Official Report 610KB pdf
Scottish Land Commission (Number of Land Commissioners) Regulations 2026 (SSI 2026/284)
09:01
Our second item is consideration of a Scottish statutory instrument. We are joined by Gillian Martin, Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs, and her Scottish Government officials Emma Ash, senior policy adviser on land reform; Faye Cooke, solicitor; and Patrick Kirkham, head of land reform.
The SSI is laid under the negative procedure, which means that it will come into force unless the Parliament agrees to a motion to annul it. Such a motion has been lodged by Donald MacKinnon. He joins us, along with Ariane Burgess, for this session. I note that the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee made no comment on the instrument.
I believe that the cabinet secretary would like to make a brief opening statement before we go to questions from members.
I appreciate the opportunity to make an opening statement. I hope that the information that has been provided will assist members to support the SSI.
I want to be clear from the outset that progress on land reform is a priority for the Government. I fully expect the Scottish Land Commission to continue playing its key role in supporting Scotland’s land reform journey.
The effect of the SSI is that the Scottish Land Commission’s size will not change, but its make-up will change. The addition of the new land and communities commissioner will be balanced by removing a land commissioner post and not backfilling the land commissioner vacancy that arose as a result of the unexpected resignation of Dr Calum MacLeod earlier this year.
Dr MacLeod’s resignation coincided with the initiation of the recruitment process to appoint the new land and communities commissioner, which prompted us to consider the balance and composition of the board in the light of the commission’s evolving responsibilities and wider public service reform objectives. In doing so, I considered the commission’s overall capacity, expertise and experience in providing strategic leadership, oversight and challenge, as well as the support and day-to-day delivery work that are provided by the commission’s staff. I want to be clear that there will be no reduction in staffing associated with this specific proposal.
I believe that the commission can continue to discharge its statutory functions effectively. It will have six commissioners: four land commissioners, the tenant farming commissioner and the new land and communities commissioner. I appreciate that the direct financial savings associated with the proposal are modest; nonetheless, they will allow the commission to spend that money on its day-to-day work instead of on the costs of an additional commissioner.
Public service reform is about ensuring that service delivery is proportionate, streamlined and designed to meet Scotland’s needs in the most efficient way while ensuring that structures and processes that support delivery remain sustainable, responsive and fit for purpose. This decision is consistent with the framework that was established in Parliament in the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016, which expressly provides for ministers to alter the number of land commissioners by regulations. That power recognises that the commission’s composition may require adjustment over time. Indeed, depending on the work programme of the Land Commission, an additional commissioner may be needed in the future, and the framework allows for ministers to revisit the issue. We are making an adjustment, and a decision might be made in the future to appoint an additional commissioner.
I will talk briefly about the committee’s and Donald MacKinnon’s interest in Gaelic representation. There is no doubt that the departure of a Gaelic-speaking commissioner is a loss. However, I want to be clear that there is no guarantee that a Gaelic speaker would be successful in a future recruitment exercise. Indeed, the number of successful applicants with Gaelic has, sadly, been low through three different appointment rounds for land commissioners, despite a command of the language being included as a desirable criterion in recent appointment rounds.
I know that the commission remains strongly committed to supporting and promoting Gaelic. It continues to engage constructively on those issues, and the recently published consultation on its Gaelic language plan demonstrates that ongoing commitment. We have circulated the land and communities commissioner advert among Gaelic stakeholders, and the board has advised that it has circulated the advert among its Gaelic-speaking networks as it recruits its next commissioner. We continue to strongly encourage applications from Gaelic speakers in future recruitment rounds. The need for the expertise that Dr MacLeod brought to the board, including in relation to human rights and Gaelic, will be considered in future recruitment exercises.
Ultimately, having considered those factors, I am satisfied that the commission will remain well placed to fulfil its statutory functions and continue its important work in support of Scotland’s land reform agenda. I am happy to take any questions that committee members have.
