Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]

Meeting date: Wednesday, November 18, 2026


Contents


Crime and Antisocial Behaviour (E-bikes and E-scooters)

09:03

The Convener

Our next item of business is an evidence session for our inquiry into crime and antisocial behaviour associated with e-bikes and e-scooters. We will hear evidence from Assistant Chief Constable Alan Waddell, who is responsible for operational support at Police Scotland; Chief Superintendent Scott McCarren, who is the head of road policing; and Will Linden, who is the deputy head of the Scottish Violence Reduction Unit. Good morning to them, and welcome to the meeting. We are tight for time as we have a packed agenda, so I will launch straight in.

As this is our first public evidence-taking session on the issue of antisocial behaviour related to e-scooters and illegal e-bikes, I am keen to set the scene. For a start, we have had NHS Scotland recording 446 e-bike and e-scooter accidents in just eight weeks; there has been viral footage of someone dressed from head to toe in black, riding an e-scooter at up to 40 mph on the M8 over the Kingston bridge; in May, a 94-year-old grandmother from Fife spent three months in hospital after being hit by a Sur-Ron bike; evidence from Police Scotland today details a 15-year-old illegal e-bike rider travelling on the wrong side of the road and colliding with a car; and, compared with last year’s data, we have seen a 157 per cent increase in crimes and offences relating to e-scooters and e-bikes.

My first question, therefore, which is directed to the assistant chief constable, is, can you understand why I, and thousands of people in the east end of Glasgow, talk about this issue being an epidemic in our community? How do you think we have got to this place?

Assistant Chief Constable Alan Waddell (Police Scotland)

Thank you, convener. I absolutely understand the concerns that have been raised and I hope that, in our submission to the committee, we have conveyed that we recognise the strength of feeling that exists and our commitment to working with partners to address the issue.

As you have outlined, and as we have said clearly in our submission, harm prevention is our primary focus. Dangerous riding can cause serious injury to riders, other road users and pedestrians, and we also understand the impact on our communities of the persistent illegal use of e-bikes and e-scooters and the wearing of face masks. We have made it really clear that we do not have a full data set on this matter; we are working with partners to try to understand things, but, as we have made clear, the impact has not been fully recorded at this time.

In our evidence today, I want to reassure committee members that an active and co-ordinated police response is in place. I am here because I, along with my colleague Scott McCarren, have responsibility for road policing. We took responsibility for co-ordinating our response earlier this year, and we have put in place internal structures to ensure national oversight of the brilliant work that some of our colleagues are doing locally to try to address this issue.

We are also clear that existing powers enable action to be taken. For example, we have powers to remove illegal e-bikes and e-scooters from communities, and I think that the fact that 1,200 have been seized from the start of the year to the end of October demonstrates our commitment in that respect. However, such seizures are never going to be the whole solution, so we need to have conversations about prevention and the limiting of supply. We look forward to those.

This is a real challenge in our communities, but there is a focused police response in place. That said, any approach to resolving this issue will have to go beyond policing.

The Convener

Earlier this month, the Daily Record published photos and video footage showing officers in Glasgow being brazenly taunted and goaded by illegal e-bike riders performing wheelies just a metre or two away from their van. Is that part of a trend of people playing a game of cat and mouse with the police on these vehicles?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

We have seen those kinds of examples. They are not the whole picture—illegal e-bikes and e-scooters are used for a variety of reasons, and Will Linden might come on to talk about that—but we do know of such occasions.

The sense that I get—committee members might get this, too—is that there is a desire for a more proactive policing response in such circumstances. However, when it comes to pursuits, those using e-bikes and e-scooters in our communities are also quite vulnerable road users, so we have to be careful in the tactics that we employ; otherwise, they could result in serious harm to those road users, other road users or our officers. However, we are proactively looking at that issue and we are trying to support our officers in that space.

The Convener

I should say that you do not need to operate your microphone—we have people who will look after that for you. You have enough on your plate; you should not have to deal with microphones, too.

I will now hand over to my colleague Amanda Bland.

Amanda Bland (Central Scotland and Lothians West) (Ind)

I am interested in your comments about pursuits, and I agree with you about the vulnerability of all parties. You also said that you are proactively supporting officers. How do you do that during a chase? As you have quite rightly pointed out, that sort of thing is dangerous for everyone—the officers, the person on the bike and the public. What advice is being given, and what action is being taken?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I will shortly pass over to my colleague Scott McCarren to answer that question. We have proven policies, procedures and practices for assessing the threat, risk and harm that individual incidents pose, which influences the decision on whether a pursuit is appropriate in the circumstances. Depending on the level of threat, harm and risk posed, a pursuit may well be appropriate and we will do that, but there will be other occasions when it is not appropriate, in which case we will make other plans to try to disrupt the behaviour.

The focus must be on our community policing teams, which understand where the behaviour is happening on a repeated basis. Those teams will be able to generate the intelligence and understanding from the community as to who is responsible, which allows for tailored and focused activity to try to disrupt the behaviour—sometimes as it happens and sometimes at a later date when that is safer, more proportionate and better for all involved. The national structures that are in place ensure that we inform all our local policing divisions and officers of the best, consistent guidance so that we support them in that space. However, this is undoubtedly a challenging environment for officers.

