Official Report 282KB pdf
Party Leaders
14:00
The next item of business is First Minister’s questions for party leaders. The first person to ask questions will be Michael Marra, who has seven minutes for questions and answers.
NHS Grampian
The horrific revelations last week of children put at risk by NHS Grampian were the tip of an iceberg. We now know that at least 19 people died at Aberdeen royal infirmary in circumstances that were avoidable.
Dr Habib, a consultant at NHS Grampian, has today put his career on the line, in desperate pursuit of change, so that those who knew what was happening can be held accountable. Nineteen people—fathers, mothers, grandparents, friends and loved ones—who were in the care of our national health service when they were sick died when they should not have. First Minister, why has this happened?
The issues raised and communicated this morning by Dr Habib are of the gravest concern. Last week, Mr Marra would have heard my expression of regret about the contents of the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report on the conduct of NHS Grampian. The standard of care and the necessity of high-quality care and patient safety being uppermost in all circumstances is paramount in the national health service, so the revelations and the points raised this morning are of the deepest concern to me.
It is important that, in all circumstances where concerns are raised, they are properly pursued. Obviously, we rely on health boards to undertake that responsibility, as it is their statutory duty to do so. With the events of last week and the conclusion of the process involving Healthcare Improvement Scotland, the Scottish Government has come to the conclusion—as the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care set out on Tuesday—that NHS Grampian must undertake very significant improvement and change to deliver on those expectations. That is what the Government expects.
I am afraid that that just does not wash. Families were not told and the public were not told, but the First Minister was told. I asked the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care in the chamber this week if there was anything else that had been covered up by NHS Grampian. She said nothing; there was no answer. Ministers had been told, however. Four times, Dr Habib wrote to Scottish ministers—three times to you, First Minister—seeking help for the people in his care. Nothing was done to stop the deaths—nothing.
Crucially, a 2022 external review that was commissioned by NHS Grampian—I have a copy here—considered 45 cases where whistleblowers raised concerns regarding liver and pancreatic surgery. Nineteen of those deaths were deemed to have been avoidable and due to issues with the surgery. The death rate was six times what would normally be expected. The review sets out the systemic failure, which was due to a lack of leadership, poor decision making, poor pre-operative planning and inadequate surgical care. The report was then buried, hidden from the public and the families of the dead, until this morning. First Minister, who decided to bury the evidence?
Those issues were addressed to NHS Grampian, and it is NHS Grampian’s responsibility to ensure that the performance of its clinicians and the delivery of its services are undertaken in accordance with the expectations of the approach that is set out by the Government in relation to patient safety.
The actions in relation to the changes in leadership in NHS Grampian have been undertaken to ensure that the Government can be confident about the standards of care that are in place there. That is where we have to ensure that the necessary changes are made, and the Government has made those changes.
Dr Habib was told in November 2024 by the First Minister to go to the police. He wrote to the First Minister directly, but the Government itself took no action at that time to deal with the problem.
I have had confirmation this morning that the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report was never published—it was buried by NHS Grampian. Nineteen people died. The First Minister was told not once but three times, and the health board buried the evidence. Enough is enough. The permanent secretary must commission an urgent internal review today on who knew what and when within the Scottish Government. The Lord Advocate must move now, today, towards a criminal prosecution.
Hundreds of grieving families across the country will be wondering today whether it was their son, their daughter, their mum or their dad who died needlessly and who might still be with them if only the Government had listened. Those families deserve answers and they deserve justice. The First Minister was told and did nothing. He must act today to get the answers for those families. Will he do so?
The Government acted last week to address the issues in the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report by requiring significant change in the leadership and direction of NHS Grampian. I accept that it was absolutely necessary to have undertaken that, so that we have in place new leadership that enables us to act in that fashion.
That is the commitment that I give Parliament today, and I gave that commitment to Parliament last week. The Healthcare Improvement Scotland report explains unacceptable performance in NHS Grampian, and there has to be, and there is, change in leadership to enable action to be undertaken. The issues of enormous significance that Mr Marra raises must be properly addressed by those in operational control of NHS Grampian.
On the issue of criminal prosecution, that is not for me—I cannot direct the Lord Advocate to undertake that, as Mr Marra knows. It is for the police to consider any evidence and for the Lord Advocate and the Crown to make any judgments about the merits of a criminal prosecution. That is the action that must be taken by the appropriate authorities, and it would be wrong for me to intervene in that process.
