The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 211 contributions
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
We have also undertaken a lot of work internally to grow the number of planners that we have. Andy Kinnaird might want to say a little more about that.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
We have not yet undertaken evaluation because we have not yet had another round of local government elections, so I suppose that the optimal point for us to consider that in conjunction with COSLA will be after the local government elections in May. We will continue to progress that work by monitoring diversity and encouraging people from different communities to stand for local elections in the first place, and we hope that our support for those recommendations on councillor pay will help to increase the diversity that we see in local government.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I agree that that is a challenge. At a time when our energy security is being stretched, we have to look at alternative approaches. During the summer recess, I visited a number of homes in my constituency that received funding from the Scottish Government to help to transform them and make them energy efficient. That funding has had an amazing impact through the installation of triple glazing, insulation and heat pumps in bringing families’ bills right down. The work at that small housing development, which is owned by a housing association in Glenrothes, is a small example of the ways in which central Government investment can help to bring down the costs of heating people’s homes.
That is an example from housing but there are lots of different examples across Government and ways in which we can support households to save money on their bills. We know that the winter period will be really challenging, with bills set to increase again in the coming months, so we will continue to look at those alternatives. As I said to the convener, I will be very mindful of and sympathetic to those points in budget negotiations with my cabinet colleagues in the coming weeks.
11:00
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I assure you that the Scottish Government has no pre-prepared map. We are not foisting a system on our local government partners. We have a variety of local authorities in the country, and some are much smaller than others, which makes things much more challenging for them. For example, Clackmannanshire Council is an extremely small local authority. In recent times, it has faced a financial challenge in relation to Coalsnaughton. You will be aware that the Government had to step in to provide an extra £1 million of funding to provide reassurance to that local authority. That is a relatively small sum of money, but it made all the difference to Clackmannanshire, as it was looking for financial assurance. That tells me a story about its sustainability.
In recent times, we have had other examples of events in local authorities where the Government has had to step in to provide financial assurance. Again, that speaks to the wider sustainability agenda. For example, Highland Council covers a vast geographical area of Scotland and has to meet a number of challenges across the board. I know from my time in education how challenging it is for Highland Council to recruit teachers in the north of Scotland. Strategic issues exist in parts of the country that are not just about education—they exist in our social care services as well and across the delivery of public services. An approach to public service reform that recognises that will, I hope, allow local authorities to be more local in many ways but also to share the strategic risk in ways that they cannot currently do because of the way in which our local government structures are organised.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
As you will be aware, the First Minister was asked about that on Sunday. I do not think that we will attribute figures on that at this time. However, trade union partnership working is really important. Mr McKee and I had focused engagement with the Scottish Trades Union Congress a few weeks ago, in August. We also engaged with trade union partners back in June, through a PSR event in Glasgow. We have agreed with the STUC that we will have a round table with all our trade union partners, to talk about the issues in the round, because we are clear that we cannot foist public service reform on local government, and nor would we wish to. There will be a reduction in head count across the public sector—the First Minister has been open about that—but we are not going to attribute a head count figure today. Some of the arguments were rehearsed in the chamber last week.
My final point is that the Government exists in a Parliament of minorities so, even if we wanted to foist this on local government, we could not. We need to work in partnership with all parties that are represented in the Parliament, and some that are not, and we will continue to have cross-party dialogue. My engagement has already involved some of those issues, and we have set out an approach to a cross-party round table to look at the current fiscal outlook and, ahead of the budget, to work across parties on all issues. We have to reflect that the Government does not hold all the cards, so cross-party working will be imperative.
As much as I am here to answer members’ questions, I am also really interested to hear views from you about how we drive forward this agenda in a Parliament of minorities, because we have to work together on such things.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
You are right to recount some of the challenges that we faced in that space in the previous parliamentary session, convener. Again, I reflect that the Government exists in the Parliament as a minority Government. That is not going away, so we will need to attract support for that policy, and the First Minister has been very open about that. That is why we have not predetermined a destination in relation to local government reform. In relation to the health boards, we have set out an approach, but we also need to engage with the Opposition on where we get to on the agreed proposal.
I would push back and say that we have not taken final decisions on social care at the current time. We have set out a trajectory in relation to health reform and an approach that, for example, would see health boards lead on social care. However, local government must be engaged in those conversations, and that engagement has already started. The three-month period that we have set out is part of the answer but also, as I said at the start of the meeting, we had sessions with local government back in May and throughout the summer months on social care.
