The research briefing that we received from you on the current level of tourism compared with the 50 per cent growth target that was set in “Scottish Tourism: The Next Decade—A Tourism Framework for Change” suggests that, rather than going in the right direction, we were going in the wrong direction even before the recession. Between 2005 and 2008, the total spend went down from £4,214 million to £4,047 million, and it declined again last year because of the impact of the recession.