Paragraph 1.3 states that the volumes do not cover"the activities of Members in other circumstances, for example"the activities of"Members who are Ministers of the Scottish Executive".It would somewhat clarify the situation in my mind, if not in anybody else's mind, if the paragraph referred to "members when they are acting in their capacity as ministers of the Scottish Executive". Mr Gorrie expressed concerns about paragraph 1.3, whereas Mr Butler thinks that the paragraph is sufficiently clear.