The numbers of legal challenges lodged against the Scottish Government’s tender processes and the awarding of contracts for the years from 2007 to date are as follows: 2007 – 0 lodged; 0 upheld 2008 – 0 lodged; 0 upheld 2009 – 0 lodged; 0 upheld 2010 – 1 lodged; 0 upheld 2011 – 0 lodged; 0 upheld 2012 – 3 lodged; 0 upheld 2013 – 2 lodged; 0 upheld There have been six legal challenges against Scottish Government tender processes in the years from 2007 to date, but none of those has been upheld by the courts.