Chief Superintendent Scott McCarren (Police Scotland)

As the ACC outlined, the solution to this issue is not having our officers engage in pursuits on a nightly basis, because that would be inherently dangerous to them and to the public. We consider even fully trained motorcycle users to be vulnerable road users because of the disproportionate number of them who are killed and seriously injured. Those are people who are fully trained, on roadworthy bikes and have protective clothing, whereas most of the people who are engaged in antisocial behaviour will have none of those things, so there will be significant risk to them if we start to engage regularly in pursuits. In some ways more important is the significant risk to members of the public walking along a footpath or a road, because the people who are being pursued will not be trained to ride. Therefore, we need to be very careful.

We have a monthly group that looks at pursuit tactics, and we put out guidance to advise officers about those. As the ACC said, it is about proportionality and the level of threat, risk and harm posed There have been occasions on which we have used such tactics because the threat that was posed by the rider’s behaviour merited it, but there have been other occasions on which those tactics were not merited. We must be able to justify our actions.

Amanda Bland

You said that 1,200 bikes have been seized, and you will gather intelligence as you bring those bikes in. I open up my question to all the witnesses. Will you explain to the committee which crimes relate to the bikes that have been seized, such as drug dealing, theft and organised crime? Will you talk us through the general picture of how e-bikes and e-scooters are being used in crime, or whether we are looking more at general use of them for fun?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

We do not have that data set available, although we are trying to develop more informed data on the issue. However, your point is absolutely on the money: there will be a variety of different illegal uses of e-bikes and e-scooters.

Why do you not have that data?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

It is just that our recording systems do not lend themselves to having it, but we are working to address that. What we can tell you from our professional judgment—

Is it not odd to not have that data?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

It is not unusual in these circumstances. It is something that every police force across the United Kingdom and—I would hazard a guess—across Europe is wrestling with. However, your judgment that there will be a variety of reasons behind the use of e-bikes and e-scooters is exactly what we see from our experience. There will be younger children and people who enjoy the use of e-bikes because they go fast and are fun—social media is a driver of such use—but there will also be other people who may well use e-bikes or e-scooters to facilitate illegal activity.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

I will expand on the point about data capture. We have had the same issue in other areas—I am thinking back to a while ago, when we were trying to understand mental health demand and other issues. At the moment, an analyst will do keyword searches and pick out incidents and crimes that are linked to e-bikes and e-scooters, which gives us a picture of the trend. However, we are working with our colleagues who deal with stats on our level of demand to better understand the data. We are upgrading our systems so that we can have a tick box that would allow the control room to record where an e-bike or e-scooter is involved in an incident. The crime management system would then use a function to articulate that, taking away the need for a keyword search and that kind of analysis.

With those data search difficulties in mind, are you able to effectively share information across the UK—you also mentioned Europe—to see cross-border patterns?

09:15

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Yes, that is what we have here. Our submission gives you a pattern of crimes and incidents, and you can see the increase. That is management information that gives you an idea of the significant increase, which I am sure reflects what you are hearing from your communities. Our submission shows you that there has been a significant increase in recorded incidents relating to e-bikes and e-scooters and a significant increase in crime in that regard. We cannot say that that is the full picture. There might be slight underreporting because of the methods that we are using to extract the data, but that data will be enhanced through further work.

You can see a similar thing in the national health service reporting that was referred to, where a survey was used. I assume that NHS systems are the same in that they do not allow a box to be ticked to report the use of an e-bike or e-scooter when someone comes in. As we go forward, we want to work on that as a collective so that we capture the data in a better, more accurate way.

Convener, my next question links to supply chains, but I am happy to leave it if you need to move on.

That is great. I appreciate your courtesy to other members, Ms Bland. I think that Pauline McNeill wants to zero in on e-bikes, but first Mr Kerr has questions on enforcement measures.

For clarity on the legal status of e-bikes and e-scooters, under the Road Traffic Act 1988, e-bikes are legal, provided that they travel at less than 15.5 mph. Is that correct?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Yes.

E-scooters are not mentioned—

Chief Superintendent McCarren

It is illegal to use them on public—

Are they completely illegal?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

You can use e-scooters on private property, but their use on public property is entirely illegal.

Therefore, the scooters that we see whizzing along pavements and roads are all illegal.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Yes.

In that case, what is the standing instruction to officers when they see—as we all do—all those scooters, given that they are available for 120 quid or so from Amazon?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

The standing instruction is that, if we have the opportunity, we will engage and look to seize the scooter. Of course, the officers you are talking about are the same officers who are involved in community policing and response policing—

And there are not many of them—

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

—and they are dealing with a whole variety of competing demands. Some of that is a capacity challenge, and there is no getting away from that.

Stephen Kerr

Yes. The fact is that the thin blue line is incredibly stretched, and the front line of available police officers is diminished, which does not help. To underline the point, I note that all e-scooters are illegal unless they are being used on private property.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Correct.

What is the protocol if someone is observed conducting themselves in a dangerous fashion? If they are moving at 15.5 mph—probably faster in some cases—what can an officer do?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

You can see that, compared with last year, the number of e-bike and e-scooter seizures is up significantly.

Yes, so how does that happen?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

We use a number of tactics, some of which we might not want to speak about in a public forum, but we would be more than happy to talk about those in a private session, if that would be helpful. We could then go into far more detail.