Thanks very much. I now invite members to ask questions—I point out that we will debate the motion under the next agenda item, so we are just asking questions at this point. I will bring in committee members first and then go to Donald MacKinnon and Ariane Burgess.
Good morning, cabinet secretary. I understand taking the opportunity to reassess capacity and need when someone resigns, but we very recently had such an opportunity during discussion of the new land and communities commissioner, and the idea of reducing the number of commissioners did not come up in committee.
I am worried about the possibility that someone who currently sits on a similar public body and who is thinking of resigning might wonder whether their resignation might end up in their post being abolished. Can you give us any reassurance on that point and outline any further justification for the way in which this has been done?
Ms Roddick’s question makes it sound as if there is a sort of blanket strategy of taking such an approach whenever there is a resignation. However, this decision was taken on its own merits. Obviously, we consider the composition of boards at various points. I am not quite sure when we would next have an opportunity to consider the composition of the Land Commission board—I think it might be 2029; my colleagues might be able to confirm that.
Two things happened. First, the land and communities commissioner post was going to be advertised, and then an additional vacancy arose as the result of Dr MacLeod resigning. Those two things happening at the same time gave me a chance to look at the board’s composition in the light of the future work programme and the capacity in the organisation, and I decided that not backfilling the vacancy and just recruiting the land and communities commissioner would allow us time.
Does that answer your question, Emma?
I want to make it clear—
I am sorry, cabinet secretary—does that answer Emma Roddick’s question?
I want to say yes, but I would like to hear a bit more.
Okay. Cabinet secretary?
I do want to answer the substantive question. The analysis was done, and I must make it clear that no one on any other board should be worried about this being a strategy that is going to be applied elsewhere. This decision was based on its own merits. I was given the landscape of the board, the decisions to be taken and the recruitment processes for the new land and communities commissioner. My decision, which was based on the current board’s capacity, was not to backfill but to concentrate instead on getting a commissioner in.
I would also point out that, in future years, another decision could be made—this is not a set-in-stone situation. For the moment, our analysis has led us to believe that it would be best to stick with six commissioners, as I have outlined, rather than have seven and have to go out and recruit two of them.
Good morning, cabinet secretary. In your opening remarks, you outlined the perceived difficulties with recruiting Gaelic-speaking members to public bodies. Do you consider that you are meeting the intention of the legislation—particularly section 11(2) of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016—in knowingly leaving the commission without a Gaelic-speaking member and failing to address the opportunity of allowing at this stage the appointment of a new member who could be Gaelic speaking?
With regard to the appointment of the land and communities commissioner, having a Gaelic speaker would be a desirable—what is the word?
Criterion.
Criterion—thank you. The word went out of my head. Being a Gaelic speaker would be a desirable criterion. The organisation could also contract in Gaelic-speaking assistants to help with its Gaelic language work and ensure that it had that capacity.
There is no guarantee that a successful applicant for any of the board posts will be a Gaelic speaker—there are many criteria associated with the various posts—but I find it disappointing that, as I have said, the last three rounds of recruiting commissioners have not resulted in our getting a successful applicant with Gaelic language skills.
I have already outlined how the commission has tried to recruit for the new post that it is trying to fill and what it is doing to reach out to Gaelic-speaking communities and those with Gaelic language skills, and it has given me information about how it is trying to encourage more Gaelic speakers to put themselves forward for the new role. However, there is no guarantee that a Gaelic speaker will either apply or be successful.
I appreciate all of that, but by saying that speaking Gaelic is only a desirable criterion in the current process instead of, say, making it an essential criterion in the appointment of this additional commissioner, who could have been recruited, are you not giving the impression, or sending a message, to our Gaelic-speaking communities that you do not think that having a Gaelic-speaking member of the commission is all that important?
It comes down to the framework, Mr Baxter. It does not dictate that you have to have a Gaelic speaker, or that that is essential.
I will bring in Patrick Kirkham, who leads on land reform, to make an additional comment.
