In setting out the Scottish Government's reasons for wanting to have a pilot, the Policy Memorandum (para 565) notes that:
While important research into single judge rape trials has been conducted in other jurisdictions as identified by an international evidence briefing on alternatives to jury trials commissioned by the working group,iSee Alternatives to Jury Trials: an evidence briefing (mentioned above when discussing the Lady Dorrian Review Governance Group). the Scottish Government shares the ultimate conclusion of Lady Dorrian's Review that it is only by studying these in the context of our justice system that we can form an objective and informed understanding of their impact in Scotland...