Chamber and committees

The Capital Spending Review sets the broad parameters for Scottish Budgets to 2025-26 as best can be done at this time and outlines high-level spending plans to deliver Programme for Government and Bute House commitments. This is against a backdrop of real-term reductions in the capital grant provided by UK Government.

Whilst the CSR sets out high-level multi-year spending parameters, it does not provide the Scottish Government with the authority to spend public funds. Annual budgets will continue to be set through the annual parliamentary budget Bill process and the annual budget will be based on the latest fiscal information.

The Pig Producers Hardship Support Scheme was first published in August 2021, when a £715,000 fund was made available. All 39 applications received were successful, totalling a spend of approximately £654,000.

In February 2022, the scheme was extended to offer a further £680,000 and had 32 applicants, leading to a total spend of c£675,000. There were no unsuccessful applications.

In June 2022, a further extension to the scheme of £410,000 saw 32 applications, with no unsuccessful applicants. The total spend for this third and final round of the Pig Hardship Scheme is estimated at £406,000 with payments to be made by the end of August.

This amounts to c£654,000 being paid out in 2021 and approximately £1,081,000960 to be paid in total this calendar year. Due to the nature of the scheme, the same applicants could apply for multiple rounds of support.

Since 2016, the Scottish Government has worked with 63 individuals who are public figures on 104 occasions as part of communication campaigns delivered via the central Scottish Government Marketing Team. Of those 63 individuals, 4 have been part of a Scottish Government television advert. The remaining 59 have been involved through social media advertising, digital or public relations activity only. The Scottish Government does not hold details of communications activity undertaken by agencies.

The public figures who have worked with the Scottish Government on communications campaigns since 2016 are: Amber Zoe (Presenter); Arabella Weir (Actress); Barbara Dickson (Singer); Boogie (DJ); Bruce Fumey (Comedian); Callum Gallacher (DJ); Carol Smillie (TV Presenter); Cassi Gillespie (Radio Presenter); Cat Cubie (Presenter); Cat Harvey (Presenter); Charlie Reid (Musician); Chris Brookmyre (Author); Clare Grogan (Singer); Craig Reid (Musician); Des Clarke (Comedian); Dougray Scott (Actor); Dr Punam Krishan (TV Doctor); Edith Bowman (DJ/Presenter); Edward Reid (Performer); Elaine C Smith (Actress); Eunice Olumide (Model); Ewen Cameron (Presenter); Fred MacCauley (Comedian); Gail Porter (Presenter); Gary Maclean (Chef); Gavin Mitchell (Actor); Gordon Clark (Musician); Grant Stott (Presenter); Hayley Scanlan (Fashion Designer); Heather MacRae (Golfer); Huw Jones (Rugby Player); Iain Stirling (Comedian); Jackie MacNamara (Footballer); Jai McDowall (Singer); Jane McCarry (Actor); Janey Godley (Comedian); Jennifer Reoch (Presenter); Keryn Matthew (Miss Scotland); Kieron Achara (Basketball Player); Laura Boyd (Reporter); Laura Fraser (Actress); Lawrence Chaney (Drag Queen); Leah MacRae (Actress); Lee Craigie (Cyclist); Les McKeown (Musician); Lorraine Kelly (Presenter); Lorraine McIntosh (Musician); Mac Twins (DJ/Authors); Mark Cox (Comedian); Mollie Hughes (Explorer); Moyo Akande (Actress); Nicola Roy (Actress); Peter Sawkins (Baker); Raman Bhardwaj (Reporter); Ricky Ross (Musician); River City Cast (TV); Ruaridh Jackson (Rugby Player); Sanjeev Kohli (Comedian); Scott Hastings (Rugby Player); Shaheeda Sinckler (Singer); Simon Donnelly (Footballer); Sir Alex Ferguson (Football Manager); Stuart Hogg (Rugby Player).

On 44 occasions there was no payment to the public figure. For the balance, the fee paid to each individual is part of a commercial negotiation between the appointed agency to produce the campaign, within an overall agreed production budget, and the relevant individual. Therefore, this is either information not held by the Scottish Government or it cannot be disclosed as this would release confidential financial information relating to the services offered by each individual. However, historical Freedom of Information requests relating to the “Stop The Spike” campaign featuring Janey Godley has resulted in that fee being published following agreement it could be released. The fee in that instance was £10,000.

Treatment at the specialist service provided by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is targeted specifically at those who have experienced transvaginal mesh complications. This is in recognition of the painful and life changing side effects experienced by some women who have received transvaginal mesh implants. The creation of specialist centres of this nature was a recommendation of the Independent Medicines and Medical Devices Safety Review, and the centre in Glasgow forms part of a network of similar centres in other parts of the UK.

I would strongly encourage anyone who suspects that their mesh implant is related to symptoms they are experiencing to contact their GP in the first instance, regardless of whether that is a transvaginal implant or another form of mesh. GPs act as a gateway to care provided by other parts of the NHS and can therefore ensure that patients can see the right person at the right place at the right time, in a safe, effective and efficient manner.

