Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 19:39]

Meeting date: Tuesday, November 17, 2026


Contents


NHS Grampian

The next item of business is a statement by Angela Constance on NHS Grampian. Questions will be taken at the end of the statement, so there should be no interventions or interruptions.

15:05

The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care (Angela Constance)

Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s independent “NHS Grampian Responsive Diagnostic Review”, which was published last week, left me with a profound sense of concern. The findings will be distressing for everyone across the north-east. Behind the findings are people who placed their trust in the national health service and had every right to expect safe, high-quality care, and they deserved better.

On Friday, I visited Aberdeen to hear directly from management, the board, staff, trade unions, patients and the public. It was important to me to do that, and I thank everyone who took the time to meet me. My door will remain open.

I reiterate my commitment to transparency. By the end of November, I will write to the Health, Care and Sport Committee, setting out a detailed timeline of the Government’s activity and correspondence with NHS Grampian over the past year, alongside the milestones that I expect to be demonstrated. I know that some MSPs had the chance to speak directly with the interim chair during the cross-party briefing that I organised yesterday, but I want to begin by setting out some important context.

The HIS review was formally commissioned by the chief executive in May 2026, eight months after she took up her post, and she was right to do so. As the review outlines, although there were some clear failures within the past year, many of the issues are long standing and systemic. I have seen from the review and from my time in Grampian that the chief executive has held up her hands and apologised where she has made mistakes, and she has shown a commitment to dismantling the poor organisational culture that led to many of the issues. Importantly, both the chief executive and the interim chair know that they have until the end of the year to provide evidence of urgent improvements. The board requires stability to do that.

I have been asked what role the Government has played. HIS operates independently of the Government and is responsible for monitoring the quality of care that is provided across our NHS. HIS raises issues directly with health boards and with the Government. When it does, I am clear that the learning should always be applied across our entire NHS.

In the case of NHS Grampian, the relevant period began in February 2025, when HIS first raised concerns with the board that, ultimately, contributed to the board’s escalation. In April 2025, HIS wrote to the Government regarding cardiology services at Dr Gray’s hospital. By 22 April, there was clear cross-party concern about NHS Grampian’s performance and financial position, with members questioning whether further escalation was necessary.

In response, on 12 May, we took the decision to escalate NHS Grampian to stage 4, specifically in relation to finance, leadership and governance, and the assurance board was established. Later that month, we commissioned the KPMG review that HIS referenced. In October 2025, the Government lodged in the Parliament a Government-initiated question that referred to that report. Thereafter, NHS Grampian agreed an improvement plan to take forward KPMG’s recommendations. The HIS review notes that some recommendations were not followed through.

My predecessor chaired the board’s annual review in October 2025. At that point, it was stated by NHS Grampian that clear progress was being made in making improvements, including for significant adverse event reviews. That raises serious questions about the accuracy of the information that was being scrutinised by the board and shared with the Government.

The HIS review notes that, although surgeons were instructed in late June 2026 to cease paediatric surgery at Dr Gray’s, that instruction was not implemented until August. That is an extremely serious and wholly unacceptable failure.

When I became aware of the paediatric service cessation in August, through media interest, I acted immediately by speaking to the chief executive, setting clear expectations for safe and rapid restoration, and visiting Dr Gray’s within days to meet the chief executive and staff.

In August, the board chair announced that she was stepping down. The Government took steps to appoint a new interim chair of the board, John Connaghan CBE, who started in October. John has my utmost confidence because he has a clear track record of delivery within the NHS. As the report highlights, information was not being openly or properly shared or escalated to or by the board, so it is vital that change happens now.

On leadership, I welcome that the board has already taken immediate action to change senior medical leadership. The new interim medical director, who took up post yesterday, is one of the Government’s deputy chief medical officers, Dr Graham Ellis, who has an outstanding record. That is how seriously I take these issues at Grampian.

On accountability and oversight, the report points to disturbing failures of governance, along with passivity and a lack of curiosity from the board. We have a new interim board chair and the board membership is changing significantly, with four new non-executives currently being appointed, replacing almost 50 per cent of the board.

