Official Report 292KB pdf
The next item of business is a debate on motion S7M-02053, in the name of Shirley-Anne Somerville, on energy prices and the cost of living. Members who wish to speak in the debate should press their request-to-speak buttons now.
15:43
Everyone in this chamber will be acutely aware of the daily financial pressures that people are facing as a result of the increasing cost of living and, in particular, rising energy bills. Every community in Scotland is impacted by what has become one of the defining challenges facing households and businesses right now.
It is clear that the devolution of energy powers is needed to address the soaring energy prices and cost-of-living pressures facing households across Scotland. That has been brought into sharp focus, with the energy price cap anticipated to reach £2,000 in January and the United Kingdom Government failing to deliver on its promise to cut bills by £300, as it claimed to want to do during the election. The UK Government has also failed to implement the Scottish Government’s proposals for a social tariff.
In contrast, this Government is providing a package of measures to support people, within the limited powers currently available to us. We know that the effects of the Covid-19 pandemic, international inflationary pressures, conflict in Europe, instability in the middle east and volatility in international energy markets have all contributed to rising costs. Those pressures are not unique to Scotland, but they are felt acutely across the country, and many of the levers that are needed to fully address them are still reserved to Westminster.
The UK budget delivers a real-terms cut in Scotland’s budget of around £650 million for 2027-28. That reduces considerably our ability to spend on public services and on supporting people with the cost of living when they most need that support. For example, social security is an essential investment in the shared safety net to which all of us, at any point in our lives, may need to turn for help. It is unacceptable that, in the UK Government’s budget, there was no announcement about ending wider austerity policies that are pushing families into poverty, such as the bedroom tax, the benefit cap and the young parent penalty on universal credit.
The Government has received £755 million in revenues from ScotWind. Why has it not used more of that windfall to provide lasting benefits for consumers, rather than treating it as a convenient way to manage its wider budget?
It is important to recognise that we need to make the most of ScotWind. We recognise the opportunities. Countries across Europe that invested in future funds—such as Norway, which is sitting on £1 trillion—can make the difference that we could make if we had independence, considering that oil and gas money has been frittered away by consecutive UK Governments.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer had an opportunity to lift thousands more families out of poverty, but he chose not to do so. As a result, we will invest millions of pounds—more than £100 million, this year alone—to mitigate shortcomings in the welfare system.
One thing is within the Government’s power. Members may believe it or not, but somebody who works in a pub on the minimum wage but takes tips will now be tipped into the higher Scottish National Party tax rate. Is it not time that the cabinet secretary cut the cost of living for many Scots by cutting their tax bills?
Particularly at this time of year, it is important that we look in the round at what happens in our Parliament, including our debates. I am mindful that, during First Minister’s questions, we had demands for increases in college funding and for further money to be spent on other issues, and we always have a demand to decrease taxation. I make a general plea—I am not picking on Craig Hoy in particular—for some co-ordination in relation to the demands about how we use our budget, because we cannot demand tax cuts at the same time as we take another opportunity in the chamber to demand that the Government use money that it would not have if we implemented those tax cuts.
The current Ofgem price cap means that the average household faces annual energy costs of around £1,723. As I have mentioned, the latest projections suggest that that cap will rise to more than £2,000 early in the new year.
The UK Government’s announcement of support for energy bills does not go nearly far enough against that backdrop; nor does it come close to meeting the promise on which the UK Government came into office. Remember that promise to reduce energy bills by £300? I wonder what happened to that, because bills are now significantly higher. [Interruption.] If the member would like to intervene on that point, I will be more than happy.
Scottish Government ministers often quote that promise, which is still a promise, but they forget the second part of the sentence. The UK Labour Government promised to cut energy bills by £350 by 2030. It is still working towards that.
It is still some way off it, because, if I might politely give advice to the UK Government, I suggest that it helps if we do not increase something by a lot if we have a determination to decrease it further along the way. Members will forgive me if I am not entirely convinced that the UK Government will reach the dizzy heights of the £300 cut.
In Scotland, we are delivering the strongest winter heating package in the UK. We have forecast an investment of around £205 million in our winter heating benefits. We are guaranteeing support to people who have an identified need for additional heat over the winter months, including low-income households, families with disabled children, young people and pensioners. We are extending the Scottish emergency heating oil scheme, providing support to households that depend on expensive off-grid fuels. We are working with local government to ensure that all eligible households benefit from the one-off £100 payment for energy bill support. In addition, we are maintaining the Scottish welfare fund budget at £41 million in 2026-27. It provides vital support to those in crisis and helps people to establish independent living. We are also ensuring that, this winter, around 360,000 families will receive the automatic warm home discount rebate of £150.
We are also addressing longer-term pressures on bills. The most effective protection against future energy price shocks is ensuring that people live in warm, energy-efficient homes. That is why, this year, we are investing more than £330 million in energy-efficiency and clean-heating measures, targeting households that are most at risk of fuel poverty, so that their homes are more affordable to heat. Through programmes such as warmer homes Scotland and the work of Home Energy Scotland and other area-based schemes, thousands of households are already benefiting from warmer homes and lower bills. Many are saving between £300 and £500 annually on energy costs.
The cabinet secretary makes reference to zero-emission developments in Scotland’s homes, but is the Government’s focus not on carbon emissions in relation to new-build construction, and particularly on the use of heat pumps? In that regard, I point out that many lower-income households are facing higher bills because of the way in which energy tariffs work in this country.
If what Mr Hoy says is correct, he makes the argument for why we need a co-ordinated energy policy that is in the hands of the Scottish Parliament: so that people can take advantage of living in energy-rich Scotland, instead of not seeing the benefit of that. Mr Hoy’s position is also particularly ironic, as he has suggested that we should not have the ability to regulate further when it comes to developing energy standards for our homes, which would also help people with their fuel bills.
More than 52,000 households have been supported through the warmer homes Scotland programme since 2015. Since 2021, the social housing fund has supported around 15,000 social homes with energy-efficiency and clean-heat improvements. Those investments help to tackle fuel poverty while supporting our transition to net zero.
However, the fundamental fiscal policy levers to make a real difference lie with the UK Government. Its lack of action on energy pricing and market reform has meant that, despite Scotland possessing some of the best renewable resources in Europe, our communities often see little or no benefit whatsoever.
Although energy prices remain a serious concern, hardship for many emerges not because of one issue, but because of the cumulative impact of many costs rising at the same time. One of the clearest lessons from recent years is that tackling poverty and economic insecurity require sustained effort across a range of policy areas. It is well understood that poverty impacts every aspect of life, from physical and mental health and wellbeing to educational attainment and long-term outcomes. That is exactly why this Government continues to place tackling poverty at the heart of its programme.
Children do not choose the circumstances into which they are born. This year, we will invest more than £3.5 billion in measures aimed at tackling poverty and supporting households with the cost of living. Those measures include the provision of 1,140 hours of early learning and childcare, saving families around £6,400 per eligible child; making free school meals available to more than 360,000 pupils, saving families who take up that offer £450 per child per year; providing free bus travel for more than 2.4 million people, including children and young people under 22, disabled people and everyone aged 60 or over; and delivering the £2 bus cap across the Strathclyde area, building on our pilot in the Highlands and Islands.
We are also delivering the five family payments, including the Scottish child payment, which could be worth more than £11,000 by the time an eligible child turns six and around £26,000 by the time they turn 16. That compares with savings of less than £2,000 for families in England and Wales, where support ends when an eligible child turns four. The Scottish child payment remains one of the most significant anti-poverty interventions anywhere in the UK. Alongside our wider package of support, it is helping to improve family incomes. An independent analysis indicates that Scottish Government policies are expected to keep around 100,000 children out of relative poverty this year.
Our plans go much further. They include consulting on plans to introduce a cap on the price of essential food items to ensure that supermarket prices are affordable, delivering the national transformation of childcare support and introducing the £2 cap on bus fares nationwide. We are also building on efforts over the past decade to keep rail fare increases as low as possible and to remove peak fares permanently.
We also need to recognise that the cost of living challenge does not affect everyone equally. Certain groups face additional costs that cannot simply be reduced or avoided. Disabled people often face unavoidable additional energy costs associated with heating requirements or specialist equipment. Rural and island households frequently face higher costs for fuel, transport and housing. Those households cannot simply reduce their energy use without facing serious consequences. That is why our support continues to focus on where it is needed most and why we have provided additional funding through initiatives such as the islands cost crisis emergency fund, while continuing to support rural and island communities. We have also worked with the industry, vulnerable groups and disabled people’s organisations to identify the specific challenges that disabled people face when they interact with energy suppliers. We will continue to work collaboratively to identify workable solutions.
