The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 8273 contributions
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
I do not want to stop you going through all of the points, but everyone on the panel is thinking, “Oh, she’s stealing all my points”.
I will move on but, before I do, may I say that my manners left me briefly at the beginning of the meeting, for which I apologise. I should have welcomed Finlay Carson, convener of the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee, and Rhoda Grant, both of whom have joined us and will get a chance to ask questions at the end. Sorry to cut you off, Clare. I move now to Calum Duncan.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
Tavish Scott wants to explain why the industry will not invest in a five-year plan. Or will it?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
I will let Tavish Scott in, if he can be brief.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
You can keep your answer to this one brief, then. [Laughter.]
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
Mark, we are quite tight for time, and I would like to give Finlay Carson and Rhoda Grant two questions each but not to every member of the panel. That is just to be clear, Mr Carson.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
Okay. I am afraid that we are at our time limit, Rhoda.
I will ask a final question, which will require a yes or no answer and one sentence. You will all get a chance to answer it.
My problem is that what I have heard this morning is that there needs to be a balance between nature, environment and jobs, and that is absolutely critical. However, we have some dichotomies. For example, are there unseen effects on other species from electro-fishing for razor clams? Do we know what that truly means? Is there habitat destruction from dredging, and is a huge length of time required to recover from that?
I am not going to pass comment on aquaculture, except to say that the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee report was apposite in 2018 and it remains apposite today. However, there are potential conflicts there between wild salmon and other crustaceans.
When it comes to renewables, that balance may affect demersal fisheries, and it may affect the chopping up of seabirds that are suffering from avian flu. Should we be taking steps to stop the sand eel fishery and ensure that seabirds have enough food? What damage is plastic waste doing to our flora and fauna?
We all want to be good neighbours, but we are all competing for the same space. Is it possible to be good neighbours and to develop everything that the Government wants—yes or no? What is the one thing that each of you needs to do to make sure that that happens?
Does Tavish Scott want to start off on that?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
With regard to future meetings, we must also decide whether to consider our work programme in private. Do we agree to do that?
Members indicated agreement.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
If any witnesses think that we have missed out particular things in the plan, it would help if they commented on that. I will ignore Calum Duncan now, because I need to go to the next member, but if you have additional stuff that you would like to see, please come back to us. The next question will come from Mark Ruskell.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
Does Calum Duncan agree?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 12 December 2023
Edward Mountain
There is an assumption.
Clare, do you want to say anything?