The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1810 contributions
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
Thanks very much. That is good because those are things that we can look at.
Philip Rycroft mentioned one or two of those things, as well as regions in England. Do you have any reflections on how we fix where we have got to after Brexit?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
It has been really insightful to hear the collective experience and different perspectives that you have all given us this morning. It is very welcome.
I want to go back to the opening comments about the impact of Brexit on devolution and what needs to be fixed. I am thinking through those issues. Jim Gallagher, your paper contains a really interesting phrase: “constitutional carelessness”. William Wragg, a committee convener, said last week, “It’s politics”. This morning, Philip Rycroft said that it is the way that we have got used to working.
How do we move from here, where we feel that it is not working, to a system that will work? I am keen to hear your perspectives on what would be your priority. The evidence that we have had has included changing how the Governments work together; deciding whether the Governments should have to work together; dispute resolution and what that would look like; the possibility of entrenching Sewel; and interparliamentary work. What would be your priorities? How do you incentivise respect to make devolution work? You have been on the inside, in the civil service. If the question is too difficult, you do not have to answer, but I am thinking about how, practically, we can move on from here. What solutions should the committee be looking at to generate a bit of progress?
I am not sure who I want to come in first. Who looks most nervous about it? I am trying to be constructive and get solutions. Andrew McCormick, would you like to kick off?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
In your paper, you have given practical examples of how to do that parliamentary scrutiny. It is very much worth us looking at that.
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
I apologise for being slightly late to the start of the session.
To ask the Scottish Government whether it has plans to extend free bus travel to everyone under the age of 26. (S6O-01986)
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 9 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
Many students are now facing the cost of living crisis but do not qualify for the under-22 bus pass. I have met some of them who are struggling to cope financially, as getting to college or university, and part-time work too, can mean that they are paying in the region of £40 to £50 a week as a minimum just for bus travel.
Will the minister commit to considering the issue further? Will she talk to the National Union of Students Scotland to understand the barriers that many students face? It is not just about paying out now; it is about an investment in the future and in getting young people to commit to being on public transport for the future. That can only be good for our bus services and our climate.
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 2 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
When something is clearly a devolved issue, to what extent will you actively consult committees in the devolved legislatures in order not just to understand the politics of the situation, but to gain interparliamentary awareness, so that committee members can identify what the devolved tensions are in a formal way?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 2 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
That is helpful. I will leave that with you and your committee to think about. When you compare our report with the Senedd committee’s report, you can see that there are a lot of cross-overs. There is quite a range of people on our committee.
I will follow up on that question with Huw Irranca-Davies. I was very interested in your committee’s report, because of the cross-overs with what our committee thought. I want to hear your comments on solutions for interparliamentary and intergovernmental relations. I will start with interparliamentary relations, because you talked about your committee engaging directly with counterpart committees. What are the key lessons for developing solutions in respect of devolution across the UK?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 2 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
That is very interesting and helpful for our report. What about the intergovernmental solutions that you have suggested in your report? In particular, you mention two potential solutions—a formal dispute resolution procedure and an independent secretariat—to strengthen intergovernmental work. Were those proposals agreed on a cross-party basis in your committee?
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 2 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
Where is the disconnect, then? We received really strong representations from witnesses at last week’s committee meeting, which was backed up by the huge number of people who wrote in and by the campaigns that are being run. People are very worried about the loss of access to live performances.
Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee
Meeting date: 2 March 2023
Sarah Boyack
What kind of feedback have you had from the different Governments on those issues? To what extent are Governments prepared to provide for intergovernmental discussions, negotiations and transparency?