, because, as I have said in previous debates, I am not and never will be a Weegie.

Here we are again, back discussing local government reform. Colleagues will not be surprised to hear that I have a few things to say about Renfrewshire and what I believe that Renfrewshire should become. Luckily, the Scottish Government’s amendment gives me ample opportunity to do that.

At one point, I thought that the minister, Hannah Mary Goodlad, was about to say that

“With great power comes great responsibility.”

Alas, Stan Lee’s famous line from 1962 almost made it, but not quite. However, it is true.

During the previous debate on this issue, I warned the Government that I had hunners to say on it, and members have heard only some of those points so far. However, there is a serious point here. We have an opportunity to change the way in which local government works in Scotland, and I believe that we should take that opportunity now.

For me, the starting point is quite simple. What are we trying to achieve? Local government reform must be about delivering better public services; it cannot simply be reform for reform’s sake. Nobody in Paisley is sitting at home, worrying about how many tiers of local government we have; they are worried about the roads, their children’s schooling, care for their elderly relatives and whether the services that they depend on actually work.

Lloyd Melville

George Adam is making good points. He might recognise from his experience that, too often in local government, the answer can be no before a question is even asked. Does he agree that, in many organisations, reform of structure must come with a change in culture, and that, if it does not, we are just wasting our time?

George Adam

I agree. To me, the purpose of moving to strategic authorities is to bring about a situation in which we have in place the people who want to make a difference and change things, and not just the usual suspects who constantly say no and stop us delivering for our constituents.

In September, I spoke about my vision for a Renfrewshire strategic authority that would cover not only the Renfrewshire Council area that we all know today but a wider, historical Renfrewshire area that would bring together the areas that are currently covered by Renfrewshire Council, East Renfrewshire Council and Inverclyde Council. Before anybody starts, I am not suggesting that Greenock should be run from Paisley, although some of my constituents might think that that would be a good thing. What I am suggesting is that we look seriously at how those communities could work together strategically, while keeping local decisions where they belong, with local people.

In the wider Renfrewshire area, we have Glasgow airport; the advanced manufacturing innovation district; Greenock ocean terminal; the University of the West of Scotland and West College Scotland, which cover the whole area; plus established industries and businesses with enormous potential. Surely that is a valid argument for bringing those opportunities together under one strategic authority, so that we could plan transport, infrastructure, economic development and investment across the whole area, rather than having three councils working within boundaries that were gerrymandered by a Tory Government more than 30 years ago.

Education is another example. There are opportunities to work together on specialist provision and additional support needs, while keeping that important local connection with families and the people we serve.

The test is whether the service will be better and easier to access and whether we will get better outcomes from the money that we spend. If the answer is yes, we should seriously consider changing how we deliver that service. However, if all that we will achieve is a new council logo, a different name on a building or another layer of bureaucracy, what is the point?

There is another side to my proposal. I want to see proper local councils based around towns and communities such as Paisley, Renfrew, Johnstone, Barrhead, Greenock, Gourock and Port Glasgow. Those councils should have a meaningful—and I mean meaningful—say in what happens in their towns in the future. It should not be a case of a committee meeting occasionally to discuss potholes and how many grit bins there are before sending a recommendation to someone miles away. There should be proper dialogue.

I assure members that neither a buddie nor someone from Greenock is particularly keen to be described as someone who lives in a suburb of Glasgow, and that will always be the case. We can work with Glasgow without becoming part of some enormous greater Glasgow authority.

Council tax reform could also be part of the discussion. It is difficult to seriously defend a system that is based on property valuations from 1991, so I will not try to, but it is extremely important that we consider what any changes might look like. The Scottish Government has been working with COSLA on a fairer and more progressive system, including proposals for new bands for properties that are worth more than £1 million. The people of Scotland have personal financial pressures to deal with at the moment, so any reforms must protect those who are least able to pay.

If powers come from Westminster, we need regional structures that are capable of exercising such powers, with democratic accountability. We should examine whether the responsibilities that currently sit with public bodies could be better delivered at a regional level.