At the same time, we will continue to mitigate the impact of the UK Government’s welfare policies that push households into hardship. For example, we are investing a record £117 million in discretionary housing payments to support those who are impacted by the bedroom tax, the benefit cap and the freeze on the local housing allowance, which we know to be one of the drivers of homelessness. There is much that the Government has done and will continue to do to support people who are struggling with energy prices and the wider cost of living crisis. We will do what we can with the resources that are available to us, because we know that Scotland needs warm homes and affordable energy. Everyone should have those rights. Our ability to deliver them is based only in part on the powers that we have.
If the UK Government will not act, it must devolve those powers to the Scottish Parliament so that we can go further and ensure that households, communities and businesses feel the full benefits of being in an energy-rich Scotland. I look forward to hearing the contributions of members from across the chamber today.
I move,
That the Parliament notes that soaring energy bills, combined with severe cost of living pressures, are placing unprecedented pressures on households and businesses this winter; highlights that Ofgem’s energy price cap is forecast to go beyond £2,000 from January 2027; regrets that the UK Labour administration has failed to cut energy bills by £300, as promised during the 2024 General Election; welcomes the support already provided by the Scottish Government on a package of measures, within its limited powers, to reduce household bills; calls on the UK Government to go further than the temporary measures announced in the recent Budget and to implement the Scottish Government’s proposals for a social tariff in the form of bill discounts targeted at those in greatest need, and believes that, if the UK Government won’t act, it must devolve powers to the Scottish Parliament so that the necessary actions can be taken.
I call Mark Griffin to speak to and move amendment S7M-02053.3.
15:57
The past decade has clearly been a long, bumpy and expensive road. Everyday worries about how to make it to the end of the month have hung over far too many families for too long. There is no doubt that conflicts in Ukraine and the middle east are exacerbating the situation in the here and now, but we can stand here and—
Will the member take an intervention?
Yes, I will.
It is undeniable that those conflicts are causing international pressures, but is it not the case that the Ukraine conflict had been under way for two full years before Labour promised to cut bills by £300? Is it not the case, given that it is now citing international pressures, that Labour went into that general election making a promise that it could not deliver because it was relying on international markets to govern prices?
The cabinet secretary herself pointed out the international conflicts that are at play and that are causing global energy shocks. The UK Labour Government promised to cut electricity and energy bills by 2030; it is still 2026.
A lot of work to cut energy bills is being carried out every single day.
Will the member take an intervention on that point?
Let me make this point.
The UK Government introduced measures in the budget to reduce people’s outgoings immediately. It has also introduced the warm homes loan scheme to support householders to invest in energy efficiency and microgeneration measures that will cut their bills.
I thank Mr Griffin for taking the intervention, but he will surely recall that the Labour Party’s pledge was to reduce energy bills by up to £300 per year up to 2030.
If we were to reduce energy bills by £300 per year, people would have negative energy bills. That is not the promise that was made. The promise was to reduce energy bills by £300 by 2030. That is as clear as day in the UK Labour manifesto. I am glad that Mr McMillan is a keen student of that manifesto, but he should perhaps read it a bit more closely.
We can stand in the chamber and spend time arguing and political point scoring about who caused the current situation and who is to blame, but it would do the people who sent us here an absolute disservice. What they want from the Government and the Parliament is the problems solved and a bit of breathing space, so we should focus on those solutions and on how we provide that breathing space to the people who need it most. When people are worried about paying their bills, keeping the heating on and making it to the end of the month, they do not care about political point scoring—they just need money to pay their bills.
That is the point.
Housing policy, fuel poverty programmes, energy efficiency schemes and winter support payments are devolved. We have a wide range of policy and financial levers that are used to support people—[Interruption.]
The member must be heard.
That is not exactly the “limited” range of powers that the Government points to in its motion.
People at home are entitled to ask a straightforward question of the Government: why is it not fully utilising the powers that it has at its disposal? Why should Scots believe that the answer lies in the devolution settlement? The Government’s response to problems that it faces is, all too often, to blame someone else and to pretend that powers that lie elsewhere are the solution, rather than taking action on the problem itself.
Even if the problem was devolution, I have heard nothing today from the Government on what it would do with those powers and what it wants them for. I have heard no detail on how it would attract investment into the electricity grid or on how it would manage international global energy shocks. There is no detail at all on what it would do with those devolved powers.
Will the member take an intervention?
It is almost as if the Government just wants to argue for devolution of those powers as the solution, rather than taking the tough choices and doing the work on delivering the solutions that people want right now. It is clear—
Will the member take an intervention?
I am sorry—I will not take an intervention at this point.
It is clear that the Government has chosen to use today’s debate to focus on what it cannot do, rather than getting on with what it can do. We need practical solutions that help people where it matters most: in their household budgets.
Not only can we pass on the support that is coming from the UK Labour Government; we have the opportunity to go further than that, because of the relative imbalance between the number of properties in council tax bands A to D in the rest of the UK and the number of such properties in Scotland.
[Made a request to intervene.]
Last month’s budget delivered £208 million of additional funding for Scotland linked to the household—
[Made a request to intervene.]
Sorry—did the minister want to make an intervention?
Yes. First, the cabinet secretary set out a range of areas, such as a social tariff to bring down energy bills, where we would go further. I would love to hear any plans or ideas that the member has, too, because that would be helpful.
Secondly, with regard to blaming others, I was delighted to see the sudden change of heart from the Cabinet Office, no less, with Hamish Falconer blaming Brexit for food costs going up, but where did that move to agreeing with the Scottish Government on Brexit come from?
I do not think that there is a change of heart—it is clear to anyone that Brexit and the increased regulation between markets in the UK and Europe has had an impact on food costs and a range of other issues. That is patently obvious.
I want to press the Government on the funding that will come as a result of the household energy payment. The Scottish Government has committed to matching the £100 payment to households in council tax bands A to D, which Scottish Labour welcomes, but we are calling on the Government to use the extra funding that will come with Barnett consequentials as an opportunity to go further than that. We are asking it to use the extra funds provided to ensure that larger households that are struggling to pay the rent and heat their homes are not left behind, by extending that £100 payment to households receiving council tax reductions in bands E to H. We are also asking the Government to increase the winter heating payment from £62 to £100 to everyone who is eligible, and to maximise uptake of the warm homes discount.
[Made a request to intervene.]
Together, those measures are an example of the powers that the Scottish Government already has—fully costed within the envelope of funding from the UK Government funding package—and could implement today.
I am intrigued by Mark Griffin’s claims that all this can be done within the consequentials, including the further work on the social security payments. I also wonder whether he considers that to be a one-year increase or an increase in perpetuity. If it is the latter, will that be part of Labour’s budget negotiations? That funding would clearly not be covered by consequentials from the UK Government in future years.
No. We are talking about a fully funded, costed proposal that I am sure the finance spokesperson will share with the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government. It is immediate action this year that stems from the UK Government’s announcement of one-year funding linked to the household energy payment.
Is that for next year and the year after?
It is fully costed for this year, and the funding comes from the one-year fund from the UK Government. We are asking the Scottish Government to match that and to use the additional funding that it would have over and above what it needs to pay that £100 household energy payment to households in council tax bands A to D.
Will the member give way?
The member should be winding up.
Perhaps I will have the opportunity to intervene on the cabinet secretary later and she can make her point to me then.
That is a practical solution, using the powers that we already have, to support families who are struggling right now.
I ask members to support my amendment. I move amendment S7M-02053.3, to leave out from “regrets” to end and insert:
“recognises that wider pressures on international energy markets, including the impact of conflicts in Ukraine and Iran, are continuing to place significant pressure on household energy bills; welcomes the practical action taken by the UK Labour Government in its Autumn Budget to create immediate breathing space for families with the rising cost of living and to help households with energy costs; notes that these measures have generated additional funding for devolved governments; believes that Scotland should use this to deliver further support to those who need it most; calls, therefore, on the Scottish Government to use the additional funds to extend the UK Government’s £100 energy payment to all households in receipt of Council Tax Reduction and to increase the Winter Heating Payment to £100; further calls on the Scottish Government to maximise uptake of the Warm Home Discount, and notes that these measures combined could deliver up to £350 of extra assistance to the poorest households this winter.”
I call Duncan Massey to speak to and move amendment S7M-02053.4
16:06
This week, I was reminded of the children’s nursery rhyme “The Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly”. It is certainly an old favourite of mine and my kids, or at least it was when they were younger and actually nice. The story serves as a metaphor, illustrating how an initial mistake or lie can spiral out of control, with matters tending to get worse and worse when someone tries to fix it with ever more elaborate and complex schemes rather than fixing the underlying issue or problem. It is surely an apt metaphor for, and criticism of, nearly all Government policy.
