Dr Roger Smyth, Chair of the Legislative Oversight Forum of the Royal College of Psychiatrists in Scotland, explained the different considerations that inform the process of appointing a named person when he gave evidence to the Committee:
There is a balance to be struck here between, on the one hand, upholding the rights of individuals to have a named person of their choice and for as many people who want a named person to be able to identify and notarise them and, on the other, ensuring that people are not placed in the position of becoming a named person unwillingly, unknowingly or without proper scrutiny of the roles that they would be expected to undertake.