It is an issue that local government regularly and routinely raises with the Scottish Government. It was raised with me at the political meeting that I had with group leaders in August and it has been raised with me consistently by local government and COSLA throughout that time. It was raised with the First Minister when we met the presidential team at Bute house a number of weeks ago. On Friday, there will be a special meeting of COSLA group leaders with the First Minister, Ivan McKee and me. I may write to the convener on the back of that meeting, if that would be helpful, to share more detail of any of the outcomes that have arisen from it, because I appreciate that we will be moving at relative pace in the next few months when it comes to the next steps.
We have not arrived at a final destination on social care. We have to work with local government. That space was challenging in the previous parliamentary session, for all the reasons that you are aware of, convener. I go back to the point about partnership working. There is an opportunity in that.
The health board perspective is that IJBs and integration are not working; budgets are not aligned; and it can be deeply challenging when it comes to the way in which they deliver services. An example is delayed discharge and some of the issues that exist in our local communities on that. The approach to budgeting on that is not helpful to people in our communities in the services that they experience.
I go back to the points on partnership working but also the point that I made to Gary Bouse: the issue is how we improve our services for the people that we all represent. We are not foisting a social care system on local government but are working with it. It is hoped that the three-month period will allow us to come to a consensus on the next steps on social care.
You are right to highlight the challenge in the previous parliamentary session. We are very keen to avoid that. We can deliver on arriving at consensus only through partnership working, so we will continue that approach, and I will be more than happy to write to the committee on the back of Friday’s meeting, to share any further detail that arises from that engagement with COSLA.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
The overall assessment from the Accounts Commission is deeply challenging and we in the Scottish Government would agree that that situation needs to be resolved.
The sustainability of where we are just now is, in itself, an argument for public service reform because it tells us that the status quo is not working. There are a number of councillors and former councillors in the room who will all recognise, in the detail that they see as elected members, that where we are just now in budgeting for services is not sustainable. The Accounts Commission is telling us a story about the situation in our communities that we know exists in terms of how we provide for budgets at the current time; however, it is also telling us that things have to change.
To my mind, that is the rationale for public service reform: we cannot stand still. Our services are really struggling across a range of fronts. I can talk to the record funding that is going to local government, which is good, but our current systems and structures are probably not meeting our constituents’ needs in the way that they should. Public service reform offers us an opportunity to ensure that that funding, which the Government has ring fenced for local government in order to protect it, gets to those who need it most.
The Accounts Commission critique is one that we would recognise, which is exactly why we are driving forward PSR.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
We can agree to disagree. In relation to equal pay and the broader issues, I give the committee the assurance that I have written to the UK Government about those matters, as has Ms Somerville. We have not yet received a response.
As I recounted in my original answer, a significant uplift in funding was provided to Glasgow City Council in this year’s funding settlement and I have given the council’s leadership team the assurance that, once again, we will look favourably at Glasgow’s position in the budget allocations. I remind the committee that I do not yet know what the UK Government’s allocation will be for Scotland. We are somewhat prejudging the outcome of the UK Government’s budget, which will not be announced until the end of October. As soon as we have that information, we will be able to engage with Glasgow City Council in more detail.
Throughout the summer months, there has been extensive engagement with the council by officials as well as at a political level between me, Ms Somerville and the council’s leadership. That dialogue will continue as we approach the Scottish Government’s budget which, in my view, will mirror the approach that was taken in the previous financial year.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I have been a minister for a number of years now so it would be remiss of me to announce at committee different taxes that may be passed on to local government—I am not going to do that. There is a general point, which is that local government has an opportunity, through further devolution and through PSR, to gain more responsibilities, which may lead to financial opportunities. Although we may debate the Government’s approach and suggest that the three-month period is perhaps too short, or not long enough, there is an opportunity for COSLA and local government to grasp the nettle and transform the way that we deliver public services. The committee will forgive me for not announcing any views on specific taxes, but it would be quite wrong for me to set that out.
We have to have partnership working, so I return to the points that I made to the convener at the start of the evidence session: we cannot and will not foist a system on local government; we will work in partnership with local government on this. As a serving councillor, you know that local authorities have very strong views about their powers and what additionality might be provided to them as a result of PSR and further devolution. We will continue to work with COSLA to develop a partnership approach on that; I hope that it will be a shared approach not just with COSLA but with cross-party support from the Parliament.
Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee
Meeting date: 9 September 2026
Jenny Gilruth
I hear the point that the deputy convener has made. I am very aware of the case and, of course, of the issues around education cuts in Glasgow. I was education secretary at the time, so I am au fait with the detail, but I will not provide public commentary on the matter, for good reason.
In the round, I would want to directly engage with COSLA on the matter—that would be quite right and proper. Although I am sure that there will be views on some of the issues that you have raised, thus far COSLA far not raised them with me. However, I am more than happy to take that away and to hear from COSLA if it wants to pursue those issues.