Energy perhaps represents the clearest example of that failure and that type of thinking. Across Scotland, the UK and, indeed, much of Europe, our energy system is simply not working. British industry has the highest energy costs in the world, and our household bills are also among the highest in the world. Conflicts involving Iran and Russia have caused price spikes, but we are far more exposed to the shocks than other nations.
Decades of delusional policy making have left Scotland, Britain and most of Europe badly exposed to energy reality. The main underlying issue is that we have gone down a route of prioritising net zero above everything else, pushing intermittent renewables too far, too quickly, with no understanding of either the cost for the new underlying system or the vulnerabilities that such an approach creates.
As far as I understand it, Duncan Massey’s party is defined largely by two issues: turning away from net zero and reducing immigration to next to nothing. Does he recognise that, if we do not get to grips with the climate emergency, we will supercharge immigration and illegal migration to this country as people flee parts of our world that simply become unliveable?
That is fanciful and not backed by the science. [Interruption.] I will come to that issue later.
The UK’s emissions account for only 0.8 per cent of global emissions. Reducing that to zero, if we could, which is not possible, would effectively have no impact.
This is our energy policy: like the lady who swallowed a fly, the approach started out small. We wanted to reduce emissions. Great—I back that. However, the approach then became getting to net zero. The thinking was, “We don’t worry about the cost. We can do it easily. It will be cheap and it will add jobs.” It was wishful thinking then, and it is basically a big, fat lie now.
It started with Governments thinking that they had great success with moving to gas, which led to the UK’s emissions being the lowest in Europe. Then Governments thought, “We’ll get rid of our remaining coal plants. What is the worst that can happen?” Next came carbon taxes for industry. After that, they went down the wind route. It was accepted that subsidies would be needed to get that going, but 40 years later, we are still paying them, and they are going up and up. The next thing that Governments said was that the existing grid was not suited for renewables.
Presumably, by those subsidies, the member means contracts for difference—or, at least, that was what Richard Tice was talking about in July 2025 when he said that they should be ended. Why does the member rule out a mechanism that gives investors certainty and protects consumers from volatile gas prices?
Obviously, high subsidies drive high costs.
When it comes to the grid, costs are going up and up. There are giant pylons through half of our countryside and, in Scotland alone, the grid build-out is forecast to cost up to £44 billion over the next five years. That goes straight to people’s bills and comes along with a nice, risk-free return for the utility companies involved, while the supply chain sits in China.
Do not worry about the intermittency; it is always windy somewhere—except that it is not. It is difficult to manage. In low-wind conditions, we are significantly dependent on France for its nuclear power, or we have to beg older gas plants to start up again with offers of record prices. There is an increasing risk of failure. Two weekends ago, Torness was the backbone of Scotland’s grid. What will happen when it shuts? We will be at severe risk of blackouts. Then, the Government thinks, “Oh, we’ll just shut down our oil and gas industry. Surely, we won’t need all that home-grown oil and gas and the associated jobs.”
The result of all those steps is that we have a failing system. Not only do we have some of the highest energy prices in the developed world; it is doing nothing to reduce global emissions. As I have just said, the UK is responsible for 0.8 per cent of global emissions; Scotland is responsible for a mere 0.08 per cent. Those global emissions are going up, as other nations focus on pragmatic energy policies.
Now, the estimated household bill under the price cap is beyond £2,000. That is a disaster for people out there. What are we going to do to fix it? There will be no acknowledgement of the actual problem: a failing energy system driving ever-higher costs. No, we will focus on ever-more elaborate and complex schemes that are bound, eventually, to fail or run out of money. There is the price cap itself; the proposed household energy payment; the cut in VAT on electricity from 5 per cent to 0 per cent; and the movement of policy levies—that is, older renewables subsidies—from bills to general taxation. Now, the gas standing charge is being removed.
To mix my metaphors, those are sticking plasters on a broken dam and a broken system. The nub of the issue is that, like the old lady who swallowed a fly, we are not fixing the underlying issue. We are just adding ever-more elaborate and complex schemes, or sticking plasters.
To conclude, first and foremost, we need to fix our energy system by focusing on cheap, abundant, reliable energy. Until our energy system is fixed, we can argue about all the policy mitigations and interventions that we like, but we will need more and more until, eventually, the whole thing falls apart. The old lady who swallowed a fly is dead, of course.
I move amendment S7M-02053.4, to leave out from “welcomes” to end and insert:
“notes that the Scottish Government has supported Net Zero and made calls for the UK Government to go even further, which Parliament regards as having increased the cost of living; further notes that Office of National Statistics’ CPI and energy intensity data show that, even allowing for global factors, energy costs per household in the UK are, on average currently £1,700 higher than in the USA, based on their current energy costs; calls on the UK and Scottish governments to abandon Net Zero and to focus fully on reducing energy costs, with renewables deployed only when this can be done without subsidy, to deliver cheap, abundant and reliable energy.”
I call Holly Bruce to speak to and move amendment S7M-02053.1.
16:13
I am not sure how I will be able to follow that performance.
Twenty-nine per cent of people in Scotland live in fuel poverty. That is completely unacceptable. That is 29 per cent too many households who face freezing conditions through the winter and are forced to choose between heating their homes and putting food on the table. That is also 29 per cent too many families whose health suffers and whose participation in school and work suffers, and who are let down when they most need support. We can, and must, do better than that.
In the past six years, oil and gas companies have raked in more than £143 billion of profits while, year on year, millions of families across Scotland and the UK have been plunged further into fuel poverty. I cannot imagine the amounts of stress, fear and impossible financial pressure that have been shouldered by families while oil bosses have taken the energy crisis as an opportunity to exploit. In what world can we justify their making £143 billion in UK profits while folk make a conscious decision not to put their heating on because they do not have enough money to do so? Can anyone in this chamber justify that? Would members rather keep making the rich richer and the poor poorer, colder and angrier?
More than two thirds of people in the UK say that they are worried about paying for their heating if bills go up again next year. Up and down the country, people are struggling despite doing everything that they can to keep afloat. Many council tenants will self-disconnect or cap their gas meters. If we truly want energy to be in Scotland’s hands, we need to back publicly owned and community-derived renewable energy that pays back to the people of Scotland by way of cheaper bills.
Will the member take an intervention?
I will not.
Continuing to allow fossil fuel companies and their shareholders to pursue endless profits at the expense of everybody else can no longer be an option.
I welcome the UK Government’s announcement in its budget that £100 will be taken off energy bills, which many of my constituents will benefit from, and I am pleased to hear that the Scottish Government will work with local government to roll out the policy. Over the past eight months alone, Advice Direct Scotland has paid out £26,700 in heating support across Glasgow to help people who would otherwise not have been able to keep their heating on. That pressure will only get worse as temperatures drop over the coming months and if the price cap rises to £2,000, as it is set to do in January.
I fundamentally agree with the Scottish Government’s motion that a social tariff would provide a much more targeted and effective metric of support for those who are in need now. We need to tackle the poverty premium that results in households with the least facing the highest costs. We know that people living in poverty are more likely to live in fuel-inefficient homes. For example, those with debt are forced to pay through a meter rather than through a contract, which results in extortionate charges.
Will the member take an intervention?
I will not at this point.
The deletion of the call for further devolved powers in this area, which would be the result of agreeing to the Labour and Liberal Democrat amendments, would make it all the harder for Scotland to do the right thing for the most vulnerable. Surely both parties would agree that utilising our powers in this area and asking for more would be welcome.
We need to support those in poverty and in debt so that any financial support that they receive can go towards keeping them warm. How is a family struggling with debt supposed to heat their home while the bailiffs are knocking on the door for old council tax arrears?
I welcome Government programmes such as the warmer homes Scotland and area-based schemes, which help to reduce bills, upgrade people’s homes and provide practical support to households that are experiencing or are at risk of fuel poverty. However, there needs to be continued investment in such schemes so that they can provide long-term solutions for struggling families.
I welcome local community action. South Seeds, a local charity in my constituency, has been providing assistance with energy bills and debt to vulnerable residents across the south side for more than 10 years. It provides practical support in navigating a convoluted system by assisting residents with access to financial aid, such as the warm home discount, or emergency fuel vouchers at the point of need. Its work is vital.
Like many members, I would like the Government to go further in supporting households immediately this winter. What measures is the Government proposing today to put more money in people’s pockets before the cold weather hits?
Instead of simply supporting people once they are already in poverty, we need to tackle the structural problems in our energy system—a system that is fundamentally broken and is driving people into poverty in the first place. The UK and Scottish Governments must use their joint powers on energy to tackle those structural problems. The UK Government must continue to support the clean energy transition and our shift away from fossil fuels. The Scottish Government must support households to move towards cleaner and cheaper heating by progressing the much-delayed heat in buildings bill, which the Greens have been relentlessly pushing for, so that we can take action.