None of this should be about creating structures simply for the sake of it. I am not precious about the current arrangements. They were created by the Scottish Office in the 1990s and can be changed. I want the Renfrewshire proposal to be examined and discussed in the communities that it would serve.

What matters is whether we can deliver better services and give people more control over decisions that affect their lives. We believe that decisions about Scotland should be made in Scotland. Surely the same principle should be applied to our towns and communities. The people of Paisley should have a proper say in Paisley’s future, just as people across Scotland should have a say in theirs. Naturally, I will not complain if, out of all this, the Scottish Government starts to look at the old county of Renfrewshire.

We move to winding-up speeches.

17:12

Murdo Fraser

In between hurling insults at me, Ross Greer rather misrepresented the Conservative position in relation to previous engagement on council tax reform. I appreciate that this was, I think, before he was an MSP, but I refer him to the Conservative tax reform paper that was produced in 2016 by an expert commission, chaired by Sir Iain McMillan, that brought together experts, economists and senior business figures. The paper set out how, at that stage, council tax should be reformed, with a recommendation that the bands be stretched. It is ironic that, at that point, the Scottish Government ignored completely the other work that had been done on proposals for alternatives to council tax. What did it propose? It proposed stretching council tax bands, so the Conservatives have had more influence over council tax reform than many other parties represented in the chamber, including perhaps Mr Greer’s party.

We are not against the notion of further reform. We are happy to listen to suggestions, but we are not prepared to accept the starting point that council tax must go until we know what people are proposing as an alternative. Let us weigh up the current council tax with any alternatives.

Will Murdo Fraser take an intervention?

Will Murdo Fraser take an intervention?

I will give way to Mr Greer, given that I mentioned him.

Ross Greer

I remember the paper that the Conservatives produced, which is why I found it confusing that they did not take part in the cross-party commission that every other party took part in. Do the proposals in that paper still represent the Conservatives’ starting position on local tax reform?

Murdo Fraser

That was our position at the time, which was 10 years ago. Those proposals were, in effect, implemented—indeed, the Government at the time went further.

I want to make an important point about where we are now. Council tax was introduced as a replacement for the rates. It was intended to be a hybrid tax, with a personal element representing the consumption of local services by people living in a property. That is why, for example, the system includes a 25 per cent discount for single people, to reflect the fact that they do not consume local services to the extent that a couple or a family does. Therefore, whatever the replacement to the council tax is, it should reflect such use of council services similarly.

If we have a tax that is based purely on property, we will end up with situations in which single elderly people, perhaps widows, are living in what was their family home—and it might be a large family home of considerable value—but might have very low incomes. Asking such people to pay a substantial annual sum from their low income for council services that they do not consume would not be fair, and it would not meet the test of fairness.

Again, I refer members to my amendment.

17:15

Julie MacDougall (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Reform)

Since being elected to the Parliament, I have been a staunch advocate for real and long-lasting changes to the way that the Scottish local government system works. I think that everyone in the chamber agrees that an overhaul of our current council tax system is well overdue. It is the job of MSPs to find a collective way forward.

However, although Ross Greer touched on that sentiment in his motion, I cannot support it because of the way in which he hopes to push predominantly his own party’s view on this issue. My colleague Angela Ross has already explained many of our reasons why we cannot support it, and I will try not to repeat them.

Instead, I will use my time to reflect on the council consultations that have been held so far by the Scottish Government and on what we should learn from that process. Unlike the SNP members and others across the chamber, COSLA and the heads of many Scottish councils have been interested in talking to Reform UK about the issue. All of them have expressed a general sense of discontentment about the way that much of the Government’s consultations have so far been handled. There has been a fundamental lack of communication from the Government about the plan for how the consultations will be held and about what outcome the Government hopes to achieve. Ultimately, that work has done nothing except introduce more uncertainty for our councils.