I want to give a small clarification with regard to the legal duties on ministers under the 2016 act. The section in question says that
“In appointing the Land Commissioners, … ministers must take every reasonable step”
for there to be a Gaelic speaker. That duty applies to actions that are taken during the making of appointments, so when an appointment round for the land commissioner is live, all such steps must be taken, including the publication of materials in Gaelic and their circulation among Gaelic communities. It is not a general duty on ministers at all times; there have been times in the past when there was no fluent Gaelic speaker on the commission, and that did not mean that there was a duty to appoint additional commissioners.
09:15
With regard to making that criterion essential, I will just note that the criteria are already quite specific and there is not always as large a pool of candidates as you might imagine there is for filling a vacancy. Making that criterion essential would quite limit the available pool, particularly given the other essential criteria and the role specification. I think that that is why, in the legislation, being a Gaelic speaker is set as desirable and not as essential—it is just to make sure that a suitable candidate can still be found.
Andrew, it is back to you, briefly.
Thank you, Mr Kirkham, for your lesson about the difference between reasonable steps and requirements in the legislation, which I already fully understood.
Cabinet secretary, Michael Russell has acknowledged that the commission can no longer offer engagement through a commissioner speaking Gaelic, and he mentions recording a message in Gaelic as a learner. I commend him for learning the language, but do you, as cabinet secretary, accept that that is not an adequate substitute for having a fluent Gaelic-speaking commissioner who is able to engage directly with those communities?
As I said, it is extremely desirable that the commission has a Gaelic speaker, and I know that Mr Russell has learned Gaelic only in his adult life. However, as Patrick Kirkham outlined, and as you said that you fully understand, that is not an essential criterion.
I really regret that Dr MacLeod has stepped down. Obviously, he had his reasons for doing that, but he is a Gaelic speaker and he brought a great deal to the commission. However, there is no guarantee that a successful recruitment for his former post would mean that a Gaelic speaker filled it. The post of land and communities commissioner is out for recruitment at the moment, and I really hope that Gaelic speakers will apply for it.
I will broaden this out. My position is that, given that we are in the middle of a discussion on public service reform, any discussion around the future of the Scottish Land Commission should form part of that, rather than it being for us to take a piecemeal approach by reviewing one commission.
Whether or not you recognise this as a problem, cabinet secretary, I do not believe that the concentration of land ownership has been addressed. Has the commission delivered what it was set up to deliver? The key question is whether its functions are best delivered through a stand-alone organisation or should be absorbed into existing Government structures and agencies as part of public sector reform. The functions that are currently undertaken by the commission need to be considered within the wider piece of public service reform. They should not be seen as just part of a piecemeal decision that we are taking today.
I have a different view from that of Mr Carson, and he knows that. The Conservatives’ position is that the Land Commission should not be a stand-alone body, but I take a different view. It is a relatively small organisation, but I think that it does great work. All cabinet secretaries have been asked to look at the bodies under their portfolios. As cabinet secretary, I have no plans currently for the Land Commission to be absorbed into any other body. Its functions are well served by its being a stand-alone body, and I have no desire to absorb it into any other body.
Mr Carson did not say which body the Land Commission should be absorbed into. In the past few months, I have set out plans to bring together three bodies under my portfolio into an environment agency—although it is important to say that public service reform is about more than the number of bodies that we have. I have set out my criteria for the bodies that I am bringing into one environment agency, and I have decided that the Scottish Land Commission will remain as it is.
Public service reform is in all of our minds at the moment, but I have made the decision on the basis of the capacity of the current board and its work programme. There is a small saving in money for the commission, and it will be able to deploy that in other functions. It is not that much money—it is probably only about £15,000 a year. However, the regulations allow me to look from time to time at the make-up of the body, and that is what I have done on this occasion.
I want to build on your answer to Mr Carson. You have alluded a couple of times to the relatively modest financial saving, so it seems that this is a service delivery question. Finlay Carson and I are not particularly in favour of the Scottish Land Commission, but, regardless of that, is it the case that the work of the commission is best served by reducing the number of commissioners, so this is not a financial decision?