Yes, that would be helpful. You are saying that you have strategies.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Yes, we have strategies, which is why we have seized so many. However, it comes back to community policing, and that is what underpins our policing response now, because a wider partnership response is required. I am sure that we will talk about the availability of e-bikes and e-scooters, which is a significant issue, but when it comes to the police response, we have a collective response between community policing and more specialist officers. For example, our recent use of drones has aided us to have an impact on the issue.

How common is the use of drones? This week, I saw that fabulous video from London.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

It is becoming more common. We now have the advantage of having a national group to look at the issue. It has been doing outstanding work for a significant time for local policing divisions, including fantastic engagement and enforcement work as well as carrying out a lot of prevention measures. We have a monthly group that my colleague Andy Barclay chairs, and we have representation from every local policing division dialling into that. We are sharing best practice; for example, a division might talk about the benefit of using drones or a particular tactic and that will be shared across all the divisions. We have seen some excellent work in Aberdeen, Fife, Lanarkshire and right across the country, and there have been some great successes.

Does that apply to other forces across the UK? I guess that everyone will be trying different things and having success with some.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

I attend a quarterly meeting of heads of roads policing from forces across the UK. We discuss our top priorities, and every force talks about e-bikes and e-scooters, so the issue is not unique to Scotland, and, in some areas, it is worse than it is here.

That is interesting. So, across the entirety of the UK, e-bikes and e-scooters are a number 1 or number 2 issue?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Yes.

Stephen Kerr

What can be done about conversion kits, which convert bicycles to e-bikes and can be bought online? That is clearly a gap in legislation. If something can be sold that will make something that is legal into something that is illegal, such as an e-bike, there is clearly a gap somewhere.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

That comes back to the initial point about availability. You can go into any major retailer and buy e-bikes and e-scooters, because they are—

Even though they are illegal?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Well, they are to be used on private property.

Do you think that people understand that e-scooters are illegal?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Can I come in?

Can I ask that one question and then come back to you on the other issue?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I am happy to answer your current question as well. I think that there is a partial understanding about legal situation. I do not think that it is fully understood. We have done significant communication work, through our local policing divisions with community safety partnerships and community planning partnerships, but there is still a bit of a gap in knowledge.

We are about to run a Christmas campaign to make people aware of the hazards of buying them for gifts. I think that there is still work to be done—

So, are you saying that parents do not understand that, if they buy an e-scooter for one of their children this Christmas, and on Christmas morning they take it on to the street in front of their house, they are breaking the law?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

That is correct.

Your point about conversion kits touches on a point that I really wanted to discuss. We cannot enforce our way out of this, and it is a significant challenge. I hope that the issues lead us to a conversation around the availability of e-scooters and e-bikes that are, in effect, illegal to use on the road. There has to be a conversation about whether we can limit or ban the sale of those, or, if there is no appetite for doing that, about the regulatory framework that is needed to accompany those sales. What accountability should be placed on companies that sell those products? What accountability will be placed on the individuals who buy them? What does that mean for safety, equipment, guidance and so on? Those are the natural next steps—

Those are the gaps that need to be filled.

We will come on to legislative reform and how we can resolve this issue. I would like to bring in Pauline McNeill, one of my colleagues from Glasgow, who is keen to ask more questions on touring bikes.

Pauline McNeill (Glasgow) (Lab)

Good morning. First, I thank Police Scotland for the work that you are doing, which I think is bold. I had the chance to go out with the team in Glasgow and see the seizure of an illegal e-bike, and I learned quite a lot from that.

As Stephen Kerr says, one issue is around the sale of bikes, whether they are Sur-Ron bikes or e-bikes that are meant for off-road use. There may also be a bit of ignorance around the modifying of bikes. It seems to me, as a layperson, that most of the e-bikes that I see have been modified. Is there any data on how many of the e-bikes that you have seized so far have been modified and how many have not?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

All the ones that we have seized are illegal. Either they were illegal when they were bought, such as the bike that you saw being seized, or they were originally a legal, electrically assisted pedal cycle that was converted so that it became illegal. I do not have any statistics to hand on those that started off as legal and were changed to illegal.

There will, no doubt, be people watching this meeting who will be keen for us to point out that electrically assisted pedal cycles, if they are under the 15.5mph limit and are pedalled, are entirely legal, and a lot of people use those bikes for the right reasons. It is worth pointing that out. In effect, if you see someone out on a bike and they are not pedalling—unless they are going downhill—it is highly likely that that bike is illegal, because it has to be pedalled for it to be counted as legal: it cannot have no pedals, and it should not continue to move if they have their foot off the pedal.

Pauline McNeill

I learned that that is the difference when I was out and about with the police. Sur-Ron bikes seem to be one of the big issues.

Allan Waddell, as you said, we cannot just use enforcement—there has to be some other way to stop this coming down the track. The issue of sales is a reserved matter, but is it is Police Scotland’s view that having either restrictions on the buying of Sur-Ron bikes or warnings about the sale of Sur-Ron bikes should be pursued?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

There needs to be a move towards being really clear about the position. Either we place a limit on the sale of those products that end up being used illegally on the roads, or, if there is not an appetite for that, we ensure that we are really clear about the regulatory framework that accompanies them, which feels like the next natural step.

One of the things that we are looking to do, in conjunction with partners in health, criminal justice, Transport Scotland and the Violence Reduction Unit, is to establish a forum that brings together the Scottish perspective on the issue. I hope that that can be used to influence colleagues and the Government down south.