I can assure Mr Marra and Parliament that the Scottish Government is intent on ensuring that NHS Grampian properly carries out its functions, and that is what we have required it to do.
The First Minister is carefully avoiding the fact that, on four occasions, the issue was raised directly with ministers: ministers who are sitting on the front bench now, and one who is sitting behind him. He knows that that was the case. I have seen the letters—they were sent to him and nothing was done.
If these were urgent issues that had to be addressed, they should have been addressed, and that is why the permanent secretary should investigate right now. This must not be a repeat of the Government’s approach to the Queen Elizabeth university hospital or Eljamel in Tayside—to be dragged kicking and screaming towards justice. Families have waited years for answers. Will the First Minister deliver them?
In all the cases of correspondence coming into Government from Dr Habib, there have been appropriate responses issued to ensure that the necessary action could be pursued in relation to those questions. Advice was given in relation to evidence that could be provided, for example to the police, and about the support provided by the national whistleblowing service, which is a function that operates independently of Government to ensure that these issues are properly and fully challenged.
The Government has made clear its dissatisfaction with the conduct of NHS Grampian, which is why the significant changes in leadership have been required, and that is exactly what the Government is putting in place.
Homelessness
I am sure that the First Minister has noticed that the weather has recently taken a turn for the worse, and that nights are much colder. That makes the plight of homeless people sleeping on our streets more difficult. Some of them will be veterans, many are victims of drug or alcohol addiction, and others have fallen on hard times. Does the First Minister know how many of our fellow Scots are presently sleeping on the streets?
I do not have an accurate figure for the number of people who are sleeping on our streets. It is difficult to establish that precise number. However, I say to Mr Offord that the Government is taking a number of steps, through the investment that we make in homelessness services, to support individuals to overcome adversity and find secure housing, and that we are investing in the creation of housing infrastructure to ensure that the needs of the population are met in Scotland. That is reflected in the budget choices that the Government has made.
Indeed, we do not have up-to-date information, so perhaps the First Minister’s Government might rectify that.
One of the best ways to avoid young people having homeless futures is to ensure that they get into good jobs today. This week, Labour’s Alan Milburn called that a moral duty, and Reform agrees with that. However, for us, that must involve meaningful work in real jobs that are sustainable and add value to families and communities, not just another state-sponsored merry-go-round.
In 2020, the Scottish National Party introduced a young person’s guarantee called no one left behind. Since then, the number of out-of-work 16 to 24-year-old Scots has nearly doubled from 30,000 to 55,000. What does the First Minister say to the 55,000 young Scots who have been left behind?
I recognise the importance of the issues that Malcolm Offord raises, which are central to the Milburn review that was published earlier this week. There is a lot in the Milburn review that reflects the policy direction of the Scottish Government with regard to the no one left behind programme, which Mr Offord mentioned. The published unemployment and inactivity rates data tell us that, as a consequence of our efforts, Scotland has a higher employment rate and a lower inactivity rate among 16 to 24-year-olds than is the case in the United Kingdom overall. That gives me some encouragement that the steps that we are taking are providing better outcomes for young people.
In addition, the Skills Development Scotland annual participation measure showed that, in 2026, 93.6 per cent of young people were participating in education, employment or training. There is work to do to make sure that all young people are able to play an active part in our economy and to be contributors to our economy. I absolutely sign up the Government to that aspiration. We will look carefully at the contents of the Milburn review to identify whether there are other steps that we can take to strengthen our approach to ensuring that all young people have the best start in life and the best opportunity to participate in our economy.
It is clear that the First Minister thinks that there is no crisis here at all. I disagree: I think that there is a crisis here. Some 55,000 young Scots are not working. That is completely unacceptable, no matter what happens in the rest of the United Kingdom.
Of course, Màiri McAllan says that the answer to youth unemployment is to rejoin the European Union. Really? To allow a flood of 100,000 young EU migrants to gobble up the vacancies that our own young people need? Why would the First Minister allow outsiders to take starter jobs away from our own young Scots?
This morning, at the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities conference, I expressed my concern about the use of divisive language in our political discourse, and that was a classic example of the divisive discourse that is now part and parcel of what Malcolm Offord says to this Parliament every week. Malcolm Offord and his colleagues need to think long and hard about the way in which they raise these issues and how they spread division within our country.
