When questioned in June 2018, Scottish Government officials said there was not evidence that the Commission would require statutory footing in order to provide valuable advice.iiEnvironment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee, Official Report, 19 June 2018, Col 16 Still the Cabinet Secretary noted that she was open to having an "upfront debate"iiEnvironment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee, Official Report, 8 May 2018, Col 31 about it, including what the practical implications of this would be.