In studying for this session, I picked up on the fact that some companies are marketing e-scooters to children as young as three. Have you seen that?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Yes, e-scooters are attractive to children. They see them on social media—perhaps not when they are as young as three—and I can understand why there is an appetite for them. Will Linden might want to touch on that issue.

Mr Linden, not just because you have a great surname, do you want to add to that?

Will Linden (Scottish Violence Reduction Unit)

There are massive problems with e-bike legislation, given the attractiveness of e-bikes to kids. We are moving into the Christmas period, and we will see a spike in their use again. They are attractive partly because of their availability, partly because of need and partly because they are a free way for a young person to indulge in thrill-seeking behaviour—and well-meaning parents want to get their kids what they want for Christmas.

It is difficult to change legislation: it takes time, especially if it involves reserved matters. However, as has been mentioned, it is possible to go to websites and buy the types of bikes that are illegal to use on the streets, without seeing any warning or notice aside from a wee line that says that the bike is only suitable for use off-road. That is not good enough. If you buy a knife or alcohol, you will see that they come with warnings and information.

What we are doing is enabling parents to buy their kids stuff that is helping them to break the law. We first need to think carefully about how we educate parents in relation to that one aspect. There are different aspects to this activity, from the thrill-seeking young kids riding bikes with face masks on who are just out having fun to the people using the bikes for criminality. We need to think about the first thing that we need to tackle, which I think is the safety element: the safety of the riders and the safety of the public in general. After that, we can think about what comes next.

There is a lot to say about the matter, but the issue of thrill-seeking young people is a specific issue to consider.

Ms McNeill, do you have further questions for the witnesses on this issue?

Not on this issue. I have other questions, but I can come back in later.

That is fine. Ben Macpherson, who represents Leith, has some questions.

Ben Macpherson (Edinburgh North Eastern and Leith) (SNP)

First, I acknowledge that this is a difficult area, and we appreciate your time and your efforts so far on it. Today’s update on the action that has been taken and other recent updates on seizures using existing powers are most welcome, and we appreciate that harm prevention needs to be at the heart of everything that you are doing.

What I receive most correspondence about as a constituency MSP, and have done for some time—indeed, Will Linden and I met two years ago to discuss this matter when it was an emerging trend in our communities rather than the established situation that it has, sadly, since become—is the fact that a very small minority of young people ride these vehicles irresponsibly and often undertake serious criminality when they are doing that. What people say to me is, “Why can’t the police do more?”

I am reminded of operation soteria, an initiative to combat motorcycle theft that took place in the years after I was elected in 2016 and involved the use of new technology such as SmartWater as well as helicopters—I appreciate that now it would be drones—which allowed the police to follow people who went off road or used pedestrian pathways and so on. What lessons have been learned from that approach?

The public want to see not just seizure, but action on the streets to stop this activity, while appreciating that harm reduction needs to be at the heart of what is done. The rule of law is a perception. People are seeing such things happening in their communities and thinking, “Why can’t the police do more?” So, what more can we do and how can we help you?

09:30

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Your point is well made and it has got me thinking about whether we need to do more on communications. We removed 1,200 e-bikes and e-scooters between the start of the year and the end of October, and we have added about another 150 bikes to that total since that date. That is the action that you are talking about. We are taking action and we are on the front foot, but that has somehow not landed; your point about perception is entirely correct and we need to think about how we are updating communities so that they are confident that we are responding.

Scott McCarren talked about the forum that we chair nationally that includes all our local policing divisions, which is exactly what you have asked for. We discuss innovative practice and results, and we ensure that best practice is shared across the country and learned from. We tried to capture some of the initiatives in our written submission to the committee. Scott, is there anything else that you want to highlight?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

I know that the committee is aware that we ran operation overlap in October to increase seizures and, more importantly, to increase awareness of the issue. We had a lot of media coverage. My friend Andy Barclay did a lot of pieces to camera and we put out almost daily—

Ben Macpherson

I am sorry to interrupt you, but people are getting the message that Police Scotland is taking effective and robust action through seizures. That has been understood, especially in recent weeks and months, but what more can be done on the streets of our communities? Sometimes, bikes and scooters are driven around on some of the busiest streets of our capital city; I have seen people doing wheelies along Princes Street. I appreciate that pursuit comes with a load of risks, but people want to be assured that the law is catching up with those individuals, even if it is slow. What consequences are there for those riders, especially if they are young people? I appreciate that a whole load of risk analysis needs to be done; we do not want young people to fall off the bikes. It is bad for them and bad for the community that they are riding them so recklessly. Our committee inquiry aims to help to address the problem and to build an awareness that the issues are being followed up, action is being taken, and that the activity will not be allowed to continue.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

There is a danger that I will repeat myself, although I do not mean to. I go back to the importance of community policing and having established community teams who understand where repeat offending is taking place and who is involved, so that they can target them appropriately. You have touched on some of that; there are different groups of people. We do not want to criminalise children for the use of e-bikes; we think that there is space for education and diversion from harm.

Ben Macpherson

I appreciate that we do not want to criminalise children; nobody wants to do that. However, from my casework, I know that people on those vehicles can use them to sexually harass people, hit people with weapons, pursue people and scare them, or run drugs through communities—that is the hard end of how minors are using those items. That is problematic. We need more powers and actions to address that.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

It is absolutely problematic. What you have described is a tactic that criminals use. In those cases, the illegal use of e-bikes or e-scooters is a manifestation of how people go about their business. Rightly, that is where you would expect us to be targeting people for the underlying cause. If anyone is involved in organised criminality, drug dealing, or sexual harm, in the first instance, we should be all over that as a basic response and we should deal with the use of e-bikes as part of how they go about their business.

