Skip to main content
Loading…
Chamber and committees

Finance and Public Administration Committee [Draft]

Meeting date: Wednesday, November 18, 2026


Contents


Scottish Fiscal Commission (Appointments)

The Convener

The next item of business is to take evidence on two nominations for appointment to the Scottish Fiscal Commission. The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government recently wrote to the committee nominating Melissa Davey and Professor Stephen Millard for appointment as commissioners at the Scottish Fiscal Commission.

Members have received copies of the nominees’ CVs and the person specifications for the roles. We will hear first from Melissa Davey, followed by Professor Millard.

I welcome Melissa Davey to the meeting. I remind you, Melissa, that the microphone will be operated by broadcasting, so you do not need to press the button.

We will move straight to questions. Just to kick things off, Ms Davey, can you tell us why you are the best person for this job?

Melissa Davey

I think that my background makes me very well suited for the role. I started my career as an economist, and I am an economist by training. I spent several years providing high-quality analysis and forecasting to the monetary policy committee of the Bank of England.

Later on, I specialised in communications. I ran the bank’s inflation report, and I was involved in that throughout periods of intense uncertainty—the financial crisis, the euro area crisis and then Brexit. One particular thing that we did during my time on the inflation report was to think about broadening our audience. We worked on our communications—not just communicating with a business audience or economists in the City but thinking about how to get our messages to the general public. I know that the Scottish Fiscal Commission is also focusing on that, following its OECD review.

Since I did my jobs on the economics side, I have been working as director of the independent evaluation office in the bank. I report directly to our court of directors, and I help its members in their role of keeping the performance of the bank under review. We do in-depth evaluations of different aspects of the bank’s policy. That experience of providing independent challenge to a large organisation is very relevant to the role of commissioner, and it has given me really good insights into governance. An important aspect of the role is that it is not just about the economics, the forecasts and the communications; it is also about running the commission. I think that, overall, I bring a good package of skills and experience for the role. Furthermore, I have a lifetime of commitment to public service.

Thank you for that comprehensive overview of your CV.

Do you see a difference in the role of commissioner, given that it has a Scottish context, while your experience has been with the Bank of England in the main?

Melissa Davey

Yes. There are lots of specific aspects of the Scottish economy, particularly the fiscal framework, on which I would get up to speed. I have started my revision already.

Although I worked in the UK central bank, I ran the bank’s agency network for a time. We have offices all around the country, in the regions and devolved nations. One of the great things about that job involved getting out and about around the country. I used to visit my colleagues in Scotland regularly. I would get out and meet businesses and talk to audiences, which helped me to get an understanding of the different challenges that are faced in different regions and devolved nations of the country. I bring that background.

Overall, although it is indeed a different role, lots of my skills are relevant to this role, and I would use them to the best of my ability to carry out the role in the SFC.

A couple of other members would like to ask questions.

Liam Kerr

Ms Davey, your role at the Bank of England involved independently evaluating the performance of what is a major public institution, providing challenge and making recommendations for improvements. If you were appointed to the Scottish Fiscal Commission, how would you approach challenging the Scottish Government if you thought that its economic expectations or spending assumptions were overly optimistic, particularly if those findings would be politically uncomfortable?

Melissa Davey

That was a necessary part of my job in my IEO role, and it would be a necessary part of my job if I was lucky enough to be appointed to the SFC. It is important to be clear on your remit and role. The SFC has a role in challenging the Government, when appropriate, and in being clear on the challenges with the fiscal position. It is important for independence to be clear in your remit, as I said, and to be clear in the judgments that you make and in the analysis that you undertake, because you must be able to explain where your judgments have come from when providing challenge. I take an analytical and technocratic perspective on the challenges that I see, and there is a need to be clear in that regard. It is important to have such roles.

In relation to communications, it is clear to me that the SFC’s role within the framework is to provide challenge to the Government. It is not a case of saying, “We think that you should do this,” but it should set out the challenges that the Government faces based on the nature of the data, the forecasts and the fiscal framework. It is important to take a clear, technocratic and analytical approach to that. It is not about saying what we think should happen; it is about explaining the implications of the data and the other factors that I mentioned.

I understand.

The SFC’s forecasts can have major implications for public spending and can often be highly technical. What more could the commission do to make its work understandable to the public, without sacrificing analytical rigour?

Melissa Davey

I have experience of that from my time at the Bank of England. It is important that your communications do not all face the same audience. We should think about how we can tailor our communications to different audiences.

Obviously, I have been reading a lot of the SFC’s material, which includes some very good, detailed analysis of its forecasts. It already produces a front page that draws out the main messages, and the insights that it has produced over the past year, following the OECD review, are really good in providing an explanation to a non-technical audience. More might be able to be done through the use of simple infographics and so on to engage with people.