The seriousness of the issues demands a decisive response from ministers. Although accountability for driving sustainable change remains with the board, it is our responsibility to ensure that NHS Grampian has both support and challenge to deliver rapid and sustained improvement. NHS Grampian will therefore remain within a strengthened stage 4 framework, with a new focus directly on patient safety, clinical governance, leadership and delivery of the review’s recommendations. The option to move to stage 5 remains, and I will reassess the situation in six weeks’ time.

I can announce that we have established an external intervention support team, comprising experienced senior NHS leaders who are entirely external to Grampian, with expertise in organisational and operational recovery, clinical governance, patient safety and performance improvement. Working alongside NHS Grampian, the team will provide intensive turnaround support. I have today published details of that team.

We are enhancing independent assurance through Healthcare Improvement Scotland, including an early review of Grampian within three months to assess progress. That will be followed by ongoing assurance reviews, which will be published. I intend to offer regular and ongoing briefings to MSPs so that Parliament can continue to scrutinise progress.

On patient safety, I met the Patient Safety Commissioner for Scotland last week and I have asked for her assistance in providing external scrutiny of NHS Grampian. I am open to any further options that she considers necessary to restore confidence and I very much welcome the commitment that she has shown to date.

Taken together, these measures are designed to support improvement, strengthen accountability and rebuild trust and confidence, while ensuring that NHS Grampian is judged by the pace and substance of the improvements that it delivers.

That is our response to the wider challenges laid out in the review in relation to governance and accountability. However, the review also speaks directly to specific concerns and vulnerabilities at Dr Gray’s hospital. I have heard some commentary in the press in recent days about what public service reform might mean for the future of Dr Gray’s. What is evidenced in this report is that the status quo is not working. That is due to a failure of leadership, governance and accountability, but it also lays bare both the geographical and service isolation of Dr Gray’s and the challenges that it has faced in terms of workforce recruitment and retention.

My intention through public service reform is to ensure much better integration between services—particularly for rural communities—and a sustainable future for Dr Gray’s. That will be essential. Let me be categorical: Dr Gray’s hospital will remain a key asset for the care of patients in the north and will be a primary focus of our work to recover Grampian.

Finally, and of significant concern to me, there are the issues in relation to organisational culture. I find it completely intolerable that the review found a culture of “us” and “them”. That will not be tolerated going forward and I have written to the staff side and trade unions to make clear that staff who raise concerns have a right to be heard without fear of detriment.

I have also written to Scotland’s independent national whistleblowing officer to invite them to engage with NHS Grampian’s work. There can be no lasting improvement in patient safety, organisational culture or public confidence unless staff are confident that their voices are heard and their concerns addressed.

The HIS review and the three inspection reports highlight the professionalism, compassion and commitment of NHS Grampian staff. The evidence is clear that the principal challenge lies not with front-line staff but with leadership. I welcome that NHS Grampian has established a dedicated helpline for patients and their families. It is important that patients continue to access their local services. They are safe, and that is evidenced by the HIS reports on the professionalism of staff who are delivering services directly on the ground.

I recognise that it will take time to rebuild trust and confidence and to embed lasting change, but people should expect to see early evidence of progress. The review’s findings fall far short of the standard that patients have the right to expect from their health service. In the months ahead, I am committed to maintaining regular engagement with staff and local communities to ensure that recovery is informed by those who are most affected.

Before I conclude, I place on record my thanks to the Healthcare Improvement Scotland review team for this thorough review. Addressing the issues that are identified in the report is not the responsibility of any one organisation or of NHS Grampian alone. As the HIS report states, this must be a catalyst of change. The findings are too serious and the issues that have been identified have persisted for too long. The people of Grampian deserve better, and that is the shared task that is before us.

I will allow around 20 minutes for the cabinet secretary to answer questions on the issues raised in the statement. Members who wish to ask a question should press their request-to-speak button now.

Jackie Baillie (Dumbarton) (Lab)

I thank the cabinet secretary for the advance copy of her statement.

The failure of governance and oversight at NHS Grampian potentially has very serious consequences, with harm caused to patients, including children. The Healthcare Improvement Scotland report identified serious safety issues that were ignored by the board.