The Convener

Before I bring in Mr Macpherson, who will have further questions, I acknowledge that the committee is very aware of the pressures that Police Scotland is under and we fully recognise the pressures that you and your colleagues face. We have just been through a pre-budget scrutiny process and our report will be coming out this week.

Considering the proliferation of that particular phenomenon, do you feel that you have been under pressure to respond to it and have perhaps been a bit late to the party in relation to the challenges that communities have faced with the spike in activity?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I hope that we have not been late to the party. The reason that Scott McCarren and I are sitting here is that we have identified that it is a challenge across the country, and we want to take ownership of and leadership on the response. Those are the structures that we have in place and that is what has been shown across our communities. As both Scott and I touched on, we have good examples of local policing working in conjunction with national divisions to target the issue. However, we are in no way complacent. We understand and are alive to the scale of the challenge. Mr Macpherson spoke of the volume of letters that he receives; it is no different for us in that we receive a significant number of letters that show concerns about the issue. We are not complacent—we know that we need to do more.

Ben Macpherson

The committee and the wider Parliament have been interested in the issue of face coverings, which are worn by the very small minority of people who use those vehicles in order to engage in quite serious criminality and harm.

For understandable reasons, there is a very high bar for the use of section 60 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994: it must be activated by Police Scotland’s senior level for a specific area at a specific time. Some officers have said to me that we can only use it in certain circumstances. However, given that we are facing higher use of face coverings by those who want to engage in harm and criminality, do we not need to look at that again? Although there are all the human rights considerations, you need more help here, and we need to enable and empower you to tackle the issue, do we not?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I agree with the officers that you quoted, but I will caveat and qualify that a bit. Your description of section 60 is entirely correct—I was asked about it in the summer, but the focus at that stage was primarily around the consistent level of protest that we were seeing.

We have no specific power in Scotland in relation to face coverings. Section 60 is effective in dealing with challenging protests or perhaps football matches for which we have intelligence on what level of violence or carriage of weapons we might see. However, we do not have the same powers as the rest of the United Kingdom. In England and Wales, for example, section 60AA of the 1994 act speaks specifically to face coverings, and there is a slightly lower bar for how that legislation could be—

That section was introduced recently by primary legislation in Westminster, was it not?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I cannot quite remember when it was introduced, but England and Wales certainly have it.

I come at the issue from several lenses, one of which is operational effectiveness and whether we are equipping our officers to do the job that you and the public would like them to do. Currently, there are no powers in Scotland to remove face masks in the circumstances that you described. The fact that we are the police means that we still expect officers to engage and deal with people who act suspiciously or intimidatingly, but we have no specific power in that space, so I think that the time is right to have a debate about what such a power might or might not look like, while recognising that we need to be cognisant of human rights.

We want to inform that conversation. We also need to be clear that the fact that we can enact legislation does not necessarily mean that we will be able to enforce it, depending on the circumstances. For example, even though the legislation is in place, it might be challenging for two or three officers to deal with a large group wearing face masks, so we think that the time is right to have a conversation about and explore the issue.

We are really focused on our legitimacy as an organisation—policing legitimacy is important. Although we and the Police Federation, as well as other groups, have a voice in that regard, there are other interested parties, which is why the debate should be led at the behest of public and elected member opinion, and we could inform it. We are very open to having further conversations around the issue. Indeed, I should say that one of my colleagues has already had a conversation with the police division of the Scottish Government about it, so the Government has reached out.

The Convener

That is very helpful. I might come back to that point later in relation to reform and resolution, but one of the issues that you have correctly identified is that of prevention, and I know that Ms Chapman and Ms McNeill have some questions on that. I hand over to Ms Chapman.

Maggie Chapman (North East Scotland) (Green)

Good morning, and thank you for being here. As the convener said, I am interested in exploring and unpicking some of the prevention points. That is not to minimise the harm that is being done now, but we also want to prevent harm in the future.

I will go back to something that was said earlier around the data that we have. As was indicated, if illegal vehicles are being used in ways that breach traffic legislation, that is different to people just having fun on vehicles that are being used illegally, but are themselves not illegal. It is different again to antisocial behaviour, which includes intimidation and harassment, and it is different again to behaviour being used to facilitate other criminal activity. If we do not have the data on that, how do we understand where to focus our prevention efforts? Each of those strands of behaviour will have different prevention tactics.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

If someone is using an illegal e-bike or e-scooter to commit a theft or a robbery, we will have that recorded as a robbery or a theft and we can understand what method that person used. Local policing divisions will be acutely aware of what those vehicles are being used for and what can be done to prevent that. That is why we come back to the point that we made at the start, which is that community policing will underpin our response. Local divisions will have that data and understand the concerns in their area, but when we are presenting a national picture of figures, we use keyword searches and other methodologies to understand the best data to present to Government.