One of the challenges when trying to explain things to a more general audience is finding the sweet spot between what people are interested in and what we think they need to know. People are probably not interested in the intricacies of some of the tax decisions that have to be made, but they are probably quite interested in our analysis of income tax or our view on what will happen to wage growth, for example. We need to think about what we can provide to draw people in, and then we might be able to explain to them something else that would be useful for them to know about the state of Scottish finances.

Angela Ross

That sounds good. I appreciate a front page with all the infographics and information.

You stated that one of your priorities would be developing a deeper understanding of Scotland’s fiscal framework. What aspects of the framework present the greatest fiscal risks?

Melissa Davey

The challenge of the fiscal framework is the need to have a view on not just the outlook for Scotland but the outlook for the UK and not just the Scottish Government’s decisions but decisions that are being taken in Westminster. I suspect that bringing all those things together means that there is more uncertainty about projections than you would have in a country that does not have that complex framework.

12:00

We saw that very recently in the tax reconciliation news that the budget will be lower because of forecast errors by the SFC and OBR going in different directions. There is more challenge in relation to uncertainty in the forecast because of that, which is obviously a feature of the work. It will take time for me to get up to speed on exactly how that works, but I have a lot of confidence that I will be able to do that, and I have spent the past eight years turning my hand to completely different topics every nine months and having to get up to speed very quickly on those.

I appreciate that. If it helps, as a new politician, I am doing the same thing.

Liam McArthur

Good afternoon. I am interested in your point about expanding audiences and the work that you have clearly been doing on that at the Bank of England. Is that simply about making the information that is produced more accessible generally to the public and anyone who might have an interest, or is it a case of targeting particular stakeholders whose engagement with the SFC has perhaps not been as regular as it might have been?

Melissa Davey

I think that it is about both of those, and it is something that I would like to explore with colleagues in the SFC, were I to be appointed. One of the things that I learned when I did my job running the regional agency network is that it is good to get out and talk to people. The agents will regularly do round-table meetings and presentations at different forums. During my time running the network, we broadened from a business audience to include people in the third sector, for example. Going out and presenting your information to a different audience and receiving a different sort of challenge helps you to develop your own thinking, but you also get a lot of good will from being seen to be out and about. That struck me when I did the agency job, because so many people would come to us and say, for example, “It’s really good that you’ve got these people out in Scotland, coming and talking to businesses, taking messages back to policy makers and then coming to tell us what you made of them and how that has affected your policy decisions.”

I am interested in exploring whether presenting to different audiences is something that the SFC could do more of. At the moment, it talks to tax specialists and so on, but there might be something to the idea of broadening that out with business audiences. However, I would have to explore that, were I to get the job.

Liam McArthur

I will not speak for the committee, but I have seen that in action with the Bank of England in visits that were made to Orkney over the years, and I know how well received those were and how beneficial it was for those who engaged with the process. I certainly support exploring that with the SFC, if possible.

Melissa Davey

Policy members always love a trip to Orkney, too.

Who wouldn’t?

The Convener

There are no further questions, Ms Davey, so I thank you for your evidence. I will briefly suspend the meeting to allow for a changeover of witnesses.

12:03

Meeting suspended.

12:04

On resuming—

The Convener

We will now continue our consideration of appointments to the Scottish Fiscal Commission. I welcome Professor Stephen Millard, who has also been nominated as commissioner. We will move straight to questions, and I pose the same question to you as I did to Melissa Davey: why do you feel that you are the best person for the role?

Professor Stephen Millard

Like Melissa, I have three decades of experience of doing economics and economic research in a policy-making context. I started off by doing a PhD at Northwestern University, which was about using macroeconomic modelling to understand labour market policy. I then spent 26 years at the Bank of England working on monetary policy, financial stability policy and financial market infrastructures. All that work was about using economic models to evaluate and assess policy.

For the past four years, I have been working as the deputy director for macroeconomic modelling and forecasting at the National Institute of Economic and Social Research in London. We are the UK’s oldest independent research institute, and our quarterly macroeconomic forecasts are widely respected among UK journalists and the UK policy-making community.

In addition, for the past two years, I have been a member of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, which, in essence, is the Republic of Ireland’s equivalent of the Scottish Fiscal Commission. There are slight differences between what the Scottish Fiscal Commission does and what the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council does, but, in essence, the jobs are very similar. I am the vice-chair of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, and I will be able to bring that experience to the role in Scotland.

I should also say that, in my work on economics and forecasting, as well as in my role in Ireland, I have put forward an independent view. NIESR, in particular, prides itself on being independent of any political party or special interest group. Such independence is, of course, crucially important for the Scottish Fiscal Commission.

Thank you. I turn to colleagues who have questions, starting with Angela Ross.

In the light of your work with the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, what similarities and differences do you see between the fiscal risks that Scotland faces and those that Ireland faces?

