As set out in a letter to Willie Rennie MSP on 3 September 2015, having carefully considered the matter, including taking advice from the Permanent Secretary, the First Minister is satisfied that the decision taken by the Cabinet Secretary for Culture, Europe and External Affairs to award funding was based solely on the merits of the case following an objective assessment by Scottish Government officials. Neither the cabinet secretary’s decision nor the objective assessment undertaken by officials was in any way influenced by factors external to the merits of the case.