Official Report 369KB pdf
The next item of business is Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body question time.
AI-generated Casework Requests
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body what action it is taking to support MSP staff, in light of reported concerns regarding an increase in the number of artificial intelligence-generated casework requests. (S7O-00554)
The corporate body recognises that increasing volumes of digitally generated and AI-assisted correspondence can place additional pressure on already busy members and their teams. In particular, high-volume digital campaigns can make it more difficult for offices to identify and prioritise urgent individual casework. The casework system that is provided by the Parliament includes functionality to help members’ offices to manage high-volume campaign correspondence, and training on that functionality is available to members and their staff through the Parliament’s learning and development programme.
Officials are also working with the system supplier as it develops new AI-supported functionality. Alongside that work, officials will continue to assess what further guidance, training and technical improvements could safely reduce the administrative burden on members’ offices, while ensuring that genuine constituent correspondence is handled appropriately.
As the member noted, the rise of generative AI has led to a massive upsurge in the volume of casework that members receive, which includes pages and pages of legal citations and references to often obscure standards and practice. I know that other members are concerned about the issue on behalf of their staff. As caseworkers are not lawyers, they do not have the requisite expertise to be able to provide responses to questions of so many pages in a timely manner, even assuming that the citations are correct—and, in many cases, we have found that they are not.
In no way do I wish to limit democratic engagement, but what can be done to streamline requests and ensure that constituents are well informed about the inevitable delays that such lengthy requests lead to?
I recognise the concerns that the member raises. Generative AI has made it much easier to produce lengthy and highly technical correspondence, which can include legal citations and references that may not always be accurate. That is not unique to MSP casework. The Information Commissioner’s Office has reported increasing volumes of complex, AI-generated information requests, including requests that misquote legislation, while the Financial Ombudsman Service has highlighted needlessly long submissions containing fabricated laws, misquoted regulations and invented previous decisions.
I think that there is a practical role for the corporate body here. We can look at whether clearer guidance and standard responses could help members’ offices to explain what an MSP can and cannot reasonably do and to manage constituents’ expectations about response times when correspondence is particularly lengthy or complex. Alongside that, we will continue working with the casework system supplier on ways in which technology and training can help offices to manage increasing volumes efficiently while ensuring that genuine constituent concerns continue to receive appropriate attention.
Official Reports (Publication Times)
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body what measures it is taking to reduce the time taken to publish the Official Report following parliamentary proceedings. (S7O-00556)
Official Reports are published as soon as practicable during and after meetings. The Official Report of chamber business is produced on the day, with all business up to the end of decision time appearing progressively online within three hours. The report of members’ business is published as soon as possible the following day. Committee Official Reports are produced to a publication schedule that is set weekly. The reports are prioritised as agreed by the Conveners Group in 2001—that is, based first on the date of the next meeting and then on the type of business.
There has been an increase in the number of hours in the public parliamentary week, with both chamber hours and committee hours increasing. On average, there were more than 42 hours of public parliamentary business each week between the start of September and the October recess. That was considerably higher than the equivalent periods in the previous sessions and beyond the OR’s current capacity of around 37 hours a week.
The member refers to weekly publication of committee Official Reports. However, to give a recent example, last Friday morning, on 13 November, I noticed that the last published Official Reports of the Finance and Public Administration Committee that were available were for 28 October. The Official Reports of two committee meetings were not available for reference by members.
This is not a new issue. It was evident in the previous session. If the OR’s capacity is not sufficient to service this Parliament, something must be done about it by the SPCB. What specific measures are being considered or, indeed, introduced to reduce the time taken to publish a draft Official Report of committee proceedings? I am specifically asking about committee proceedings. How are the timings monitored? Is the SPCB satisfied with the time taken to publish committee proceedings?