I want to make clear that I do not think something as massive as local government reform is straightforward or easy—it is not. However, it was the Government’s choice to embark on its policy programme and it has a moral duty to hold meaningful consultations and make firm decisions about what serves our communities best.

My worry about the Green motion is that the Green party members’ ideological attachment to imposing a so-called progressive income tax without considering any other viable alternatives will come at the cost of what is affordable for our constituents and what is financially sustainable for our councils. Single-mindedness such as that is what led to infamous policies such as Humza Yousaf’s council tax freeze. I like to remind the Government about that when I can, because it is one of the major contributing factors to many councils becoming more financially unstable.

In the Marie Curie briefing that I read this morning, there was a powerful quote from a family member of a person who faces terminal illness. They said:

“Nobody should be worrying about money when they are facing a terminal diagnosis. It made what was the most stressful situation even worse.”

That is why our communities need meaningful consultations on any major changes to things such as council tax. Council tax reform should be fair, proportionate, provide real value for money and fund excellent public services. Our constituents deserve so much better than paying more tax only to receive less council services. Fighting against that reality should be the real aim of today’s debate.

We cannot repeat the mistakes of the past. We need to ensure that we get council tax changes right. To do that, we have to step beyond the Holyrood bubble and put the delivery of services before idealised structures at every point of the decision-making process. I am very keen to work with all members from across the chamber, and I will support any calls to do that.

17:19

Daniel Johnson (Edinburgh Southern) (Lab)

Who knew that council tax could be the stuff of interesting, engaged and, at times, exciting debate? It is quite remarkable. The Scottish Parliament is truly innovative in that regard if no other.

This has been an excellent debate, and it was framed well by Ross Greer at the start: if the majority of the population were paying the wrong rate of income tax, there would be outrage. The reality is that council tax was introduced in a hurried fashion. As I said in my intervention on Ross Greer, we have never had people paying the right rates. Household bands were literally set by people marking down on a clipboard what they thought a property was worth while they sat in the passenger seat of a car as they were driven down the road in 1990 or 1991. The fact that that is still the basis on which most people are taxed is totally unacceptable.

What is more, the unfairness has compounded over time. When I first became an MSP, I found it remarkable when constituents pointed out the unfairness that, because they lived in newer properties, they were in a much higher council tax band, as those properties were valued at the point at which they were built, which was often decades after the 1991 valuation period.

I will make a final historical point. This is often overlooked, but it points to the inadequacy of the tax. When council tax was introduced, VAT was increased by 2.5 percentage points, rising from 15 per cent to 17.5 per cent. That was explicitly intended to make up the shortfall and provide an increase in funding for local government. That measure has been lost in the mists of time.

The point is that the basis on which the tax was conceived is now out of date. As the minister mentioned, concerns about its sustainability were being raised from the outset, which shows its inadequacy. We must get on with reforming it.

My colleague Joe Fagan was absolutely right: for much of council tax’s existence—for the past 20 years—it has been completely within the SNP’s power to do something about it. Indeed, the SNP had a 2007 manifesto commitment to replace it. It has held multiple commissions since then. Frankly, much as I am encouraged by the minister’s commitment to getting rid of council tax by 2031, I think that we will all be quite surprised if that turns out to happen. Prove us wrong, minister.

The point about fiscal sustainability is key. We have to look at this in the round, which means considering both non-domestic rates and council tax. However, Murdo Fraser’s point about something like a Barnett formula—a form of systematic assurance that local government gets its fair share—is critical. It is a fact that local government’s share of Scottish Government funding has fallen from around a third of the Government’s total funding to around a quarter over that period. Regardless of what we think about individual budget settlements, that clearly points to a falling share.

We must also talk about local government reform. Although many members have talked about a process and a consultation, neither of those exist. All that we have is a loose description of rapid conversation and a very short paper with one model in it. For those SNP members—

Will the member give way?

I think that I need to close very shortly.

You can take an intervention, if you so wish.

Okay. I will take the minister’s intervention.

