Education, Children and Young People Committee Stage 1 Report on the Children (Care, Care Experience and Services Planning) (Scotland) Bill. Retrieved from https://digitalpublications.parliament.scot/Committees/Report/ECYP/2025/12/17/2cf08836-9408-4f29-bba4-66d6e593f033#5627952a-4dbf-4dc3-8600-b0921a279113.dita:
called for the Scottish Government to explore how Bill provisions on aftercare and a register of foster carers could be brought within scope of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024 (UNCRC Act)
asked for further information about aftercare eligibility, highlighting that under the provisions in the Bill, those leaving care prior to the age of 16 would have to request assessment before they could be considered for support
called for further work to ensure costings for aftercare provisions were accurate, as stakeholders had raised concerns about figures used being an underestimate and out of date
recommended mandatory training for all corporate parents
asked the Scottish Government for a response to stakeholder concerns that expanded corporate parenting duties could lead to state intrusion
recommended that the Bill should include a definition of 'independent advocacy' and, in the absence of this, there should be clarity around who qualifies for lifelong advocacy
stated an opt-out model of advocacy should be explored for the children's hearings system
stated that the Bill's lack of a clear definition of care experience was "unhelpful", suggesting the Bill could include a duty to develop regulations to define care experience
sought further information on proposals to limit profit in residential care, including how the Scottish Government proposes to define 'excessive profit'
stated the Committee's support for proposals requiring Independent Fostering Agencies (IFAs) to become registered charities, as long as there was sufficient lead-in time to secure a smooth transition
called for further information about the proposed register of foster carers, including where responsibility for the register would lie
raised concerns about proposals for single member panels in the children's hearings system, calling for the Scottish Government to respond to this and other concerns raised in relation to hearings system proposals
expressed support for the introduction of paid Chairs in the hearings system, seeking further information about the plans for transition
expressed uncertainty about the addition of paid specialist panel members to the children's hearings system, highlighting stakeholder concerns about the potential for power imbalances and calling for clarity from the Scottish Government on the role of specialist members
welcomed the removal of the obligation for children and young people to attend their hearing, but stated the belief that this should be replaced with a presumption to attend (with the exception of babies and very young children) and steps should be taken to increase participation
raised concerns about proposals for post-referral discussions with the Principal Reporter, stating that this should instead be an opportunity to meet with the Chair of the Hearing
raised concerns about proposals around establishing 'grounds' for a children's hearing, stating these risked making the process "significantly more complex" and calling for section 14 of the Bill to be revisited
stated support for automatic 'relevant person' status for parents or those with parental rights to attend hearings to be removed in prescribed circumstances
highlighted concerns around proposed changes to the test for referral to the Principal Reporter meaning some children and young people may miss out on support
welcomed the addition of 'support' to the statutory referral criteria of 'protection, guidance, treatment or control' and called for the Scottish Government to work toward removal of the terms 'treatment' and 'control'
raised concerns in relation to a lack of understanding around the Bill's proposals for Integration Joint Boards (IJBs) to join local authorities and health boards on the list of bodies required to plan children's services, stating the intended purpose of the changes was unclear.