16:18
Soaring energy bills and the cost of living are putting intolerable stress on households and businesses. For many people, keeping the lights on and the heating running is a real struggle, so the cabinet secretary is right to recognise Labour’s broken manifesto promise to cut energy bills by £300—although, of course, making undeliverable manifesto promises on the back of a fag packet is something with which the Scottish Government is rather familiar. In fact, that tendency is demonstrated by the second half of its motion.
The Scottish Parliament already has substantial powers on energy and could take action to reduce energy costs. We should remember that the SNP retains its long-standing presumption against oil and gas developments, which suppresses potential tax receipts that could be used to help.
We should remember that the SNP used its powers to ban new nuclear developments. France generated just under three quarters of its electricity from nuclear last year, which gave it reliable, low-carbon generation, reduced its exposure to volatile gas markets, and meant that its electricity prices increased by just 1.4 per cent in the year to September.
Of course, the Scottish Government used its powers to lease the seabed for ScotWind, raising £755 million. It could have used that money to reduce bills, but instead it used it to support the Government’s wider fiscal situation and allocated so much of it that the minister appeared before the Finance and Public Administration Committee a fortnight ago with virtually no idea how much was left.
Liam Kerr has some gumption to talk about spending receipts from energy resources on day-to-day spending when the UK Treasury, under consecutive Tory and Labour Governments, took £350 billion out of Scotland’s North Sea and we did not get any benefit from that at all.
That is absolute nonsense, because the revenue generated by the North Sea has come back in the form of record block grants, year after year after year, to this very Parliament. The Scottish Government already has the powers needed to help people with their energy bills and to target the support where people need it most. There is nothing to prevent it from—
Will the member give way?
In a second, minister.
There is nothing to prevent the Government from providing targeted financial assistance, investing in more energy efficiency, improving insulation and tackling fuel poverty. It does not need additional powers to do any of those things, but of course it is easier for the SNP to suggest that devolving energy powers would mean cheaper electricity. Changing the decision maker does not change the cost of generating electricity, the price of gas on international markets, or the cost of building and maintaining the infrastructure that we need.
On the point about a futures fund, the UK was the only country to discover major resources in oil and gas and not put it in a futures fund. Timor-Leste did it, Niger did it, and Azerbaijan, just after it was independent, did it. Norway raised £1.5 trillion, which assisted with the transition to renewables. Does the member agree with Labour, who are late to the party, in saying that that was a failure in energy policy?
That is a recital of history. What is interesting is that the Scottish Government is now talking about setting up its own wealth fund. That is interesting, but just a week ago, when I asked about it, the minister could not tell me how much it would be capitalised with, how much would be ring fenced and how it would be replenished, so this Government is raising these grievances on the hoof.
Will the member give way?
Let me make some progress.
I listened to the cabinet secretary’s opening remarks and she failed to explain how contracts for difference would be funded if everything were devolved. Nor did she explain who would pay for the up to £70 billion investment needed in the electricity transmission network. Devolving energy policy does not make those costs disappear. Maybe the cabinet secretary will try to explain that in closing.
Remember, Presiding Officer, that Scotland remains part of an integrated electricity market. When Scotland generates a surplus, it can be exported. When renewable generation falls, we benefit from electricity that is generated elsewhere. That is the point that I want to take up with the Greens. It is true that gas-fired generation frequently sets the wholesale electricity price, because it is the most expensive generation needed to meet demand. What I mean is that electricity supply and demand must be balanced continuously and the market needs to ensure that sufficient generation is available when renewables cannot meet demand, which means gas setting the price. I am therefore pleased to inform Holly Bruce that, to examine ways to reduce consumers’ exposure to volatile gas prices, the UK Government—and, to be fair, the Scottish Government—commenced a joint consultation in October looking at a wholesale CFD scheme that would move eligible existing low-carbon generators on to fixed-price arrangements. That is practical market reform.
This is a debate about a very serious issue—the cost of living and energy prices. However, the SNP’s motion is not a serious contribution. It continues the argument that the SNP started in May, when it called for all energy powers to be devolved, with Stephen Gethins explicitly arguing that doing so would bring bills down, but then, as now, the SNP could not explain what it would actually do with those powers and how much it would save—
The member needs to wind up.
With respect, I took two interventions, Presiding Officer.
The member has had his time back for interventions and needs to wind up.
We need practical solutions to the problem, a reliable and diverse energy supply and a Government that is prepared to use the powers that it has. The Government has had those powers for years—it should get on and use them.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. When I spoke earlier, I did not move my amendment to the motion. I can move it formally now.
I move amendment S7M-02053.1, to insert at end:
“; recognises that programmes such as Warmer Homes Scotland and Area Based Schemes can help reduce bills, upgrade homes and provide practical support to households experiencing, or at risk of, fuel poverty; believes that to deliver affordable energy in the long term, the UK Government must decouple the price of electricity from that of gas and Scotland must redouble its efforts to invest in renewables; recognises that powers to support the transition to clean heating and to insulate homes rest with the Scottish Parliament, and therefore calls on the Scottish Government to ensure that the forthcoming Heat in Buildings Bill includes strong measures in both of these areas to help create warm homes for all.”
Thank you.
I call Morven-May MacCallum to speak to and move amendment S7M-02053.2.
16:25
I declare that I am a sitting councillor.
I will spend the time that I have today highlighting some of the challenges that people in my region face. Rural and island households face a significant cost of living premium, with higher food prices, greater transport costs, more expensive heating and older, less efficient housing. That has already been recognised by many in the third sector, with the Poverty Alliance calling for targeted action to help people in rural communities with energy costs, transport, housing and service provision.
We all know that those in the older population are particularly vulnerable. Research by Independent Age estimates that 41 per cent of older people in my region have cut back on heating, and that 15 per cent have skipped meals. Nobody should have to choose between keeping their home warm and eating.
That is before we get on to the poor deal that our island communities get. Concerningly, extreme fuel poverty affects 34 per cent of Orkney households, compared with just 14 per cent of households nationally. The Orkney fuel poverty charity Tackling Household Affordable Warmth, or THAW, has reported an 850 per cent increase in demand for support since the energy price spike in 2022. I know from my conversations with the citizens advice bureau in Shetland that it is seeing similar numbers.
All that sits uncomfortably with the fact that those island communities are powering this country. Scotland is an energy-rich nation, and my region generates a large share of that energy. In parts of the Highlands and Islands, the turbines dominate the view from every window in people’s houses, yet those same households are the ones who are in fuel poverty. Community benefit was meant to be the answer to that, but the guidance governing that is badly out of date. Rewriting that guidance so that communities receive a far greater share of what is made, generated, stored and transmitted near them would do a great deal to help them and is within the Government’s gift, as is transferring a fairer share of ScotWind rental income to the councils that host those infrastructures. Let us work together to turn the tide on that.
We need to start doing things differently, because the figures that I outlined indicate that we are a long way off meeting our statutory fuel poverty targets for 2040. I appreciate the Scottish Government’s position is that to do things differently, we need to devolve more energy powers to the Parliament. I understand that argument, and parts of the system genuinely need to be reformed, but I gently say that, on this matter, we need to focus on the things that relate to our constituents and are of concern to them.
Let us talk about the Scottish Government’s emergency oil scheme, which exists to help rural households to deal with the high cost of heating oil. A recent Scottish Liberal Democrat freedom of information request found that, of the £10 million allocated to the fund, only £2.4 million has been spent and that, of the 15,600 applicants, fewer than 6,000 received any payment. The rejection of more than 9,500 applications suggests to me that there is an issue with the eligibility criteria, and we can investigate that right now.
The Scottish Government already has the power to reduce fuel poverty, improve housing, support struggling households and make a difference in the community. The case for new powers is always strongest when it comes from a Government that uses the powers that it currently has.
The member needs to wind up.
I therefore kindly ask ministers to review that scheme.
The member may wish to move her amendment.
I move amendment S7M-02053.2, to leave out from “, and believes that” to end and insert:
“; believes that rural and island communities, where some of the highest levels of fuel poverty in Scotland can be found, are facing the prospect of even higher bills for the heating oil on which many households rely, and calls therefore on the UK Government to introduce a three-month zero rate of VAT on domestic heating oil and to develop a price cap to shield those communities from sudden increases in the price of heating oil.”
