Four large public seminars were organised by the Scottish Executive, as follows: Location Number Attending Chair Panelists Dundee 113 Drew Walker, NHS Tayside Tom McCabe, MSP Paul Waterston, Scottish Licensed Trade Association (SLTA) Maureen Moore, ASH Scotland Paul Ballard, NHS Tayside Glasgow 237 Debbie Wilkie, Scottish Civic Forum (SCF) Tom MCabe, MSP Paul Waterston, SLTA Maureen Moore, ASH Scotland Laurence Gruer, NHS Health Scotland Jim Devine, UNISON Inverness 93 Debbie Wilkie, SCF Tom McCabe, MSP Paul Waterston, SLTA Maureen Moore, ASH Scotland John Wrench, NHS Highland Bruce Crabtree, GMB Aberdeen 124 Debbie Wilkie, SCF Tom McCabe, MSP Stuart Ross, SLTA James Friend, NHS Health Scotland Maureen Moore, ASH Scotland Kenny Simpson, GMB In addition, the Scottish Civic Forum held a further 11 smaller events in local communities across Scotland, as outlined in the following table.