The inspection was in April this year, and red flags were raised with the Scottish Government’s deputy chief medical officer in May this year. Why were ministers not alerted to the issue in May, given the substantial safety issues at stake? Why did the cabinet secretary say to the press that she found out only a few weeks ago when, in her statement, she said that she visited in August because of her concerns? Was the previous cabinet secretary told? Is it not beyond belief that those who should be held accountable have all mysteriously left their posts?

We know that there was at least one serious adverse event review when a patient died in theatre. Will the cabinet secretary instruct a thorough review of all patient cases since the safety issues were first identified about which there are potential concerns?

Angela Constance

I am grateful to Ms Baillie for her scrutiny on this serious matter. I for one do not demur from one word in the Healthcare Improvement Scotland diagnostic review of NHS Grampian, as it is a substantial and thorough piece of work. As I said in my statement and have said elsewhere, I was sighted on the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report at the end of October—the precise date is 29 October. I was aware of some of the issues around Dr Gray’s in August, and I was also aware that the HIS report would be forthcoming.

As I said in my statement, I am committed to transparency and will outline the Government’s engagement on the issue over the past year. I will do that to the Health, Care and Sport Committee, as it is important. However, as the HIS report says, we need to move beyond describing the problems and get on with the action, and that is the focus right now.

On Ms Baillie’s question on serious adverse event reviews, she will recall from the briefing yesterday that the interim chair said that he was prepared to change the priority that is given to any individual adverse event review. I will make sure that her comments are passed to the interim chair and the board and given all due consideration.

Max Bannerman (Highlands and Islands) (Reform)

I thank the cabinet secretary for advance sight of her statement. In it, she said that

“the option to move to stage 5 remains”

and that she will

“reassess the situation in six weeks’ time.”

Will that reassessment take account of the findings of the external intervention support team that has been set up to work alongside NHS Grampian in order to provide “intensive turnaround support”?

Will the cabinet secretary also commit to coming back to the Parliament with a new statement in early January, once those findings have been made?

Angela Constance

That is an eminently sensible suggestion; any decision that I make on further escalation should be informed by the external intervention support team. As always, I am more than happy to come to the Parliament to make statements. I stress that I will review the decision on escalation within six weeks and that all options remain on the table. I am focused on actions that are meaningful—not cosmetic actions, but actions that will lead to lasting change now and in the future. I will, of course, keep the Parliament updated on how we are ensuring that there is accountability at every level in NHS Grampian.

Laura Mitchell (Moray) (SNP)

The review makes it clear that, too often, NHS Grampian’s leadership views Dr Gray’s hospital as the problem, despite its importance to the delivery of healthcare in Moray and across the north of Scotland. The review’s first recommendation is to implement a

“respectful and sustainable plan for Dr Gray’s Hospital”.

However, there have been multiple strategies from NHS Grampian over the years, and they have all achieved very little. Will the cabinet secretary make it clear to NHS Grampian that, for the people in Moray, it must now have a serious plan for the future of Dr Gray’s hospital, which includes investment in its staff, services and infrastructure, in order to ensure that our district general hospital can meet the needs of the local population?

Angela Constance

I agree with the analysis that Ms Mitchell has provided, and I agree 100 per cent that Dr Gray’s hospital is not the problem. It is an essential district general hospital that serves Moray and contributes to healthcare across the north of Scotland, and the problems have been the failure to integrate and support it properly within the wider NHS Grampian system.

The review was clear that another plan on paper will not be enough. NHS Grampian must develop a credible, respectful and sustainable plan for Dr Gray’s hospital with clarity on its future role, workforce, service and infrastructure, and the hospital must have a much stronger relationship with the Aberdeen royal infirmary.

Maggie Chapman (North East Scotland) (Green)

As the cabinet secretary highlighted, the HIS reports are clear that NHS Grampian staff are professional, compassionate and committed to the wellbeing of their patients. However, they do not always feel heard and, when they raise concerns, they feel dismissed or sidelined. There cannot be lasting improvement without staff being confident that they will be taken seriously, that they will be heard and that their concerns will be addressed. Will the cabinet secretary commit to an independent assessment of staff confidence in speaking up, including among doctors in training and other front-line staff? Will she also ensure that staff-side representatives and trade unions are involved in monitoring whether the culture is genuinely changing?