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Just in case I did not do this at the time, I move amendment S7M-02053.5, to leave out from “welcomes” to end and insert:
“believes that lasting reductions in energy bills require greater domestic energy production, stronger energy security and lower policy costs; calls on the UK Government to support continued North Sea oil and gas production and to reduce green and energy levies that add to household and business bills, and calls on the Scottish Government to use its existing powers to reduce devolved costs and regulatory burdens rather than pursue interventions, such as food price controls, that risk increasing costs further.”
Thank you, Mr Kerr. That is now on the record.
We move to the open debate.
16:30
I will touch on the point about Scotland being an energy-rich country. It is an energy-rich country, and it is now widely considered—even by the UK Labour chancellor—that, if we had had a sovereign wealth fund or a future fund, it would now be worth a massive £1 trillion. Some people say that it would be worth a bit more than that.
[Made a request to intervene.]
I have just started, Mr Hoy.
Over the weekend, I was alarmed to read that the pitch by former University of Aberdeen economist Tony Mackay to create a sovereign wealth fund akin to the Norwegian wealth fund was rejected by UK politicians in the 1970s. On the one hand, I am pleased that a sovereign wealth fund was not just an SNP policy; esteemed economists also thought that it was a good idea. However, the energy wealth that was generated was instead used to destroy communities by shutting down industry and the hopes and dreams of many people for their futures. I know that because of the community that I come from, in which I still live.
I raise those points because they are relevant to today’s debate. How many more homes could we insulate if Scotland had access to a sovereign wealth fund of £1 trillion? How many new homes could we build to an even better standard? How many pensioners would be living without worrying about turning on the heating—or would be living overall? How much better would life be for every person living in Scotland?
During the 2024 election, Labour told the electorate to vote for it to reduce energy bills by £300. When Labour came to power, the energy price cap was £1,568. One year later, it was £1,720. Now, it is £1,723, and it is expected to increase to almost £2,000 in January. That is hardly £300 cheaper. Labour’s amendment references the
“conflicts in Ukraine and Iran”.
As my colleague Alan Brown touched on earlier, the Ukraine conflict had been under way for two years before Labour came to power.
When the £100 winter payment comes along for this year, it will not even touch the sides of any new energy increases. I am sure that the households that are struggling will enjoy the warmth in the one room that they are living in because they are scared to turn the heating on across all their rooms.
If Labour were to be serious about keeping people warm, it could introduce a social tariff and scrap the link between gas and electricity prices. The scrapping of standing charges is welcome, but it is also one of those policies that will give with one hand and take away with the other. With domestic energy usage typically being higher in Scotland, our constituents will have the privilege of paying even more for their energy, because energy costs will still increase. That is despite Scotland producing the vast majority of oil and gas in the UK and generating more than one third of the UK’s renewable energy.
Scotland clearly has the energy, but it does not have the power that most energy powers have, and regulation still remains with Westminster.
Will the member take an intervention?
I am sorry—no.
While Scotland continues to have some of the highest energy bills in Europe, the Scottish Parliament cannot change energy regulation. That is why energy powers need to be devolved to this Parliament.
In addition to that energy bombshell for Scotland, the recent UK Labour budget will also deliver a £650 million real-terms cut to Scotland’s budget for the next year. That will have an impact on how this Parliament can undertake its activities in the next financial year, including its maintenance of cost of living measures to help households.
I will also highlight one inconvenient truth for the Greens with regard to their amendment. The programmes that they highlight—warmer homes Scotland and the area-based schemes—are excellent. In Inverclyde, 2,324 properties have accessed the area-based schemes. However, I know that there are people who refuse to take part in such activities. I am not sure whether the Greens are saying that they will force people to do the things in those programmes. The programmes are beneficial and helpful, and they help households and individuals. However, even though people can apply and get funding, sometimes without needing to pay a penny, some of them will still not want to take part in those activities.
People want Governments, Parliaments and politicians to do what they can to help society, but the previous Tory Government crashed the economy and broke Brexit Britain. It got its come-uppance by being kicked out of Downing Street in 2024. I welcome the fact that Labour is now on a route to rejoin the European Union—
You need to wind up.
Okay.
However, a route back into the EU must also mean a second independence referendum for Scotland. The public will not accept anything less.
16:35
Once upon a time, high energy prices meant a very different thing in Aberdeen than they did across the rest of Scotland. For all of my adult life until a few years ago, Aberdeen’s fortunes rose and fell with the price of oil. We were an oil capital and an energy capital, and we are now Europe’s capital of energy excellence. Our local workforce is excellent. Our workers are some of the most highly skilled, innovative and pioneering in the world.
For most of my life and most of my time working in politics, especially when the price of oil was over $100 a barrel, the biggest challenge that Aberdeen faced was described as “poverty among plenty”. Aberdeen was a city of two tales. In the small pockets that oil wealth had not crept into quite so much—many of them in the Northfield ward, which I represented—there was a problem with inequality, and it caused issues across the city. House prices, rents and even hotel rates became unaffordable to a lot of folk, but at least it felt like something that we had the power to mitigate.
Even when prices fell and we saw pay cuts and job losses, that at least went along with household bills and petrol prices being a little bit lower. When talented engineers and energy workers received redundancy payments, many invested them in starting businesses of their own. Aberdeen reinvented itself time and time again through the ingenuity of its folk. That is a cycle that our city has worked with for decades.
About five years ago, the cost of living crisis started to take hold—and this is where my comments get a lot closer to the wording of the motion. Aberdeen is a city with so much energy and potential, a city whose economy was once so strong that it could make or break the whole UK budget, and a city with tens of billions of barrels of oil sitting off our coast, so why can so many of my constituents not afford to keep their heating on and keep themselves and their families warm? More folk are going cold in Aberdeen than would be the case if Westminster had done nothing at all, because the windfall tax has pushed so many folk out of work.
However, the most frustrating thing about the windfall tax in its current form is not the amount of money that it has taken out of the north-east economy. It is that the tax could bring in more revenue if it did not hammer the energy industry quite so hard. We could have more jobs, not just in the north-east but in the whole of Scotland.
Will the member take an intervention?
I am sorry, but I do not know how much time I have for interventions, and my time is short.
Any time for interventions is added to a member’s time, but it is up to the member to decide whether to take them.
Time was cut quite short earlier, Presiding Officer.
We could have had fewer households struggling to get by and more tax revenues to help everyone else.
However, here is the thing that I really do not understand. I get that global oil prices are high, and I understand the reasons for that. The actions of tyrants such as Putin and Trump have pushed prices up in every country, but by the time energy reaches households and businesses, why is it so much more expensive here than anywhere else in Europe? That is not a failing of Labour or the Conservatives. It is a failing of the United Kingdom as an institution, regardless of whoever is in power.
Do not get me wrong. Both parties have failed at various levels, and both parties—and now Reform, too—have pushed the narrative that we need to choose between oil and gas and renewables. I say once again that we can have it all. We can have oil and gas, carbon capture, wind energy, tidal energy, air and ground source heat, and even solar on some days.
At a time when so many folk are struggling with their bills, why are so many politicians more concerned with reducing the places where energy comes from, rather than helping folks to heat their homes, protecting jobs for energy workers today and creating them for future generations? There is a sense that Labour has betrayed people, especially in Aberdeen. The party betrayed our energy workers, costing thousands of jobs. It betrayed us with the pittance of jobs that Great British Energy has created in Aberdeen. We have been betrayed by its failure to cut energy bills and the fact that it has forced record levels of fuel poverty onto an oil capital. Surely, we could do things better than that if Scotland had control over itself.
16:40
Scotland is an incredibly energy-rich country. We have been blessed with oil and gas reserves in our North Sea, with environments that are perfectly suited to capturing wind and wave power, and with one of the most educated energy workforces in the world. Scotland produces the vast majority of the UK’s oil and gas and generates more than a third of the UK’s renewable energy, yet we continue to face some of the highest energy bills in Europe. That does not add up. If we were independent, it simply would not be the case.
So many of the challenges that keep the cost of energy bills high in Scotland could be straightforward to fix, but the powers for energy remain reserved to Westminster. Frankly, many of those fixes would not be in the interests of the Westminster institution. For example, had the revenues from the North Sea not been frittered away by successive Westminster governments and they had instead followed the example of independent Norway, which has roughly 5 million people, and put the revenue into a sovereign wealth fund, more than £1 trillion would now be available to invest in bringing down bills and investing in the just transition across Scotland.
Does the member hope that, in his closing remarks, the minister will signal the end of the SNP’s presumption against oil and gas?
He is missing the point of what I was talking about. Had past UK governments invested in a sovereign wealth fund—
It is a straight question.