Professor Millard

The risks are very different in the sense that, if you were to take a bird’s-eye view of the Irish fiscal position and of the Scottish fiscal position, you would think immediately that the Scottish fiscal position is quite tight and that it is difficult to find the resources that are needed for improving public services, dealing with the green transition and dealing with demographic change in Scotland. In Ireland, on the other hand, the public finances are in exceptionally good health. The Government is running a fairly hefty budget surplus and is putting aside money for the future to deal with demographic change and climate change.

However, there is a big risk in that the fiscal position in Ireland is based on the tax revenue that comes from just a handful of very large US companies. If that tax revenue were to move back to the States, the Irish fiscal position would look a lot worse—it would move from there being a surplus of 3 per cent of GDP, roughly, to there being a deficit of 3 per cent of GDP. The position is that risky. The job of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council always seems to be to remind the Irish Government of how risky that position is and why it needs to put money aside while the going is good. Although the Irish Government is doing that to a degree, it might not be doing it to the extent that we would like.

That is the position in Ireland, whereas, in Scotland, it is more a question of making choices about how to use the relatively scarcer resources that are available here.

Thank you. Do you believe that the current Scottish fiscal framework gives enough flexibility for long-term investment, or does it impose constraints that concern you, as an economist?

Professor Millard

To be quite honest, I would really need to get into the detail of the current fiscal arrangements before I would be able to answer that question.

That is no problem. Do you know enough about the Scottish Fiscal Commission’s forecasts to say how you might challenge or scrutinise them in particular detail, or is that still to come?

Professor Millard

The detail is very much still to come. As Melissa Davey said in her evidence, the big challenge for the Scottish Fiscal Commission is that its forecast interacts with the forecast that is produced by the Office for Budget Responsibility in London, and forecast errors in both places can add up to create a headache for the Scottish Government. It will be absolutely key—to a degree, I hope to be able to do this, given my existing contacts with the OBR that I acquired through NIESR—that we work on developing that link and ensure that those forecasts are compatible with each other and as good as they can possibly be.

Thank you. How could the SFC better or more effectively communicate uncertainty to the Parliament and to the public?

Professor Millard

Communicating uncertainty is very difficult. The traditional approach has been to produce fans around forecasts. The evidence suggests that the public understand that, if you have a wide fan, you are very uncertain; if you have a narrow fan, you are much more sure of your forecast. That is useful.

A lot of the uncertainty that is associated with forecasts relates to the particular effects of things that might happen, such as the oil price suddenly jumping to $150 a barrel and staying there for a length of time. Alternatively, the war in the middle east might suddenly stop, everything might be wonderful again and oil prices might fall to $70 and stay there for a long time. You cannot really capture such scenarios in those fan charts. You have to explain to the public that, “Here is a possible story. If that were to happen, then this would be the effect on Scottish GDP and the Scottish budget position. If this other thing were to happen, this would be the effect.” You have to concentrate on explaining situations to the public via stories rather than necessarily providing a technical picture, which would not capture what you wanted it to.

I appreciate a good story. Thank you.

Liam Kerr

Good morning. My question relates to Angela Ross’s third point. As you know, the Scottish Fiscal Commission has confirmed that the 2027-28 Scottish budget faces a £720 million negative reconciliation, which largely reflects stronger than expected income tax receipts in the rest of the UK. Given your experience at NIESR and the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, do you yet see a way in which the SFC could improve its forecasting of Scotland’s income tax performance relative to that of the rest of the UK?

Professor Millard

I will repeat what I said earlier: the mistake was made by both the Scottish Fiscal Commission and the Office for Budget Responsibility in London. The two mistakes added together created the real problem.

Can we improve our forecasting? We are always looking to do so, whether that is at NIESR, the OBR, the Bank of England or wherever. At the end of the day, forecasting is very difficult; there are no two ways about it. The one thing that you know about any forecast is that it will be wrong, but you hope that it will not be wrong by too much and that, if it does go wrong, you will understand exactly why it went wrong.

The answer is not so much to improve the central forecast per se, because we are always trying to do that, but to ask yourself, in the context of the Scottish budget, “If I were wrong by an average amount or something like that, and the OBR were wrong by an average amount, what is the worst that that could mean for the Scottish budget?” You could then make it clear, as you do the forecast, exactly what range of possible outcomes could happen, and plan for that accordingly.

In some senses, that is the best that we can do, but, as I said, you are always looking to improve your forecasting performance.

Understood.

The Convener

No other members have indicated that they have any further questions for you, Professor Millard, so thank you for your attendance at the committee today.

The committee will consider in private whether to agree to the nominations and will report to the Parliament on our decision thereafter. At our next meeting on Wednesday 25 November, the committee will hear evidence on the UK budget implications for the Scottish budget and on the fiscal framework review. That concludes the public part of today’s meeting.

12:15

Meeting continued in private until 12:27.