Skip to main content
Loading…

Chamber and committees

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Filter your results Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Session 6: 13 May 2021 to 8 April 2026
  7. Current session: 14 May 2026 to 16 November 2026
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 15 contributions

|

Health, Care and Sport Committee [Draft]

Subordinate Legislation

Meeting date: 7 October 2026

Maree Todd

Thank you for the opportunity to speak to the committee about the order.

The order removes an unjustified difference between the rights of civil and forensic mental health patients. It will allow the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland to specify, review and modify recorded matters for patients subject to compulsion orders, compulsion orders with restriction orders, hospital directions and transfer-for-treatment directions.

A recorded matter is a treatment, care or a service that the tribunal considers appropriate to specify formally. It may relate to medical treatment, rehabilitation, communication support or discharge planning. That provision is already available to patients who are subject to civil compulsory treatment orders.

In October 2022, the Court of Session held that the absence of an equivalent power for patients subject to a compulsion order amounted to unjustified discrimination under article 14 of the European convention on human rights, and the Scottish Government accepted that legislation was needed to remedy that.

The order extends the remedy across the main relevant forensic orders. We consider that fair, coherent and proportionate, as limiting it to compulsion orders would leave patients on other forensic orders without equivalent access.

The order will integrate recorded matters into existing review and tribunal processes. It will enable patients and named persons to seek modifications, place duties on relevant professionals and Scottish ministers, and provide a route back to the tribunal where a recorded matter is not delivered.

Our consultation received 23 responses, which broadly supported the policy intention. Respondents highlighted the need for clear guidance, accessible information, advocacy and legal support, alongside concerns about capacity and service availability. We are working with delivery partners to address those points.

This is a targeted change. Around 635 people were subject to the relevant forensic orders on 1 January 2025, based on the most recent data available from the Mental Welfare Commission. The estimated number of recorded matter cases is around 19 to 64 each year. The additional activity should be modest and largely accommodated through existing processes.

We acknowledge that progressing the remedy has taken some time. However, the work required careful legal development across several forensic orders and completion of the statutory remedial order process. Subject to Parliament’s approval, the changes will take effect from 13 November 2026.

This is a necessary, rights-based and proportionate reform. It addresses the incompatibility that was identified by the court and supports parity between civil and forensic patients. I invite the committee to recommend that the order be approved.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

Well, it is nearby. A unit within the mainstream school supports children with additional support needs, and the work that it is doing is phenomenal. When I asked the teachers specifically about how supported they felt in their training and in their ability to support those young learners, they told me that one of the most important things for them was their access to the full multidisciplinary team, which visits the school. When those specialists come in, they sometimes support individual children, but they also often help staff to support learners in their learning. Staff are clearly supporting parents to do that, too.

I want that to happen everywhere. One of the reasons that I visited that school was that we had announced £7.6 million of funding to support community interventions for neurodivergence, and I would like to see the quality of care and learning that happens there to take place everywhere.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

That is a fair summary, but you did not mention the increase in the number of people who are seeking support. Ten years ago, when we first considered an LDAN bill, there was a low level of awareness, particularly in relation to neurodivergence—people did not know about it or understand what it was. Since then awareness has greatly increased, and many more people—the number has sometimes increased by several hundred percent—are seeking diagnosis, assessment and support in many parts of our country. We cannot fix the problem overnight, as much as we would all wish to. There will need to be a process to ensure that people get support. People will, to an extent, need to be triaged, and we will need to build a system that can respond to the level of need.

That will not happen overnight, but I am committed to it happening, because I agree with you. I know that you were focused on the LDAN bill and that you did a lot of work to ensure that it became a commitment of the Scottish Government. Yesterday, I met a lived experience advisory panel, and I share its disappointment at the change of direction. However, at this time, I need to focus on improving service delivery, not on creating legislation that gives people expectations and rights that cannot be upheld unless there is a system that has been built to respond to those needs. We are not for a second deprioritising that work; we are just shifting our focus to practical improvements, policy reform and targeted investment to get a more rapid impact, which is what we all want to see.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

How do I unpick all that? We need to be very careful in how we talk about drugs and harm reduction. It is not an either/or when it comes to rehab and harm reduction strategies, which might cover opioid substitution therapy, right up to facilities like the Thistle, which are safe injection rooms.

