We are not in a position to comment on the accuracy of the report, but we do not think that it is appropriate that Governments should cite and rely on figures that cannot be shown to be independent or objective.The PACEC report concluded that £240 million is generated by the shooting industry, yet figures from VisitScotland's UK tourism survey estimate that visitor spend from shooting, stalking and hunting amounts to £20 million, in comparison with the £160 million that is generated by people who come to Scotland to watch wildlife and birds—that is, to enjoy our wildlife rather than to kill it.