As I said, we undertook an analysis of the board’s capacity. You will have seen that the chair of the commission, Michael Russell, wrote to you with his views. Initially, he expressed disappointment, but he said that he understood and reaffirmed that the board has capacity to deliver its work programme. We must recognise that the change does not affect the number of staff—the people who do the day-to-day work of the commission—or capacity
I have made this decision at this point on the basis of the work programme and the capacity that already exists in the board, as well as the recruitment process for the new commissioner. The board will have a cohort of six commissioners, and I feel satisfied that, for a body of its size and given the work programme that it has in front of it, it will be able to deliver.
Good morning, cabinet secretary. You mentioned a few times in your statement and in response to questions that the tenant farming commissioner and the new land and communities commissioner bring the total number of members of the board up to six.
Yes.
How does that compare with other similar public bodies?
There are other bodies that have a larger staff cohort and have a board of a similar size. Scottish Canals has 309 staff but also has a board of six. The Scottish Law Commission has a board of five, the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator has a board of seven and the Scottish Human Rights Commission has a board of five. It is a fairly standard size of board for that size of organisation. As I said, Scottish Canals has a much larger staff count but has a board of six.
Six is a reasonable number, but I guess that the important consideration is the capacity of the board to deliver the work programme. That is why the regulations and the framework allow us to make such decisions. We could have made the decision at the end of the tenure of the current commissioners, in 2029, but there was a moment when the commission could have recruited two commissioners, and I took the view that it should concentrate its efforts on the land and communities commissioner. Officials spoke to the Land Commission, and we felt satisfied that that would allow the commission to take forward its work programme.
It is regrettable that a Gaelic speaker has stepped down, as I said. However, I hope that, with the recruitment of a new commissioner, there might be a successful applicant who is fluent in Gaelic.
Thank you for your opening remarks and for answering the questions so far.
There seems to be a bit of inconsistency in the argument that is being made. On the one hand, we have heard quite a lot this morning about public service reform, which is reflected in some of the correspondence—particularly in the initial note accompanying the SSI. On the other hand, given your response to Emma Roddick’s question, it seems that the decision is being taken in isolation—“on its own merits”, as you said. There is a feeling that the decision to make such a significant change to a public body should be taken from a position of having an overall strategy that looks at the wider context. I think that we would expect the make-up of public bodies to be determined in that way.
Which one is it? Is this change part of a wider strategy and part of the public service reform agenda, or is it happening in isolation?
I think that it is both. My answer to Emma Roddick was very specific to the question that she asked about whether it is a strategy that, when a board member on any board steps down, the role is automatically not backfilled. She was asking about that, and I said that it is not a strategy.
I took the public service reform agenda and the particular circumstances of the resignation of the board member, which, in effect, leaves an additional vacancy, in the round. I do not make decisions on the basis of one particular criterion; I look at everything. I have public service reform in my mind in a lot of the decisions that I make across my whole portfolio, so the decision is part of a strategy.
You mentioned my answer to Emma Roddick, who asked me a very specific question: is it the Scottish Government’s strategy that, when somebody is thinking of resigning from a board, the Government will, in effect, automatically get rid of that post? The answer to that is no. Is public service reform a strategy that we all have at the forefront of our mind as we make decisions? Yes, but—as I said to Jamie Langan in my previous answer—the saving in this case is modest. The number 1 reason, therefore, was not about saving money; the money that that decision releases still sits with the Scottish Land Commission, and it is able to use that money for its day-to-day functions.
I have a follow-up question on the number of land commissioners. The Parliament, in passing the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2025, took the view that there should be an additional commissioner—the land and communities commissioner, which you mentioned—in addition to the five land commissioners that existed at that point, plus the tenant farming commissioner.