If that activity is happening in different places, how is it translating into prevention, rather than just the diagnosis of a problem?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Again, to prevent something, we need to understand what the issue is in the first place. We are repeating ourselves, but it comes down to a local policing division or area commander understanding the problems in their area. It is down to a subdivisional management team looking daily, as we all do, at the data on what is happening and what trends there are and asking how we best respond to that activity, whether that is through high-visibility patrols or, more importantly, partnership working with other groups. It is about how we have the best impact in each area. In our governance group, it is important for us to recognise that every division has different needs and issues, and it is about working together.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

We have a number of examples of prevention activity that are on the go just now. For example, as a parent, Scott McCarren received a letter that the Lanarkshire division distributed through all the schools.

However, I think that Ms Chapman is asking how we evaluate the effectiveness of our prevention activity, and we do not have that data at the moment, because the work is multifaceted. The ongoing prevention efforts are being made in a number of different ways and involve different groups. There is no silver bullet that will prevent this behaviour.

You have talked about partnership working as well. Some of the prevention issues are not policing issues—they are social work and broader societal issues.

Will Linden

This is quite a challenging area for prevention because of the multifaceted nature of the problem. If we are referring to young people’s behaviour, it is about education and supporting parents, as well as a campaign to make people aware.

There are also lessons to be taken from the past, particularly around young people’s behaviour. This is not the first time that this has happened, and we have moral panics every now and again about different things. We can even go back to the BMX bandits in the 1980s. The big difference between the BMXs and these vehicles is their power and the inherent danger of riding them, but there was the same moral outcry about gangs of kids in the streets riding their bikes on the pavements and terrorising neighbourhoods. To deal with that, the authorities built lots of BMX tracks and tried to force those young people away from the streets by providing services. It was not just about education; it was about providing an alternative.

What we have now is a slightly different thing. We have the same idea of thrill seeking, and you could build something to provide for that, but I will throw something else into the mix. We have talked about face masks and a little bit about this too: one of the biggest drivers of this behaviour, particularly around the thrill-seeking stuff, is content creation and social media.

It goes back to the policing tactics for some of what we have seen before. We talk about policing, responses, justice and consequences, but what we are seeing across different countries—and I have not done a detailed evaluation of this; I have just looked at it casually—is that different jurisdictions, some of which have much more robust policing, for want of a better phrase, of young people than we have in the UK and Scotland are experiencing the same trend. All of it is linked to content creation and the idea of that content being promoted on social media.

Therefore, if we want to tackle the problem, we need to find out what the drivers are. One is thrill-seeking, and, as I said, we can talk about the criminality aspect of that separately, but we want to establish what about that thrill-seeking is appealing. Are they doing it for the kicks or are they doing it for the clicks? We need to start thinking about it in different ways. We do not quite have a grasp of that yet.

09:45

Maggie Chapman

That was a helpful presentation. If we considered this to be a public health issue or a violence prevention issue, rather than focusing on whether the vehicles are illegal or whether they are breaking road traffic rules, we would take a very different approach. Do you see the beginnings of the development of the partnerships that are needed to tackle the issue, or coherent awareness of the issue across different public services, or have you not seen that yet?

Will Linden

I would not say we have seen that for e-bikes specifically, because it is a niche area. I am going to be honest; e-bikes are a big concern, but we are also considering wider antisocial behaviour, levels of violence and so on. Apart from the work to create a group to look at the response, prevention and what can be done in partnership, which is starting to kick off and was discussed by Alan Waddell and Scott McCarren, there is no consistent strategy across the country.

However, the work has to be linked into other things, such as a youth work strategy and an education strategy. We should stop looking at such things in silos. That is part of the problem. We can have a stand-alone group do the work, but we have to think about how that work connects to existing services and programmes so that all of the onus to deliver the work does not fall on schools. We say to schools “Why don’t you talk about drugs, alcohol, healthy eating, violence, vaping and now e-bikes? Oh, and by the way, can you teach English and maths, as well?” We need to think about the best way of doing this. Schools are important, and having strategies is important, but everything needs to be linked.

When the VRU talks about primary, secondary and tertiary prevention, where are the gaps? Where do you or other services need more resources?

Will Linden

More resources are needed across all areas of prevention, but if I was going to look at one area in particular, it would be secondary prevention. When young people and others are involved in high-risk behaviour, that brings a lot of media attention, which in turn helps to demonise young people and causes fear in communities. Demonisation and fear go hand in hand.

We therefore need to know how to tackle it by providing additional resources and support for young people to find alternative ways of biking or of meeting their need for thrill-seeking. That will help reduce the number of incidents, and if we start reducing the number of incidents we can concentrate on some of the other activity that relates to organised crime, drugs and violence rather than having a big number of young people and others involved in high-risk activity, which, under the letter of the law, is illegal.

Later in the meeting, I am keen that we talk about reform and resolution, but before I do that, I will bring in my colleague from Clydebank, Ms McNair.

My questions have been covered, but I am quite happy to come back in afterwards.

The Convener

That is very helpful and incredibly kind of you, Ms McNair. Now, we will move on to talk about legislative reform and resolution I will bring in other colleagues on this, too. Assistant Chief Constable Waddell, I was heartened by some of the language that you used in regard to section 60 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, which Ben Macpherson asked about. If I picked you up correctly, you said that conversations about that are now ongoing with the police division of the Scottish Government. When did those discussions start?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I would be lying if I gave you an exact date.

Would you be happy to write to us and give us an answer?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Yes, absolutely. I would be happy to confirm that.

The Convener

I appreciate that. That is very kind of you. Later, I will come on to what additional powers and resources you need.