Norway owns around 1 per cent of all the companies in the world. Our energy has been mishandled by successive UK governments because it was not handled by Scotland. At a time when energy security has never been more important, Westminster was perfectly happy to save the steelworks in Scunthorpe in England and allow Scotland’s only oil refinery in Grangemouth to cease production, despite Scottish Labour’s outrageous false promises to save the workforce during the 2024 general election. Why? Because it was in Westminster’s interests and not in the interests of Scotland. Put bluntly, most often, Westminster’s interests align with the electorate in England, rather than the people of Scotland.
I am deeply concerned that the people of Scotland are about to be sold down the river for Westminster’s interests once again. Last week, I asked Stephen Gethins, the Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Energy, about the snappily-titled strategic spatial energy plan. The plan has been produced by the National Energy System Operator and will outline a Great Britain-wide framework spanning 2030 to 2050 for the location, capacity and timing of electricity and hydrogen generation and storage. There are six potential pathways for how that might look, which are to be decided on by the UK Government. A decision is expected this year, although it is hard to know much about the process, given that it appears to take place in a black box.
There is serious concern in the industry about the damage that many of the pathways that have been proposed by the National Energy System Operator would do to Scotland’s renewable energy sector and the associated supply chain. There is a strong concern that, in an attempt to reduce bills in London and the south-east of England, the UK Government will choose to deprioritise investment in onshore and offshore wind in Scotland and the grid. If one of those disastrous pathways is selected, it would threaten ongoing investment in Scotland’s energy infrastructure, as well as jobs in our energy sector and the supply chain that supports our transition to net zero energy.
I was extremely grateful for the minister’s confirmation that the Scottish Government would only support an SSEP that reflects Scotland’s full energy potential. That is why the powers for energy need to be devolved and why Scotland needs independence. Unlike Westminster, the Scottish Parliament’s interests will always align with the interests of Scotland. The people of Scotland deserve a Government that is always on their side.
Although we remain shackled to a failing union, I am proud to be a member of a party that is doing everything that it can to bring down bills. That includes campaigning for the adoption of a social tariff to help those who are at the sharpest end of fuel poverty—it would be interesting to hear what Labour has to say about that in summing up—and our host of cost of living support initiatives that help families in poverty, such as the Scottish child payment.
With an independent Scotland, we would have the opportunity to build a fairer, greener and more prosperous nation—a country that harnesses its vast natural resources for the benefit of its people and ensures that the wealth created here works for the people who live here. That is the future that Scotland deserves.
16:45
I have spoken to constituents across Angus North and Mearns who are delaying filling their oil tanks because they simply cannot afford the up-front cost. Even I did not fill the tank to the brim this autumn, as I usually would. I ordered only what I could budget for, and I will have to ration my usage carefully. If I had filled my tank, it would have cost me well over £1,000—twice what it cost last year. Unlike households connected to the gas grid, rural families must find hundreds of pounds at once to heat their homes. That is a significant issue across the north-east and all of rural Scotland. Around one in every 10 households relies on heating oil, and 42 per cent of properties in Aberdeenshire are not connected to the gas grid.
I pay tribute to the member for her work on this issue in particular. She will be aware that the current scheme does not yet include many people who are in need of support. Last week, I asked the minister to urgently review that aspect of the scheme. Does the member support that call?
I absolutely do, Mr Melville, and I will come to that in my speech.
Over the past year, those households have been hit by sharply rising costs, and the Competition and Markets Authority reports that prices rise more steeply in remote rural areas, where there are fewer suppliers and higher delivery costs. Despite repeated warnings from rural communities and the CMA, the UK Labour Government has yet to set out a timetable for regulating the domestic heating oil market, where there is no cap on prices. The UK Government also chooses not to heed the SNP’s calls for a temporary cut to VAT on heating oil. That has left many off-grid households continuing to struggle to make ends meet, especially those who have vulnerabilities and need the heating on all day. In contrast to that inaction, the Scottish emergency heating oil scheme has provided welcome support to those households who are most in need, and I am glad the decision was made to extend the scheme through the winter months, because there is clear demand for assistance.
Last week, Advice Direct Scotland informed me that it received more than 1,300 applications for heating support across Angus over just three months and that almost all of those related to heating oil. The scheme is another example of the SNP Government’s having to mitigate the impacts of Westminster policies. The mitigation is to be commended, but it is not reaching enough people. As of 10 November, just over 5,200 households in Scotland had received support, but around 142,000 households across Scotland rely on heating oil, and we know that fuel poverty remains a serious issue in rural communities. We must ensure that everyone who is eligible is aware of the scheme and can access it quickly and easily and that those who are just outside eligibility are also considered.
In the meantime, I have spoken to constituents who are struggling with rising costs but who do not qualify for the scheme under the current means-testing criteria. They fall outside the eligibility thresholds, sometimes only marginally, and face significant pressure as a result of rising heating oil bills. I urge ministers to complete the work on keeping eligibility criteria under review as quickly as possible.
Earlier this year, the Government committed to exploring a heating oil price checker, based on the model operating in Northern Ireland, and that work needs to be progressed urgently. At a time when every penny counts, consumers need better information. Households deserve access to clear and transparent pricing information. Rural communities in Scotland should not pay a premium simply because of where they live. Rural households deserve fair prices, clear information and support that reaches them when they need it. That means action is needed from the UK Labour Government on regulation and taxation, and continued action is needed in Scotland to ensure that we do what we can within the constraints of devolution to ensure that no family is forced to choose between keeping warm and making ends meet without falling into debt this winter.
16:49
Across East Lothian Coast and Lammermuirs, families and businesses are facing another winter of intense pressure. Soaring energy bills, layered on top of the wider cost of living crisis, are creating unprecedented hardship. People are choosing between heating and eating.
Last week, I visited East Lothian food bank, which has seen a marked increase in the number of people talking to it about energy debt—that is before the new energy price cap rise. Around 30 per cent of households in East Lothian are in fuel poverty, which is around 17,000 households. That is impacting 35,000 to 40,000 people right now, as we approach winter. Many businesses are also struggling with rising overheads, and, as we approach winter time, their viability will be impacted.
Rural households that are reliant on heating oil, or LPG, feel the cold particularly sharply. Dawn Black just spoke about that. Many people in East Lothian rely on heating oil, but costs have risen sharply. A few members have already talked about that.
We know that the outlook in relation to the energy price cap is bleak. Again, a few members, including Stuart McMillan, have talked about that. Independent forecasts and major suppliers put the Ofgem energy price cap from January to March at somewhere between roughly £2,000 and £2,200 for a typical dual-fuel household. That is a substantial rise from the current level of around £1,723. For many of my constituents who are already stretched, that is not an abstract figure; it is money that they simply do not have.
Labour came to power in 2024 promising to cut energy bills by around £300—we heard Mark Griffin trying to defend that—but that is now unlikely. The cap was about £1,500 at that time, but it will now go up to £2,200, with future increases proposed. That pledge was often repeated during the election campaign, but, here we are, well into Labour’s term, and bills remain stubbornly high and are forecast to rise further.
I am sure that Paul McLennan will remember, as I do, a leaflet that came through the door promising £1,000 off bills if people voted Labour in the 2022 election. Does he agree that Labour has quite a track record of making broken promises about people’s bills?
I agree with that. I think that I remember that, which was during a council campaign. I still struggle to find out how Labour was going to cut that £1,000 through a council campaign.
I will talk about the temporary measures in the UK Government’s budget. There is a £100 payment for many households, the extension of zero VAT for a few months, and the moving of gas standing charges on to unit rates. Those measures offer some limited short-term relief, but they fall far short of what is needed and are nowhere near the scale of the support that people were led to expect.
Within the limited powers available to it, the Scottish Government has acted. We have heard about schemes such as warmer homes Scotland, which delivers improvements and cuts bills every year for thousands of households. There is the pension age winter heating payment, the winter heating payment and other targeted help. The Scottish Government has also said that it will pass on the Barnett share of the £100 energy payment scheme, so that households in Scotland will benefit. Those measures matter, and they make a real difference to the people who receive them.
Like me, many of Paul McLennan’s constituents are off grid and rely on heating oil. Will he take on board the comments of Morven-May MacCallum, who invited the Government to look again at the eligibility criteria for funds whose purpose is to support rural residents with heating bills, so that those residents actually get the support that they need this winter?
I am sure that the cabinet secretary will pick up on that point as she concludes the debate. That issue needs to be looked at every year.
I will return to some points about the fundamental failure of reserved energy policy to deliver affordable, secure power. Nobody today has talked about what Scotland really needs right now—which could be brought in by the UK Government right now—which is a proper social tariff with targeted bill discounts for those in greater need, based on income, household circumstances, medical need and rurality. The Scottish Government has brought together a working group on that proposal, which includes suppliers, consumer groups and fuel poverty organisations, and it has set out clear recommendations. Scenario modelling shows that around 660,000 people in Scotland could benefit from that right now, with average savings of hundreds of pounds and a significant reduction in fuel poverty. That is a practical, fair and deliverable proposal. I would urge the UK Government to go further than the temporary budget measures and implement a genuine social tariff of the kind that Scotland has proposed.