Do you have any reflections on that decision that Parliament took? It was not that Parliament thought that a commissioner on the current board should also have a responsibility as the land and communities commissioner. The 2025 act provided for an addition on top of the five land commissioners and the tenant farming commissioner—a new land and communities commissioner. You seem to be suggesting that, by having no change, with the total number of board members remaining at six, that is what Parliament wanted in 2025. I do not think that that is what was voted for back then—it was an additional land and communities commissioner on top of the five land commissioners and the tenant farming commissioner.
The land and communities commissioner is being added to the board because of the work programme resulting from the land reform legislation that was taken through in the previous session of Parliament. As cabinet secretary, I am sitting with the situation as it is presented to me. At that point in time, we did not know that there was going to be a resignation—that happened in June, and the cabinet secretary at the time accepted that resignation. When I came into post, I was presented with a situation in which there would be two vacancies, and I considered that. I have explained my thinking around that: I will make decisions on the basis of the situation that is before me.
If I thought that removing one of the board members would mean that the Scottish Land Commission could not carry out its functions, I would not have made that decision. That is the crux of the matter.
Are you saying that the work programme and the remit of the Land Commission are getting bigger over time, or are they getting smaller?
09:30
I think that they are changing. There are certain activities that the Land Commission will undertake as a result of the legislation—for example, it will provide advice on the secondary legislation associated with the 2025 act—but I feel confident that it has the capacity to do that.
Is its work programme getting bigger over time?
If it is, we have a framework for adapting the board to respond—[Interruption.]
I am sorry, cabinet secretary. Could you say that again?
If the Land Commission believes that its board needs to have additional capacity as a result of its work programme changing or increasing, it can make such representation to the cabinet secretary.
It has been interesting to hear the responses that you have given to colleagues so far.
Before I got into this role, I did a lot of work on governance. My understanding is that the remit of the five commissioners is much broader than that of the roles of the tenant farming commissioner and the new land and communities commissioner, which are much more specific. You have referred several times to the work programme. As someone who was involved in the passing of the 2025 act, my sense is that the work programme will grow. For example, the introduction of natural capital market scrutiny will mean that the commissioners’ work will expand. Therefore, I believe that we need the existing five commissioners as well as the two specialist commissioners.
How will the four commissioners deliver the new duties under the 2025 act, such as those relating to natural capital market scrutiny and the land management plan work? You have said that the proposed saving is a modest one. I think that undoing the board of a crucial organisation is a slippery slope. I will say more about this later, but the Scottish Land Commission has transformed how people experience land in Scotland, regardless of whether they own it. The commission performs an essential role, and I believe that it needs to have a full complement of commissioners.
I agree with Donald MacKinnon. When we passed the 2025 act, we thought that we would have the five commissioners and the tenant farming commissioner plus the new land and communities commissioner. Will you explain how a reduction in the number of commissioners will help the commission to deliver on the 2025 act, along with the previous work that it still has to do?
I agree with your statement that the Scottish Land Commission has transformed how people think about land. Its work, including in providing advice to the people of Scotland, is essential, as its role as an adviser to me, as cabinet secretary.
Although the commissioners provide strategic oversight, they undertake the role for only two days a month. The day-to-day delivery of the commission’s work is supported by its staff, in which there will be no reduction. We gave consideration to the support that is provided by the commission’s staff, including the resource associated with delivering the new functions, and to the fact that the recruitment process for the land and communities commissioner is under way.
In its letter to the committee, the commission confirms that it continues to have
“an effective mix of skills”
and that it can draw on external expertise as needed. The commission did not say to me that it would not be able to function because of the decision that I have made. In its letter, it set out its thoughts on the reduction in the number of commissioners. It said that it understood the reduction and that it would be able to discharge its responsibilities with the cohort that it has.
Thank you, cabinet secretary.
Our third item of business is a debate on a motion to annul the Scottish Land Commission (Number of Land Commissioners) Regulations 2026. I remind Scottish Government officials that they are not able to speak during this debate, and I invite Donald MacKinnon to speak briefly to and move the motion.
