I suggest that he should drill down into that issue in some detail and consider low incomes, the fact that the annual survey of hourly earnings ignores people who work less than 18 hours a week, the fact that Scotland is still exporting many of its skilled high earners, the fact that many people are in part-time work or have short-term contracts and the fact that the reason why we have exceeded the Lisbon target for women in the workforce is because many Scottish women are in the workforce because of basic family necessity.