Was Daniel Johnson aware that, last Friday, we introduced a wider consultation to enable the public to submit their views on local government reform? Perhaps he missed that.

Daniel Johnson

The last time that I checked, an online survey was available, not a formal consultation.

The Scottish Government has proposed that there be fewer, larger councils without really explaining why it wants to do that. I consider it positive that we are talking about regional structures and redistribution, but George Adam hit the nail on the head: we need much greater clarity on the rationale behind the proposals. I have a further question: why has the Government dismissed combined authorities or other models? We need a full exploration—

Will the member take an intervention?

Will I get my time back, Presiding Officer?

You will.

In that case, I am happy to give way.

Alex Kerr

I was delighted to hear that Daniel Johnson agreed with my call to devolve non-domestic rates, so I thank him for that. Does the member also agree with my call to increase this Parliament’s borrowing powers so that we can invest properly in the regions? Will he call on the Prime Minister to devolve that power?

Daniel Johnson

I very much welcome the member’s support for the UK Government’s proposals to devolve business rates. I do not think that I have time to talk about the full implications of the fiscal formula. [Interruption.] Another time. I would be willing to do that—there is a discussion to be had there.

The point is that, yes, we need discussion, but we also need a process, not something that has been hurriedly put together, which, unfortunately, is why we cannot support the Government’s amendment, although I consider there to be much merit in it.

17:24

The Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform (Ivan McKee)

The debate has highlighted the important shared ambition across the chamber to ensure that Scotland’s system of local governance and public service delivery is equipped to meet the challenges of the future. The Scottish Government believes that the reform of local governance has an important role to play in meeting that objective.

We recognise the pressures that public services face and the expectations of communities, and we need to ensure that scarce resources are used as effectively as possible. That is why we have begun this national conversation about where decisions should be made—

Excuse me, cabinet secretary. There are too many private conversations going on and too many folk wandering about the chamber. I would like to hear the cabinet secretary’s contribution without so many distractions, please.

Ivan McKee

Thank you.

That is why we have begun this conversation about where decisions should be made and how services can be best organised to do what this is all about, which is delivering better outcomes for the people of Scotland.

It is quite clear to anybody who has been paying attention that the proposals that have been published are not final decisions. They are the starting point for discussion and engagement. That discussion has been quite interesting, because it has divided people into two camps: those who have engaged with the process, made constructive suggestions and proposals, expressed ideas and contributed to the discussion; and those who have done nothing other than spend three months complaining that three months is not long enough to have a conversation. The divide is between those who are focused on how we improve services and those who are only focused on how we protect existing structures.

We are committed to listening to local government, communities, trade unions and members across this chamber in order to inform our approach to reform. We have held more than 50 meetings at ministerial level, and that approach will continue as we move through this process and beyond. Throughout this work, our guiding principle has been to get—

Calum Kerr rose—

Will I get my time back if I take an intervention?

Of course.

Calum Kerr

We have heard lots of creative ideas, and there has also been a bit of grumpiness, but I have an idea. Will the cabinet secretary join me in encouraging people to actively contribute to the ongoing consultation? Peebles and district community council shared with me its seven-page submission. I encourage others to follow the lead of that community council.

Ivan McKee

That leads me on to the next point that I want to talk about, which George Adam also touched on: the importance of moving decision making closer to communities. That principle is an essential part of the ideas that the Government has proposed, and communities have been invited to comment on those ideas and to identify the powers that they would like to see at the local level. I am delighted that Peebles community council is taking the lead on that. I know that other communities have done the same, and I encourage others who represent their communities to make proposals.

Will the cabinet secretary give way?

I hope that Murdo Fraser will articulate how his local community might want to have more powers devolved to it.

Murdo Fraser

I am grateful to the cabinet secretary for giving way and for that invitation, to which I will respond directly. I represent people in Fife, who are very clear that they do not want to be part of a larger region; they regard Fife as a region in itself. As I said in the debate, the view of councillors across the political spectrum in Perth and Kinross is that their area should be a region in its own right. Will the cabinet secretary listen to those views, rather than ride roughshod over them?