Angela Constance

Let me be clear to Ms Chapman and the Parliament, as I have been clear to the interim chair and chief executive: there can be no long-lasting change without the close involvement of staff. When I visited NHS Grampian on Friday, I had the opportunity to meet the area partnership forum, and I stressed that point again. A thorough review has been conducted by Healthcare Improvement Scotland and, as much as I am loth to enter into a cycle of constant reviews when what we need is constant action, I will raise the point that Ms Chapman made with the interim chair, who spoke at the briefing yesterday about the activity that has been undertaken to encourage staff to speak up. I repeat that staff should have the confidence to speak up without fear of detriment.

Alexander Burnett (Aberdeenshire West) (Con)

For 10 years, we have warned the Government of a growing crisis in NHS Grampian. There are no minor injury units on Deeside, Insch hospital is being closed, there have been reduced services in Huntly, there has been ambulance stacking at the ARI and rural general practitioner practices are collapsing. The list goes on, but this Government has never listened, and there is no confidence that this review will deliver anything different. NHS Grampian has a deficit of £76 million and is the second lowest funded health board. Will the cabinet secretary guarantee that her planned NHS reforms will not impact rural healthcare provision, and will she finally provide the funding that is so desperately needed?

Angela Constance

I am firm in stating that I think that this review is different because it lifts the lid on and acknowledges the long history to aspects of these matters, as well as identifying some deeply serious concerns in the past year. We now have all the issues of concern in one place, and the focus has to be on addressing them.

On funding, NHS Grampian is trusted with £1.5 billion of public money. I know that, as we enter the budget negotiations, there will be—as always—a debate about the quantum. In general terms, however, it is all too simple to say that the issue is primarily about funding; it is an issue of behaviours, poor accountability, and decision-making and governance that have absolutely been lacking. We have to remember the terms of the report, which has called it all out for what it actually is.

Yi-pei Chou Turvey (North East Scotland) (LD)

I recognise the dedication of the workers across NHS Grampian who have carried the burden of the challenges for some time, often under intense pressure. I have met doctors who have said to me that they want to cry when they go to work, and doctors who have lost trust in the management and its decisions.

What assessments have been made of the impact on staff morale, wellbeing and retention? How will rebuilding confidence among the workforce form part of the recovery plan?

Angela Constance

Morale among staff at all levels within NHS Grampian is absolutely crucial. That is why there is, and must continue to be, an impetus to act on the detailed diagnostic review to ensure that the actions that are required, as identified by Healthcare Improvement Scotland, are addressed. Ultimately, NHS Grampian will be judged on the outcomes that it delivers. However, the member raises an important point. We all have a responsibility to ensure that staff morale is maintained on this journey and that both patient confidence and public confidence are retained.

Jack Middleton (Aberdeen Central) (SNP)

The situation at NHS Grampian underlines a wider issue that public service reform will have to address. Too many executives are earning massive salaries but facing such little accountability that they can preside over serious failures such as this and still walk away with a massive pay-off that, in the end, is paid for by the taxpayer.

If those at the top of the health board have not delivered meaningful improvement by the end of the year, how quickly will the cabinet secretary intervene? Does she agree that executives who have presided over such a mess and failed in their duties should not be rewarded for that failure with hefty pay-outs from the taxpayer?

Angela Constance

The member is right that senior leadership comes with real accountability. Patients and front-line staff have been badly let down, and those who are responsible for leading NHS Grampian must now demonstrate rapid and sustained progress. As I said in my statement, I expect clear progress before Christmas and, as outlined, I will review matters within six weeks. I assure the member that I will act quickly if progress is not delivered, and all further escalation options will remain available.

It is clear to me that the status quo is not working. The purpose of public service reform is to have greater integration of services—not less. It is about levelling up and not levelling down on accountability, standards, governance, leadership and culture. It is also about having more flexible use of our resources to ensure that we can work beyond boundaries, whether those are structural or geographic.

