The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2002 contributions
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
Our next agenda item is taking evidence on the Children (Withdrawal from Religious Education and Amendment of UNCRC Compatibility Duty) (Scotland) Bill. This is our second evidence session on the bill, and this morning we will hear from two panels of witnesses.
I welcome our first panel. We are joined in the room by: Juliet Harris, director, Together (Scottish Alliance for Children’s Rights); Gina Wilson, head of strategy, Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland; and Gavin Yates, executive director, Connect. We are joined remotely by Louise Church, who is the Scottish Youth Parliament’s member for Galloway and West Dumfries and also a member of its education and lifelong learning committee.
We turn to questions from members. I ask our witnesses to indicate to me when they would like to come in to respond to a member’s question or to any of the points that are raised. Louise Church, if you wish to come in, please type R in the chat function and the clerks will bring that to my attention.
I will kick us off. Last week, the committee heard from three panels of witnesses. They were all quite critical of the bill in various ways, and they were not supportive of it. What are your thoughts on the general principles of the bill?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
I welcome our second panel of witnesses. Dr Douglas Hutchison is executive director of education at Glasgow City Council and is representing the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland, and Susan Quinn is the convener of the education committee at the Educational Institute of Scotland. Good morning and welcome to you. We will move straight to questions, and I will kick off.
We heard critical feedback from the three panels of witnesses last week, and we heard various critical views about the bill from this morning’s first panel. What are your views on the general principles of the bill?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
We have questions from Marie McNair, who is joining us remotely.
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
That concludes our questions. Thank you once again for joining us. We will discuss the remaining items on our agenda in private.
11:32 Meeting continued in private until 12:23.Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
We will move to questions from Maggie Chapman.
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
That brings our first session to a close. I thank all our witnesses for attending.
I will suspend the meeting briefly to allow a changeover of witnesses.
10:41 Meeting suspended.
10:45 On resuming—
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
We are going to move on to discuss part 2 of the bill. However, before we do that, what is your opinion on the fact that part of the bill amends the Education Act 1980, which is a UK act, and it will not be possible to challenge a breach of the amendments under the 2024 act, as the bill only covers acts of the Scottish Parliament? What is your view on whether part 1 of the bill achieves its objective of complying with the UNCRC, as well as providing coherence and clarity of the process for withdrawal from religious observance and religious and moral education? Do you have any further thoughts on that approach?
10:15Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 7 October 2025
Karen Adam
I appreciate the dry and technical nature of the points that the witnesses have made today, but it is important that we get them on the record. I say to Gina Wilson that, if she wants to send us the amendments that she referred to, we would appreciate it, as it would allow us to understand where those views are coming from. We have a fantastic team at the Scottish Parliament that supports MSPs in understanding any legalese and helping us to make headway on these things.
We now have questions from Marie McNair, who joins us remotely.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 2 October 2025
Karen Adam
New figures from Energy Action Scotland show that energy debt has soared to a record £4.4 billion in just four years, with vulnerable Scots burdened with £400 million of that. It is a disgrace that, in an energy-rich country, so many people are in fuel poverty, and especially that, under a Labour United Kingdom Government that pledged to cut bills, the energy price cap has risen again to £1,755. Does the First Minister share my concern that Labour—the UK Government—has lost control of the cost of living crisis? Can he set out what the Scottish Government is doing to support households in the face of the UK Government’s inaction?
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 1 October 2025
Karen Adam
It is important to recognise something that we do not say nearly enough in the Parliament: Scotland has fantastic schools that are led by great teachers and filled with hard-working young people. Too often we talk about education in the Parliament as if our pupils are a problem to be solved, which I find incredibly insulting and frustrating. Childhood and adolescence are not problems; they are very normal stages in human development that are full of learning and growth. Our job is to support that journey, not reduce it to soundbites that paint young people in the worst possible light.