The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 52 contributions
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
My final question is on thresholds, which we talked about earlier. There has been some support in the discussions that we have had in recent weeks for adopting a cumulative approach. There might be projects that fall below the threshold and would not qualify—road building is the example that is often used—but if five or 10 projects were to be collected together, they would breach the threshold, and there might be a better understanding of—
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
No, I mean a collection of projects that would come under the threshold and would therefore not qualify. We have heard that there is some support for a cumulative approach that would group similar projects together and recognise that, collectively, they would go above the threshold and merit an assessment.
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
Over the past couple of weeks, we have taken evidence on the three strands of the joint budget review. I will focus on the net zero assessment strand. Last week, we heard from Lewis Barlow at WSP, who assessed the net zero assessment pilot. There has not been a formal response to the pilot. Is the Government intending to give a formal response to explain which recommendations it will take forward? Also, we heard from another witness that there was a lack of clarity on where we are in the process of rolling out net zero assessments.
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
I will come to more specific questions on recommendations, thresholds, cumulative approaches and those kinds of things. A number of recommendations were made following an assessment of the pilot. Have they all been taken forward?
You mentioned that net zero assessments have been rolled out, but there is also the question of the recommendations, the stage that they have reached in being taken forward, which ones have been accepted and which ones require further consideration.
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
It would be helpful if the Government could take that point away and consider whether more transparency can be built into that bit of the process, which might be post-decision. That would help to build confidence or knowledge among MSPs, because compromises will have to be made as we head towards net zero.
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
I think that the committee would be interested to find out whether there are opportunities for more transparency in relation to how the Government makes decisions. Collectively, around the Parliament and certainly on this committee, we want progress to be made in this area, so are there opportunities for the committee to have a better understanding of where compromises will be made? There will have to be compromises on policy decisions. It might be that you will explain that such opportunities are not possible, but there is an appetite to think about whether the committee or MSPs could be more involved in decisions that are made through the net zero assessment process, so that there would be more transparency. Therefore, one consideration is whether there are opportunities to influence the process. It might also be possible to get a better understanding of why a decision was made, so it might be that greater transparency around how and why decisions are made comes post-decision.
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
Okay—thank you.
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
Going forward, will the assessment include all policies? Will it also include resource and capital-intensive policies?
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
Perhaps it could be done within an established timescale. That might be something—
Climate Action Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 8 October 2026
Claire Baker
Thank you. That was helpful, and I look forward to receiving the correspondence.
Over the past few weeks, the committee has also looked at the net zero assessments and considered whether there could be more transparency and whether there will be an opportunity to influence what happens in the assessments. From the outside, it looks as though the net zero assessment will be carried out, at which point the Government will decide on any changes and what will go forward, and, once it goes through the taxonomy process, we will get more information that evaluates whether it has been positive or negative. I think that the Government has previously said to the committee that assessments would not be shared directly in the budget documents and that information would come into the public domain once it goes back to the taxonomy process. Over recent weeks, there has been discussion about whether there should be more opportunities in the net zero assessment phase for transparency on how decisions are made about what to take forward or what compromises are decided on at that stage.