The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 2641 contributions
Social Justice and Social Security Committee
Meeting date: 13 June 2024
Bob Doris
Do you expect a lot of that to be spelled out in the financial memorandum? I am conscious that local authorities and a range of partner public bodies will get annual budgets from the Parliament, and Government might say, “That is on a year-to-year basis. The financial memorandum concerns the transition, but the annual budgets for how we resource the work adequately are just that: annual budgets.” What are your views on that?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
I have a very general question that might be more about part 2 of the bill. In response to Jackie Dunbar’s question about patterns of land ownership in the country, Mr Russell referred us to Andy Wightman’s 2024 update to “Who Owns Scotland”.
More generally, what will a successful bill look like in 10 years’ time in relation to the pattern of land ownership in Scotland? Should we still expect to see the same 20 huge companies having the same extremely dense levels of ownership in the country? Should we see land being owned by much smaller concerns? What will success look like in that regard? How can we monitor the impact on tenants and those with smallholdings? Data can be used to show anything. What we are interested in is the impact on the ground and whether the bill improves the quality of experience for individual leaseholders and for communities. What does success look like?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
Can I push you on that, Mr Russell? Cross-compliance is not direct compliance. Some family concerns can be very large companies and they might consider it to be cheaper to just pay £5,000 rather than comply fully, which is burdensome.
Could we increase the fine threshold? Could we look at penalties based on turnover of the business?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
Thank you.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
Good morning, and thank you for supporting our evidence session this morning.
I want to ask about land management plans, but can I ask you not to talk yet about compliance, enforcement, monitoring, reporting or the size of holdings, as I will ask questions about those things later.
First, and principally for large holdings that will be required to produce a land management plan, do the provisions adequately articulate meaningful extensive community engagement, including using the land rights and responsibilities statement? I am not sure who is best placed to answer that.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
That is helpful. There is a balance to be struck, of course, Mr Russell, which I think is the point that you are making. The bill does not include cumulative holdings. A landowner could have four concerns each of 2,000 hectares—a massive operation that would not be covered by this bill. Should the bill consider cumulative holdings, Mr Russell?
09:45Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
I am sorry to focus on you, Emma, but this is a line of questioning that I was hoping to pursue. Land management plans would have to take cognisance of the land rights and responsibilities statement, but they would not have to follow it. I understand that they will have to have regard for the land rights and responsibilities statement, but that it has no statutory underpinning and will be voluntary. What is your view on that? If any of the other witnesses have different views, it would be good to get them on the record, too.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
I am new to this, Hamish, and you are not, and I am trying to scrutinise the bill. Are there examples where that happens elsewhere in the world and has the Land Commission thought about what a model in Scotland could look like?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
I hope you will not mind me pushing you a bit further, Mr Russell, but I did not ask about cross-compliance. I understand cross-compliance. I asked about direct compliance and whether for some businesses, a £5,000 fine just would not cut it. Is it the view of the Land Commission that the £5,000 fine should be reviewed?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee
Meeting date: 11 June 2024
Bob Doris
That is helpful. Convener, you will be relieved to hear this is my final question—I know that other members need to get in and that you want to move on the lines of questioning.
Some concerns have been raised about the reporting process and it has been suggested that we should widen the scope of who can report and that investigations should be more robust. I must admit that I am not across the detail of this particular area, but I would be very keen to have witnesses to put on record their thoughts to better inform our consideration of this legislation.