The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2641 contributions
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 19 December 2024
Bob Doris
I do not want to ask too much more, given that a lot more information will be put into the public domain on 7 January, which is not very far away. However, I saw in my notes that there could be a potential implication in relation to the benefits cap. The Scottish Government mitigates the UK benefits cap in some respects—in relation to discretionary housing payments, for example—and it tries to avoid clawback on that. Is that another cost factor that might have to be taken into account? If the DWP claws money back because of that mitigation, that would have to be projected into the overall cost for us, which could be even higher.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 19 December 2024
Bob Doris
You will be glad to hear that this is not related to the evidence session. I would like to put something on the record. I have given the convener advance warning.
On 31 October, I suggested that Mr Balfour had questioned in the Scottish Parliament why we were building Scotland’s social security system and that he had said that it might be cheaper to simply run it from Westminster. I suggested that that was Mr Balfour’s consistent position. Mr Balfour quite forcefully disagreed, and I offered to apologise if I had misrepresented his parliamentary contributions. You will have guessed what is coming next, convener. Having checked the Official Report, I cannot find the position that I characterised in Mr Balfour’s parliamentary contributions. I can find that only in a blog that was written outwith the Parliament.
I therefore apologise for inaccurately representing Mr Balfour’s stated position in his contributions to the Scottish Parliament. I am disappointed that he is not here as I put that on the record, but I will reach out to him personally.
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 19 December 2024
Bob Doris
Briefly, should that be in your remit, Professor Roy? The Scottish Government works up the numbers. Others might say, “Well, it would work them up—it’s marking its own homework, so perhaps the Fiscal Commission should be doing that.” Should it be in your remit?
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 19 December 2024
Bob Doris
It might not matter in those terms, in relation to what you say about the aggregate position of the Scottish finances, but it certainly matters in our scrutiny role here, when we are trying to work out the long-term implications of UK decisions for policy decisions that the Scottish Government makes, as we are trying to do today.
Professor Roy articulated the position very well, but what I am trying to get at is that the winter fuel payment change was like a bolt out of the blue. It would not have been reasonable to have forecast what the risk was in relation to that, because most people did not expect the UK Government to do that. However, there is an expectation that there could be a squeeze on spend on disability payments in the UK.
Does the Scottish Fiscal Commission identify the risks of potential UK policy changes—because those are in the public domain and are being floated, if you like, proactively—then cost some of that and give it to the Scottish Government, or does the Scottish Government say, “Here are three things that have potential policy implications for Scotland—go and cost up our fiscal risk in relation to them”? Does any such proactive work happen, Professor Roy?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 17 December 2024
Bob Doris
What you are saying is that that should be attended to; in other words, it should not be allowed to happen without more significant compensation for the tenant.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 17 December 2024
Bob Doris
I am going to let everyone have one more cut at this, if that is okay, convener, because this is quite an important part of the legislation.
Mr Lean, you talked about unintended consequences in relation to some of this stuff and how they might disincentivise landowners from leasing. Do you have any further comments on that, after what we have heard? I want to capture the views of all the witnesses on this particular section, because the committee then has to reflect on them.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 17 December 2024
Bob Doris
The bill does not suggest that.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 17 December 2024
Bob Doris
I will hear Mr Wood and finally Mr Oates.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 17 December 2024
Bob Doris
I thank all four witnesses for helping me to get my head around that complex area in the bill. I have no further questions at this time.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 17 December 2024
Bob Doris
That is helpful.
I will bring in the other witnesses shortly but, given that you have a different view, Martin Hall, and that you spoke relatively briefly in relation to reviewing some of the arrangements in principle, how would you respond to some of the concerns that Hamish has put on the record this morning?