The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 833 contributions
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
Yes—I would not diminish any of that; we absolutely heard that. As we are creating law, what I am trying to get to is whether it is possible, in law, to protect citizens from silent judgment.
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
I am okay, convener. I will come back in later.
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
Do you agree that, in relation to proportionality when we are talking about rights, post-legislative scrutiny—there is that phrase again—is an important tool to give everyone that comfort?
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
Okay. In relation to reviewing the legislation, what would be an appropriate mechanism in the bill to ensure that there is continued proportionality, that rights are balanced and that women are protected?
11:45Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
When we are talking about the balance of rights, it is important for us to try to bottom everything out. There are top-level things that every reasonable person would agree with, but we want to avoid unintended consequences.
My other question is about proportionality, which you have covered in your answers to colleagues. Is there anything else that you want to say about the evidence that you gathered from those accessing services and those who want to partake in protest or vigil?
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
I am sorry, but that just triggered something in my mind. The police officer who gave evidence to the committee talked about controversial marches—I assume that he was talking about the marches that take place in the west of Scotland—and he said that if someone were to display an opposing flag in their house, the police would ask them to take it down, because it could be seen as incitement. Could it be the case that, if a person’s property were in an exclusion zone, an overt depiction of their Christianity could be seen in that way? Who would decide that?
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
How would the Scottish Government respond to claims that anti-abortion views were excluded from the process? You have said that they were not.
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
Good morning, minister. For absolute clarity, is it the Scottish Government’s intention that someone who is engaged in silent prayer—without placards, rosaries or any other visible thing that would enable them to be picked out—would be caught by the section 4 criminal offence?
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
Obviously, in law, it is important to be crystal clear. People need to know whether they are committing a criminal offence, and I guess that the police need to know. How will we place the intention in someone’s mind as they silently pray?
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 19 March 2024
Ruth Maguire
You used the phrase “silently judging”. How do I know whether someone is silently judging me?