I am grateful for that supplementary question, which raises all kinds of concerns that I know will be shared by members across the chamber. The OR team is looking at ways to respond to these challenges by reviewing and adopting new working methods to create efficiencies while maintaining the accuracy, accessibility and reliability of the report. Alongside that, staff have worked beyond contracted hours on public holidays to meet demand as much as possible. In September and October, almost all—but clearly not all—ORs were published before the committee’s next meeting.
The OR team already uses automatic speech recognition to produce a first draft of the report, and it is looking at exploring artificial intelligence tools that will support the reviewing of reports before publication. However, I sound a note of caution that AI tools remain inconsistent, as we heard in the answer to the previous question, with inaccurate transcriptions and even hallucinations being a frequent issue, particularly given the nuanced and complex business that the Parliament often considers.
I am sure that this is a question that we will return to, and I am grateful for the question.
In order to get to all the questions, we will need to have shorter questions and answers.
MSP Staff (Consultation on Changes)
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, regarding changes to processes that directly affect the day-to-day roles of MSP staff, such as allowances and the booking of First Minister Questions tickets and meeting rooms, whether it will survey MSP staff to assess whether these changes have been beneficial and whether staff felt adequately consulted prior to their implementation. (S7O-00553)
Members’ staff will have the opportunity to share their views in an upcoming survey on workplace services and facilities in December, which I hope the member will welcome. The survey will give members’ staff a clear and confidential way to share their experiences of working at Holyrood, in constituency offices and from home. It will ask for their views on the impact of recent changes on their day-to-day roles and on whether they feel that they were appropriately consulted before those changes were introduced. The data gathered from the survey will help the SPCB to identify practical changes that will make workplace services easier to use, and it will help to inform future improvement work and investment.
I certainly welcome that survey, and I am sure that MSP staff will welcome the member’s comments, too. However, over several years, a number of departments within the Parliament have made changes that have placed additional demands on MSP offices and their staff. We have to remember that Parliament should be reducing the burden of MSP offices, not adding to it. Given that MSP staff are the day-to-day face of Parliament in our communities across Scotland, and that, anecdotally, many MSP staff feel that changes are often introduced without sufficient consultation with those who will be most affected by them, will the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body commit to consulting MSP staff before implementing significant changes that affect their day-to-day roles and responsibilities?
I agree with the member that it is vitally important that we do that. The survey will help. There is also a staff forum, which began in 2018, and we are in the process of arranging the appointment of staff members to that consultative forum for session 7, which we are in now. So, there is the combination of those initiatives and what is done by MSPs themselves.
The review of the dignity at work programme arrangements with the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body will consider proposals from MSP staff trade unions to strengthen engagement and communication between SPCB officials and MSP staff, while—importantly—respecting the existing employment structure.
I agree that it is time to ensure that we address the changes that have happened in the Parliament—I know that the member has previously raised changes to the booking system, for example—to ensure that we get feedback from MSP staff so that we get it right.
Public Gallery (Visitor Management)
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body when it last reviewed the procedures for managing visitors entering and leaving the public gallery during chamber proceedings and committee meetings. (S7O-00565)
Visitors to our public galleries are subject to the Parliament’s visitor behaviour policy, and we expect visitors to observe proceedings without causing disruption. The specific procedures around people entering and leaving the galleries were last looked at during session 5, when concerns were raised about disruption from movement in the gallery, particularly during the changeover following First Minister’s questions.
I want to be clear that I very much welcome visitors to the Parliament. We want to encourage more visits, and I commend the work of the security team across the Parliament.
However, on numerous occasions, I have witnessed business being disrupted or disturbed by visitors arriving and leaving during statements. Even today, a group left when Russell Findlay was on his feet during FMQs—thankfully, they did so pretty quietly, but it could have been very disruptive. I have seen it happen during sensitive committee meetings, for example, while grieving parents were talking about the loss of their children. I wonder whether we want to give more consideration to the etiquette and procedures for visitors entering and leaving during parliamentary business, as theatres and other settings where visitors are welcome do.
I am glad that the member has recognised the importance of ensuring that Parliament is a welcoming place for visitors. I recognise Ben Macpherson’s concerns, which I know he has raised at a committee meeting previously.
