Retrieved from http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/S5PrivateBillsProposals/Scottish_Government_Written_Submission.pdf [accessed 31 August 2017]In the additional information provided to the Committee the Promoters confirmed that consideration was given to continuing the right to appeal provisions in the 1846 Act but that it was decided, on balance, not to do so for the following reasons—
the values which underpin the calculation of the annual assessments are set out in the Bill (which was not the case in the 1846 Act);
the only variable factor is the amount of the Commission's budget;
there is therefore much less scope for challenge compared to the 1846 Act and challenges are only likely to be made because of—
- an error in an assessment (in which case a heritor would not be obliged to pay and the matter would be resolved directly with the Commission);
- the budget being too high (which, as previously discussed, would not be the case as Commissioners are heritors and can and will only set the budget to cover what is necessary);
- or as a result of revaluation of the assumed and base values, or amendment to a land category (the Bill provides many...