Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Current session: 13 May 2021 to 6 February 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 7190 contributions

|

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

A couple of times, you have said that a certain aspect is maybe not for the bill, but it sounds as though it has a lot of potential unintended consequences. You talked about someone needing to offload 100 grand of profit and how they could do that. If I was a tax adviser managing someone’s affairs and I was looking at this session, I would be thinking, “Okay, we’ve got this bill coming in and it’s not going to make changes, but they will probably do that in the next five years, so I’ll send a leaflet to all the crofters and say, ‘I will buy your grazing shares,’ because that’s investable, or the risk is worth taking.” We then might be here in five years’ time, saying, “Do you know what? The horse has bolted, because we have a whole lot of absentee owners of grazing shares that we’re just not going to get back without fighting through the courts.”

You say that the bill is not the place to deal with the issue, but does it need to go further? I was going to ask this next question at the very end of the session. Does the bill need to go further to address some of the loopholes and put safeguards in place now, rather than highlighting those loopholes and allowing them to be exploited over the next four or five years until a new crofting bill is introduced?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

Do you want to come back in, Josh?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

Donna Smith, you touched on safeguards.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

Thank you. That brings us tidily to our next theme, which is the enforcement of crofters’ duties, and questions from Alasdair Allan.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

Does Donna Smith want to comment?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

We need to define communities a bit more strictly. The committee has heard evidence about communities, and there are broad definitions of a community, whether it means people who live in a locality or a community of people who share a certain viewpoint. What is your definition of communities? Communities would have the right to buy crofts. How would you define that?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

Emma Roddick has a supplementary question, but I will bring in Jackie McCreery first.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

I have a final wrap-up question. As I touched on earlier, the aims of the bill are quite clear. The policy memorandum sets out that it is about strengthening crofting through seven key aspects. However, multiple stakeholders have suggested that the bill is not sufficient to cover what is needed. Some have stated that, although it has taken eight years, it does nothing to address what is already a complex web of legislation and that all that it does is make minor tweaks.

Throughout this evidence session, we have focused on what is not in the bill rather than on what is in it, and on potential loopholes and unintended consequences. What are your views? Does the bill need to be significantly amended, or do we leave it generally as it is and hope that we can get another crofting bill in the next parliamentary session?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

Thank you.

At this point, I must apologise—I have a screen right in front of me, so it should not have been difficult to remember, but we also have Anne Murray with us. Anne, would you like to introduce yourself? I apologise for missing you out.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill (Stage 1)

Meeting date: 29 October 2025

Finlay Carson

Do you have any examples of that happening at the moment? How does the Crofting Commission deal with cases of abandoned crofts where people are suggesting that they are still being used for environmental purposes?