The UK is currently experiencing the worst ever outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI). Prior to this, the largest outbreak involved 26 cases of HPAI in the UK in 2020/2021 and 13 cases in 2016/2017. In contrast, as of 28 July 2022, there have been 127 premises confirmed as infected with HPAI H5N1 within the UK: eleven in Scotland, five in Wales, six in Northern Ireland and 105 in England.

Of the total cases in the UK, only three have been gamebird premises, with none of these being in Scotland.

However, what has impacted the UK gamebird industry this year is the considerable number of HPAI cases in France, where approximately 80% of partridge chicks and 50-60% of pheasant chicks for the UK industry are sourced. Many of these source farms are caught up in disease control zones. Therefore, movement restrictions on both live birds and eggs are in place.

The Scottish Government supports farmers during the ongoing UK-wide avian influenza outbreak through the provision of timely advice and guidance to poultry and other captive bird keepers on risks, legal requirements and biosecurity. This information is made available through social media, news releases and on gov.scot, as these continue to be vital tools in protecting birds.

Compensation is paid for birds humanely euthanased as part of our disease response in line with valuation tables, which are updated regularly by the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA) on behalf of the Scottish Government. The Scottish Government do not compensate for any dead or visibly ill birds, which is in line with the policy in England and Wales.

The Scottish Government has reminded keepers that the Avian Influenza Prevention Zone (AIPZ), and associated robust biosecurity measures, remain in place across Scotland (and the rest of GB). These measures include keeping their flocks separate from wild birds.

If a larger poultry or other captive bird business is situated in a disease control zone, there may be trade issues associated with regionalisation. The Scottish Government works with the Defra Market Access and Veterinary Trade Facilitation teams, who liaise with poultry industry stakeholders and the APHA Centre for International Trade (CIT) to understand and address issues and priorities for poultry exports.

Defra Market Access also liaise with British Embassy colleagues globally to answer trade related queries from Central Competent Authorities, provide updates to third country trading partners and seek clarity in terms of trade where required. The Scottish Government works with a range of partner organisations and agencies to support affected businesses where required.

The Scottish Government has also made an additional £1 million of funding available to APHA to cover the agency’s additional expenses associated with tackling the current avian influenza outbreak.

The Scottish Government is mindful of the use of mesh in non-transvaginal settings. In February 2018, the then-Chief Medical Officer wrote to NHS Scotland Medical Directors about public interest in the use of mesh implants, including in hernia repair. Medical Directors were asked to ensure that clinicians offer patients all appropriate options for surgery, as well as the option of no surgery. In addition, the importance of shared decision making, informed consent and listening and acting upon patients’ concerns was noted.

Furthermore, the Scottish Government has commissioned the Scottish Health Technologies Group (SHTG) to produce two reports on the use of mesh in hernia repair; the first published in January 2020 and the second in December 2021 . These reports, based on current published evidence, support the continued use of mesh in a variety of abdominal wall and groin hernia subject to all the tenets of Realistic Medicine – ensuring shared decision making and informed consent with knowledge of the benefits, risks alternative measures and the possibility of doing nothing. The findings of the reports have been discussed with professional bodies, including the Royal Colleges and the British Hernia Society.

The Chief Medical Officer (CMO) wrote to the Board Chief Executives and Medical Directors in December 2021 to draw their attention to the SHTG report. In the letter, the CMO asked Health Boards to consider the availability of non-mesh surgery, how best to address skill gaps, if they exist, and the development of broader clinical networks for management of complex cases. The actions resulting from this will be discussed at a meeting of the Scottish Association of Medical Directors in August.

There is also work ongoing with regard to establishing a Medical Device Information System (MDIS) which will provide important surveillance and outcome information.

I refer the member to the answer to question S5W-24134 on 18 July 2019.. All answers to written Parliamentary Questions are available on the Parliament's website, the search facility for which can be found at https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/written-questions-and-answers

The Scottish Government is aware of the international consensus principles for ethical wildlife control and alongside the recent Parliamentary debate on the issue, I previously met with OneKind to discuss those principles in more detail, and last month Scottish Government officials attended a workshop organised by both John Muir Trust and OneKind on the principles and how they could be applied in deer management.

Animal welfare remains at the heart of our wildlife management policies and we have taken a number of steps in recent years in order to ensure the highest standards of animal and wildlife welfare in Scotland.

NatureScot has invited stakeholders such as the Scottish Animal Welfare Commission and animal welfare organisations such as the Wild Animal Welfare Committee to work with them on exploring where they think we can go further in regards to animal welfare and the international consensus principles for ethical wildlife control being applied within the Shared Approach.

NHS Ayrshire & Arran purchased Carrick Glen from Circle BMI for £1.8 million on 31st March 2022. Work is ongoing to finalise the Full Business Case for the new National Treatment Centre and redesign and redevelopment costs are yet to be finalised.

The Programme for Government 2021-22 committed to expanding the availability of the Caledonian System, with the aim of making it available to all Scottish local authorities by the end of the parliamentary term.

Consideration must be given to the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on the operation of the Caledonian System, our ability to assess and evaluate during this period, and what lessons might be learned to further enhance the programme.