However, they suggested that the Bill could be improved, to—
Provide greater legal certainty about when reporting restrictions begin to apply;
Ensure that children and young people can realise their right to waive their anonymity, without committing a criminal offence;
Allow courts to extend reporting restrictions for child complainers and witnesses – as well as children convicted of a crime;
Remove the Scottish Government's power to dispense with reporting restrictions;
Review the maximum penalty for violating these reporting restrictions, which is currently only £2,500; and
Update reporting restrictions in civil as well as criminal cases which involve children, to bring greater consistency to the law as a whole.Dr Andrew Tickell and Seonaid Stevenson-McCabe written evidence
Together Scotland, Social Work Scotland and CYPCS welcomed the inclusion at Section 12 of the Bill of restrictions on reporting suspected criminal offences involving children, as it "addresses the current gap in the law whereby child accused and victims can legally be identified prior to the commencement of formal criminal proceedings.”Children and Young People's Commissioner for Scotland written evidence
However, the CYPCS similarly called for clarity as to when anonymity protections are triggered before the formal commencement of criminal proceedings, stating—
“Currently, it is not clear when suspicion is crystallised. One approach would be to activate...