The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 68 contributions
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Thank you for coming in. You must forgive my ignorance as I learn about all the different bodies that are involved in this area. Last night, I attended the Equality and Human Rights Commission reception that was kindly hosted by Carol Mochan. Given that Scotland already has the Equality and Human Rights Commission, the courts, ombudsmen, sector-specific regulators and so on, what specific function does the Scottish Human Rights Commission perform that none of the other bodies performs? What measurable benefit does that produce for the ordinary Scottish person?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Thanks for coming in, Cat. I understand that Engender made a response to the human rights bill consultation, and I want to ask a little bit about whose views were represented. How many women were consulted and how did you go about doing that? Was the consultation in person or was it direct contact? Did you also include women with whom you disagree on the conflict between sex-based rights and gender identity?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
I absolutely support your stance on the importance of good data.
I guess that my question is for Charlie McMillan. When the consortium and several of its member or partner organisations give the committee substantially the same recommendation, should that be recorded in data as having come from multiple independent sources, or should it be grouped together as a co-ordinated position?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Thank you for coming in today. You have talked about the polarisation of the debate and you mentioned women. Your organisation says that a new human rights bill should provide additional protections for LGBT people. Do you want the bill to introduce gender identity as a new legal category? If so, how would you define it?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
I do not dispute what you are saying, but there is a document on your website that states that the Equality Act 2010 includes gender identity, when the protected characteristic is actually gender reassignment. I just wondered whether you are going to correct that statement and what legal checking is applied to the material that you publish.
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Yes.
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Thank you.
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Juliet Harris, thank you for speaking to the committee—I am beginning to grasp the complexity of what you have been discussing. Your advice about speaking to the children’s commissioner is very good. You kind of answered my question in your response to Holly Bruce’s question, but I want to take things down a level. Given the UNCRC issue, what specific additional problems might there be with the proposed human rights bill. You gave the example of the legislation on religious observance, but should we be aware of any other issues?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Sure. I will frame my question in this way: what is Engender’s position on the matter?
Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee
Meeting date: 17 September 2026
Amanda Lindsay
Yes. I talked in the chamber this week about commercial sexual exploitation. This might be a question for Cat Murphy, because I know that when she was at Amnesty International, she defended the decriminalisation of prostitution and criticised the Nordic model of criminalising buyers. What is Engender’s position on this matter? I think that it is perhaps at odds with Scotland’s equally safe framework, which treats commercial sexual exploitation as a form of violence against women.