Energy policy decisions made at Westminster have left Scottish households exposed for far too long. Alex Kerr talked about the strategic spatial energy plan, and there are various pathways proposed by the UK Government that would be disastrous for Scotland. It needs to look at that right now. There are also a few other things that the Scottish Government could look at. For example, we need to advance the progression of community energy initiatives and how we support the growth of heat networks. Jackie Dunbar rightly mentioned the role of solar in that.
The people of East Lothian Coast and Lammermuirs, and people across Scotland, cannot wait for another winter of broken promises and inadequate support. They need bills that are affordable now and a long-term energy system that works for them, not against them. I support the Scottish Government’s motion.
We move to the winding-up speeches.
16:54
I welcome the debate, particularly as it is in Government time. Without question, the cost of living is the issue that, next to health, is of most concern to my constituents—as it is, I am sure, to the constituents of other members. There is a lot to agree with in the Government’s motion, and, if the Government accepts our amendment, we will back it.
There are a couple of omissions, to which I will speak very briefly. Those include growth. We urgently need to grow the Scottish economy in order to foster an environment for good and competitive jobs that pay decent wages. However, the need of our constituents is urgent and immediate. The tectonic shifts in the energy market that we are discussing are about reform and transmission, but they are also about smaller things such as community benefit, to which my colleague Morven-May MacCallum referred in her excellent speech.
We need to be honest with people. Political parties are often not honest enough on the topic. A hundred pounds here or there will not touch the sides, given that fuel bills are fast becoming unrecognisable from what they were just four years ago. We do not want to give people false hope, but we need to protect the vulnerable. Therefore, in all the policies that we enact and want to encourage the chancellor to deliver from Westminster, we need to bear that in mind.
I do not think that the Reform amendment represents serious politics. We cannot talk about turning away from net zero in one breath and talk about the need to end immigration in the next. Climate change is the final boss of the 21st century, and it will lead to mass migration as big parts of our planet become uninhabitable.
Perhaps Alex Cole-Hamilton can point me to the reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change that are driving those bold statements, because, when I read the IPCC reports, I do not see anything that comes close to suggesting that kind of thing. It seems that he is making things up on the hoof.
That is not a credible intervention. Every reasonable and rational parliamentarian in this place knows that climate change is real, is changing our planet, is making large swathes of land mass uninhabitable and will lead to mass migration on a scale that we have never seen before. It is just not real for Reform members to pretend otherwise, and they need to wake up to that.
The Conservative amendment falls into a similar trap.
I will use the time that remains to me to talk to the Liberal Democrat amendment. The Ofgem forecast for January is horrifying. It will, undoubtedly, bring anxiety to many homes in this country—including those in my constituency of Edinburgh North Western—as people wonder how they will make ends meet. Christmas is coming, and people spend a lot of money. January is not a time when people have a lot of money, and the issue is really going to bite.
The chancellor’s budget last month provided some sensible changes, such as the removal of standing charges from gas bills, which have been pushing up those bills even as people have tried to reduce their energy consumption. However there should have been more in the budget to bring down those bills. On that point, I agree with the cabinet secretary. For example, the chancellor could have listened to my Liberal Democrat colleague Daisy Cooper MP and brought forward an essential energy guarantee, which would have cut energy bills by a further £100 a year.
As my colleague Morven-May MacCallum talked about in her opening speech, we absolutely need to do more in our rural and island communities that rely on domestic heating oil. As our amendment highlights, we need the UK Government to step up to the plate and provide help for those communities. A point that Morven-May MacCallum made bears repeating, so I remind the Scottish Government and SNP members that, despite the high number of applications to the Government’s oil fund, only £2.4 million of the £10 million that was made available has been disbursed. Given that rural communities have some of the highest rates of fuel poverty in the country, they need to be able to access that support. Something in the system is just not working.
The cabinet secretary highlighted the steps that the Scottish Government has taken to help families through the rising cost of living. Although I acknowledge those, I also argue that the Scottish Government has not got everything right. A clear example of that is the warmer homes Scotland scheme, which has made slow progress in ensuring that the people who are most at risk of fuel poverty are in more efficient homes and in helping them to make the change to renewable energy sources such as heat pumps.
That is why we support Holly Bruce’s amendment. In her excellent speech, she raised the fact that we are not driving down the demand for fossil fuels in this country by making it easier for our constituents to heat their homes. We are never going to be able to tackle fuel poverty, deal with rising energy bills and tackle emissions if we do not speed that up.
16:59
This has been a full debate, but, to extend the energy metaphor, it has generated more heat than light.
Before I turn to the cost of energy, let us take a step back. Alex Cole-Hamilton was absolutely correct to mention that economic growth is one of the engines through which we can attack the growing cost of living; however, as I said to the minister earlier, there is one lever at the Government’s disposal that it has not pulled. The Government states in its motion that there are
“severe cost of living pressures”,
but the largest pressure that many households face is their tax bill, and this Government singularly fails to address that.
I suspect that, in its budget, the Scottish Government will yet again freeze thresholds on income tax, falling into a trap that has now been repeated by the Labour Government, which means that many more Scots who are struggling to pay their bills this winter will be writing ever bigger cheques to the Scottish exchequer. As I said to the minister, a young Scot working full time in a pub, after taking into account their tips, will now be paying a higher rate of tax. I do not think that those are the people with the broadest shoulders. They are the people who are struggling to pay their energy bills, and it is frankly ridiculous that the cabinet secretary is taxing them more than they would be taxed in the rest of the UK.
Let us look at the other issues raised in the debate. The cabinet secretary again obsessed about clean heat and net zero, but I would like to remind her of what Tony Cain of the Association of Local Authority Chief Housing Officers said before the Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee recently:
“The problem is that our challenge comes from fuel poverty, not carbon. Carbon emissions from social housing are in the roundings of Scotland’s annual emissions calculations”.
He went on:
“One of the issues with switching to zero-emissions heating systems such as heat pumps is that, given the current structure of energy pricing, that can actually drive fuel poverty.”—[Official Report, Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee, 11 November 2026; c 17.]
That means that the Scottish Government’s own heat and energy in buildings policy is further adding to the problem of fuel poverty.
I agree with Mark Griffin’s contribution where he said that the Scottish Government is blaming someone else. It is very good at doing that, but so, too, is the Labour Government, which brought on board Great British Energy to drive down bills, which is proving toothless in its ability to do that.
Duncan Massey seemed to be obsessed with the old lady who swallowed a fly. Yet again, he came to the chamber and appeared to only swallow his foot, because the binary, simplistic solutions that Reform keeps bringing to the Parliament are undoubtedly its weakness. I do not think that its amendment or its policy has credibility, because there is more nuance to the subject than Reform gives the Parliament credit for.
Holly Bruce was hopelessly simplistic in yet another attack on the profits of large energy firms. It is those profits that, in many cases, drive people’s pensions, and those pensions are helping them to pay their bills this winter.
I agree very much with Morven-May MacCallum about what more the Scottish Government could do to help those who are off grid. It could look at that pot of money that has not yet being allocated, either to ensure that money from it is going out the door to those who qualify already, or to extend the eligibility criteria for it in order to use it for many more people who will face fuel poverty this winter.
Jackie Dunbar saying that another party has turned its back on Scotland’s oil and gas workers is laughable coming from a member of the SNP, which did exactly that throughout the previous parliamentary session.
I close by reflecting on Alex Kerr’s contribution. It was quite clear when I read the SNP motion, as it is in every point that the SNP has made in the debate, that this debate not about driving down bills for ordinary, hard-working Scots, or about energy policy, or about the cost of living. It was about more and more grievance in relation to independence.
On the topic of the strategic spatial energy plan, which I spent quite a bit of time talking about, would the Conservatives back the Scottish Government in refusing to adopt any of the six pathways that would harm Scotland’s onshore and offshore renewable energy sector and the associated supply chain? I am looking for a very simple answer.
I would do what I think Mr McLennan would like us to do, which is to back nuclear energy in Scotland, so that we expand our energy base—[Interruption.]—and deliver the real energy security that Scotland so clearly needs.
This debate, yet again—
Will the member give way?
I do not have time.
This debate—yet again—was about independence, but I think that the people who struggle to pay their bills this winter will see right through it. It was yet more grievance from the SNP, yet more blaming other people and yet more saying, “If only we had more powers, we could do the job,” when each and every day, the SNP abuses and misuses the powers that it has.