Thank you, convener. I appreciate this opportunity to return to the committee and speak to my motion. I do not want to repeat the points that I made the last time I was here, though I stand by all of them. Instead, I will pick up on some of what we have heard this morning from the cabinet secretary and on the correspondence that the committee has received.
With regard to what we have heard this morning, I still think that there are questions to answer as to why this reduction is necessary. I do not feel that we have heard any suitable justification on financial, organisational or structural grounds, particularly around the impact on the function of the commission.
We have heard quite a lot about public service reform, and I just want to reflect briefly on how that has played out in the correspondence that has been received. For a start, I was struck by the omission of any reference to public service reform in the cabinet secretary’s latest written response to the *committee. Even though it appears to have been a key part of the rationale behind the decision, as has been outlined in the policy note and again this morning, it did not seem to form a substantive part of the argument made in the response. Indeed, in correspondence that has been received from Michael Russell, the chair of the Land Commission, he states, while expressing his disappointment, that
“we understand the imperative regarding public service reform”.
I have to say that I am left puzzled by what this decision is about and where it sits in the wider context. Is this a one-off decision, or is it a new approach? Either way, my view remains that the structure and future function of public bodies such as the Scottish Land Commission should be considered in a strategic way, not, as appears to be the case here, as part of some ad hoc process.
In correspondence to the committee, Community Land Scotland said:
“Community Land Scotland are unconvinced about the public finance saving from reducing the number of Commissioners. For an extremely modest financial saving the governance and capacity of the Commission will be impacted, at a time when it is taking on greater responsibilities. This would appear to be very short-sighted.”
A similar concern has been raised by NFU Scotland, which has said:
“Reducing the number of Land Commissioners risks limiting the breadth of experience, expertise and representation within the Scottish Land Commission.”
I remain concerned that reducing the number of land commissioners will make it harder for the Scottish Government to comply with the 2016 act and its obligations to make every reasonable effort to recruit a Gaelic speaker and to ensure that the other skills listed in the act are represented on the board. I therefore urge committee members to vote for the motion in my name.
I move,
That the Rural Affairs Committee recommends that the Scottish Land Commission (Number of Land Commissioners) Regulations 2026 (SSI 2026/284) be annulled.
Thank you. I invite contributions from other members before I bring in the cabinet secretary.
Convener, cabinet secretary and colleagues, Scotland has a proud history of land reform. Since the creation of this Parliament, we have moved in leaps and bounds—or maybe a little bit slower than that—with every act that we have passed that has put us on the path to transforming who owns land, who manages it and who benefits from it. What we are tackling is a legacy. The Highland clearances began what we are still living with—that is, one of the most concentrated patterns of land ownership in Europe.
For me, land reform is about four things: who owns the land, who manages it, who benefits from its rising value and who gets to make the decisions. Often, when we refer to land reform, it is as something quite opaque, but for many people it sits alongside self-determination. It is about agency and communities having a real say over the decisions that shape their lives. It is incredibly disempowering to live in a township or a village where you do not own the land and the landowner makes whatever decisions they want, and I know that that is happening in communities across the Highlands and Islands.
Look at what happens when communities own their land. On Eigg, they run their own energy system, they have a forest nursery and they are building their own housing. They are charting their own course. On the Galson estate, on Lewis, which Donald MacKinnon will know well, they have three community-owned turbines generating £4.35 million and employing a great number of people in the area. It is absolutely transformative.
We talk endlessly about investment and jobs but rarely about land. Across Scotland, there are concerns about renewable energy, yet nobody points to private landowners collecting high rents for simply hosting wind farms. At Galson, that money stays in the community. If we are serious about community wealth building, we need far more of that right now. Communities own only about 3 per cent of Scotland’s land, although the Government set a target of a million acres in community ownership by 2020. It missed that target and replaced it with a count of assets, not acres.
I have noticed, over the time that I have been in Parliament, that when a target becomes hard to meet, it is redefined. Now, instead of strengthening the Scottish Land Commission, we are being asked to cut it. With one hand, the Government is bringing in the land and communities commissioner, and, with the other hand, it is removing a commissioner with a far broader remit, just as the commission needs more capacity.