Michael Marra (North East Scotland) (Lab)

The cabinet secretary is well aware of the cultural issues that exist in NHS management, where senior managers in boards have repeatedly shown themselves to be more interested in managing headlines than in fixing patient care. The inspection report is clear that inspectors were misled by NHS Grampian, and the cabinet secretary set out in her statement concerns as to the veracity of information that was supplied to the Government. Given that, is the cabinet secretary satisfied that there has been the fullest and frankest of inspections at NHS Grampian and that those in charge have not covered anything else up?

Angela Constance

I have faith in Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s review. We can all agree that it has not minced its words, and I do not believe that it has left any stone unturned. I have confidence in the interim chair and the other changes that have been made, although those are matters for the board.

The member is right to point to concerns about veracity. I continue to peruse and stress the factual information of some aspects. To be blunt, confidence will have to be rebuilt with ministers and that journey has started. I demand the highest of standards and that all facts, whether they are positive or negative, are accurately laid in front of ministers. I am sure that the Parliament expects that, too.

Dawn Black (Angus North and Mearns) (SNP)

The cabinet secretary has stated that she visited NHS Grampian and chaired its annual review on Friday. Can she provide more detail on what was discussed and precisely what priorities have been outlined for the coming year, within the context of healthcare reform and considering that the interim chair is in post only until April 2027?

Angela Constance

I was pleased to have had the opportunity to chair NHS Grampian’s annual review in Aberdeen last Friday. I met a range of local stakeholders, including the area clinical forum, the area partnership forum, and patients and carers, as well as holding a public meeting with a question and answer session. I also had a private meeting with the board, the chief executive, and the interim chair. The private meeting was followed up by correspondence from the Government detailing our reflections.

Ultimately, the purpose of the review is to hold the board to account for its delivery against local and national priorities. In the light of the HIS report, I was clear throughout the day that I expect the board to take immediate action to start addressing the report’s findings. The interim chair has been appointed for a period of six months, but as he intimated yesterday during a meeting of a cross-party group of MSPs, he will be flexible. I assure the Parliament that all the arrangements will be kept under review, because we need stability and solid progress.

Helen McDade (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Reform)

I thank the cabinet secretary for her statement. I wonder whether parents of children in Dr Gray’s hospital who have been affected would agree with the cabinet secretary that the chief executive officer has shown a commitment to dismantle the poor organisational culture. In 2014, separate investigations by HIS and the Royal College of Surgeons identified substantial problems involving leadership, clinical governance, professional relationships and surgical services at Aberdeen royal infirmary. Some of those issues will sound familiar. Given the ongoing long-term deficiencies in NHS Grampian, the CEO should surely have tackled them from day 1. However, it took her eight months to commission the HIS review when the concerns were pointed out by the press, and she was in charge when, in June this year, the board ignored an instruction from HIS to cease paediatric surgery at Dr Gray’s, which is surely unforgivable.

Could the member pose a question, please?

Would £150,000 not be usefully saved by removing the CEO from post and bringing in change managers, rather than more people from the NHS?

Angela Constance

As the HIS report accurately reflects, there is a long history. There have been interventions at various levels, progress has been made, and things have slipped, before other interventions have been required. In fairness, and in terms of the breadth and depth of concerns that the report lays out, I do not think that we can lay it all at the doorstep of one individual.

The chief executive commissioned the report and has been frank and candid. When I was in Aberdeen, a number of staff spoke out about the beginnings of a changing culture because of the chief executive’s leadership. However, I stress to the member and Parliament that I have been very clear with the chief executive and others that we need demonstrable progress by the end of the year.

Emma Roddick (Inverness and Nairn) (SNP)

Following the well-made points by the constituency MSP, Laura Mitchell, it is clear that what is needed here is leadership. Families in and around Moray have waited far too long for certainty, as have staff in the hospital and, for example, in the Scottish Ambulance Service. Services at Dr Gray’s hospital must be restored as quickly as it is safe to do so. How will the Scottish Government offer leadership to ensure that that is the case, including making sure that the board delivers a dedicated workforce plan to attract the necessary staff for services such as maternity and orthopaedics?

