Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 5 May 2021
  6. Current session: 12 May 2021 to 20 August 2025
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 29 contributions

|

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Decision on Taking Business in Private

Meeting date: 30 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

Thank you, convener. I have no relevant interests.

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Ministerial Statement

Meeting date: 30 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

Of course. I am happy to concede that point. My anxiety is that, as we have heard from eminent academics this morning, vaccination certification could drive down uptake in hesitant—or, rather, vaccine-sceptical—groups. If they feel browbeaten, they might not take up vaccination.

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Ministerial Statement

Meeting date: 30 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

Thank you for that. My final area of questioning is about proportionality.

Last week, we heard from the Scottish Human Rights Commission that there is anxiety that the scheme will roll back our application of human rights, including statutory ones. Judith Robertson, the chair, made it clear that it is acceptable for states to do that in times of pressing need—obviously, coronavirus is a pressing need—but only if the scheme that is being introduced and the rollback of rights that goes with it can demonstrably impact on pushing down against that need. She also talked about proportionality, as did you.

My question is on the evidence of proportionality. Meeting the test that was set to us by the Scottish Human Rights Commission requires the Government to evidence that it has considered alternatives to the scheme. Are you satisfied that you have considered the use of testing as an alternative to vaccination certification to an extent that would satisfy the Scottish Human Rights Commission?

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Vaccination Certification

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

I will be very brief, convener, and I am grateful to you for letting me in.

In the interests of time, I will ask a couple of yes or no questions. Professor Montgomery, you referred in your opening remarks to a festival in Cornwall called, I think, Boardmasters, that required vaccination passports for entry. Nevertheless, 5,000 people still got sick. Was there a requirement to provide evidence of a negative lateral flow test at that festival, too?

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Vaccination Certification

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

Thank you very much.

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Vaccination Certification

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

Okay. That was very helpful. So, even though everyone knew that everyone else was double-jabbed and people were presenting their lateral flow test results, 5,000 people still got sick. It just shows that this is not a foolproof approach.

Judith Robertson, you made it very clear—indeed, I wrote it down—that states and Governments can set aside their duty to act compatibly with rights such as the right to family life, privacy and freedom of thought only if it were necessary to address a pressing social need. What if the Government does not act compatibly with those rights and does not present any evidence that such a move is necessary to address a social need? Is there a sanction that would apply?

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Vaccination Certification

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

From what you have said today, you do not seem to be satisfied that—as yet—you have seen sufficient evidence from the Government that the measure is necessary to address a very pressing social need. In fact, we have seen from the festival in Cornwall evidence to the contrary that it does not actually do so. What evidence would satisfy the requirement to set aside those very important human rights?

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Vaccination Certification

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

This is obviously a very controversial issue; indeed, the Night Time Industries Association has just mounted a legal challenge against the proposal. If the Government were to be found sitting on compelling empirical evidence that suggests that the measure is an effective means of addressing this very pressing social need, would that surprise you? After all, if I was in Government and had that evidence, I would rush it out and put it to the fore.

COVID-19 Recovery Committee

Decision on Taking Business in Private

Meeting date: 23 September 2021

Alex Cole-Hamilton

Thank you, convener. I am grateful to be here. I have no interests to declare.