The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 833 contributions
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 3 May 2023
Ruth Maguire
Yes.
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 3 May 2023
Ruth Maguire
You say that the bill builds on what is already there. I find it interesting that you have said that you feel that there is no change when, clearly, the bill widens the criteria. I am not necessarily disagreeing, but I think that it is important to be very clear about any potential risks or benefits of broadening those criteria. It is not more of the same; it is different.
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 3 May 2023
Ruth Maguire
That is helpful, thank you.
My final question is about the effectiveness of MRCs. The policy memorandum says that no evaluation of the effectiveness of MRCs has been carried out. How will their effectiveness be evaluated going forward?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 26 April 2023
Ruth Maguire
I would like some clarification from Stephen Bermingham. You said that we could not tell a victim details of a compulsory supervision order, which I absolutely appreciate. You will all have real-life examples of where harm has been done and there is a victim. In terms of the victim’s safety planning, you said that there could be informal ways that children and their families might be able to understand—I will just say it bluntly—that they would be safe and they would not encounter the person who had harmed them in certain areas. Is that the sort of thing that you mean, whereby their victims could be partially informed without getting the details of the individuals? Does that make sense?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 26 April 2023
Ruth Maguire
I hear what you are saying and I am sure that, in extreme circumstances, they would have to do so. I suppose that I am thinking of examples—I will not start talking about specific ones—whereby harm can be caused that is not reaching that level, which we could be preventing.
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 26 April 2023
Ruth Maguire
I am grateful that you raised that, because another of our concerns is the subjectivity of that change. In its submission, SWS also mentioned some concerns in that area. Is there anything that you would like to share in that regard?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 26 April 2023
Ruth Maguire
Is that element of the safety of the victim covered in existing guidance for practitioners and professionals?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 26 April 2023
Ruth Maguire
I am skipping the queue—thank you, convener, and apologies to other committee members.
We have heard some concerns that compulsory supervision orders might not attract the same safeguards—the obvious one is the entitlement to legal representation—against depriving children of their liberty. I noted that Children’s Hearings Scotland had some concerns about the methods for tracking people, which the Information Commissioner might share in terms of the right to privacy.
I am keen to hear reflections on that point so that we can get on record what the concerns are about that. Does Jenny Brotchie want to go first?
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 26 April 2023
Ruth Maguire
That is helpful. Thank you.
Education, Children and Young People Committee
Meeting date: 26 April 2023
Ruth Maguire
If that would be acceptable, yes, I do.