On the issue of seizure, Chief Inspector Jonny Watters, who is the local head of policing in Shettleston and for whom I have a huge amount of respect, has told me—and you have alluded to this, I think, in your evidence—that when the police stop somebody on an e-scooter on Shettleston Road, there is quite a lengthy delay before a private contractor can come and take it away. Obviously, that ties up police time. How might we be able to speed that process up? I understand that there are some challenges when it comes to enforcement.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

It is an issue, and if the Parliament, or this committee, could do more about it, we would welcome it. Our service level agreement with the contractor says that it should be 30 minutes, but I believe, right enough, that Ms McNeill waited longer than that when she was out with colleagues. The average time is around 30 minutes, but it all adds to the capacity issue. If an officer seizes an e-bike or e-scooter, that is another 30 minutes in which they are not able to deal with other matters. It also comes with a cost, which the police are footing.

I know that the resale auction of e-bikes and e-scooters still happens in other parts of the UK, but am I right in thinking that it stopped here only in September?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

That is correct.

The Convener

There have been numerous cases of this activity, some of which have been in the media. How confident are you that there are checks and balances in place to ensure that individuals who have committed criminality, whether it be collisions or knocking down folk, and have had their e-bike or e-scooter seized are not back out, riding their e-scooter or e-bike, after they have hit somebody and been involved in a police incident?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

We have given instructions that the vehicles are now to be destroyed. They are seized under section 165A—

But what if they go and get a new one?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Well, if they get a new one, we do not know—

I guess that my question is this: where is the deterrent? If a young man in Fife, say, hits an elderly woman, what is the deterrent to ensure that he is not back out on an e-bike or e-scooter?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

If that happens, and the individual is identified at the time, they will be charged, and the e-bike will be taken off them. If identification happens later on, we might seize the bike as production, but if identification happens at the time, we will seize the bike under section 165A of the Road Traffic Act 1988. The individual will not get it back, and they will be reported to the procurator fiscal. In essence, though, they could go back out the next day and purchase another e-bike. As we have already said, e-bikes are widely available, and that brings us back to the initial question about availability and regulation and the fact that more needs to be done in that space.

The Convener

I am conscious that other folks want to come in, but I was very interested to see that, in operation armour in the north-east, individuals who had had their bikes seized and were arrested had been found with drugs on them. I have certainly heard anecdotally that, in Glasgow, these vehicles are essentially a form of Deliveroo for drugs. Are we seeing examples of those who are apprehended being found with drugs on them? Are the bikes being used to move drugs around communities?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

There are undoubtedly such examples, yes.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

Operation armour has highlighted such examples, as you have pointed out, and there is intelligence that the bikes are being used for that purpose.

The Convener

Before I bring in colleagues who have been trying to catch my eye, are there any powers and resources that you do not have but which would help ensure that, if I were to bring you before the committee next year, you could tell me that there had been a reduction in these incidents? What do you need in your toolkit that you do not currently have?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Capacity is one. I know that members have talked about this in relation to the budget bill, but a really strong and effective community policing resource is fundamental in targeting this activity.

I talked earlier about reducing the prevalence of these things on our roads, but we need help in that respect. We can enforce all we like, but if the supply is continuing to hit the streets, what we do is almost a fool’s errand.

I am not saying that we are looking for extra powers with regard to face masks, but there is a gap there, and a willingness to explore the issue is where we are at. We would certainly welcome further conversations in that respect, but we also want to hear other voices in that space.

The Convener

Okay. My understanding is that you were saying that you might need new powers, but we can go back and look at the Official Report on that.

I know that colleagues have been seeking to catch my eye, but I did promise Ms McNeill that I would bring her back in if she wanted to, and I will always look after a fellow Glasgow MSP.

Pauline McNeill

No bias there.

On the question of powers and what other parts of the UK are doing, I believe that Nottingham, and the UK Government, have been looking at on-the-spot fines for antisocial behaviour. This is where things get a little bit complicated, because you have these people riding on the roads, others riding on the pavement and so on. Would it be helpful if the police had the power to issue on-the-spot fines?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

There is a technical bit that I will ask Scott McCarren to cover, as it relates to the power in section 165A to recover an e-bike or e-scooter. If we do that within 24 hours, we will be able to seize it. We might know that a Ms Pauline McNeill, say, had been out riding, but we were unable to stop her at the time. If we can trace her within 24 hours, we can take the e-bike or e-scooter; if not, we have no further recourse, and that is where an antisocial behaviour approach is worth considering.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

If someone were involved in a serious crime, we would go to the procurator fiscal to get a warrant, go to their house and seize whatever we had to seize. We have engaged extensively with our officers on the front line about the section 165A procedure and we are satisfied that that procedure is sufficient for us to seize the vehicle. If the e-bike use is proved to be illegal, it is, in effect, treated as a motorcycle and the driver should have insurance and a driving licence, which they cannot get for that. We are satisfied that section 165A of the legislation gives us a power to seize it at that time.

One area that could be looked at, which has been discussed—the Cabinet Secretary for Justice mentioned it in his submission—is section 126 of the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004, which requires a warning to be given initially. Further dialogue could be had about getting rid of that warning, similarly to what has happened in England and Wales. If we got information at a later date that someone had been riding an illegal e-bike or e-scooter, perhaps that power would be more useful than the powers that we currently have. We think that that should be looked at.