Angela Constance

We have a very clear commitment to service restoration—whether that is maternity or other services. However, that must be done when it is safe to do so. That is detailed work, and I assure members that I and my officials are on it.

The point about leadership is well made: this must be the line in the sand for Dr Gray’s, and for Aberdeen royal infirmary and NHS Grampian as a whole. We have to draw a line under the past and start to see demonstrable improvement in the short term but also a long-term commitment to progress. I have no doubt that MSPs across the chamber will have an acute eye on the detail, which is to be welcomed, because we all have a role to play if we want to achieve the aspirations in the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report, which must be a catalyst for change.

Kayleigh Kinross-O’Neill (Edinburgh and Lothians East) (Green)

The HIS review found that NHS Grampian had no coherent medical workforce strategy; that only 45 per cent of consultant job plans across the board, and just 27 per cent of job plans at Dr Gray’s hospital, had been signed off; and that repeated reliance on local consultants and very small clinical teams was undermining continuity and resilience. What specific action, with what timescales, can the Scottish Government require NHS Grampian to take to deliver a sustainable medical workforce plan, particularly for Dr Gray’s hospital?

Angela Constance

It was very remiss of me not to pick up on a similar point raised by Ms Roddick about the importance of the workforce. The board of NHS Grampian has very clear responsibilities in that regard, and it will be held to account on that. However, it is fair to say that there must also be synergy between national workforce planning and planning undertaken at health board level. On the specificity about dates, I will take the matter to the interim chair of the board and the chief executive and come back to the member with the details.

Jackie Dunbar (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP)

I thank the cabinet secretary for organising yesterday’s briefing and giving us the opportunity to question her and the interim chair of the board.

Patient safety must come first, and folk in Aberdeen Donside and across NHS Grampian must have confidence in the care they receive. Will the cabinet secretary reaffirm that patient safety will come first and advise how that will be enforced in any future plans by the new leadership?

Angela Constance

Ms Dunbar echoes Ms Baillie’s point that patient safety must come first in each and every decision. The changes that we are putting in place, which are unprecedented in terms of support and scrutiny, are designed to ensure that safety concerns are identified early, properly escalated and acted upon with clear accountability for delivery. The intervention support team will provide additional expertise and challenge; the assurance board will track progress and hold NHS Grampian to account; and Healthcare Improvement Scotland will provide further independent assurance. Therefore, patient safety will not simply be an aspiration but will be tested through strengthened governance measures, with clear milestones and independent scrutiny, and with further intervention available if sufficient progress is not made.

Tim Eagle (Highlands and Islands) (Con)

There has been a lot of chat about governance and oversight, and there is no doubt that there have been failures at chief executive and board level. However, to get real for a second: NHS Grampian has been monitored by the Scottish Government at stage 2 since November 2023. For three years, NHS Grampian has been failing on this Government’s watch. That is not good enough for patients. I have also heard countless times that Dr Gray’s is essential, and yet nothing is ever done. Stage 5 has clearly been considered. What will need to happen in order for the cabinet secretary not to escalate to stage 5 when she reassesses the situation in six weeks’ time?

Angela Constance

With the greatest of respect, I encourage Mr Eagle to read the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report, because it is very clear about where responsibility lies.

To be frank, I have also acknowledged that there is a long history to this—one that is longer than I would have liked. I am determined to now draw that line in the sand and ensure that there is only one direction going forward, which has to be about measurable progress.

Mr Eagle also asked what considerations I will make in relation to escalating to stage 5. I will do so, quite simply, if there is a lack of demonstrable progress.

Will the cabinet secretary publish what recommendations were not followed through after the KPMG review? Crucially, why were they not actioned?

Angela Constance

Again, the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report acknowledges that not all of the recommendations were followed through. That relates to a much broader concern about decisions being made in NHS Grampian and then not being fulfilled, and about a lack of scrutiny, governance and follow-through, in terms of action being taken on what has been decided at the top. I am more than happy to write to the member on the specific recommendations that were not followed.

That concludes the ministerial statement on NHS Grampian.