The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 865 contributions
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
I have a final question for the cabinet secretary. Do you agree in principle that research that is conducted using public funds should be made publicly available?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
I have a quick follow-up question for Dr Needle. You have mentioned today, and you have written to us about, scientific literature on the spawning behaviour of cod—specifically on movement up to 10m from the sea bed—which has affected the decision. Can you share with the committee the specific papers that you were referring to, please?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
Last week, we heard from Elaine Whyte of the Clyde Fishermen’s Association. When I asked her about the report, she said that those four reports were “nothing to do with” the Clyde Fishermen’s Association. She also said:
“we have nothing to do with the science. We just let the others use our vessels.”—[Official Report, Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee, 2 March 2022; c 18.]
If it is not the responsibility of the CFA, the Government or Marine Scotland science, whose responsibility is it to publish those findings and make them publicly available? Is it the responsibility of the University of St Andrews?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
Are you able to share with the committee exactly where the spawning cod were found? The consultation document says that they were found “in the closed area”. From what you have seen in the study, are you able to give us a specific location?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
You could always follow that up afterwards.
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
So, rather than allow—
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
Dr Needle, you are nodding.
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 9 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
I am not sure how everything works, but I will say what I think.
The closure has not been introduced fairly. I would like the Government to go away, rethink it and bring it back, if that is an option. If we need to annul the order for that to happen, on balance I support that.
I am concerned about the evidence base. I am supportive of a precautionary approach, but that needs to be balanced with economic factors and livelihoods. The Government has not got the balance right on that.
During the meeting, I have been looking at the research papers that were cited, and I cannot even see that thing about 5m to 10m above the sea bed; it seems to be based on tidal activity rather than fishing. I just do not feel that, on the whole, the approach is right. I therefore support the motion to annul.
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 2 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
Good morning. I think that I have understood this. You are saying that bycatch is the biggest of the main factors that impact on cod spawning that we have potential to do something about. With that in mind, can spatial management be a tool to reduce trawling bycatch? Is differentiation between different types of fishing in different areas a useful route to go down?
Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee
Meeting date: 2 March 2022
Mercedes Villalba
I have a quick question for Simon Macdonald. You seemed to suggest that predators, rather than fishers, are having the biggest impact on cod stock. However, research that I have seen from Marine Scotland science, in conjunction with the European Commission, states that
“a drastic reduction of juvenile whiting bycatch is necessary for the ... stock to recover”
and that
“Predation from grey seals had little impact overall”.
Will you share the evidence for your statement with the committee?