Consequently, a pilot ran from November 2003 for two years in Edinburgh, Ayr and Kilmarnock and a full evaluation was undertaken and published.Key findings from the pilot were that, although take-up rates in other jurisdictions averaged around 30 per cent, the take-up in Scotland was quite low at just under 15 per cent, which was partly because the Scottish pilot included many relatively minor crimes. Response rates varied from nil for fire-raising, to 60 per cent for murder and causing death by dangerous driving, and included 46 per cent for rape and 51 per cent for sexual offences excluding rape.