The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 172 contributions
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
Does that not refer to other misconduct cases in which there is an allegation of gross misconduct? That is my understanding. We are not talking about cases that would go anywhere near a court hearing; we are talking about accelerated misconduct hearings where there is an allegation of gross misconduct, which are not limited to cases with criminal convictions.
Does it not cause you concern that one of the Scottish Police Federation’s big concerns is that the regulations represent a big change and will be unfair to its members? Rob Hay said in his evidence that his members get only two days’ training for the hearings that they conduct, which alarms me. He also said that no two officers conduct hearings in the same way. Given that the regulations represent a big change, and that we have heard evidence that there is a lot of variation, do you understand the concerns from your ordinary rank-and-file officers about the regulations that we are being asked to sign off today?
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
Good morning. First, I have a quick technical question on the new regulations in relation to fast tracking to dismissal. Am I correct in my understanding that, regardless of the level of criminal offence—it could be a driving offence or any criminal offence—there would be fast tracking to dismissal under the new regulations? Or would there be a hearing, following a conviction?
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
We are talking about accelerated misconduct hearings, which are not limited to criminal convictions—they deal with other misconduct matters. Am I correct?
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
I welcome that, but would it not have been better to have done it beforehand? Another concern, which relates to the publication of misconduct outcomes, is that the Police Federation does not think that the proper safeguards are in place. So, it is about the balance between publishing reports of misconduct so that the public can see what is going on or what has happened with a complaint and ensuring that the proper safeguards are in place.
I have difficulty with the detail, because I have seen the exchange of letters from the federation to Kevin Lee, the head of the conduct department, in which the federation continues to express concerns about the lack of engagement, in contrast to the engagement that it had with the Scottish Government in 2014 when they worked together on the regulations. It mentioned that there were still 14 judicial reviews on the implementation of the conduct framework, several of which it won.
I am really struggling to understand why your whole department did not try to get more agreement with and more perception of fairness for those who are affected by the policy change. Many of those things have been put in the regulations that we did not see during the passage of the 2025 act.
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
I appreciate that—
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
I totally take your point that there must be trade-offs, but I will just finish my point. I confess that I have not been able to read everything—there is a lot, so I am trying to focus on areas of concern. The Police Federation is concerned about accelerated misconduct hearings—it does not seem to accept that the new procedure will remove the bias. It is also concerned about the variety of standards in relation to the current two-day training process; about the publication of the misconduct outcomes and the lack of safeguards; and about the extension of the removal of verbal warnings. As far as I can see, not many trade-offs have been going on here for those who are affected, which gives me real cause for concern. Although I want to be clear that I want a lot of the regulations to be enforced—I want change and modernisation—I am not comfortable with the fact that so many rank-and-file police officers seem to be unhappy about the balance of fairness.
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
I was not really expecting this technical instrument in relation to the sexual offences court. Are there going to be more? I know that you cannot answer that, but can we ask?
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
I, too, put on record my thanks to all those who gave evidence to the committee, and I thank the cabinet secretary and those from Police Scotland for their time.
First, it is unfortunate, looking back, that Dame Elish Angiolini’s “Independent Review of Complaints Handling, Investigations and Misconduct Issues in Relation to Policing: Final Report” is six years old but we are only now seeing the regulations, and a lot has changed. I fully support the views of the Government and the chief constable on increasing public confidence in policing, and for that reason I would be happy for us to pass some of the regulations without question.
There has been a lot of debate about numbers, and I am not sure that we have got to the bottom of that yet. Police Scotland reported that there are 52 live gross misconduct cases, and there were 424 assessments. That number is important, because it has been suggested that, if there was an independent legal chair for all officers, it would have to cover the 424, but that is unclear to me—it might just be the 52.
11:45
Fourteen officers were sacked this year for gross misconduct. That number is up, which is a sign that not everything in the current regulations is wrong. Maggie Chapman is right to raise the question of public confidence versus fairness. We have to decide where the balance lies in that regard.
I am pretty concerned about the bar for misconduct being too low. I note that there were seven cases that the Scottish Police Federation took and won. It filtered out the cases in which it felt that the bar was too low, and it won them all.
I understand the practicalities around independent chairs. As a practical question, aside from the question of fairness, I asked whether we would have enough people to appoint. However, the aspect that offends me most of all is the provision for accelerated misconduct hearings. We heard from many police officers who described their experience—we are talking not about criminal cases but about misconduct cases. There has been no attempt in the regulations, or in any other sphere that I can see, to fix the delay in misconduct cases. That bothers me.
It is almost as if everything has been thrown at the fast track for dismissal of officers where there has been criminal behaviour—and rightly so, to improve public confidence—but there is nothing in these regulations to alleviate the concerns about the current scandal of delays, with officers waiting several years just to have their case heard. That says to me that there is an unevenness in the way in which the regulations have been approached.
I mentioned in my lines of questioning regulation 16(c), which refers to a presenting officer. This is a much more adversarial process, obviously, but consideration could be given to gross misconduct before an investigation has been completed. In whose book is that a fair process?
On the question of training, we have had commitments that that will be looked at, but I would have preferred it if that had been addressed before the regulations came before us today. I am not content with the minor issues around the removal of verbal warnings and the extension of warnings up to five years—that seems extraordinary. I could be wrong—I will stand corrected if I am—but I do not know of any other such provisions.
On the publication of the outcome of misconduct hearings, the Scottish Police Federation is very concerned about that on behalf of its members, because not enough consideration has been given to safeguards. We know that, in these times, if allegations are put out in public that are then not proven, those allegations are still out there, so I do not think that that has been given enough consideration.
On the fast tracking of serious criminal cases, we have had to wrestle with some contradictory evidence. We heard from Lynn Ratcliff, who went through the matter in some detail, but we heard other evidence to suggest that the procedure does not require to wait until there is an appeal hearing or sentencing hearing, and that there could be a quicker process. It was suggested that that could be done in 35 days. The committee has to wrestle with those contradictory pieces of information and decide what to do about them.
In conclusion, although parts of the regulations need modernisation, it gives me cause for concern that there is such a wide gulf of disagreement between the Scottish Police Federation, the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents and the Government. Had the disagreement simply been on the appointment of independent legal chairs, I would be less concerned. I know that I got an answer to my question about engagement.
However, according to the Scottish Police Federation, there was a lot more close working on the 2014 regulations than there has been on those that we have before us. Again we have contradictory information on which to form a judgment. Even though I disagree with some of the content of the regulations, I would be much happier if there had been less disagreement with the regulations among the rank-and-file officers.
As Stephen Kerr rightly pointed out, if we do not recommend annulling the regulations today, we have some promises that we can pursue, but the regulations will come into force and that will be it. This is therefore a big decision for the committee.
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
Good morning. First, I thank Police Scotland for the work that you are doing, which I think is bold. I had the chance to go out with the team in Glasgow and see the seizure of an illegal e-bike, and I learned quite a lot from that.
As Stephen Kerr says, one issue is around the sale of bikes, whether they are Sur-Ron bikes or e-bikes that are meant for off-road use. There may also be a bit of ignorance around the modifying of bikes. It seems to me, as a layperson, that most of the e-bikes that I see have been modified. Is there any data on how many of the e-bikes that you have seized so far have been modified and how many have not?
Criminal Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 18 November 2026
Pauline McNeill
No bias there.
On the question of powers and what other parts of the UK are doing, I believe that Nottingham, and the UK Government, have been looking at on-the-spot fines for antisocial behaviour. This is where things get a little bit complicated, because you have these people riding on the roads, others riding on the pavement and so on. Would it be helpful if the police had the power to issue on-the-spot fines?