The focus should be on driving down bills for hard-working Scots today. The Scottish Government has the levers to do so; it does not need to look elsewhere. It is high time that it took responsibility for the policies that are doing so much damage to ordinary hard-working Scots, who will be watching the debate in the chamber today and asking this Government what it will do to drive down bills.
17:05
I begin by declaring an interest: I am a sitting councillor on Orkney Islands Council.
Like many aspects of the energy portfolio, energy pricing has a profound effect on people in Scotland, yet despite the multiple debates on the point today, it is clear that we do not control energy pricing. Our energy market is volatile and leaves households and businesses susceptible to global price shocks. It gives them no choice but to cut back on other essentials because their energy bills have once again soared. That is not the starting point from which we build strong local economies or tackle fuel poverty at the systemic level.
Six minutes is entirely inadequate to cover a topic that is so wide ranging in impacts and causes, so I will focus today on individuals and their place in the energy market. Ultimately, far too many people in Scotland have no agency in our energy market and are vulnerable. That problem is the shaky foundation that we must address before we are truly able to tackle the power imbalance in the energy market and systemic fuel poverty. We must empower individuals and businesses to escape the spiralling costs of an energy system that is built to deliver for England, not for Scotland.
On that front, there is some hope, because we have powers here in Scotland to begin to tackle the issue. Moreover, the heat in buildings bill and a delivery plan are set to be introduced. The bill must take us towards a future in which households and businesses are not just passive actors in the energy market who are doomed to accept rising bills and price crises when they happen and to cut what they spend on everything else accordingly. We know what can be done because we are already doing it across the country, just not at the scale required.
A future in which people are empowered is one in which they can produce, store, sell and buy energy. It is one in which microgeneration is even more commonplace, whether that is of solar, hydro or wind. In that future, more people and businesses across Scotland are actively producing their own energy and are not depending solely on buying it from the grid. It is a future in which storing energy that someone has generated themself or bought cheaply on a variable tariff protects them from market peaks. It is also one in which households and businesses are not simply customers in a marketplace; they are actively buying and selling strategically to reduce their bills and, in many cases, generate an income. That might all sound utopian to some people, and some will argue that it is, but it is far from that: it is already a reality for many people.
There are two problems. First, that reality is not nearly as accessible to people as it needs to be, in cost terms or in terms of accessing a supply chain that can deliver the solutions en masse. Secondly, we do not yet have the vision and determination from the Government on how to get there. Nowhere is the importance of the issue clearer than in my home of Orkney and the wider Highlands and Islands, where the cost of keeping warm is not an abstract debate but a daily reality, as Morven-May MacCallum rightly pointed out. The latest local authority figures from the Scottish house condition survey, which cover 2022-24, show that, as Morven-May MacCallum said, Orkney has the highest rate of fuel poverty in the whole of Scotland. Fifty-one per cent of households are in fuel poverty and 34 per cent are in extreme fuel poverty. That is more than one in three households in my community who are being forced to spend a huge share of what they have just to stay warm, and they often still cannot do so.
However, the picture on the front line is just as stark. Our local fuel poverty action charity, THAW Orkney, as Morven-May MacCallum rightly said, supported 603 households last year, which was a 9 per cent increase on the year before. In cases in which it was able to assess a client’s situation, only 10 per cent of clients were not in fuel poverty. All other clients who were assessed were in fuel poverty, and 62 per cent of those assessed were in extreme fuel poverty.
What is THAW asking for? It is asking for simple things. The main property issue that people bring to THAW, which no current scheme can help with, is the need to replace or improve double glazing. Many double-glazing units are now old enough that the seals have failed. They let in moisture, they let out heat and they leave people paying to warm the outdoors. However, Home Energy Scotland loans are currently available only for upgrading single glazing. The same goes for renewables. Loans should be made available for solar photovoltaic systems on their own, not only for hybrid PV water-heating systems.
Battery storage is now being installed as part of some warmer homes Scotland applications, which is welcome, but home batteries should be included in Home Energy Scotland grants and loans, too. In an island community with abundant wind and more sun than one might expect, letting people generate and store their own power is one of the most direct routes out of fuel poverty that we can influence and enable from the Parliament. If Orkney has the highest rate of fuel poverty in Scotland while being home to some of the most ambitious community and household energy generation in the country, the lesson is plain. The problem is not a lack of will to make those improvements and changes but a system that is not delivering the benefits to nearly enough people.
When the heat in buildings bill and the delivery plan come forward, we need a change of pace—we need leadership and ambition, and a plan that can deliver warmer homes for all.
17:10
In a modern energy-rich country such as Scotland, nobody should have to come home from a hard day’s work, keep their outdoor coat on in the living room and leave the boiler switched off just to save on the gas bill. Nobody should be leaving the oven door propped open after cooking just to take the chill off the kitchen, or find themselves standing in a supermarket aisle, quietly putting food back on the shelf because the total at the till has crept up too high. Yet, across Scotland, those quiet compromises are the daily routine. When hard-working people cannot afford basic warmth and food without resorting to survival hacks, it is a national failure.
It was never meant to be like this. For generations, the promise was simple: work hard and pay your way, and your living standards rise. Today, however, too many Scots feel poorer than they did years ago, and nowhere is that pressure felt more sharply than by those who live alone. As a single parent or as someone on a single wage, you cannot share the cost of heating four walls or spread the fixed household costs. You carry 100 per cent of those costs yourself.
We need to grow the economy, as we have heard, and we need to enable businesses to do that. Energy is the master input in the entire economy. When energy becomes more expensive, everything else becomes more expensive, too. For years, politicians have treated affordability as an afterthought and assumed that households would simply absorb the cost of energy transition.
The result is an economy left increasingly exposed to global shocks, and working families left carrying the bill. We need abundant cheap energy—nuclear, oil and gas and renewables—to give us energy security. Countries that produce and use their own energy enjoy a major economic advantage while others use domestic supply to keep costs lower and to keep industries competitive. We have become increasingly exposed to volatile global markets. At the same time, we have reduced domestic energy production without having a reliable alternative that is capable of meeting demands. That exposure is driving the economic squeeze that families now feel.
We should look first at how energy drives inflation. When energy costs rise, the farmer, the haulier and the manufacturer pay more, and those costs do not disappear—they turn up in food prices, household bills and business costs across Scotland.
The Food and Drink Federation highlights that energy is woven through the entire food production process, from ovens and refrigeration to heating, cooling, cleaning and storage. It estimates that energy accounts for around 8 per cent of production costs, while rising energy prices also increase the costs of ingredients, packaging and farming and so on. When energy costs rise, food costs follow.
Will Angela Ross take a brief intervention?
Yes, I will.
Angela Ross talked about energy costs increasing. The initial cost for Hinkley Point C was £17 billion; the cost is now being estimated at around £49 billion when it eventually goes on stream. That indicates that energy costs for the consumer will increase. How much more will the consumer have to pay because of Hinkley Point C?
We need a spread of energy, with a mix across the portfolio that will enable us to have energy security from many different sources. If a nuclear reactor such as Torness closes, we need an alternative, so we must have a spread.
Cheap and reliable energy matters for other reasons, too. UK businesses face some of the highest industrial electricity costs in the world. We know from what Craig Hoy said earlier about France and the nuclear energy there that its electricity prices are lower. When firms are spending their money keeping the lights on and machinery running, they cannot invest, expand or raise wages, and, when productivity suffers, living standards suffer with it.
That pressure is not felt equally, as we have heard. Private sector workers, the self-employed and small business owners have no automatic protection from rising costs. Anyone who earns a modest middle income in Scotland already finds themselves paying higher taxes than elsewhere in the UK while receiving none of the support that is targeted at lower-income households.
We cannot tax or subsidise our way out of an energy-driven cost of living crisis. We need a serious and financially grounded energy strategy that captures economic value here in Scotland. I suggest that, before any new regulation, mandate or energy policy is approved, its impact on household bills and business costs should be examined.
We must also stop wasting Scotland’s energy potential. Right now, because grid infrastructure has failed to keep pace with generation, wind farms can be paid to switch off while consumers continue to pay higher bills. That is not an energy success story; it is planning failure.
We know that energy is reserved, but, as has been mentioned, let us remember that Holyrood controls planning, business rates and industrial strategy. Continued ideological opposition to, for example, nuclear power in Scotland should not continue.
We must put financial security alongside energy security and build a balanced energy mix that supports domestic energy production, invest in the infrastructure needed to use and distribute that energy effectively, and use the powers that this Parliament already has to attract investment, build industry, boost productivity, strengthen food security, ease pressure on household budgets and help hard-working Scots to feel better off once again.
The rest of this Official Report will be published progressively as soon as the text is available.
Previous
NHS Grampian