Visitors should be able to observe parliamentary business without disrupting proceedings, and that principle is already reflected in our arrangements for public galleries. However, there are practical considerations. Parliamentary business can continue for lengthy periods, and visitors might need to leave for a range of reasons, so we would want to ensure that any arrangements are proportionate and workable, rather than preventing people from leaving when they need to do so.
However, we commit to considering the matter further to see how we can manage the movement more sensitively. Guidelines are issued to visitors when they come to the Parliament, and one of the things that we might be able to do is to reinforce to visitors on entry the need to be sensitive when they leave the chamber public gallery or committee public gallery.
Engagement with External Organisations in Parliament
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body what processes and guidance are in place regarding engagement between external organisations and MSPs within the Parliament, including the location of engagement activities and the conduct expected of parliamentary members and staff in that context. (S7O-00564)
The Parliament provides a range of opportunities for external organisations to engage with members, including through the member-sponsored events and exhibitions programme. For member-sponsored exhibitions, the events and exhibitions team considers the availability of the dates requested and the size and scale of the proposed exhibition when determining the most appropriate location.
The Parliament expects everyone who is engaging in activities on the parliamentary estate to treat others with dignity, courtesy and respect and has a zero-tolerance approach to unacceptable behaviour, including bullying, harassment and sexual harassment. Staff from the events and exhibitions team are available throughout member-sponsored exhibitions to provide support and response to any concerns that may arise.
Concerns have been raised with me about the Parliament’s engagement stall, which is located outside the members block and is now directly opposite political offices, which presents challenges for organisations that wish to engage with MSPs. I ask the corporate body to consider alternative locations within the parliamentary estate that could be made available for external organisations to engage with MSPs and to reflect on broadening the range of options, which might help to ensure that such activities take place in a more appropriate setting.
What guidance applies to the distribution of party-political material within the parliamentary estate, particularly when that material relates to external organisations that have been invited into the Parliament as part of such engagement activity?
That is two supplementaries, so I ask you to allow me a bit of time, Presiding Officer.
The corporate body allocates parliamentary resources impartially. We do so on the reasonable expectation that everyone—that is everyone—who engages in parliamentary activities will behave with courtesy and respect towards others. However, we speak to exhibitors about the arrangements and any concerns that they may have. If an exhibitor raised a particular concern about location, we would take that seriously and, if another suitable location was available, would work with them to make alternative arrangements.
On the second point, the corporate body sets the rules and guidance that govern the appropriate use of parliamentary resources. That includes through the reimbursement of members expenses scheme. If a concern or complaint is raised about the use of parliamentary resources, there are established arrangements for that to be considered and, where appropriate, investigated.
Broadcasting (Accessibility)
I call Emma Roddick for question 6.
[Inaudible.]
I do not believe that you have your microphone on, Emma Roddick. There may be a technical problem. Would you like to try one more time?
That is ironic. Can you hear me now?
We can hear you, thank you.
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body what consideration it has given to improving the accessibility of the Parliament’s broadcasting services by adding speaker labels to captions. (S7O-00555)
It is almost as if the member was making a point.
The Scottish Parliament broadcasting service provides industry-standard live subtitling for the chamber and committee proceedings across Scottish Parliament TV, internal television channels and in-room monitors. In committee meetings, subtitles are colour coded to distinguish between individual contributors, a feature that is currently being trialled for chamber broadcasts.
Speaker names are not displayed on screen as that is not industry standard and risks restricting the space that is required to present captions clearly and legibly.
However, improving accessibility is core to the service. Work has been undertaken on a forthcoming pilot on Scottish Parliament TV, which will introduce an interactive speaker list and enable users to navigate a meeting timeline, view individual contributors and directly access the corresponding video segments.