For my part, there would be many positive advantages to Scotland being a member of the European Union. Membership would offer our citizens freedom of movement—the ability to move into other destinations in Europe, free of all the bureaucracy and obstacles of today, to pursue their interests, academic development and employment opportunities—and it would allow us to benefit from the contribution that is made by people of other nationalities.
Anyone looking at Scotland today can only come to the conclusion that Scotland has benefited from being an open, outward-looking society, and I am determined to ensure that that always remains the case.
I implore the First Minister to deal with the real issue and help working Scots and young Scots to get the best possible start in life. There is a golden opportunity coming up for the First Minister to rectify this mess: the upcoming budget can give a lifeline to young people in Scotland by incentivising employers in Scotland to hire them. The Reform Party Scotland has a tonne of ideas on how to get young Scots back to work, because we care about them. Will the First Minister meet me to discuss those ideas?
I have explained the position that my Government is going to take—we are not going to seek collaboration with the Reform group in the Scottish Parliament. That is a political decision that I have made because I will not associate my party and Government with the divisive ideas that are put forward by Malcolm Offord and Reform. I appreciate that that position will not be universally popular among Reform members, but I have a duty to the people whom I represent and to Scotland, to make sure that I do everything that I can to maintain Scotland’s position as a welcoming, inclusive country, and part of that means not engaging with Reform UK.
NHS Grampian
I will start by associating myself with the remarks that have been made today on the disturbing revelations about the NHS Grampian situation. There will, naturally, be a lot of anxiety from those in the NHS Grampian region who are seeing today’s news coverage and potentially thinking twice about attending hospitals for planned or unscheduled care. Many of the issues that we are dealing with take long-term work but, in the short term, what will the Government do to ensure that those patients can access safe healthcare in which they can have confidence?
The Government will build on the steps that we have already taken to change the leadership of NHS Grampian and ensure that the type of reassurance that members of the public require can be provided. Those steps include: the appointment of an experienced national health service professional as the chair of the board; the taking forward and implementation of the Healthcare Improvement Scotland report that the NHS Grampian chief executive commissioned; and ensuring that the NHS Grampian medical leadership is able to address the substantive issues that were raised this morning by the contribution of Dr Habib. In addition, one of our deputy chief medical officers has been appointed as a new medical director in NHS Grampian to ensure that the quality of leadership is in place to address these very issues.
I acknowledge and understand the unease that Gillian Mackay recounts to Parliament, which I have heard from my parliamentary colleagues who represent communities in the north-east of Scotland, including Aberdeen and Moray. However, in the annual review of NHS Grampian last Friday, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care engaged extensively with professional healthcare staff who are routinely and daily delivering healthcare services in NHS Grampian. Those professionals are committed to ensuring that that level of care is delivered. I hope that the Government’s actions, as well as the determination of healthcare professionals to deliver the clinical care that is required, address the legitimate points that Gillian Mackay raises with me this afternoon.
I think that we can all agree that patients coming to harm in our NHS is unacceptable. I commit the Scottish Greens to working with patients and across party lines to ensure that justice is done for all those affected.
Last weekend, more than 6,000 people from Scottish communities that are threatened by hyperscale data centres took to the streets of Edinburgh to protest against those energy-sucking artificial intelligence giants. The determination date for the first of those data centres, in Larbert, has now lapsed; the developer has refused an extension and the decision could be left to the Scottish Government. The community there faces continuing uncertainty over the proposed hyperscale centre. Worryingly, emails that were sent to my office suggest that the Scottish Government is not keen to meet campaigners. Will the First Minister help to ease some of that uncertainty by confirming when his Government will make its planning guidance for data centres public?
First, I recognise the level of public concern about those issues, and I take seriously the points that the people who demonstrated in Edinburgh on Saturday raised.
Secondly, in response to a question from Gillian Mackay’s colleague Laura Moodie on Tuesday, I made clear my determination to listen to the points that those who are concerned have raised. All that information weighs heavily in the formulation of the advice and the planning guidance that the Government makes available. I expect that guidance to be available before the Christmas recess, and I expect that it will be published to Parliament in the normal fashion.
I appreciate that the Government has committed to publishing the guidance by the end of this year, but to allow Parliament to scrutinise it before Christmas, it would have to be published no later than the start of the last week of term, on 15 December. Will there be a statement from ministers to Parliament before Christmas?
That is my expectation, yes.