Will Linden

I am not a big fan of fining people, because of the inherent problems with financial inequality and targeting of certain areas.

It is a big enough financial penalty to take the e-bikes away. More resources need to be given to support confiscating the bikes, rather than fining people. For an e-bike of the brand that was mentioned earlier, we are talking about a cost of more than £1,000 to replace it. That is more than an on-the-spot fine would be. Therefore, that is the more effective way to do it: even if they tried to replace the bikes, there would be more of a financial penalty than there would be from an on-the-spot fine.

I would be worried about the fines not getting paid and about what that would lead to. It would become a cycle.

Pauline McNeill

That is helpful.

Lastly, I have concerns about something that has been highlighted to the committee, which is the weight of some of these bikes, should there be an accident. I know of one case that happened to somebody in my team in Glasgow. An e-bike was involved and her leg was fractured. That situation is not uncommon. Can you comment on that? The sheer weight of the bikes is one reason why more work needs to be done to ensure that those who use them, even if it is legal for them to do so—

I ask witnesses to give a brief answer to that. We only have a couple of minutes left and I am keen to bring in Mr Kerr and Mr Macpherson.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

When anybody uses e-bikes such as those that you describe, there is a risk of serious harm if they are used inappropriately and involved in a collision. Absolutely, that is a conversation to have.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

It is similar to motorcycles. One point that I want to raise, in case it is missed, is that an NHS report has given us data that we did not have before. That report used a survey, so the data is not exact, but, of those who were surveyed, only 4.7 per cent said that they used e-bikes on private land. That gives you an idea of the prevalent ways in which e-bikes are being used after they are bought.

That is helpful—I am glad that you put that on the record.

We have about two minutes left. I know that Mr Kerr and Mr Macpherson will be keen to use that time and will be patient with each other. I bring in Mr Kerr first.

Stephen Kerr

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell, I agree with the convener that your earlier comments about face coverings were welcome. You somewhat threw me—and others who are listening—when you said that the police are not asking for additional powers. You have identified gaps in the law whereby officers do not have powers to take action, and then you said that. Can you be clear? Surely, the police would welcome those powers.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

We think that there is a gap and we need to work with the Government and other interested parties to make sure that any legislation is appropriate and fit for purpose.

Is that a yes, though?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Yes, we want to come to the table and have conversations about it.

I am sorry—that is very mealy mouthed. Either you want and need the powers or you do not. You cannot say that there is a gap and then say that. Just say that you want the powers. What is wrong with saying that?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I have not been mealy mouthed. I think that I have been clear—

I think that you have been, but that last answer was a politician’s answer.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

I must be in the right place, then.

You are talking to politicians. Can you be absolutely clear? The police identify a gap; the officers on the ground are saying that there is a gap; you need the powers.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

There is a gap. We need to inform the powers, but we need to make sure that the powers work.

Sure—but you need them.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

We need to make sure that they are also compliant with other legal considerations.

10:00

Stephen Kerr

But the point is that you need them.

My last—very quick—question is about operation armour, which involved three weeks of concentrated effort and a massive resource commitment. There were huge results and it was very successful, but it shows that what you needed to bring that about was a concentration of resources. You do not have front-line resources—the committee has gone through that issue to the point of exhaustion. What has been the consequence of operation armour in Aberdeen? Has the incidence of the use of these bikes and scooters gone back up or has the problem been dealt with?

Chief Superintendent McCarren

The data is not agile enough to give a definite answer to that.

You do not know.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

The community—

Chief Superintendent McCarren, if you want to look at that and then write to the committee about it, we would appreciate it. We are very tight on time today.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

I will do that. We do really—

I bring in Mr Macpherson to ask the final question.

Thank you, convener.

Do the police need more help from the Crown to tackle this issue?

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

There has not been an absence of help from the Crown. It is a key part of the criminal justice process and we work together in this space.

Chief Superintendent McCarren

We are engaging directly with the Crown about this.

So, it is alive to how problematic the issue is in our communities. For the record, I, too, hugely respect the Crown’s work.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Yes.

Ben Macpherson

Can we learn from the Metropolitan Police? Even this week, we saw footage of a prolific phone thief using an e-bike, being knocked off their bike and being charged. I am not saying that Police Scotland is not robust—it is appropriate that they are so—but can lessons be learned? The situation is worse down there, and we do not want to get to that point.

Assistant Chief Constable Waddell

Lessons can be learned across the United Kingdom and we are entirely in that space.

As a final comment, we are robust. People should not leave this forum thinking that, in any way, shape or form, we are not robust about dealing with this matter. That is why about 1,350 e-bikes have been removed so far. However, we continue to seek to learn.

For the record, we are grateful and appreciate that.

The Convener

On that point, this committee would have lots of questions about that. You can tell from the fact that it has been such an engaging session that there is more for us to get into.

It is appropriate to finish by recognising the work of all your colleagues, who do an incredibly difficult job. Any observers who look at our pre-budget scrutiny report, which will be published later this week, will see that there is a big focus on police officers and resources. This committee is acutely aware of that issue. My final point is to say an enormous thanks to the police service in Scotland, which has our enormous gratitude as it tries to tackle these difficult issues.

We thank the witnesses for their attendance. I suspend the meeting briefly to allow for a change of witnesses.

10:02

Meeting suspended.

10:07

On resuming—