The commission is the engine of land reform. Its research on concentrated ownership shaped the 2025 act and its protocols are changing how landowners engage with communities. It is about to take on more work around large landholdings and the land management plans, as well as on the scrutiny of natural capital markets. This is the moment at which it needs more, not less, capacity.
In my five years in this role, I have seen the commission transform how people relate to land—even land that they do not own. The commission helped me to understand—not as an MSP, but as a person—that I should have a say in what happens to the land near me when it affects my life, and that is true of everyone in Scotland. It is the spirit of the land rights and responsibilities statement, and the commission is the body that makes that real.
Cutting a land commissioner right now weakens all of that, so I urge colleagues on the committee to support Donald MacKinnon’s motion to annul the instrument.
I apologise for my unintentional audible interjection during the cabinet secretary’s comments. I think, however, that if I had been in the committee room, I might still have interrupted her with the same interjection, because it was clear that she was unable to directly answer the question that you posed to her about the capacity of the Land Commission and whether it was facing considerable additional work. Ariane Burgess has just ably outlined the importance of that work, and the fact that it is expanding in quantity and detail sums up the problem with the reduction in the capacity of the Land Commission.
I note that the cabinet secretary was unable to answer that question directly. It looked as though she was trying to prevent herself from giving a direct yes—that the amount of work is increasing—because that would undermine her argument for reducing the capacity of the commission at this stage.
Donald MacKinnon outlined that it was Parliament’s intention to increase the capacity of the commission by appointing additional commissioners, increasing the number from five to seven. The cabinet secretary seems willing to ignore that intention on rather flimsy grounds, which is completely unjustified in respect of the very limited financial savings that she has indicated are possible as a result of the reduction.
I remain unsatisfied with her answers to my questions about the loss of Gaelic-speaking representation on the commission. Gaelic-speaking representation is important for many of the communities that I represent, particularly with regard to land. Land, language, culture and communities are all intertwined in the Highlands and Islands. The cabinet secretary used—or seemed to fall back on—the excuse that it is very difficult to recruit Gaelic-speaking commissioners, but I do not think that that is a justification for reducing the numbers, and I will be supporting Donald MacKinnon’s recommendation for annulment.
I have real concerns, particularly on the back of Ariane Burgess’s contribution. I believe that land reform ultimately involves political choices, which should be made by ministers. I have concerns about mission creep with the Land Commission, which has, in my view, increasingly sought to influence the choices that should be on the table, rather than simply providing evidence on which those choices should be based.
09:45
I have a lot of sympathy with Donald MacKinnon’s argument that the decision is rather piecemeal and that it should form part of a bigger piece of work looking at public sector reform. I believe that the function of the Scottish Land Commission should be, and could well be, better delivered through being absorbed into existing structures such as NatureScot, Forestry and Land Scotland, and local authorities. That is not just about cost savings; it is about streamlining the public sector to avoid duplication, ensuring that policy, advice, research and stakeholder engagement are delivered as effectively as possible. This is not the time or the place to make that change, but, given that we do not believe that the Scottish Land Commission is the best way to deliver value for money or the best service, I am not minded to support Donald MacKinnon’s motion to annul.
There has been a lot of discussion around capacity this morning, and a lot of what Donald MacKinnon put forward relates to whether the commission will have the capacity to deliver what is needed. However, the cabinet secretary has been clear that the main capacity for the work that needs to be done is within the staffing of the commission, as opposed to the board. The staffing is not being reduced, so the work capacity within the commission is still there. The existing commissioners have indicated that a total of six commissioners, including the new commissioner for land and communities, is workable, so I will be supporting the SSI.
It is quite clear that the remit of the Land Commission is expanding. We have seen that through the recent land reform legislation, and I find it difficult to believe that its work programme as a result of that is not also expanding.