The Greens are proud to stand with the workers at Rockstar North, who did the hard work behind “Grand Theft Auto VI”, as they stand up against bad working practices and try to unionise their workforce. Last night, the Scottish National Party angered anti-AI campaigners by posting AI-generated GTA memes on its social media, despite huge concerns about the impact of AI and AI data centres on artists, workers and the environment. Does the First Minister understand why people are concerned about his Government’s approach to AI and the big companies behind it?
First, I do not want to offend anyone with anything that we get up to, and I am sorry if we did—that was not my intention. Secondly, I understand the concerns about AI. Indeed, I share those concerns, because we are all working our way through significant industrial changes and challenges, which are happening before our eyes. I am acutely alive to that unease.
Equally, sometimes, in our healthcare services, when it is applied to routine healthcare treatments and assessments, AI is advancing the ability to identify the risk of cancer to which members of the public are exposed. We must consider the advantages of AI, which might improve clinical practice and help in other areas, too.
However, we must be alert to the risks, and that is what the Government will consider as part of the issues around AI data centres, because risks will come with their development. Those issues will be fully explored in the guidance that we set out. In broader and wider policy, substantial issues will have to be addressed and considered, and the Government will do exactly that.
Russell Findlay has five minutes for questions and answers.
Aberdeen Royal Infirmary
Countless patients suffered avoidable deaths at Aberdeen royal infirmary. If John Swinney required surgery there tomorrow, would he have any concerns? (S7F-00079)
I would not have concerns, because our clinical professionals are undertaking good work in the national health service across the country. We should have confidence in them to undertake their roles, which carry significant responsibility. I encourage people to be confident in the delivery of NHS services in Scotland, and specifically in NHS Grampian.
That did not answer my question. Patients and their families across north-east Scotland are deeply concerned. Aberdeen royal infirmary whistleblowers have been raising the alarm about avoidable patient deaths since at least 2014. Why were they ignored by John Swinney’s Government?
On a number of occasions, over a number of years, where concerns have been expressed they have been pursued by NHS Grampian and a range of external bodies. I appreciate and acknowledge the depth of concern about the situation in NHS Grampian.
What I said to Parliament last week and what the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care set out to Parliament on Tuesday are mechanisms designed to put in place the steps that are necessary to ensure that patient confidence can be at its highest level. I assure Parliament that the individuals that we have put in place have an obligation to ensure that it is the case. The Government will give everything that we need to give to ensure that confidence can be assured.
Those whistleblowers were ignored not only by his Government: First Minister John Swinney was warned—personally and in writing—not only once or twice but at least three times, and did nothing. Why is that?
Where issues of clinical practice are raised with ministers, the appropriate area of the Government takes up those issues with the relevant bodies and gives the relevant advice to the individuals who have raised the concerns.
On wider questions about the performance of NHS Grampian, the Government has intervened, as I recounted to Parliament last week, on different occasions during the past few years, in particular during the spring of 2025, when we escalated the supervision of NHS Grampian and put in place additional measures to ensure that improvement in its performance was rigorously pursued. That led to the establishment of the Healthcare Improvement Scotland review and its report, which I addressed in my answers to questions in Parliament last week.
As a consequence of all of that, the performance of NHS Grampian and the legitimate issues about patient safety that Russell Findlay raises can be pursued through the changes that we required to be made in the leadership of NHS Grampian. Those steps are necessary to ensure that the issues with performance and legitimate concerns are properly addressed.
This is what John Swinney’s Scotland looks like: patients have died, families were lied to, whistleblowers were destroyed and failure was rewarded. Highly paid NHS Grampian bosses were not held to account; they were protected and promoted. Why does he think that that perverse culture is acceptable?
I do not, in any way shape or form, think that that type of culture is acceptable. In my answers to Michael Marra last week, I made clear my determination for the culture of leadership in our public services to be one that addresses areas of failure, inadequate performance and, in the NHS specifically, issues that involve patient risk. There has to be a culture of openness to ensure that that is the case. That is the culture that I expect to be in place, and that is the culture that the health secretary and I will insist on in our dialogue with the national health service.
John Swinney’s answer is completely detached from reality. Senior whistleblowers have exposed a deep-rooted culture of dishonesty, denial, arrogance, incompetence and cover-ups on an industrial scale. That rotten culture has been imposed by this rotten Scottish National Party Government. It contaminates Scotland’s public bodies. How can anyone believe that John Swinney will fix the problem when he is responsible for creating it?
