The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1604 contributions
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
I will not go into the detail of the options for change at the moment—you have put that on hold anyway—but I will talk about your budget asks. If you get what you want, will it give you more money to look at the list of fire stations that you are considering closing?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
Is there anything built into the budget for that added pressure? Have you asked for anything for that? I presume that you will not meet those time limits on day 1, but maybe you will.
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
In your submission, you also talked about the impact of the change in the law on corroboration. Obviously, the slight change in the law will mean more work for prosecutors, but does it necessarily mean that there will be a lot more cases? I am trying to ascertain what additional resource will be required for that law change.
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
Good morning. I will begin by asking John Logue about the time limits in the High Court, which we have discussed before. The Covid emergency time limit comes to an end in November, except for cases that have already started. I presume that that means that, at the end of November, we will go back to the time limits in the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995. What is the time period—does the Crown have 80 days to indict cases for the High Court?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
I understand that. What do you need from the Government in the budget, given what you have said to the committee about the likely increase in waiting times for the High Court?
Criminal Justice Committee Draft
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
Yes; it is not a straightforward question. I asked it only because, in the briefing for the meeting that I mentioned, the women said that, in their countries, where the selling of sex had been legalised, it became difficult to prove consent in a court of criminal law. I would be interested to hear whether you have any views on that.
I want to ask Detective Superintendent Bertram about cases where the sale of sex happens in brothels. We have looked at the situation in Germany, where an estimated 1.2 million men buy sex every day and where sex work was legalised in 2002. We have heard evidence that legalising or decriminalising sex work does not really affect brothels, and would not lead to a proliferation of them, but the experience in Germany would suggest otherwise. Do you have a view on that? As we have heard evidence on decriminalisation, I would be interested to hear your view on whether that would lead to more brothels, for example.
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
Liliana Torres Jiménez, you have spoken about the technicalities involved in the framing of the legislation. What is your view of the issue of consent, which is an issue in sexual offences such as rape?
Outside the committee, I went to a meeting held by Ash Regan, which was attended by women who had been involved in the sex trade in various countries such as Canada and Sweden. I appreciate that those countries have different laws. However, the women spoke about the difficulties there in prosecuting crimes of rape and other sexual offences that turn on the question of consent when the sale of sex is legal and—to use the phrase that they did—a contractual matter.
Do you see similar problems in Scotland for women who face the same threats as others who are involved in the sex trade and who might be the victims of crime even if the act of selling sex were to be lawful?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
If the sale of sex were to be lawful, would the issue of consent cause any difficulties in dealing with sexual crimes?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
Yes. We have heard a lot of evidence that we should just decriminalise it. However, if we did that, my concern would be that the harm to women who are involved in prostitution that we have spoken about—
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Pauline McNeill
Chief constable, I want to ask you first about the closure of police stations. A number have closed for different reasons, although it has mainly been for budget reasons. There is a list of proposed further police station closures, although I believe that some of those are being held back for the budget outcome. The situation is concerning for communities, as well as for police officers. If I consider my constituency in Glasgow, were Stewart Street station to close, Baird Street would be the nearest. There are implications for everyone.
If the Government acceded to your request for budgetary capital and revenue, what would that mean for those police stations? Would it give you room for manoeuvre to save some of them?