Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Session 6: 13 May 2021 to 8 April 2026
  7. Current session: 14 May 2026 to 16 November 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 211 contributions

|

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

In my experience, it is a key feature to have interministerial engagement among the devolved Governments. That has been my experience in education and in transport: there is always a level of intergovernmental engagement, and there are existing structures that provide for that.

In my experience, those bilaterals are extremely important. They build relationships with counterparts, and we get a good understanding of our counterparts’ experience and perspective in relation to engagement with the UK Government on a range of different issues. Those relationships are hugely important and highly valuable to Scottish ministers in how we engage with the UK Government more broadly.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

That is an interesting point. My view is that there was a greater risk of that happening under the previous Prime Minister, who convened the last meeting of the council of the nations and regions. The Scottish Government was sceptical about our being placed on equal footing with mayors, for example, and I do not think that that was particularly well received in Scotland, to put it mildly.

However, the current Prime Minister, Mr Burnham, has been keen to differentiate between mayors and leaders of the devolved Governments, and we have seen that already through the way in which he has engaged. We should recognise that that is a shift and a recognition that these structures and arrangements are different.

Ultimately, the test of the structures lies in the engagement. You can create as many structures as you like and have as much transparency and send as many letters to committees as you want, but, at the end of the day, we are talking about politicians and, sometimes, a lot of this boils down to politics.

Mr Burnham is taking a pragmatic and positive approach. It is different from that of his predecessor, which, in turn, was very different from his predecessor. Indeed, take the number of breaches of the Sewel convention under the previous Conservative Administration, for example. I am aware that the committee pursued that matter during the previous session of Parliament. We have not seen the same under the current Administration. Things shifted, and they have shifted again under Mr Burnham.

We will continue to try to take a pragmatic approach in that engagement. If there is any suggestion that Scotland is being put on a par with regions in England, for example, we will resist that strongly.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

It is vast.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

I do not necessarily think that we need to copy our neighbours’ homework to deliver local democracy more efficiently.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

The Welsh constitution minister—apologies. Those ministers and I were all physically present in Belfast for a meeting, and I feel that the optics of three UK Government ministers zooming in online was not great. I made that point to Darren Hughes when I met him at the British-Irish Council. Meeting in person is important to enable us to build relationships and understand better how one another’s Governments work, so I made that ask at the last interministerial meeting. We hope that another meeting will be scheduled in the coming weeks, to be hosted in Edinburgh by the Scottish Government. I will share more detail on that with the committee when we have managed to agree a date for that.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

Indeed, and it might not be as robust as having a framework that is mutually agreed between two Governments. I am not ruling that out today. These are things that we will want to pursue with the new Prime Minister and his team.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

We have seen those reports, and there is a level of concern. We are not sure that that will apply to Scotland in the same way, because there are different reporting structures to the Parliament, but we would like to give the committee reassurance on those points. If I may, convener, I would like to write to the committee with further detail, having first sought assurance from the UK Government that that will not apply to Scotland. Our initial observation is that we do not think that it will apply here, because of the reporting structures being different in Scotland, but I would first like to get that clarity and I will then write to the committee on that point to provide assurance.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

That is a really interesting question. It had not been working until recently. I know that the previous committee covered the issue in its legacy report. Under the previous Conservative Administration, we saw breaches in a variety of areas as the UK Government overrode the Scottish Parliament. That has not been good for our democracy and was a breach of Sewel.

That has shifted under the Labour Government, which is welcome. That goes back to the convener’s overall question about whether structures can prevent that sort of behaviour by Administrations of varying political colours. I am sure that the committee will reflect on the fact that we should be mindful of how those structures might be strengthened to ensure that we do not revert to that sort of approach to breaches of Sewel.

I think that the Supreme Court has essentially ruled out putting Sewel on a statutory footing, so there are constitutional challenges. However, when we have a new Prime Minister who says that he is committed to the devolution agenda, there is also an opportunity to revisit the role of Sewel and to ensure that we do not have a repeat of the egregious examples that we saw under the previous Conservative Administration, which passed swathes of legislation without the consent of this Parliament.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

Our view is that the Scottish Parliament should legislate on matters that are devolved to this Parliament. There may be examples—I gave one earlier—of areas where we need to engage with the UK Government, including, for example, areas that predate this Parliament. I gave the niche example of the SQA, which was created before this Parliament existed and could, therefore, be dissolved only by an act of the UK Parliament, which had to legislate for that. We will engage with UK Government ministers on those issues, but our preference is for any matters that are devolved to the Scottish Parliament to be dealt with solely by Scottish ministers and that only with our consent would they be legislated for by UK Government ministers. That consent is imperative to the intergovernmental landscape.

Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee

Scottish Government Priorities (Intergovernmental Relations)

Meeting date: 8 September 2026

Jenny Gilruth

My principled position is that I do not think that there are reasonable circumstances in which UK Government ministers should be legislating in devolved areas. However, we have to be pragmatic. The example that I provided in relation to the Education (Scotland) Bill required UK Government legislation to allow me to dissolve the SQA so that we could create Qualifications Scotland. That is pragmatic politics.

We could take a principled position that devolved legislation is, quite rightly, the responsibility of elected ministers in this Parliament. However, we will always need a degree of engagement with the UK Government while Scotland remains part of the United Kingdom. That is how our legal frameworks work, and for as long as we remain part of the United Kingdom we will have to have a level of engagement with UK Government ministers. Our ask is that that is done pragmatically and with our consent.

That is the test of the point of your question: that any engagement on such issues is made with the Scottish Government’s express consent. We did that through the section 104 order, which we agreed to in the process of dissolving the SQA. That was done through a consent process in which officials and ministers work together. That was agreed, and it allowed for the passage of the Education (Scotland) Bill and the establishment of Qualifications Scotland as a result. That is an example of where such an process can work in practice. The principle of consent would be our overriding view—not to take away from our overall view that all legislation in Scotland that is devolved should ultimately be a matter for ministers in Scotland.