Ivan McKee

Murdo Fraser misses the whole point on several levels. I invited him to talk about his local community, which he steadfastly did not do; he instead talked about stuff happening at a regional level. He started drawing boundaries, even though we have been very clear that we are far away from that part of the process. I have been very clear that we have held many dozens of meetings at a ministerial level and many other official engagements beyond that, so we are very much in listening mode.

People have been very duplicitous about this issue. We were very clear about our intent when we presented our ideas for discussion. They have certainly started a discussion, but people have done nothing but criticise them and say that they are not fully developed, while proposing nothing themselves. Of course the ideas are not fully developed, because if the Government had presented fully developed proposals at the outset, people would have criticised it for failing to listen before making its decisions. People’s commentary on this is absolutely all over the place.

I want to talk about the regional aspect of this discussion, because Daniel Johnson asked, “Why regions?” He should ask his Prime Minister, “Why regions?” The Prime Minister has been very clear about that. Regions are identified in the proposal that the Scottish Government has made because we need to have the ability to make strategic decisions across a coherent economic area. The Scottish Government needs to have the ability to devolve transport powers, skills powers and economic development powers to those empowered regional entities. We need a platform to be able to do that, but the current structure does not allow it to happen, as Daniel Johnson should know. If the Prime Minister is talking about devolving powers to the regions—we hope to hold him to account to do precisely that—he will have to establish a regional structure through which that devolution can take place.

Daniel Johnson

As the cabinet secretary well knows, I have probably raised the subject of regionalism with him more than he has raised it with me. He knows that for a fact. I was saying that we need to talk about it. Why was the Scottish Government dismissing regionalism that works south of the border? That is what I was asking. I ask the cabinet secretary not to put words in my mouth. It is ridiculous.

Ivan McKee

I very much look forward to Daniel Johnson engaging constructively in the process rather than criticising the proposals and the ideas that we have floated.

I want to talk about the funding aspects—another area where I want to call out Daniel Johnson. If the Labour Party is serious about council tax reform, its members need to have a good look at themselves in the mirror. Daniel Johnson has been running around Edinburgh Southern complaining about the most minor step—the first step that we have taken to improve proportionality across the council tax system, through the introduction of the mansion tax. He is saying that it is the end of the world and a tax on Edinburgh that must be resisted on all counts.

Daniel Johnson

Does the cabinet secretary acknowledge that the banding system is arbitrary and that the problem is that singling out bands F and G could exacerbate a cliff edge based on arbitrary judgments that were made in 1991? That is the point that I was making.

Ivan McKee

The member should recognise that the valuation for £1 million and £2 million properties will be done according to today’s valuation, not the 1991 valuation. We have an example of a revaluation on a minor scale being taken forward and an example of increased proportionality in the system, but Daniel Johnson is going out of his way to oppose that—like the Labour Party did a number of years ago, when my colleague Tom Arthur made proposals to put more proportionality into the council tax system. Labour members were running around the country, putting out leaflets with misinformation about how that was going to put everybody in the country’s council tax up by 15 or 20 per cent. Labour members need to have a good look at themselves if they are serious about being part of co-operation to move forward on council tax reform. They need to stop spreading misinformation about it in relation to what has happened in the past.

Does Daniel Johnson want to intervene again?

No.

Ivan McKee

So, he accepts what I have said.

We are serious about taking forward reform to local governance, because we recognise that there needs to be more power at the levels of regions and communities. The people of Scotland understand that very well. It is not about protecting structures, and those who seek only to protect structures will find themselves on the wrong side of public opinion in this debate.

We are absolutely focused on how we can take forward council tax reform in the context of consensus. For that to become a political football again does nobody any favours. Parties across the chamber need to come to that with the right approach if we are to take forward any changes in that regard.

