Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Meeting of the Parliament [Last updated 17:24]

Meeting date: Wednesday, November 18, 2026


Contents


Rosebank Oil and Gas Field

The Presiding Officer (Kenneth Gibson)

The next item of business is a debate on motion S7M-02068, in the name of Mark Ruskell, on Rosebank and upholding the Paris climate agreement.

Members who wish to speak should press their request-to-speak button now. I call Mark Ruskell to speak to and move the motion. You have six minutes, please, Mr Ruskell.

15:03

Mark Ruskell (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green)

In 2015, the world came together to sign the Paris agreement at the 21st UN climate change conference of the parties—COP21. It was a moment of hope after decades of indecision and inaction. Hundreds of thousands of people gathered on streets around the globe, including here, in Edinburgh, demanding the breakthrough.

The United Kingdom pledged, alongside other nations, to keep the climate within safe limits and to strive for a world that is liveable, not just for us but for all generations to come. Keeping the world to well below 2C of temperature increase while keeping on track for 1.5°C is not an abstract calculation; it is about saving lives.

As Nicola Sturgeon said at COP26, in Glasgow:

“every fraction of a degree above that intensifies the catastrophic nature of what we face. If we allow it to happen, we do risk life on this planet becoming unrecognisable.

Every single leader … without exception … knows that. No-one can pretend otherwise.

And each and every country gathered round the negotiating table also knows the action that is needed to prevent it. So there is no excuse for failing to act.”

Nicola Sturgeon was right, and she is still right.

There have been so many warnings. Opening up new oil and gas fields, including Rosebank, would be completely incompatible with the Paris agreement goals. The International Energy Agency has repeatedly said that, in order to keep the 1.5°C global warming limit on track, there must be no new investment in oil and gas. Research shows that burning oil and gas in existing fields, never mind at Rosebank, would blow the 1.5°C global carbon budget by a long way. Nicola Sturgeon was right: there is no excuse for failing to act.

However, five years on from COP26, in Glasgow, all that I hear from political leaders across the UK is excuses for inaction. They say that the time is not right, that the lights would go out and that we need fossil fuels to fund renewables. Those myths are perpetuated by an oil and gas industry that is quite prepared to extract every last drop, throw its North Sea workers over the cliff edge and then move its capital somewhere else while blaming governments for daring to tax its profits.

Maggie Chapman (North East Scotland) (Green)

Energy workers in my region have repeatedly felt let down by failed promises to develop a plan to shift from oil and gas to renewables. The oil and gas industry clearly has no interest in securing long-term sustainable jobs for those workers.

Does Mark Ruskell agree that we need a coherent strategy for investment in renewables, which would leverage investment from the private sector alongside state support, to ensure that workers have the certainty that such a strategy would provide instead of having to rely on a mythical failed promise such as Rosebank?

Mark Ruskell

Maggie Chapman is absolutely right. Workers in the north-east have been continuously failed. Even at times in the past 10 years when we saw record profits, we saw record job losses. The time for a plan is long overdue, as is the time for this Government to come up with an energy strategy that shows how public and private investment can work together.

This year, we have seen the Government’s commitment to a green energy transition slip. Ministers have already met with one of the developers behind Rosebank four times to discuss how projects can be brought on stream. In the past month, cabinet members welcomed the approval of Jackdaw and signed off on a new gas-fired power station at Peterhead. Last week, the First Minister confirmed that his party opposes UK legislation that would ban new oil and gas exploration. That is reckless, especially given that it comes from the same party that welcomed the world to COP26, in Glasgow, only five years ago. This is disaster capitalism. It is a headlong rush to maximise profits in the face of energy insecurity. It gives not a thought to the impact on the generations that will come after us.

Last week, the secretary general of the United Nations said at COP31 that

“fossil fuel interests keep making a killing while killing our planet.”

Let us be clear about Rosebank. The field would produce six and a half times more climate pollution than Scotland’s annual emissions. The suggestion that Rosebank will improve the UK’s energy security is a fantasy. Ninety per cent of its reserves are oil and will be sold to the highest bidder in the international market.

Monica Lennon (Glasgow) (Lab)

Mark Ruskell will be aware of reports that around £200 million of profits could flow from Rosebank’s oil to the Delek Group and that the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign has written to the Prime Minister about its concerns, calling on the UK Government to carry out a comprehensive assessment of the risks that are linked with a decision on Rosebank. Mark Ruskell made the case about the climate risk, and Rosebank would be a climate disaster, but does he recognise that it is also a serious human rights issue?

Mark Ruskell

Yes—100 per cent. I applaud Monica Lennon’s leadership on that issue. It is hugely important for this Parliament, which has committed to a boycott, divestment and sanctions policy, that the Government follows through on that enormous commitment.

