Mr Ingram met with individual CPCs on the following occasions: 5 February 2008 Clackmannanshire Council 27 March 2008 East Renfrewshire 3 June 2008 Moray 18 June 2008 Aberdeen City 12 September 2008 Stirling 12 January 2009 Aberdeen City 13 January 2009 Moray 10 March 2009 Renfrewshire 10 March 2009 East Lothian S3W-21979