I can only set out to Parliament my commitment to the approach that I am determined to take to ensure that our public services are open with the public and address performance issues so that we can confront them.
If the Government had not, for example, intervened in NHS Grampian to ensure that there was supervision of its performance, Mr Findlay might have a point. The Government acted in relation to last week’s report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland, the independent inspectors who carry out those reviews to satisfy the Government whether issues need to be addressed, and we have required leadership changes to be made in NHS Grampian. Mr Findlay might have a point if the Government had not taken that action.
I hope that the steps that we have taken, first by intervening in NHS Grampian and then by acting on the conclusions of the report from Healthcare Improvement Scotland, will give people confidence that the Government will act where there is poor performance and that individuals will be required to act to address that performance.
Alex Cole-Hamilton now has five minutes for questions and answers.
(General Practice Surgeries (Information Technology Systems)
Last week, I warned about the crisis in our accident and emergency departments. This week, we have learned that NHS Grampian is in the kind of turmoil that is, sadly, measured out in human lives. The First Minister owes it to the families of everyone who has been lost to instruct an inquiry into what was known, and by whom in his Government.
Today, I warn members about a fresh scandal in our general practices. Right now, fewer appointments are available to patients because of a faulty computer system called Vision, which is being forced on every GP surgery in Scotland, despite our largest health board warning that the system is causing significant disruption.
Does the First Minister think that the roll-out of Vision is going well?
I addressed the issues with the information technology system for GPs with Mr Harley in Parliament on Tuesday. Those issues arise from the fact that the existing system is coming to the end of its life and that, because of changes in the marketplace, the Vision IT system is the only one available on the market.
That system is being provided and rolled out to GP practices. We want to ensure that any disruption to members of the public during the roll-out of services is avoided and that will be the approach that is taken during the roll-out of that system.
That is a nightmare for GPs. It is not just another IT scandal; it is also a human one. Right now, doctors at one surgery in Bishopbriggs can see only half the number of patients that they used to and one practice in Kirkcaldy sent text messages to patients to say that it could offer emergency appointments only. In Clarkston, patients could not book an appointment, order a prescription or get a fit note and, in NHS Forth Valley, an answer to a freedom of information request showed that the Vision system can silently and autonomously change the dose of a common drug to only a fifth of what patients should be getting.
Given all those issues, why is the First Minister still forcing our GPs to use a system that is riddled with bugs?
As I explained in my earlier answer, the current system is coming to the end of its life and the Vision IT system is the only one that is available to provide a continuation of administrative services.
Public Services Delivery Scotland is working closely with the GP community to support the roll-out and implementation of the Vision system to ensure that it meets the needs of general practice.
That system was bungled from the start. The Scottish Government has been working on it for seven years, but it is garbage. We have been inundated with messages. One GP told us that he will not even work in a practice that has been moved on to Vision because it is so bad. Practice staff say that admin is taking twice as long because the system keeps freezing and crashing. The First Minister says that that is inevitable and that we have to move on to the Vision system, but Wales has completely pulled the plug on its roll-out of Vision. As if GPs in Scotland did not have enough on their plates, the Government has ignored their warnings and ploughed on regardless. Why is that?
The reasons are contained in the answers that I have already given to Mr Cole-Hamilton. A new system had to be put in place. Through the work of Public Services Delivery Scotland, we are supporting GP practices to address the issues and to ensure that continuity of care is delivered in communities, and that will remain the focus of the Government’s activities.
I am sorry, but I am just not having this. The First Minister has given me the same answer—that we had to move over to a new system—over and over again. Wales was in exactly the same position, but it abandoned the roll-out of Vision entirely. With many more surgeries still to switch over, the doctors’ trade union has told GPs to start lodging formal disputes.
The SNP seems to be incapable of delivering information technology projects. From the NHS app to the ScotRail app and from farm payments to police computers, it has a long record of doomed IT roll-outs. Will the First Minister guarantee that no more surgeries will switch over to the new system until all the problems have been ironed out?
The issues are being addressed through the engagement of Public Services Delivery Scotland to ensure that GP practices are supported with the roll-out of the system. The Government looks closely at the roll-out in all parts of the country to monitor performance and to satisfy itself with regard to the steps that are being taken. That will remain the case as the roll-out continues to progress around the country.
That concludes questions to the First Minister from party leaders. We will suspend the meeting for a minute to enable a changeover of members on the front benches.
14:36
Meeting suspended.
14:37
On resuming—