If most of the oil that is being burned is to be burned outside the UK, Rosebank must be assessed against the remaining global carbon budget for 1.5°C, not just the UK’s and Scotland’s domestic carbon budgets. That points to a major flaw in the Scottish National Party’s amendment, because the issue is not only about ensuring that we are compatible with domestic net zero targets set by climate legislation; it is about a broader failure to act in line with global advice. Given everything that we know and all the warnings and advice that we have received from scientists and independent bodies such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the IEA and the UK Climate Change Committee, the only climate-credible decision is to reject Rosebank.

There is also the cost. Far from reducing the burden on taxpayers, Rosebank would ramp it up. Researchers at Uplift have uncovered that, in effect, 80 per cent of its development costs would be paid for by generous tax reliefs. With the end of the windfall tax—wilfully cheered on by some members—Rosebank’s developers could get even more money in reliefs than they pay into the UK Treasury. While the profits of Equinor and Shell soared in the third quarter of this year, everyone else is facing skyrocketing energy bills. I know of no other sector of the economy that has been given such a forest of magic money trees. Ed Miliband was right when he said that Rosebank would be a

“Colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism”.

Approval would send a message from the North Sea that states around the world should double down on fossil fuel exploration and licensing. Bullied by Donald Trump, the world is at a dangerous point where the goal of not surpassing 1.5C degrees is barely alive. With no binding international agreements to manage the decline in fossil fuels in an orderly way, approving Rosebank could spark a free-for-all—a race to develop more oil and gas and a race towards climate breakdown.

Remember Nicola Sturgeon’s words:

“there is no excuse for failing to act.”

There is no credible excuse for MSPs not to vote for our motion at decision time.

I move,

That the Parliament agrees that new oil and gas exploration licences and the proposed Rosebank oil and gas field are incompatible with the UK’s commitments under the Paris Climate Agreement to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees, and opposes the development of the Rosebank oil and gas field.

15:11

The Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Energy (Stephen Gethins)

We have lodged a straightforward amendment, such that any new decisions on oil and gas must be made in accordance with the law, including any climate legislation. It was a failure to take that into account in the past that led to years of court action. I am sure that colleagues here can agree that we should, at least, not be repeating those mistakes of the past.

We will continue to rely on fossil fuels for years to come, so, given that domestic production has a lower carbon footprint than imports, that resource should be utilised.

All of that is within the context of reaching our net zero targets, as set out in law, by 2045. I want to be clear on that and on the importance of the amendment in my name, which I will shortly move, in reaffirming the Scottish Government’s commitment to Scotland’s climate legislation and to achieving net zero by 2045. Our statutory carbon budget framework requires sustained action to reduce emissions, and our climate change plan sets out more than 150 actions to deliver the first three carbon budgets up to 2040. I acknowledge the work that is being done on that by Gillian Martin. That commitment underpins how the Scottish Government approaches the debate.

Will the minister give way?

Stephen Gethins

I will make some progress first, if I may.

Much as I might not like it, decisions on oil and gas licensing and the consenting of individual offshore fields are reserved to the UK Government. I would much rather that they were made here, but, unfortunately, they are not decisions for this Government or Parliament at the moment. The majority of us obviously want to see that changed.

We believe that the benefits of Scotland’s energy wealth cannot be fully achieved within the current devolution settlement. It is vital that powers over Scotland’s energy are in Scotland’s hands. We will continue to make that point to the UK Government, asking it to transfer responsibility for energy powers to Scotland, as this democratically elected Parliament has overwhelmingly voted in favour of that.

We are also clear about the energy future that we want for Scotland and about the purpose that the remaining resources of the North Sea should serve in making the transition. I welcome the opportunity that Mark Ruskell’s motion provides to debate those questions today. They are important questions.

The Scottish Government is absolutely committed to tackling climate change. Climate change exists—we know it in the science. We need to keep repeating that.

Mark Ruskell

I ask the minister to reflect on how his amendment refers to legislation from this place. It relates to net zero targets, which are about domestic production and domestic emissions. However, some 90 per cent of what comes from Rosebank will be exported: it will be burned in other jurisdictions. That does not impact on the net zero targets that the minister is talking about.

Stephen Gethins

I hope that Mr Ruskell will forgive me, but I cannot pre-empt the decision on Rosebank. As I set out earlier regarding Jackdaw, which was the subject of a 92-page report, any decisions that we make must be within the law, and any decisions that the UK Government makes must be within the law. I would have thought that we would have taken that for granted. Indeed, we all take that very seriously.

The rest of this Official Report will be published progressively as soon as the text is available.