17:32

Laura Moodie (South Scotland) (Green)

In speaking now, I feel as though I should be pouring oil on troubled waters, but, given the theme of our first debate this afternoon, perhaps that is not the best analogy to use.

During the bulk of the debate, it struck me that one theme was that local government reorganisation and council tax replacement present us with an opportunity to fundamentally rewire the system. In listening to the contributions of members from across the chamber, it is clear that many of us agree that the current council tax system is broken. I was very definitely born by 1991, but I have a 13-year-old son who is the same age now as I was then—and he is 6 feet tall.

I take Daniel Johnson’s points about drive-by valuations. That approach is grossly unfair and always has been. It is worth noting that, since those valuations in 1991, the average Scottish property has increased in value by 357 per cent. However, there is huge variation in the range of increases across the country: for example, the increase in central Aberdeen has been 168 per cent, but the increase in East Lothian has been 500 per cent. That means that the relative value of properties in different parts of Scotland has changed significantly.

Apart from its inherent unfairness, the current system of council tax places a disproportionate burden on low-income families and single mothers, who are more at risk of living in poverty. Three quarters of all homes in Scotland are in bands A to D, although that proportion includes more than a third of the homes occupied by the richest 10 per cent of people in the country. Households with higher incomes are more likely to live in properties in bands E to H, but a sizeable share of lower-income households and a disproportionate number of women and single-parent families also live in those homes. That results in council tax bills being highest for many—particularly women—who have the lowest incomes.

In England, several local authorities have introduced council tax exemptions for foster carers, in recognition of the unfair burden that caregivers carry, and particularly for those who live in larger properties who accommodate foster children in their own bedrooms. Something serious needs to change if we are to make local government taxation fairer for us all. Although the redesign of Scotland’s councils will not fix underlying financial pressures, we can take a significant step towards more financial certainty by scrapping the broken council tax system and undertaking an immediate revaluation of properties. Giving councils more certainty and more flexibility on the funding that they receive can help us to achieve Scotland’s national missions, especially the defining mission of eradicating poverty.

Craig Hoy (Dumfriesshire) (Con)

Does the member accept that it is not just council tax but rents charged by councils that are rising? Is she aware of social landlords’ concerns that the increasingly onerous standards on heat in buildings are driving up rents? Would she join me in urging the Scottish Government to go no further because, ultimately, tenants will pay for those works through their rents?

Laura Moodie

Mr Hoy started well, but I have to disagree with the second part of what he said.

George Adam noted that people who are struggling to choose between heating and eating do not really care about who is in charge and which local authority area they are in. Councils can a do huge amount to address poverty, and ensuring that properties are up to scratch is a big part of that. Scotland’s relative poverty rate sits at 21 per cent, and we are very unlikely to hit the 2030 target of 10 per cent.

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation says that the current council tax model is a key barrier to investment in local services that reduce and mitigate the impacts of poverty. As Joe Fagan pointed out, one in 10 of the lowest-income households are behind on paying their council tax. Local councils can have a huge impact on reducing poverty throughout the country, especially if we give them the tax-raising powers to do so. In education, they can drive down the cost of the school day; in childcare, they can support women back into the workplace; in social work, they can deliver the Promise and whole family support, especially if they get the multiyear funding that Alex Kerr mentioned; in public transport, they can invest in public ownership, affordable fares and better bus services; and, in economic development, they can work on community wealth building and invest in social housing and regeneration. The funding that is received for the delivery of those vital services restricts councils’ ability to deliver them; it is not about where decisions are made.

I echo Morven-May MacCallum’s points about strategic cross-local authority working, which is already happening, and Katie Hagmann’s comments about the flexibility of the visitor levy being a good example.

We can all identify the problems that Scotland faces, and poverty is chief among them. We can all agree that the Parliament needs to focus on delivery, but the onus needs to be on both the Parliament and the Government to step up, to set clear priorities and to provide strategic direction to eradicate poverty. That must include a full revaluation of the council tax system as a first step.