The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 46 contributions
Rural Affairs Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Finlay Carson
Yes, thanks. I will go back to funding. Everybody recognises that agricultural funding has been eroded during the past few years. The current funding is about £16 million less than last year. We keep hearing that the original funding amounted to £660 million, but that amount was based on the legacy CAP and it was negotiated two decades ago. Now, we have a biodiversity strategy, a climate change strategy and pressures related to resilience. Not only do farmers have to be well placed to mitigate and adapt to climate change, but they are also affected daily by issues such as flooding, blue tongue and other diseases, drought and pressures from across the world that affect prices.
The Government says that it is interested in food security, but the £660 million is being diluted because more money is going to climate mitigation, biodiversity and whatever—and rightly so, if that is the direction that we want to go in. However, ministers seem unwilling to be honest about the trade-offs. There was a fixed budget, and now we hear that it is fantastic that we have multiyear, ringfenced money. However, the amount goes down in real terms every year, so it is actually bad news that we have to deal with, potentially, £660 million, with limited changes to that amount until 2030.
Does the current funding profile address the urgency of Scotland’s climate and biodiversity crisis and also the need for food security and our ability to produce food for Scotland and the UK?
Rural Affairs Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Finlay Carson
The definitions of “active farmer” and “agricultural activity” are important, though, because they could be the be-all and end-all in relation to who receives public funding, given the way in which the plan is currently drafted.
Rural Affairs Committee
Meeting date: 2 September 2026
Finlay Carson
That is all very nice and really interesting, but we did that 10 years ago.
Rural Affairs Committee
Meeting date: 2 September 2026
Finlay Carson
It is nice to see everybody. Some of you are the usual suspects, but it is good to be back around the table.
Back in March 2025, Jonnie Hall told the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee that
“we have not made any significant progress”
in using the powers that are available to the Scottish Government to deliver agricultural reform, and we heard Pete Ritchie say:
“We were expecting a big bang, but there is just a very small squeak”.—[Official Report, Rural Affairs and Islands Committee, 12 March 2025; c 4.]
Kate Rowell warned that farmers “lacked certainty” about where reform was heading.
It is 10 years since Brexit. We have had plans and consultations, but most respondents have suggested that the agricultural support framework is mainly a continuation of common agricultural policy-era support. What makes what we see in front of us a genuine reform programme rather than just a repackaging of current packages?
Jonnie, as I mentioned you, will you attack that question first?
Rural Affairs Committee
Meeting date: 2 September 2026
Finlay Carson
You are right, Martin. The fact is that we have this five-year plan in front of us and we are still discussing what we think should be in it. Davy McCracken talked about destination and outcomes. It feels a bit like having a satnav: the plan is the satnav and the Government has not actually plugged the destination into it. We find ourselves sitting in the plan, not knowing what is going to happen in five years’ time.
Let us not get into the information technology system, either. With this satnav, at every junction we come to it will say, “I’m sorry, but you can’t turn left,” or, “You can’t turn right,” because the software is not up to date. There is that to think about, too.
Stability, which we have talked about, is all very well, but there is what Jonnie Hall called “inertia by design”. The Government keeps talking about the cliff edge—everybody talks about the cliff edge—but we never want to get to it. Of course, if we just stand still, we will never drive over that cliff edge, but we are also never going to achieve any of the outcomes that everybody around the table is talking about.
We have this five-year plan in the legislation, but can anybody tell me what the support is going to look like in 2030? What reassurance can we give crofters, land managers and farmers about what the support is going to look like at the end of the plan? My question to everybody is this: what detail is missing from the plan that will give reassurance to farmers that, in 2030, they will be on the right road to delivering it?
Rural Affairs Committee
Meeting date: 24 June 2026
Finlay Carson
I declare that I am also an honorary associate member of the British Veterinary Association.