This week, published statistics showed that we not only met our target of increasing the number of publicly funded placements in residential rehab to 1,000, but actually exceeded the number this year. That means that, during the national mission period—from 2020 to 2026—there has been a 60 per cent increase in access to residential rehab.

It is a really vexing, difficult problem. More than 1,000 people die of drug harm every year, with all of the tragedy and cost that that causes in our communities. We need to take many measures and many steps in order to tackle drug harm.

11:15

With regard to opioid substitution therapy, it is important that we look at the evidence. You are a vet, so you will be used to evidence-based medicine. The evidence would suggest that opioid substitution reduces the risk of death by around 70 per cent for individuals. In a country that is facing a huge level of drug-related deaths, we must not rule out evidence-based approaches to tackling that harm. Opioid substitution therapy is not the be-all and end-all, and it is not the end of treatment for people; very often, it is the start.

I would say that the Thistle has been a life-saving intervention. We get regular data around it. There is zero evidence to support your claim that it encourages drug use.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

We made a commitment in our manifesto to publish the long-term conditions framework next year, and it will be published early next year. I am grateful for all the work that has been done by people with lived experience and other stakeholders. There has been lots of third sector involvement and I think we will come up with a really good framework that everyone will be satisfied with and will be able to work to.

On the issue of ME, as you said, we have put £4.5 million into health boards and they have now received that money. My experience of asking my local health board—NHS Highland—what it had done with the money was slightly different from yours, convener, because I found out that it is setting up and building a service.

As is sometimes the case, its communication with individuals who had been involved in developing the service was not great, so the feedback loop to people with lived experience who had helped to shape the service was not great, but I am hoping that that will improve. I am very happy to go back and see what is happening to that money nationally, then come back to the committee in future with details on what the service is shaping up to look like around the country.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

First, yes, you can expect to see population-level measures in the alcohol harm prevention plan. We have made great progress in recent years, but we have not gone far enough. In fact, the most recent statistics showed that approximately 1,200 people died of directly alcohol-attributable causes last year. That is only the tip of the iceberg—those are, largely, the people who are dying of liver disease. The number is higher than the number of those who are dying of drug-related causes, and the issue affects every community in Scotland.

We are not very good at identifying alcohol-related deaths in which alcohol is only one factor. About one in 10 breast cancer cases include alcohol as an attributable factor. Alcohol contributes to several cancers, cardiovascular disease and a range of ill health issues that we do not accurately measure. What we do accurately measure are directly alcohol-attributable deaths.

When it comes to lumping alcohol and drugs together, there is a lot of commonality across the broad spectrum of substance use. You are talking to a pharmacist—I think of all those individual drugs, and I think of alcohol as a drug. The substantial difference with alcohol is that it is legal and culturally condoned. It is not only a legal drug; it has a particular status in Scotland, which means that you need to take a different approach to tackling alcohol harm. There is a level of alcohol consumption that can be considered safe, but the medical evidence suggests that alcohol is a health-harming substance.

It is not wrong to consider alcohol and drugs together, but there is no doubt that there are times when different approaches need to be taken, simply because alcohol is a legal drug and drugs are largely illegal and drug use is largely illicit.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

Thank you very much for that question. I expect the alcohol harm prevention plan to be published pretty soon; I cannot give you a specific date, but we are working hard on it at the moment and I expect it to appear in the next couple of months.

Inequality is at the heart of all that work. There is a clear inequality in mortality and morbidity for individuals experiencing harm from alcohol, and a similar but wider inequality exists for drugs. It is really important that all our work on substance use disorders takes those inequalities into account. We spoke earlier about work that is going on in prevention, and the cabinet secretary has mentioned a couple of times that 80 per cent of people’s health is influenced by factors other than healthcare, which we see very starkly with alcohol and substance use. You are absolutely correct, including on gender inequality: it is men who are dying, and men from more socioeconomically deprived backgrounds.