I have heard from many people who are deaf or hard of hearing or who otherwise have difficulty with the spoken word that, for the likes of First Minister’s questions in particular, it can be difficult to parse exactly what is happening and who is talking. The speaker may not even be the person on the screen. Will the SPCB speak to people who use that service and who are disabled or hard of hearing, to hear what their issues are with it and what they would like to see?
I apologise—I should have acknowledged the member’s commendable track record of raising access issues throughout her time in this Parliament.
The Parliament’s broadcasting office and British Sign Language communities officer have engaged with deaf audience groups and, to date, the feedback has generally been very positive. As I said, a pilot scheme is ongoing, which may offer opportunities to provide further improvements where they are felt to be needed. Some of that work has already started through the pilot.
I will ensure that staff in the broadcasting team take on board Emma Roddick’s concerns and that they are built into that pilot.
Catering Outlets (Halal Food)
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body whether all chicken or meat served in the catering outlets is halal and, if so, for what reason diners are not offered a non-halal alternative. (S7O-00563)
I thank Helen McDade for that question—it is very interesting and I had to do a bit of investigating to find the answer.
Our catering contract was re-let during the last parliamentary session. The contract states that the corporate body strives to meet the varying demands of special dietary needs of our wider customer base, and requires that the contractor will provide for
“health related, ethnic, cultural, religious diets at all times, alongside vegan and vegetarian”
ones. In practice, that means that all chicken served across the parliamentary estate is halal and all other meat products served are non-halal.
For a great many people, animal welfare is key to their choice of food. As a veterinary surgeon, it is key to my choice. Will the corporate body make sure that, in this building, people are told how their meat is slaughtered—I think that people do not know that—and give diners a choice?
Now that we know that answer, people can choose to have chicken or other meat. Perhaps, on alternate days, we could provide options such that people could choose what they were eating for either religious or animal welfare reasons.
I will ask the catering team to review the labelling of menu items and consider whether that information could be included. That would be useful.
Several non-halal options are available daily across menus, including other meat dishes, fish, vegetarian and plant-based choices. That ensures that there is always something suitable for a wide range of dietary preferences and requirements. However, I will take the member’s suggestion away and come back to her about it.
Members’ Bills (Support)
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, in light of the delays reportedly experienced by MSPs during the previous parliamentary session, what action it has taken to increase the capacity of services, including legal services, which support MSPs to progress members’ bills. (S7O-00557)
In addition to keeping an eye on the level of resources available to clerking and legal services, which is constantly under review, the corporate body guidance that was introduced in this parliamentary session makes changes to the members’ bills process. Those include changes that seek to ensure that the process is quicker, wherever that is possible, and that it represents an efficient use of resources by corporate body staff, members and members’ staff. For example, the processing of consultation responses should be quicker. The corporate body encourages members to meet the non-Government bills unit as early as possible in the session, to ensure that policy proposals are as focused as possible, so that bills in this parliamentary session can be introduced in good time.
I welcome the steps that have been taken to increase capacity, which Stephen Kerr has outlined. However, given the difficulties experienced by members in the previous session, can the corporate body provide assurances that those measures will be sufficient to support a full programme of members’ bills without further delays? Will it commit to keeping capacity under review and taking further action, including, where necessary, providing additional resources, to ensure that members are able to progress their legislation within reasonable timescales?
Keith Brown asks a very logical question—what lessons have been learned from what happened in the previous session? The reality is that more members’ bills—there were 19 in total—were introduced in the most recent session than in any other, and that all members’ proposals that reached the final proposal stage earned the right to be introduced as a bill.
This session, the threshold to earn the right to introduce a bill is higher, requiring the support of 18 members from three parties on the bureau, as opposed to two parties on the bureau in the previous session. That change might limit the number of proposals that are introduced as bills this session. The deadline for the introduction of a member’s bill will also be six months earlier in this session.
A number of factors over and above the availability of resources impact when a bill can be introduced. Those include when in the session the idea is brought forward and the complexity and size of the proposal. The corporate body guidance encourages members to come to the non-Government bills unit as early as possible and to have focused policies.