The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 157 contributions
Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 17 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
Yes, convener. Although the action that we will take based on the general reporting grounds is satisfactory, it is worth noting that this is another example of poor legislative housekeeping on the part of the Government and that these commencement regulations ought to have superseded the existing statute seven years ago. That is quite a glaring oversight, so it would be good to understand what provisions the Government will put in place so that this sort of error will not occur again and we can be satisfied that, with regard to this kind of issue, the letter of the law is aligned more thoroughly with practice.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
Noting that we have several petitions on women’s health, and given the proposal to create petitions debates, this would certainly be a likely candidate for an early debate in the committee’s work, in addition to the evidence session that was mentioned. That is a set of worthwhile actions.
I thank Elizabeth Crammond for taking the time to attend today.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
This is a reasonable point at which to join up our work with that of the Transport Committee, mindful of the legislation that will be coming through, as well as additional work that that committee might be doing.
I think that we are minded to keep the petition open and to pursue the actions that have been proposed. The clear issue is the point made by the traffic commissioner for Scotland. I wonder whether we want to engage with the traffic commissioner on the matter, if that would be helpful. Do members of the committee agree to that?
Members: Yes.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
That sounds good. We will take on the actions suggested. I really appreciate colleagues attending today, as well as members of the campaign, who have expressed a complex area of policy very succinctly and very well to committee members and to members of the public alike. Thanks very much for all your work.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
Thanks to both of our colleagues for attending today and expressing so many compelling proposals for the petition.
I turn to members of the committee for any further thoughts or actions to propose for the petition.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
Our next petition is PE2235, which was lodged by Stephen David Jelfs and published on 29 July. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to introduce legislation requiring the mandatory registration of all publicly accessible automated external defibrillators on the Circuit national defibrillator network database and to establish a legal duty on AED owners or guardians to undertake regular and compulsory inspection, maintenance and readiness checks so that devices remain rescue ready and available for use during sudden cardiac arrest emergencies.
10:15
The Scottish Parliament information centre’s briefing explains that there is currently no legal requirement to register AEDs on the Circuit, but notes that for community groups and others who receive funding for an AED, registration on the Circuit is a common condition of funding. The briefing indicates that many AEDs conduct regular self-checks, but that owners and guardians are encouraged to check them regularly. Although there is no universal legal requirement for AEDs to be regularly checked and maintained, some AED owners may have legal duties under related legislation.
In its submission, the Scottish Government states that it does not consider the asks of the petition to be justified by the available evidence, citing that there is insufficient international evidence to demonstrate that mandatory registration and inspection regimes result in improved cardiac arrest outcomes. It adds that there is a risk that introducing additional legislative requirements could have unintended consequences by creating barriers to the purchase, deployment, and maintenance of public access AEDs. The Scottish Government indicates that its position is informed by the best available evidence and expert advice and that it works closely with the Save a Life for Scotland partnership and the University of Edinburgh’s Resuscitation Research Group—the RRG. It refers to an informal briefing that it received from the RRG, which concluded that the current evidence base is insufficient to determine whether legislation would lead to greater preparedness for cardiac arrest than the well-supported voluntary system. The Scottish Government also refers to a recent announcement by the First Minister of a £2.5 million investment to further improve outcomes from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, with that funding expected to support the installation of between 1,000 and 1,250 AEDs across Scotland.
In his written submission, PE2235/B, the petitioner welcomes the investment and the Scottish Government’s commitment to improving survival rates from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. He argues, however, that the Scottish Government’s response does not address the core issue that is raised in his petition. He contends that a lack of international evidence does not, in and of itself, demonstrate that mandatory registration and maintenance is unnecessary. He also considers that the Government’s proposal to identify local guardians is an acknowledgement that somebody must accept responsibility for AED readiness. The petitioner believes that the issue is whether the current voluntary arrangements can provide assurance that AEDs will be ready for use when they are needed. For example, he argues that that should include knowing how many AEDs are in Scotland and how many of those are registered, have an identified guardian and are properly and regularly maintained.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action on the petition?
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
That sounds as though it is a reasonable set of actions. Are members happy with the suggestions?
Members indicated agreement.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
Thank you. I appreciate your taking the time to attend. I turn to members of the committee to express any further views.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
I thank the petitioner for her submission, and we will take those actions forward.
Public Petitions Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 5 November 2026
Paul Sweeney
Do members agree to that suggestion?
Members indicated agreement.