Population health measures work very well for those men. Minimum unit pricing for alcohol is the most significant policy that we have introduced to tackle alcohol harm over the past decade or so, and the modelling suggests that it has saved hundreds of lives. It has prevented hundreds of deaths and averted hundreds of alcohol-attributable hospital admissions, and its impact has been greatest in the areas of highest deprivation, with the largest impact for those living in the 40 per cent most deprived communities. Sometimes, instead of thinking that we have to target individuals, we find that population-level measures work best in the areas where the harm is worst.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

That highlights the tension and the real area of challenge for politics, politicians and people who are involved in the public debate about those issues. Should we provide people with information that might help them to make choices that reduce harm, and should we support them to take drugs in a less harmful way, or to choose less harmful drugs, which is the question that you put to me, or does that simply encourage drug taking? That is the real tension at the heart of this.

As a public health minister, and as a health professional, I am very focused on approaching the issue from a public health perspective and reducing the harm that I see happening across Scotland right now.

You are absolutely correct to point to the harm resulting from ketamine use. It is one of several drugs that have burst on to our scene. One of the challenges that we face in tackling drug harm is that it involves an ever-changing scene and an ever-changing market. As a pharmacist, I was astonished to hear that people are using ketamine recreationally, but it is being used widely, and its chronic use can undoubtedly cause irreversible bladder harm. As you pointed to, in the north-east, a whole new service has had to be built to respond to that level of harm.

Some public health initiatives to inform people are happening. One of the challenges is that we need to be agile. I talked about the ever-changing market. Over the past few years, we have invested in a system that has brought strong benefits to Scotland: the rapid action drug alerts and response—RADAR—system, which picks up on changes in drug use and the drug market. It very quickly highlights to people on the front line—those who are working in substance use services and those who are using drugs—the associated harms. We do not see that information because we are not on that scene, so you and I will miss out on that very rapid response that comes out to the population, but the people who need to see it are aware of it.

Young people are just amazing. I have met individuals who have experienced irreversible harm from ketamine use but, through TikTok and other means that young people use to communicate, they are explaining to the population what happened to them. They are bravely saying, “Here is my experience, and here is why you need to avoid this happening to you.” That peer-to-peer education is one of our most powerful means of raising awareness and reducing harm.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

We have been working on that for a period of time, and it is a major ambition in Scotland. Again, there are great pockets of work—in Badenoch and Strathspey, which, of course, has the natural asset of the amazing environment, they are really good at including options for social prescribing in their healthcare. However, that is not happening consistently around Scotland. I have had exciting conversations with representatives of our culture sector and our sport and physical activity sector, and we are pretty keen to bring social prescribing into a proper framework that means that it is accessible for everyone in Scotland.

Social prescribing is an amazing opportunity. On physical activity, for example, if we could get people moving more, that would be like a magic pill, except that you could not overdose on it. Physical activity is a phenomenal intervention, but it is quite hard to fit it into the health service, because we are very focused on medical interventions. However, we are working on that, because we recognise that we could make enormous progress through social prescribing.

Health, Care and Sport Committee

Scottish Government Priorities

Meeting date: 16 September 2026

Maree Todd

I welcome the opportunity to be here and to talk about my very broad-ranging portfolio.

With regard to neurodiversity, you are absolutely correct. There has been an increased level of demand for services, which has caused a real challenge within the system. That has happened not just in Scotland, but all over the UK and, in fact, all over the world. We find our system overwhelmed.

We have committed to improving the system. We have committed to adopting a four-tier system for adults, as recommended by the Royal College of Psychiatrists in Scotland. The work started on that some time ago and, over the summer, I had a round-table meeting with a wide range of stakeholders to consider how we can implement the four-tier system. We have not quite decided what to call it—there is talk of a four-tier, four-level or four-phase model. It provides a number of ways for people to access care. The important thing is that individuals with neurodivergence need to be able to access support when and where they need it.

At the moment, we are very much focused on diagnosis, but although that is important, diagnosis is not the be-all and end-all. What people really need is support, and we are building a system of support for both adults and children.

The picture is slightly different for children than it is for adults, because of the work that we are doing with the education system. A number of pieces of work are under way, including the implementation of the recommendations of the McManus review, which will make a difference. However, the principle is the same: people should be able to access the right support, at the right time, where they need it and when they ask for it. Of course, we have an overarching system for children—getting it right for every child, or GIRFEC—which makes clear that there is no need to wait for a diagnosis in order to provide support. A child’s needs should be assessed. Every child has a right to access education, and any adaptations that need to be made can be put in place as soon as they are required.