Appeals received since 1 January 2007 and recalled for ministerial decision Case Reference Date Case Received Case Detail Site Address Current Status Decision Description PPA-270-444 08-01-2007 New 400-275 kV substation extension to west of existing substation thereto, new 400-275 kV substation building Beauly Substation, Wester Balblair, Beauly Withdrawn Withdrawn PPA-310-150 23-01-2007 Erection of class 1 retail unit with associated car parking, landscaping and access road 2 Kilwinning Road, Dalry Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-110-625 15-02-2007 Redevelopment of residential institution to hotel conference centre, 281 dwellings, holiday accommodation and more Blairs College, Blairs Withdrawn Withdrawn PPA-270-459 03-04-2007 Demolition of existing buildings and the erection of a (class 1) retail store, petrol station, parking and associated works Thurso Auction Mart, Ormlie Road, Thurso, KW14 7DW Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-250-687 27-04-2007 Outline planning permission for residential development 26 Ridge Way, Hillend and Donibristle, Dunfermline, Fife Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-270-468 31-05-2007 Erection of foodstore and related means of access, parking and servicing arrangements Land at Morangie Road, Tain, Highland Withdrawn Withdrawn PPA-310-159 26-06-2007 Windfarm development consisting of 19 wind turbines (max height 100m), each with capacity of 2.0MW and site infrastructure Site at Green Hill, Kelburn Estate, Fairlie, Largs, Ayrshire Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-230-951 31-08-2007 Proposed car parking 50 Fairview Road, Edinburgh EH28 8NB Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-320-285 04-09-2007 Formation of a country park, construction of 11 dwellinghouses, associated buildings to accommodate rural uses Staylee Farm (off Hulks Road) Riggend, Airdrie, Lanarkshire Ml6 7SS Withdrawn Withdrawn PPA-370-268 20-09-2007 Opportunity for extension to retail park Land to north of Liberator Drive, Ayr, South Ayrshire Withdrawn Withdrawn PPA-270-517 27-11-2007 Variation of condition numbers 2 and 20 and deletion of condition numbers 3 and 4 of outline planning permission number 06-00521-outlo South side of Alcan Site Entrance, North Road, Fort William Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-130-204 21-01-2008 Site for erection of five dwelling houses Land south west of Allt-Na-Craig, Tarbert Road, Ardrishaig, Lochgilpead, Argyll And Bute Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-270-533 12-02-2008 Extension to electricity substation with associated access road, new substation building and new static VAR compensator building Beauly Grid Substation, Wester Balblair, Beauly, Inverness-shire Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-130-209 20-02-2008 Erection of windfarm consisting of 14 turbines and ancillary development Corlarach Hill, east of Glen Fyne, Bullwood Road, Dunoon, Argyll Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-380-409 07-04-2008 Residential development (in outline) Airdrie Road, Carluke, Lanarkshire, ML8 5EW Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-130-214 16-05-2008 Installation of 16 wind turbine generators and associated equipment and works Black Craig, Glenstriven Estate, Toward Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-340-685 19-06-2008 Formation of a 14 turbine wind farm, substation, construction compound, borrow pits, access tracks and infrastructure Calliacher Wind Farm, Amulree, Strathtay Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-270-592 03-12-2008 Road widening works Culachy Junction with A82, near Fort Augustus, Highland Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-270-593 03-12-2008 Temporary widening of existing quarry access road Balbair Quarry, Beauly, Inverness Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-270-594 03-12-2008 Demolish and rebuild stone wall North verge of A82 trunk road, opposite Culachy Junction, near Fort Augustus Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-340-733 23-12-2008 Construction of windfarm consisting of 14 turbines and associated infrastructure and highway works Findownie Hill, Logiealmond and Ladywell Bridge, Dunkeld Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-270-620 11-06-2009 Construct an electrical converter substation comprising two large buildings housing electrical equipment Adjacent to west side of existing Beauly 275-132kV substation, Wester Balblair, Beauly, IV4 7BQ Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-310-208 29-07-2009 Erection of 24 wind turbines with ancillary development with access tracks, two anemometer masts and on-site buildings Wings Law, Kilbirnie, North Ayrshire, KA25 7LA Withdrawn Withdrawn PPA-270-2035 12-07-2010 Application to vary condition in application 07-00890-fulin granted by Scottish Ministers Beauly Substation, Wester Balblair Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-270-2043 26-11-2010 Construction of wind farm comprising 17 wind turbines, associated access tracks and infrastructure Approximate-ly 8km north east of Tomatin Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-340-2068 09-05-2012 Relocation of existing recycling centre and formation of a waste to energy facility (approval of matters in conditions) Doug Holden Scrap Merchants, Shore Road, Perth, PH2 8BH Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-100-2041 24-10-2012 Proposed urban village (mixed development) Broadford Works, Maberly Street, Aberdeen Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-320-2047 11-12-2012 Erection of a supermarket, petrol filling station, car parking, access, landscaping and associated works Former First bus depot Tinkers Lane – Hamilton Road – Airbles Road, Motherwell, ML1 3BJ Decision issued Appeal dismissed PPA-240-2032 05-06-2013 Coal bed methane production, including drilling, well site establishment at 14 locations and associated infrastructure Letham Moss, Falkirk, FK2 8RT Case on hold PPA-390-2029 05-06-2013 Coal bed methane production including drilling, well site establishment at 14 locations and associated infrastructure Land located 230 miles south of Powdrake Farmhouse, Powdrake Road, near Airth, Plean, FK2 8RT Case on hold PPA-400-2034 28-06-2013 Erection of six (2MW) wind turbines (max. 125 high to blade tip) with associated infrastructure Land at Pearie Law, West Calder Decision issued Appeal allowed PPA-400-2045 12-02-2014 12.6 ha residential development including green space, suds, access roads and associated infrastructure Land at Burghmuir A, east of springfield, Linlithgow Allocated to reporter ENA-410-2002 14-05-2014 Alleged breach of the erection of two turbines, two anemometer masts and the provision of associated hardstandings and the siting of a container 7 Bornish, Isle of South Uist, HS8 5SA Withdrawn Withdrawn PPA-400-2046 06-06-2014 Planning permission in principle for a 6.5 ha residential development with associated engineering works and landscaping Land at Clarendon Farm, Linlithgow Allocated to reporter PPA-230-2129 29-07-2014 Residential development (comprising 72 units) and associated works Land 213 metres south west of 22, The Wisp, Edinburgh Allocated to reporter PPA-210-2043 29-07-2014 52 residential units and associated works Land at Old Craighall Road, Old Craighall, Musselburgh Notice of Intention Issued ENA-410-2004 21-08-2014 Alleged unauthorised construction of two wind turbines and of two associated hardstandings on the site.