The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 833 contributions
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 20 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
Some of the evidence that we heard in favour of the change was about the perception of trust and people’s perceptions. We acknowledge that not everything is intentional, and you gave the example of somebody being absent. We heard full evidence from Glasgow City Council, for example, about how it deals with things. Is there not value in making changes that will improve trust in the system?
10:30Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
It is helpful to get that on the record.
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
Thank you.
Kenneth, do you have a view on whether a presumption in favour of disclosure would change how those seeking information would behave in response to being told that information was being withheld?
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
Good morning. Some of the respondents to the committee’s call for views suggested that the proposal to introduce a presumption in favour of disclosure when public authorities are considering withholding information under a qualified exemption does not change the legal position in respect of information disclosure under FOISA. Others had concerns about confusing the existing position of information disclosure under FOISA. What is your opinion and view on the proposal?
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
I will be really brief. Dr Meechan, I acknowledge what you have said about meetings being held and decisions being taken in public and all of that being transparent, but is it not the case in local authorities that there are pre-meets between officials and politicians before the public part of the meeting? I acknowledge that meetings are often live streamed and are very accessible now, but that is not the whole picture when it comes to decision making in local authorities.
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
Will you speak to how such a presumption in favour of disclosure might change the practice of FOI officers in universities?
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
So you agree that the bill would have a positive impact on public trust and confidence in the process.
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
Good morning. Thank you for being with us. Section 1 of the bill proposes an amendment to the general entitlement by inserting a presumption in favour of disclosure. Most respondents to the committee’s call for views were in favour of that. Kenneth Meechan, I was struck by the fact that you used the phrase, “If it’s not broke, don’t try to fix it” to explain your position on the bill. I wonder whether the people who are requesting information would take that view, too. The committee obviously has to look at things in the round—from the point of view of not just the providers of information but the people who are requesting it. How do you decide whether to disclose information when applying qualified exemptions, and how might a presumption in favour of disclosure change the approach to practice in that regard?
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
Finally, Gordon, from your perspective as an information requester, if the presumption were there, might it encourage users to be more proactive in seeking reviews and appeals of decisions?
Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee
Meeting date: 13 November 2025
Ruth Maguire
Gordon Martin, from the RMT’s perspective, what are your reflections on introducing a presumption in favour of disclosure? Would that change the way that public authorities engage with information requesters?