Ariane Burgess raised the important point that the Land Commission is the engine of land reform. Clearly, if there are concerns about the work of the Land Commission, as Finlay Carson articulated, a natural position would be to restrict the number of land commissioners and to reduce the commission’s capacity. I do not agree with that, however—I believe that its work is important. We could equally be sitting here with a request from the Land Commission to expand the number of commissioners to do the work, rather than to reduce that number.
In answering questions, the cabinet secretary and her officials have shown that they have stuck to the letter of the legislation—I have no concerns about that—but I do not think they have stuck to the spirit of the legislation. It is important that we retain the number of commissioners. There is also an important link between land and language and culture. We need to double down on that and support it more deeply, and I do not think that this decision will help in that regard. I will be backing the motion to annul.
As there are no other comments, I ask the cabinet secretary to wind up the debate. It is over to you, cabinet secretary.
I have heard everyone’s arguments, and I want to make one thing clear: we believe that the Scottish Land Commission is doing vital work. I say that particularly in response to what Ariane Burgess said in outlining the reason and the rationale for the existence of the commission, which has served us well and will continue to do so. There was nothing in what Ariane Burgess said about the importance of land reform with which I disagreed—absolutely nothing. She is right to say that it has transformed the picture—people are far more aware of their rights, and communities are far more able to access the land that they live on. She also highlighted some community projects, and we could all cite many more such projects that have been tremendously successful. Nothing about this decision takes anything away from that.
I considered the commission’s overall capacity, expertise and experience in providing strategic leadership, and, in its response to my decision, the commission confirmed that it had the overall capacity and expertise to perform its functions. Dawn Black was right to say that the staff cohort remains—there is no reduction in capacity in the Scottish Land Commission.
I will leave it there. Obviously, I respect the views of everyone around the table. I understand the concerns about losing a Gaelic speaker and the desire to have a Gaelic speaker on the board. I hope that we can have more Gaelic-speaking capacity in the organisation through the latest recruitment round. However, I made the decision on the basis of the board’s capacity to deliver its objectives.
Donald, do you want to briefly wind up the debate and reflect on the comments?
I have nothing to add, really. I thank all members of the committee for engaging in the discussion. I remain of the view that we do not have the justification in front of us as to why the decision has been made. One thing in particular that came out in the debate and the questioning is the point that the convener revealed about the increase in the commission’s workload. That contrasts with the move to reduce the number of commissioners—to me, those things seem to be in conflict.
Do you intend to press or withdraw your motion?
I intend to press my motion.
The question is, that motion S7M-01834, in the name of Donald MacKinnon, be agreed to. Are we agreed?
Members: No.
There will be a division. To be clear, a vote for the motion is a vote to recommend that the regulations be annulled.
For
Baxter, Andrew (Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch) (LD)
Ruskell, Mark (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green)
Against
Black, Dawn (Angus North and Mearns) (SNP)
Carson, Finlay (Galloway and West Dumfries) (Con)
Langan, Jamie (South Scotland) (Reform)
Mitchell, Laura (Moray) (SNP)
Roddick, Emma (Inverness and Nairn) (SNP)
The result of the division is: For 2, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Motion disagreed to.
The committee is required to report to Parliament on the instrument. Are members content to delegate authority to me to approve a draft report on the instrument?
Members indicated agreement.
I thank the cabinet secretary and officials for attending.
I would be grateful if those who are leaving could do so quietly. We will then move swiftly on to the next item.
09:53
Meeting suspended.
09:58
On resuming—
Scotland Act 1998 (Specification of Functions and Transfer of Property etc) (Amendment) Order 2026 (SI 2026/1095)
The fourth item on the agenda is consideration of SI 2026/1095. It has been laid under the negative procedure, which means that it will come into force unless the Parliament agrees to a motion to annul it, and no such motion has been lodged at this point. I note that the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee has made several comments on the instrument, which are summarised in the public paper. As members do not have any comments, I invite the committee to agree not to make any recommendations in relation to the instrument.
Members indicated agreement.